KELLY ANN SHEA v BRENTON IAN COX
[2014] ACTSC 7 (28 January 2014)
APPEAL – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – Appeal against sentence – charges of burglary and theft – obligation of appellant to give appellate court information about sentencing ranges – difficulties in identifying sentencing ranges in Magistrates Court – failure to provide such information not an insuperable obstacle to successful appeal based on manifest excess or inadequacy of sentence.
APPEAL – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – Appeal against sentence – charges of burglary and theft – sentencing Magistrate not in error in rejecting suitability of periodic detention –sentencing Magistrate not in error in referring to number of adjournments before matter finalised – sentencing Magistrate not in error in determining what weight to give to appellant’s prospects of rehabilitation – limited scope for establishing a failure to give adequate weight to a sentencing matter as a House v The King error.
APPEAL – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – Appeal against sentence – charges of burglary and theft – whether sentence imposed was too short – whether objective seriousness of offence was properly taken into account – seriousness of offence justified longer term of imprisonment – reasons for imposing short sentence not consistent with obligation to set appropriate sentence for offence – offender liable to serve full term of imprisonment imposed – not appropriate to trade off length of sentence against immediate time in custody – error in setting short sentence all to be served in full-time custody – appellant warned that longer sentence would be imposed – appeal maintained – appeal allowed – appellant re-sentenced.
Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT), s 79
Dinsdale v The Queen (2000) 202 CLR 321
House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499
Parker v Director of Public Prosecutions (1992) 28 NSWLR 282
Pearce v The Queen (1998) 194 CLR 610
R v Campbell [2010] ACTCA 20
EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT
ON APPEAL FROM THE MAGISTRATES COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
No. SCA 83 of 2013
Judge: Penfold J
Supreme Court of the ACT
Date: 28 January 2014
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE )
) No. SCA 83 of 2013
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
ON APPEAL FROM THE MAGISTRATES COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
BETWEEN:
KELLY SHEA Appellant
AND:
BRENTON IAN COX Respondent
ORDER
Judge: Penfold J
Date: 2 December 2013
Place: Canberra
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
The appeal be allowed.
The appellant be re-sentenced.
Introduction
Kelly Ann Shea has appealed against sentences imposed in the Magistrates Court for one offence each of burglary and theft.
The offences were committed in September 2010. It seems that Ms Shea entered a house in Fadden, through a broken glass sliding door, and removed a large number of items to a total value of around $1,500. She was linked to the burglary by DNA analysis of blood left in the house.
Police made contact with Ms Shea in December 2010, by which time she had travelled to Darwin. She did not return to Canberra in January 2011 as had been indicated…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kelly Ann Shea v Brenton Ian Cox and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] ACTSC 7
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal held that the appellant's failure to provide information about sentencing ranges in the Magistrates Court did not necessarily prevent the Court from considering the appeal. The Court found that the sentencing Magistrate was not in error in rejecting the suitability of periodic detention, referring to the number of adjournments before the matter was finalised, or determining the weight to give to the appellant's prospects of rehabilitation. However, the Court found that the reasons for imposing a short sentence were not consistent with the obligation to set an appropriate sentence for the offence. The seriousness of the offence justified a longer term of imprisonment, and the appellant was liable to serve the full term of imprisonment imposed. The Court found that it was not appropriate to trade off the length of the sentence against the immediate time in custody, and the error in setting a short sentence all to be served in full-time custody warranted the appeal being maintained.
The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and re-sentenced the appellant. The Court ordered that the appeal be allowed and that the appellant be re-sentenced.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal be allowed.
2. The appellant be re-sentenced.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case came before the Court of Appeal where Shea argued that the sentence imposed was too short and did not properly take into account the objective seriousness of the offence. Shea contended that the sentencing Magistrate erred in rejecting the suitability of periodic detention as an alternative to imprisonment and in assessing her prospects of rehabilitation. The Court of Appeal noted that the sentencing Magistrate was not in error in these respects. The Magistrate did not err in rejecting periodic detention as it was not an appropriate sentence for the gravity of the offence. The Magistrate also appropriately considered the number of adjournments before the matter was finalised and Shea's prospects of rehabilitation, weighing these factors in the context of the overall sentence imposed.
The Court of Appeal found that the reasons provided by the sentencing Magistrate for imposing a short sentence were not consistent with the obligation to set an appropriate sentence for the offence. The seriousness of the offence, including the unlawful entry and theft from a residential property, justified a longer term of imprisonment. The appeal was maintained on the ground that the sentence imposed was too short and did not appropriately reflect the seriousness of the offence. Consequently, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and ordered that Shea be re-sentenced.
The appellant, Kelly Ann Shea, was convicted on charges of burglary and theft in the Magistrates’ Court and subsequently appealed against the sentence imposed. Shea’s appeal focused on the contention that the sentence was too short, and that the sentencing magistrate failed to adequately consider the objective seriousness of the offence. The appeal came before the Court of Appeal, which had the task of reviewing the sentence imposed by the Magistrates’ Court. In considering the appeal, the Court of Appeal was required to determine whether the sentencing magistrate had erred in setting a short sentence, and if so, whether such an error was of a kind that warranted allowing the appeal and re-sentencing.
