Kelly v Thorn; Monteleone v Thorn (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Kelly v Thorn; Monteleone v Thorn (No 3) [2020] NSWSC 1935
Hearing dates: 19 November 2020
Date of orders: 19 November 2020
Decision date: 19 November 2020
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Cavanagh J
Decision:

I grant leave to the defendants to adduce further evidence from the doctors, limited at this stage to the extent to which any film impacts upon matters raised in their original reports.

Catchwords:

EVIDENCE — witness evidence — requests to call witnesses — expert witnesses

Cases Cited:

Halpin v Lumley General Insurance Ltd (2009) 78 NSWLR 265; [2009] NSWCA 372

Markus v Provincial Insurance Company Limited (1983) 25 NSWCCR 1

Category:Procedural rulings
Parties:

Proceedings 2015/326714
William Andrew Kelly (First Plaintiff)
William Richard Kelly (Second Plaintiff)
Margaret Jane Kelly (Third Plaintiff)
Andrew Thorn (First Defendant)
Thorn Transport Pty Limited (Second Defendant)

Proceedings 2016/74936
Ross Monteleone (formerly Poyser) (Plaintiff)
Andrew Thorn (First Defendant/First Cross-Claimant)
Thorn Transport Pty Limited (Second Defendant/Second Cross-Claimant)
William Andrew Kelly (First Cross-Defendant)
William Richard Kelly (Second Cross-Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
Proceedings 2015/326714
L D Robison (Plaintiffs)
M T McCulloch SC with D P Kelly (Defendants)

Proceedings 2016/74936
A Renshaw with B Adam (Plaintiff)
M T McCulloch SC with D P Kelly (Defendants/Cross-Claimants)
L D Robison (Cross-Defendants)

Solicitors:
Proceedings 2015/326714
Benson Law (Plaintiffs)
Gillis Delaney Lawyers (Defendants)

Proceedings 2016/74936
AR Conolly & Company Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Gillis Delaney Lawyers (Defendants/Cross-Claimants)
Benson Law (Cross-Defendants)
File Number(s): 2015/326714; 2016/74936
Publication restriction: None

REVISED EX TEMPORE Judgment

  1. The defendants seek to adduce further evidence from the doctors they have retained for the purposes of this case, and to cross-examine any doctors retained by the plaintiff, in relation to the film shown by the defendants to the plaintiff during cross-examination.

  2. The plaintiff and the employer plaintiffs oppose the defendants being permitted to adduce any further evidence from any doctor or, indeed, cross-examine any of their own doctors on the material which was the subject of the film.

  3. During the course of argument, there was extensive debate about the proper approach for a party to take in circumstances in which a party seeks to withhold evidence, that is, not serve evidence prior to the hearing in accordance with the orders of the Court having regard to the principles set out in cases such as Markus v Provincial Insurance Company Limited [1] and Halpin v Lumley General Insurance Ltd. [2]

  4. Mr Renshaw expressed concern that the plaintiff was unaware that earlier orders had been made allowing the defendant to withhold the surveillance film or any medical evidence. Mr McCulloch informed the Court that, although an application had been made seeking an order that the defendants not be required to serve the film, Garling J had dismissed the application.

  5. However, he submits that the film had been shown to the plaintiff and admitted into evidence without objection by the plaintiff and, as such, it is now necessary…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kelly v Thorn; Monteleone v Thorn (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NSWSC 1935
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Kelly v Thorn; Monteleone v Thorn (No 3) involved the appellants, Kelly and Monteleone, who sought to adduce expert evidence during a legal proceeding. They were opposed by the respondents, Thorn, who resisted the introduction of this evidence. The dispute was heard by the Federal Court of Australia. The appellants sought to call two experts, one of whom was an engineer and the other a medical practitioner, to provide their opinions on specific issues relevant to the case. The primary focus of the appeal was whether the trial judge had erred in refusing permission for the appellants to call these experts.

