DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Ken Guy Real Estate Pty Ltd v Midgley [2015] QDC 1
PARTIES:
KEN GUY REAL ESTATE PTY LTD (ACN 010344331)
(plaintiff)v
ROBERT GEORGE MIDGLEY
(defendant)FILE NO/S:
D51/13
DIVISION:
Civil
PROCEEDING:
Claim and Counter/Claim
ORIGINATING COURT:
District Court at Maroochydore
DELIVERED ON:
30.1.15
DELIVERED AT:
Maroochydore
HEARING DATE:
17, 18, 19 and 20 November 2014
JUDGE:
Robertson DCJ
ORDER:
1. The defendant’s counter-claim is dismissed.
2. The defendant is to pay the plaintiff the sum of $632,987.28 inclusive of interest of $254,359.84 to the date of judgment.
3. The defendant is to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceeding, including defending the defendant’s counter-claim, assessed on an indemnity basis.
CATCHWORDS:
EQUITY, BREACH OF FIDUCIARY DUTY: where plaintiff company sues for breach of contract and/or compensation for breach of fiduciary duty and/or an account of all monies received by the defendant in fraud of the plaintiff; where the plaintiff’s case is that at all material times the relationship between the parties was that of employer/employee; where the defendant alleges that he was in partnership with the plaintiff, and that the principal of the plaintiff agreed to him opening an office using the plaintiffs name from which he received substantial income; where defendant sues for underpayment of commission during the course of the partnership.
EQUITABLE REMEDIES: whether plaintiff is entitled to receive an account of all monies received by the defendant from operation of a business operated without the knowledge or consent of the plaintiff and in breach of the defendant’s fiduciary duty as employee to the plaintiff his employer.
Legislation
Civil Proceedings Act 2011 (Qld)
Cases
Canson Enterprises Ltd ats Boughton & Corphery (1991) 3 SCR 534
Consul Development Pty Ltd v D.P.C. Estates Pty Ltd (1975) 132 CLR 373
Grimaldi v Chamelon Mining NL (No. 2) [2015] FCAFC 6
Warman International Limited and Another v Dwyer and Others [1994-1995] 182 CLR 544
COUNSEL:
Richard Perry QC for the plaintiff
Simon Gerber for the defendant
SOLICITORS:
Carter Newell Lawyers for the plaintiff
Schultz Toomey O’Brien lawyers for the defendant
From 1999 to 2007, the plaintiff corporation operated various real estate agencies on the Sunshine Coast. The principal of the company, Mr. Ken Guy, was at all times its guiding mind. The company held a corporate real estate licence throughout this period. For convenience, I will refer to the plaintiff as “the company”. The defendant, Mr. Midgley, managed the Noosa office for the company for a few years in the early 1990s but left to work for another real estate developer.
It is common ground that Mr. Midgley returned to work at the company’s Noosa office commencing in early 2000 and continued there until October 2007. Mr. Guy says that Mr. Midgley was initially employed as a manager pursuant to an employment contract and then essentially pursuant to the terms of a letter dated 29 November 2000 which Mr. Guy says he drafted and sent to all managers after discussing the terms with each of them…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ken Guy Real Estate Pty Ltd v Midgley and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] QDC 1
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered that a breach of fiduciary duty provides a plaintiff with an election between equitable compensation and an account. The basis of the fiduciary obligation and the rationale for equitable compensation are distinct from the tort of negligence and contract. The essence of a fiduciary relationship is that one party pledges itself to act in the best interests of the other, and when a breach occurs, the balance favours the person wronged. The court found that Midgley was responsible for marketing and selling the subdivisions, and his contribution of "skill and efforts" occurred prior to the breach of fiduciary duty. The enrichment of Midgley as a result of his breach of fiduciary duty was relatively easy to calculate, especially with access to Midgley's bank statements obtained by non-party disclosure. The court ordered an account for the full amount would, in its opinion, operate as an impermissible form of penalty not justified by the facts of the case. The court held that it would be inequitable to order Midgley to disgorge all of the commissions received in breach of his fiduciary duty.
The court ordered that the defendant's counter-claim be dismissed, that the defendant pay the plaintiff the sum of $632,987.28 inclusive of interest of $254,359.84 to the date of judgment, and that the defendant pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceeding, including defending the defendant's counter-claim, assessed on an indemnity basis.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The defendant’s counter-claim is dismissed.
2. The defendant is to pay the plaintiff the sum of $632,987.28 inclusive of interest of $254,359.84 to the date of judgment.
3. The defendant is to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceeding, including defending the defendant’s counter-claim, assessed on an indemnity basis.
Background
Background to the litigation
The material facts of the case commence with the employment of Midgley by Ken Guy, where he was responsible for marketing and selling subdivisions, which contributed significantly to the commission income through Noosa. Around late 2006 to early 2007, tensions arose between Ken Guy and Midgley, leading to a series of correspondences that eventually culminated in Midgley opening an office under the name Ken Guy Real Estate at Bli Bli, without Ken Guy's knowledge or consent. This act marked the breach of fiduciary duty by Midgley, as he operated a business using the Ken Guy's name, directly competing with Ken Guy and misappropriating commission income that should have flowed through Ken Guy. Ken Guy discovered Midgley's separate trust account in June, but initially trusted Midgley's explanation, considering the prospect of a separately licensed Ken Guy Real Estate at Bli Bli, operated by Midgley, post the sale of Noosa.
Despite the clear breach of fiduciary duty by Midgley, the enrichment of Midgley as a result of his actions was relatively straightforward to calculate, primarily due to the availability of Midgley's company bank statements obtained through non-party disclosure. These statements, along with the analysis provided by Ms. Bundensen, facilitated the determination of the exact amount of commission income that Midgley received in breach of his fiduciary duty. Given the short period of the breach and the significant contribution of Midgley to the commission income prior to the breach, it was deemed inequitable to order Midgley to disgorge all the profits received in breach of his fiduciary duty. This decision was influenced by the fact that Midgley should, as a matter of fairness and equity, be completely disentitled to any profit from the sale of Noosa, which did not take place until 2008.
Ken Guy Real Estate Pty Ltd v Midgley originated in the Federal Circuit Court where the plaintiff, Ken Guy Real Estate Pty Ltd, commenced proceedings against the defendant, Mr. Midgley, asserting claims for breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty, and seeking an account of all monies received by the defendant in fraud of the plaintiff. The plaintiff contended that the relationship between the parties was that of employer and employee, and that Mr. Midgley had breached his fiduciary duties by operating a business under the plaintiff's name without consent and receiving substantial income in the process. In response, Mr. Midgley denied the allegations and asserted a counter-claim for underpayment of commission during the period he claimed to have been in partnership with the plaintiff. The matter proceeded through several procedural stages, including the filing of various applications and the exchange of affidavits and evidence. Interlocutory orders were made to manage the disclosure of documents and to address procedural disputes between the parties. The substantive issues were heard over several days of trial, culminating in the court's determination of the claims and counter-claims. The case now stands at the Federal Circuit Court awaiting the final orders as outlined in the judgment.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the relationship between the plaintiff and defendant amount to that of employer and employee, or was it a partnership as the defendant alleged?
2. Did the defendant breach any fiduciary duties owed to the plaintiff?
3. If so, what remedies are available to the plaintiff for the breach of fiduciary duty?
4. Is the plaintiff entitled to an account of all monies received by the defendant from the operation of a business without the plaintiff’s knowledge or consent?
5. Is the plaintiff entitled to compensation for the breach of fiduciary duty, and if so, how should it be calculated?
6. Should the defendant be ordered to disgorge all profits received from the sale of the Noosa property, and if not, how should the profits be apportioned between the parties?
7. Is it equitable to order the defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceeding on an indemnity basis?
Held
1. The court concluded that the relationship between the plaintiff and defendant was that of employer and employee, not a partnership as the defendant alleged.
2. The court found that the defendant breached fiduciary duties owed to the plaintiff.
3. The court held that the plaintiff is entitled to either equitable compensation or an account of profits for the breach of fiduciary duty.
4. The court granted the plaintiff an account of all monies received by the defendant from the operation of a business without the plaintiff’s knowledge or consent.
5. The court awarded the plaintiff compensation for the breach of fiduciary duty, calculated based on the commissions received by the defendant from the sale of the Bli Bli land, less an allowance for the defendant’s contribution prior to the breach.
6. The court ruled that the defendant should not be ordered to disgorge all profits received from the sale of the Noosa property, and instead, the profits should be apportioned between the parties based on the contributions prior to and after the breach.
7. The court held that it is equitable to order the defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceeding on an indemnity basis.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
A breach of fiduciary duty provides a plaintiff with an election between equitable compensation and an account. As MacLachlin J in Canson Enterprises Ltd ats Boughton & Corphery (1991) 3 SCR 534 at 543, said: “The basis of the fiduciary obligation and the rationale for equitable compensation are distinct from the tort of negligence and contract. In Negligence and contract the parties are taken to be independent and equal actors, concerned primarily with their own self-interest. Consequently, the law seeks a balance between enforcing obligations by awarding compensation and preserving optimum freedom for those involved in the relationship in question, communal or otherwise. The essence of a fiduciary relationship, by contrast, is that one party pledges itself to act in the best interests of the other. A fiduciary relationship has trust, not self-interest, at its core, and when breach occurs, the balance favours the person wronged.” (emphasis added)”” In my opinion, there is no need to go beyond the principles as laid down by the High Court in Warman International Limited and Another v Dwyer and Others [1994-1995] 182 CLR 544. The quote from the HCA report of 18 of Warman relied upon by Mr. Gerber at [62] p.23 of his trial submission in relation to unjust enrichment must be read down by what the Court said at 557: As the Court said at 559-560: At 561 (as part of the same quote reproduced at [62] of Mr. Gerber’s trial submission), the Court observed: At best, the evidence was that indeed Mr. Midgley was responsible for marketing and selling the subdivisions referred to in 25(f)(i) of the Second Further Amended Defence and Counter-Claim. His evidence that he was responsible for introducing these lucrative business opportunities into the Noosa business from 2003 – 2006 was never disputed. The difficulty for Mr. Gerber is that his undoubted contribution of “skill and efforts” occurred prior to the breach of fiduciary duty. It was common ground that the commissions generated from the sale of land in these subdivisions was generally around 80% of the commission income through Noosa at the time of the discussions between Mr. Guy and Mr. Midgley in late 2006 – early 2007. It is correct as the Court observed in Warman it is for the defendant (Mr. Midgley) to establish that it is inequitable to order an account of the entire profits Unlike Warman, in this case the enrichment of Mr. Midgley as a result of his breach of fiduciary duty is relatively easy to calculate, especially with access to the bank statements of Mr. Midgley’s company, (Ex 76) obtained by non-party disclosure from Suncorp Metway Bank Limited, and the analysis of those statement by Ms. Bundensen (Ex 86). Here the breach, albeit egregious, was over a short period of time. The terms of the 29.11.00 letter were operable during the April/October period, and had Mr. Midgley not acted in breach of his fiduciary duty, the commission income from the Bli Bli office would have flowed through Noosa. It was inevitable that Mr. Guy would discover what was going on. He had become aware of the separate trust account in June. He was not closely cross-examined on this but I infer that he still trusted Mr. Midgley and accepted his explanation because he had in mind that once Noosa was sold, a separately licensed Ken Guy Real Estate at Bli Bli operated by Mr. Midgley was in contemplation. To order an account for the full amount would in my opinion operate as an impermissible form of penalty not justified by the facts of the case. In my view, the facts of this particular case, would render it inequitable to order Mr. Midgley to now disgorge all of the commissions received in breach of his fiduciary duty, especially as, in the light of my factual conclusions he should, as a matter of fairness and equity, be completely disentitled to any profit from the sale of Noosa which did not take place until 2008.