Throughout the appeal process, Shea argued that the sentence was too lenient and did not appropriately reflect the gravity of her offences. The Court of Appeal examined the submissions made by Shea, the reasons provided by the sentencing magistrate, and the overall context of the case. The Court also considered the appellant's obligation to inform the appellate court about the relevant sentencing ranges, an aspect which Shea had difficulty in providing. Despite the absence of precise information on sentencing ranges, the Court did not find this to be an insuperable obstacle to considering the merits of the appeal. The appeal was centred on the manifest excess or inadequacy of the sentence, and whether the sentencing magistrate had erred in various respects, such as in assessing the suitability of periodic detention, the number of adjournments, and the weight given to Shea’s prospects of rehabilitation.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the appellant's failure to provide information about sentencing ranges in the Magistrates Court an insuperable obstacle to a successful appeal against the sentence?
2. Did the sentencing Magistrate err in rejecting the suitability of periodic detention for the appellant?
3. Did the sentencing Magistrate err in considering the number of adjournments before the matter was finalised?
4. Did the sentencing Magistrate err in determining the weight to give to the appellant's prospects of rehabilitation?
5. Was the sentence imposed by the Magistrates Court too short, considering the objective seriousness of the offence?
6. Did the sentencing Magistrate properly take into account the seriousness of the offence when determining the length of the sentence?
7. Were the reasons for imposing a short sentence consistent with the obligation to set an appropriate sentence for the offence?
8. Was it appropriate for the sentencing Magistrate to trade off the length of the sentence against the immediate time in custody?
9. Did the sentencing Magistrate err in setting a short sentence to be served entirely in full-time custody, given the appellant was warned that a longer sentence would be imposed?
10. Was the appeal against the sentence on the grounds of manifest excess or inadequacy of sentence well-founded?
Held
1. The court concluded that the appellant's failure to provide information about sentencing ranges in the Magistrates Court was not an insuperable obstacle to a successful appeal against the sentence. Result: Appeal not dismissed on this basis.
2. The court concluded that the sentencing Magistrate did not err in rejecting the suitability of periodic detention for the appellant. Result: No error found.
3. The court concluded that the sentencing Magistrate did not err in considering the number of adjournments before the matter was finalised. Result: No error found.
4. The court concluded that the sentencing Magistrate did not err in determining the weight to give to the appellant's prospects of rehabilitation. Result: No error found.
5. The court concluded that the sentence imposed by the Magistrates Court was too short, considering the objective seriousness of the offence. Result: Sentence deemed inadequate.
6. The court concluded that the sentencing Magistrate did not properly take into account the seriousness of the offence when determining the length of the sentence. Result: Error found.
7. The court concluded that the reasons for imposing the short sentence were not consistent with the obligation to set an appropriate sentence for the offence. Result: Error found.
8. The court concluded that it was not appropriate for the sentencing Magistrate to trade off the length of the sentence against the immediate time in custody. Result: Error found.
9. The court concluded that the sentencing Magistrate erred in setting a short sentence to be served entirely in full-time custody, given the appellant was warned that a longer sentence would be imposed. Result: Error found.
10. The court concluded that the appeal against the sentence on the grounds of manifest excess or inadequacy of sentence was well-founded. Result: Appeal allowed, appellant re-sentenced.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Kelly Ann Shea v Brenton Ian Cox, the appellant's failure to provide information about sentencing ranges in the Magistrates Court was a point of contention. The court held that this omission was not an insuperable obstacle to a successful appeal against the sentence, provided that the appeal was based on the manifest excess or inadequacy of the sentence. The court underscored the principle that while it is preferable for the appellant to provide such information to assist in the appellate process, the lack of it does not preclude a review of the sentence's appropriateness.
The court also considered whether the sentencing Magistrate erred in rejecting the suitability of periodic detention for the appellant. The Magistrate had reasoned that the appellant's criminal history and the nature of the offences warranted a custodial sentence. The court upheld the Magistrate's decision, finding no error in the rejection of periodic detention, as the decision was consistent with the appellant's criminal history and the seriousness of the offences.
Further, the court examined if the Magistrate erred in considering the number of adjournments before the matter was finalised. The Magistrate had noted the adjournments but did not find them to be a mitigating factor. The court agreed that the number of adjournments did not necessarily mitigate the appellant's culpability or the need for a punitive sentence.
The court also assessed whether the Magistrate erred in determining the weight to give to the appellant's prospects of rehabilitation. The appellant argued that the Magistrate had not adequately considered his potential for rehabilitation. However, the court found that there was limited scope for establishing a House v The King error in this context, as the Magistrate had considered the appellant's prospects, albeit not in great detail.
Regarding the length of the sentence, the court found that the sentence imposed by the Magistrates Court was too short considering the objective seriousness of the offence. The court held that the seriousness of the offence justified a longer term of imprisonment and that the reasons for imposing a short sentence were not consistent with the obligation to set an appropriate sentence for the offence.
The court also addressed whether the Magistrate properly took into account the seriousness of the offence when determining the length of the sentence. The court found that while the Magistrate had considered the seriousness, the sentence imposed was not commensurate with the gravity of the crimes committed.
In considering whether it was appropriate for the Magistrate to trade off the length of the sentence against the immediate time in custody, the court concluded that it was not appropriate to do so in this case. The court held that the appellant was liable to serve the full term of imprisonment imposed and that there was an error in setting a short sentence to be served entirely in full-time custody, given the appellant was warned that a longer sentence would be imposed.
Ultimately, the court determined that the appeal against the sentence on the grounds of manifest excess or inadequacy of sentence was well-founded. The court found that the original sentence was manifestly inadequate and allowed the appeal, ordering that the appellant be re-sentenced. The decision reflects the court's commitment to ensuring that sentences reflect the objective seriousness of the offences and the need for appropriate punishment and deterrence.