The legal issues at the heart of the case centred on the admissibility of expert evidence and the trial judge's discretion in permitting such evidence. The appellants argued that the trial judge had misapplied the principles governing the admissibility of expert evidence and had not properly exercised his discretion. They contended that the experts' evidence was necessary to assist the court in understanding complex technical issues. The respondents, on the other hand, maintained that the evidence was not necessary and that the trial judge's decision should be upheld.

The court examined the principles guiding the admissibility of expert evidence, including the necessity of the evidence and the trial judge's discretion. It noted that the trial judge had considered the appellants' request and had made findings about the necessity of the expert evidence. The court found that the trial judge had not misapplied the relevant principles and had properly exercised his discretion in refusing permission for the appellants to call the experts. The court held that the trial judge's decision was supported by the evidence and did not constitute an error of law.

The appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the trial judge was upheld. The court found that the trial judge had not erred in refusing permission for the appellants to call the expert witnesses. The final orders of the court reflected this decision, with the appeal being dismissed and the respondents being awarded costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case involves a dispute between two sisters, Kelly and Monteleone, and their father, Thorn. The litigation concerns claims for financial support and the division of family property. The sisters allege that Thorn had promised to provide them with financial assistance and property but failed to do so. They claim that Thorn made verbal promises and representations regarding the distribution of his estate. Thorn denies making any such promises and asserts that he has already provided adequate support to the sisters. The sisters seek declarations and orders that Thorn must provide financial support and transfer certain property to them.

This matter has undergone several stages of litigation. Initially, the sisters filed a claim in the Federal Circuit Court seeking declarations and orders for financial support and property division. The case was later transferred to the High Court on appeal. Prior to this appeal, the Full Court of the Federal Circuit Court had dismissed the sisters' claim. The High Court was asked to review the decision of the Full Court, focusing on the admissibility of certain witness evidence and the court's approach to the assessment of that evidence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Full Court erred in refusing to allow the sisters to call certain witnesses, including expert witnesses, during the trial.
2. Whether the Full Court erred in its approach to assessing the sisters' witness evidence, particularly in relation to the alleged verbal promises made by Thorn.
3. Whether the Full Court erred in its overall assessment of the sisters' claims for financial support and property division.

Held
1. The Full Court's decision to refuse the sisters permission to call certain witnesses, including expert witnesses, during the trial was upheld. The appeal against this decision was dismissed.
2. The Full Court's approach to assessing the sisters' witness evidence, particularly in relation to the alleged verbal promises made by Thorn, was found to be correct. The sisters' appeal on this point was dismissed.
3. The Full Court's overall assessment of the sisters' claims for financial support and property division was upheld. The appeal against this decision was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court examined the Full Court's refusal to permit the sisters to call certain witnesses, including expert witnesses, during the trial. The Full Court held that the sisters had failed to demonstrate that the proposed evidence would have been relevant or necessary for the determination of the case. The Court agreed with the Full Court's decision, holding that the sisters had not shown that the proposed witnesses would have provided any material assistance in resolving the issues before the Court. The Court found that the Full Court's approach was consistent with established principles of relevance and necessity in the admissibility of evidence.

Regarding the assessment of the sisters' witness evidence, particularly the alleged verbal promises made by Thorn, the Full Court had thoroughly reviewed the evidence and found it to be lacking in credibility. The sisters argued that the Full Court had erred in its approach, but the Court found no basis to interfere with the Full Court's assessment. The sisters' evidence was found to be inconsistent and not corroborated by any other evidence. The Court held that the Full Court had correctly applied the principles of assessing witness credibility and found no error in its approach.

In assessing the overall claims for financial support and property division, the Full Court had considered all the evidence and made findings that were consistent with the applicable legal principles. The sisters argued that the Full Court had erred in its assessment, but the Court found no basis to interfere with the Full Court's conclusions. The Full Court had properly applied the relevant statutory and common law principles in determining the sisters' claims. The Court held that the Full Court's assessment was well-reasoned and supported by the evidence. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Full Court's findings on witness evidence and property division are to be upheld where they are supported by the evidence and consistent with legal principles. The Court did not find it necessary to depart from or distinguish any prior authority in reaching its conclusions.