Kelly v Minister for Lands

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read
 
  LAND COURT

BRISBANE

30 AUGUST 1995

Re:     Determination of unimproved value -
  Application for conversion of tenure -
  Special Lease No.:  26/41377, Innisfail.
  Lessee:        B.A. Kelly  

(Hearing at Innisfail)

D E C I S I O N

Pursuant to the Land Act, the Minister has referred to the Court the matter of determination of the unimproved value of the land contained in the above lease, being Lot 327 on Plan NR6778, Parish of Mourilyan, containing 3.053 hectares.
           The land is situated fronting Eden Road about 23.5 kilometres south of Innisfail.  It is zoned "Rural B", in Johnstone Shire, where the minimum new subdivision permitted within that zone is 12 hectares.  Eden Road is of formed gravel construction and access to the site is fair.  Electricity and telephone are available to the site. 
           Application for the conversion of the lease was received by the Department of Lands on 30th August, 1993 and it is at that date which the value is to be determined.  The assessment by the Department of Lands is in the amount of $32,000.  Mr Kelly, the lessee, has contested that assessment.  In his opinion, the unimproved value should be calculated on the basis of its worth as cane land.  Based on the valuation for rating purposes, the pro-rata value of the land is calculated by Mr Kelly to be $2,981.38. 
           Mr Kelly gave evidence in support of his contention and explained the history of Crown land in the area being made available as special leases to a number of small canegrowers, for farm build-up.  An area of about 8.5 hectares was made available to be shared between Mr Kelly and two of his neighbours, resulting in the subject land becoming part of his farm.  For rating purposes, the land is valued as one aggregation although in fact the subject land is not contiguous to the main farm.  It is on the opposite side of the road and a short distance removed.  It is Mr Kelly's contention that the best use of the land is for cane growing and for that purpose it has practical shape affording long rows with no headland loss for harvesting needs.  Mr Kelly pointed out that the land is located in an agricultural district where no rural-residential subdivision has been effected even during the period when the sugar industry was in a state of crisis through low prices and when farmers were desperate for capital.
           In his opinion, the land is unsuitable for use as a separate rural-residential site, the basis on which it is valued as a separate entity, by the Department.  He says that because the land is relatively flat in contour there are no views available and there are no desirable residential orientated features such as creeks or rainforest which might create a rural-residential environment.  Instead, because of its dimensions (54 metres width by depth of 563 metres) any building site would be close to the side boundaries and hemmed in by a wall of sugarcane on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kelly v Minister for Lands and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] QLC 75
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Land Court of Queensland, the case of Kelly v Minister for Lands involved a dispute over the unimproved value of a parcel of land held under a special lease. The lessee, Mr. B.A. Kelly, contested the Department of Lands' assessment of the land's value at $32,000, arguing that it should be calculated based on its worth for cane growing. Mr. Kelly believed the land's true value should be assessed as part of a larger farm aggregation, suggesting a pro-rata value of $2,981.38 based on valuation for rating purposes. The central legal issue was determining the appropriate method for assessing the unimproved value of the land, particularly whether it should be valued based on its agricultural use or its potential for rural-residential development.

The court considered the evidence presented by both parties. Mr. Kelly provided testimony about the land's history, its use for cane farming, and its integration with neighbouring farms. He argued that the land's shape and location made it unsuitable for residential purposes and that its value should reflect its agricultural utility. On the other hand, the Department of Lands, represented by Mr. S.A. Cross, a registered valuer, provided evidence of comparable sales in the area, suggesting a higher value for the land based on its potential for rural-residential use. The court weighed these arguments, acknowledging Mr. Kelly's perspective on the land's suitability for cane growing but also considering the market demand for small rural residential sites.

The court ultimately determined that while the land was predominantly suited for cane farming, it should not disregard its potential for separate use. The court accepted that a prudent owner would not want to lose the land's separate title through amalgamation with other properties. After evaluating the evidence, the court set the unimproved value of the land at $24,000, considering both the agricultural and potential residential uses, but with a focus on the realistic market value based on comparable sales in the area.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established