In the Matter of the Patents Act 1952
‑ and ‑
In the Matter of Patent Application 546817 in the Name of KEITH HALL SMITH
‑ and ‑
In the Matter of an Application under Section 160 by EDWARD ANDREW BONEL for an Extension of the Time in which to Lodge Notice of Opposition.
DECISION OF A SUPERVISING EXAMINER OF PATENTS:
Patent application 546817 was advertised accepted on 19 September, 1985 and consequently the three month period allowed by sub‑section 59(1) for lodging notice of opposition expired on 19 December, 1985. A document entitled "Notice of Opposition" was received from EDWARD ANDREW BONEL on 18 December, 1985 but without the appropriate fee. On 24 December, 1985, a fresh Notice of Opposition was lodged with the appropriate fee and was accompanied by an application under paragraph 160(2)(a) for an extension of the time from 19 December, 1985 to 24 December, 1985 in which to lodge a notice of opposition. SMITH objected to the application for an extension of time and the matter was set down for a hearing on 10 February, 1985. However, both SMITH through his Patent Attorneys, Cullen, Halford & Maxwell and BONEL through his Patent Attorneys, Grant Adams & Company chose not to appear but instead lodged written submissions in the matter.
The application for an extension of time relies on the ground in paragraph 160(2)(a) of the Act which reads:
"160(2) Where, by reason of ‑
(a)an error or omission on the part of the person concerned or of his agent or attorney ...
(b)...
an act or step in relation to an application for a patent or in proceedings under this Act ... required to be done or taken within a certain time has not been so done or taken, the Commissioner may, upon application by the person concerned ... extend the time for doing the act or taking the step."
Section 160 is a remedial section and should be applied where it appears to be applicable unless there is some clear indication to the contrary. (Scaniainventor v. Commissioner of Patents (1981) 36 ALR 101 at 105). Sub‑
section 160(2) appears to be applicable to the time prescribed by sub‑section 59(1), and as there is no indication in the latter sub‑section to the contrary it may be applied, in a proper case, to allow extensions of the time provided for lodging notice of opposition. In deciding whether there is a proper case for the grant of an extension of time under paragraph 160(2)(a) there are two matters which must be considered. The first of these is whether the applicant for extension of time has established that failure to meet the time limit is due to error or omission on the part of the person concerned or of his agent or attorney. Once this test has been satisfied the Commissioner does have jurisdiction to grant an extension of time. The second matter which must be considered is that the Commissioner has a true discretion whether…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Keith Hall Smith v Edward Andrew BONEL and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1986] APO 7
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues were whether the failure to meet the time limit for lodging the notice of opposition was due to an error or omission and whether the Commissioner of Patents had the discretion to grant an extension of time under Section 160(2)(a) of the Act. The Court had to determine if Bonel's actions constituted an error or omission justifying an extension and, if so, whether the Commissioner should exercise the discretion in Bonel's favour.
The Court found that the notice of opposition was indeed filed without the required fee due to an error or omission on the part of Bonel's attorneys. The evidence, including a statutory declaration by an employee of Grant Adams & Company, established that the failure to attach the appropriate fee stamp was due to oversight and not due care. The Court noted that while there may have been a lack of due care, the error or omission still qualified under the Act. Considering the interests of the patent applicant, the potential opponent, and the public, the Court concluded that the potential opponent's interest and the public interest in ensuring patent validity outweighed the patent applicant's interest. The Court also found that Bonel acted with appropriate haste to correct the error, and there was no undue delay in making the extension application. Therefore, the Commissioner's discretion was exercised in favour of Bonel.
The Court granted an extension of time to validate the notice of opposition lodged by Bonel on 24 December 1985. Additionally, the Court ruled that the time for Bonel to serve evidence in support of the opposition would commence three months from the date of the decision. No costs were awarded in the matter.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi