Kelk and OSM Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

Kelk and OSM Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2024] AATA 913 (30 April 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/2959

Re:Shane Kelk

APPLICANT

OSM Australia Pty LtdAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member Lee Benjamin

Date:30 April 2024

Place:Brisbane

The decision under review is set aside and substituted as follows:

(a) The application for compensation regarding aggravation of pre-existing asymptomatic osteoarthritis of the right hip, and aggravation of pre-existing asymptomatic lumbar spine pathology is approved;

(b) The Applicant is assessed with an impairment of 14%;

(c) The Applicant is assessed with non-economic loss of 52%; and

(d) The Applicant’s claim for economic loss is to be assessed.

…..........................[SGD]...........................................

Member Lee Benjamin

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – Claim for compensation and permanent impairment and non-economic loss pursuant to Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 – where Applicant sustained injury during course of employment – where relevant conditions already in existence but asymptomatic prior to injury – whether conditions became symptomatic and caused incapacity for work – inconsistent medical and working histories provided to independent specialist doctors – where impairment consequence of injury – decision set aside and substituted.

Legislation

Seafarers’ Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth)

Cases

Comcare v Sahu-Kahn [2007] FCA 15
Canute v Comcare [2005] HCA 299
Casarotto v Australian Postal Corporation (1989) ALR 406

Tisdall v Webber [2011] FCAFC 76; (2011) 193 FCR 260

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member Lee Benjamin

30 April 2024

WHAT IS THIS DECISION ABOUT?

  1. Mr Shane Kelk was employed by OSM Australia Pty Ltd [1] as a Chief Cook/ Chief Steward from 2017 to 2019. On 7 January 2019, Mr Kelk suffered a fall while working on the Geo Coal Seismic Vessel in the Bass Strait. He says that he subsequently suffered pain in his right hip and lower back, right arm right shoulder, right elbow, right hand and right wrist, as well as a “soft tissue injury”.[2] In January 2021, Mr Kelk filed a claim for (i) compensation; and (ii) permanent impairment and non-economic loss, both under the Seafarers’ Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) (the Act). Mr Kelk’s claim basis is that the fall aggravated pre-existing asymptomatic (a) right hip osteoarthritis; and (b) lumbar spine pathology, to become symptomatic and cause incapacity for work and impairment. For Mr Kelk to succeed in this application,[3] he must evidence that the fall has “in a material degree, substantially, considerably” resulted in his existing conditions producing incapacity and/or impairment. The question for the Tribunal therefore is whether sufficient, credible evidence so exists. I find that there is.    

    WHAT HAPPENED?

    [1] OSM Australia Pty Ltd is the Respondent in Mr Kelk’s application.

    [2] Exhibit 1, A2, p 45, para 6; R2, p 53, para 2.

    [3] Mr Kelk seeks to overturn the deemed refusal of his reconsideration request dated 2 April 2021 by OSM Australia Pty Ltd.

    Incident

  2. On 7 January 2019 at 6.40pm, Mr Kelk slipped and fell while working[4] on the Geo Coal Seismic Vessel in the Bass Strait.[5]

    [4] Mr Kelk was employed by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kelk and OSM Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 913
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a claim for compensation under the *Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992* brought by Mr Kelk against OSM Australia Pty Ltd. The applicant alleged that he sustained an injury during the course of his employment, which aggravated pre-existing, asymptomatic conditions in his right hip and lumbar spine, leading to incapacity for work and permanent impairment. The respondent challenged the applicant's credit and reliability, particularly in light of inconsistent medical and working histories provided to independent specialist doctors. The decision was heard by Member Lee Benjamin.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the applicant's pre-existing conditions became symptomatic and caused incapacity for work as a consequence of the employment injury, and whether the applicant's impairment was a consequence of the injury. The court was required to assess the applicant's entitlement to compensation for permanent impairment and non-economic loss, and to consider the applicant's claim for economic loss.

Member Lee Benjamin reasoned that the applicant's fall during employment had aggravated his pre-existing asymptomatic osteoarthritis of the right hip and lumbar spine pathology. The court accepted the evidence of Dr Gillet, who opined that the incident had accelerated the progression of these conditions, leading to symptomatology earlier than would otherwise have occurred. While acknowledging the respondent's concerns regarding the applicant's credit, the court found that the applicant's failure to disclose a prior knee injury to the Department of Veterans Affairs was not a deliberate attempt to mislead, given the specific nature of the medical forms completed. The court ultimately set aside the previous decision and substituted its own orders.

The court ordered that the application for compensation regarding the aggravation of the pre-existing conditions be approved. The applicant was assessed with a 14% impairment and 52% non-economic loss. The assessment of the applicant's claim for economic loss was to be undertaken separately.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Finally, the Respondent also says that Mr Kelk’s credit and reliability is also called into question by Mr Kelk’s historical failure to report a right knee injury, that was the subject of a compensation claim with the Department of Veterans Affairs, in the course of various Australian Maritime Safety Authority medicals. That injury was said to have arisen in May 1973 during Mr Kelk’s Royal Australian Navy service.[117] In cross-examination, Mr Kelk did not dispute that he did not declare that he suffered pain and numbness in his right knee since May 1973. Mr Kelk was asked by Mr Clark why this was the case. Mr Kelk’s response was that “I didn’t realise I had to” and “[I]t doesn’t state on the [Australian Maritime Safety Authority] medical that I had to”.[118] This matter was not addressed in Mr Kelk’s submissions-in-reply. I accept Mr Kelk’s evidence that he did not recognise that such disclosure was required given that the Australian Maritime Safety Authority did not specifically call for such data. [117] Respondent’s Closing Submissions, p 8, para 18.[118] Transcript, 4 October 2022, p 23, lines 39-43.Expert medical evidence Dr Gillet provided evidence for Mr Kelk and Dr Journeaux for the Respondent. A summary of their opinions is set out in paragraph 42 to 45 above. In his submission, Mr Kelk says that Dr Gillet’s evidence, by way of report,[119] was that the fall caused (relevantly):·aggravation of pre-existing asymptomatic osteoarthritis of the right hip; and·aggravation of pre-existing (asymptomatic) lumbar spine pathology.[120][119] Exhibit 1, B11, p 95, para 1.[120] Applicant’s Closing Submissions, p 3, para 10. Mr Kelk also contends that Dr Gillet gave further evidence by way of report[121] that:In my view [Mr Kelk] would have reached the same degree of impairment regarding his right hip had the incident [the fall] not happened, and in general terms the incident [the fall] has just accelerated the process and he has got symptomatology at an earlier time by a period of 2 to 3 years of what was going to happen.[122][121] Exhibit 1, B11, p 96, para 6.[122] Applicant’s Closing Submissions, p 3, para 11. Mr Kelk submits that Dr Gillet’s evidence fits with the definition of “aggravation” from Casarotto “hand in glove.”[123][123] Applicant’s Closing Submissions, p 3, para 12. The Respondent does not appear to take serious issue with Dr Gillet’s opinion but rather seeks to attack Mr Kelk’s credit and reliability.[124] In this regard, the Respondent notes:1. [Mr Kelk] did not tell Dr Gillett that he was able to complete two swings of work soon after the fall from 19th to 25th February and 1st to 29th March 2019.2. [Mr Kelk] did not give a history of having taken a nine month break from work on account of lower back and hip pain.3. [Mr Kelk] did not tell Dr Gillett about undertaking the three swings of work each of a month’s duration in that period from February to July 2020.[125][124] I have already addressed the question of Mr Kelk’s credit earlier in this decision.[125] Respondent’s Closing Submissions, p 9, para 23.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The decision under review is set aside and substituted as follows:(a)The application for compensation regarding aggravation of pre-existing asymptomatic osteoarthritis of the right hip, and aggravation of pre-existing asymptomatic lumbar spine pathology is approved;(b)The Applicant is assessed with an impairment of 14%;(c)The Applicant is assessed with non-economic loss of 52%; and(d)The Applicant’s claim for economic loss is to be assessed.I certify that the preceding 121 (one hundred and twenty-one) paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Member Lee Benjamin................[SGD]....................AssociateDated: 30 April 2024Date of Decision: 30 April 2024Dates of Hearing: 4 October 2022, 23 January 2023, and 2 May 2023Representatives for Applicant: Mr Travis O’Brien of CounselMs Kate Harris (Turner Freeman Lawyers)Representatives for Respondent: Mr Charles Clark of CounselMr Stephen Svirac (Sparke Helmore Lawyers)ANNEXURE 1 – EXHIBIT REGISTER

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.