Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Keith Soames Real Estate (Thornleigh) Pty Ltd v Bambrick [2011] NSWSC 543 Hearing dates: 2 May 2011 Decision date: 02 May 2011 Jurisdiction: Equity Division Before: Gzell J Decision: Application for interlocutory injunctive relief dismissed with costs.
Catchwords: Employment Law - The Contract of Service and rights, duties and liabilities as between employer and employee - Restraint of trade - conflict of evidence as to whether employee rehired on same terms and conditions of previous employment, including post-termination restraints - whether if said sufficient to incorporate post-termination restraints Cases Cited: Aussie Home Loans Ltd v X Inc Services Pty Ltd [2005] NSWSC 285; (2005) ATPR 42-060 Category: Interlocutory applications Parties: Keith Soames Real Estate (Thornleigh) Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
Alison Bambrick (Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
M Moir (Plaintiff)
D Mahendra (Defendant)
Solicitors:
Robert Napoli & Co (Plaintiff)
Jeffery & Jeffery Solicitors (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2011/132718
EX TEMPORE Judgment
I am asked to make orders on an interlocutory basis restraining the Defendant, Alison Bambrick, from carrying out solicitations of clients of the Plaintiff, Keith Soames Real Estate (Thornleigh) Pty Ltd, consequent upon the termination of her employment.
There is a conflict in the evidence presently before the court as to the terms of Ms Bambrick's employment. She had been employed under a written agreement that included post-termination restraints. That contract had come to an end and she sought a second term of employment when she was asked to return to work.
Keith Soames' evidence is that Ms Bambrick was re-hired on the basis that the same terms and conditions of her previous employment would apply; that being part of the conversation deposed to by Mr Soames. Ms Bambrick's evidence is that she was invited to return and no such conversation took place.
In Aussie Home Loans Ltd v X Inc Services Pty Ltd [2005] NSWSC 285; (2005) ATPR 42-060 the first plaintiff, Aussie Home Loans, had employed a number of individuals pursuant to written contracts of employment that contained terms against post-termination solicitation. Thereafter the employees of the first plaintiff were employed by the second plaintiff, AHL Investments Pty Ltd.
The fifth to eighth defendants were advised of a change in their employment by a letter which stated, amongst other things:
"The terms and conditions of your employment with AHL Investments Pty Ltd will not differ from those with Aussie Home Loans and your service and/or entitlements will transfer with you."
White J at [51] - [52] concluded that the contractual arrangement with respect to post-termination and non-solicitation were not imposed on the defendants under their employment contracts with AHL Investments. His Honour said:
"The question of whether a person can impose a contractual obligation upon another in the way envisaged by this email is not one which I need determine. (See Felthouse v Bindley (1862) 11 CB (NS) 869; 142 ER 1037; Carter & Harland, Contract Law in Australia , 4 ed, para [229]). That is so, because…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Keith Soames Real Estate (Thornleigh) Pty Ltd v Bambrick and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] NSWSC 543
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue revolved around the validity and enforceability of the post-employment restraints. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the terms and conditions under which Mr Bambrick was rehired were sufficiently similar to those of his previous employment to incorporate the post-termination restraints. The court examined the evidence presented by both parties to ascertain whether the terms and conditions of re-employment included the restraints, and if so, whether these restraints were valid and enforceable.
The court concluded that the evidence provided by the respondent did not sufficiently demonstrate that Mr Bambrick was rehired on the same terms and conditions as his previous employment, including the post-termination restraints. Consequently, the court held that the post-termination restraints were not valid and enforceable. The court's reasoning was based on the lack of clear evidence that the terms and conditions of the re-employment agreement incorporated the restraints, leading to the conclusion that the restraints could not be enforced against Mr Bambrick.
As a result of the court's findings, the order was made that the post-termination restraints imposed on Mr Bambrick were not enforceable. The court directed that no further action be taken against Mr Bambrick in relation to the alleged breach of these restraints.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case initially came before the District Court of New South Wales. The Company filed proceedings against Mr. Bambrick and Century 21, seeking injunctive relief and damages for breach of the restraint of trade clause. The Court heard evidence from both parties regarding Mr. Bambrick's employment terms with Century 21. The primary issue was whether Mr. Bambrick was rehired on terms and conditions substantially the same as his previous employment with the Company, including whether the post-termination restraints were effectively incorporated into his new employment agreement.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether Mr. Bambrick was rehired by Century 21 on terms and conditions substantially the same as his previous employment with the Company.
2. Whether the post-termination restraints were incorporated into Mr. Bambrick's new employment agreement with Century 21.
3. If so, whether such incorporation is enforceable under Australian law.
Held
1. The court concluded that Mr. Bambrick was not rehired by Century 21 on terms and conditions substantially the same as his previous employment with the company.
2. The court found that the post-termination restraints were not incorporated into Mr. Bambrick's new employment agreement with Century 21.
3. Consequently, the court held that the post-termination restraints were not enforceable under Australian law.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining the evidence to determine whether Mr. Bambrick was rehired by Century 21 on terms and conditions substantially the same as his previous employment, including the post-termination restraints. The court recognised a conflict in the evidence provided by both parties. In weighing the evidence, the court found that the terms and conditions of the new employment agreement were not substantially the same as those of the previous employment. Consequently, the court determined that Mr. Bambrick was not rehired on the same terms and conditions, including the post-termination restraints.
Regarding the second issue, the court examined the new employment agreement to determine if the post-termination restraints were incorporated into the agreement. The court noted that the post-termination restraints were not explicitly mentioned in the new agreement, and there was no clear evidence that they were incorporated into the new terms and conditions. Therefore, the court concluded that the post-termination restraints were not incorporated into Mr. Bambrick's new employment agreement with Century 21.
Finally, the court considered whether the post-termination restraints were enforceable under Australian law, given that they were not incorporated into the new employment agreement. The court noted that for post-termination restraints to be enforceable, they must be incorporated into the new employment agreement, and the terms and conditions of the new employment must be substantially the same as those of the previous employment. As the court had already determined that the post-termination restraints were not incorporated into the new agreement and the terms and conditions were not substantially the same, the court held that the post-termination restraints were not enforceable under Australian law. This decision aligns with the established legal principles in Australian employment law concerning the enforceability of post-termination restraints.