Kaur (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

Kaur (Migration) [2019] AATA 6081 (20 December 2019)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANTS:  Ms Sandeep Kaur
Mr Dilbaj Singh
Miss Avleen Kaur

CASE NUMBER:  1904382

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):          BCC2016/4223473

MEMBER:Mark Bishop

DATE:20 December 2019

PLACE OF DECISION:  Melbourne

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision to cancel the first named applicant’s Class TU visa.

The Tribunal has no jurisdiction with respect to the other applicants.

Statement made on 20 December 2019 at 12:06pm

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – cancellation – Student (Temporary) (Class TU) visa – Subclass 573 (Higher Education Sector) – Federal Circuit Court remittal – ground for cancellation – enrolment – not enrolled in a registered course – consideration of discretion – duty to inquire – medical grounds for not engaging in study – unplanned pregnancy – caesarean operation – breastfeeding – medical evidence – best interests of child – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 116, 140, 348
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), Schedule 8, Condition 8202

CASES
Botha v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 362
MIAC v SZIAI (2009) 259 ALR 429
Nweke v MIAC [2012] FCA 266
Selvadurai v Minister of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs and J Good (Member of the Refugee Review Tribunal) [1994] FCA 1105

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision dated 1 February 2017 made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to cancel the first named applicant’s Subclass 573 Higher Education Sector visa under s.116(1)(b) of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The delegate cancelled the visa under s.116(1)(b) on the basis that the applicant was no longer enrolled in a course of study that is a principal course of a type specified for Subclass 573 visas. The issue in the present case is whether that ground for cancellation is made out, and if so, whether the visa should be cancelled.

  3. The delegate cancelled the visa on the basis that the applicant was not enrolled in a CRICOS registered course from 30 June 2016 until 18 January 2017. The applicant obtained further enrolment to study a Diploma of Nursing and a Bachelor of Nursing on 18 January 2017. The delegate said “… it appeared [the applicant] Sandeep Kaur did not register in a course of study of her own accord as the enrolments were obtained after the NOICC was sent on 12 January 2017”.

  4. The applicant provided a copy of the decision record dated 1 February 2017 to the Tribunal.

    Initial application for review

  5. The applicant first applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate’s cancellation on 7 February 2017. On 28 August 2018 the Tribunal, differently constituted, affirmed the decision of the delegate to cancel the applicant’s student visa.

  6. On 15 February 2019 McNab J of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia issued a consent order that the decision of the Tribunal was affected by jurisdictional error in that it failed to consider a claim of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kaur (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 6081
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal affirmed the decision to cancel the applicant's Student (Temporary) (Class TU) visa, subclass 573. The dispute centred on whether the applicant had breached condition 8202 of the Migration Regulations 1994, which requires a student visa holder to be enrolled in a registered course. The applicant contended that medical reasons, including an unplanned pregnancy, caesarean operation, and subsequent recovery, prevented her from enrolling and attending her studies.

The Tribunal was required to determine if the applicant had complied with condition 8202(2) by being enrolled in a registered course, and if not, whether discretion should be exercised to set aside the cancellation. The applicant argued that her non-enrolment was due to exceptional circumstances, including medical issues and difficulties with her education provider regarding deferment and enrolment offers. The Tribunal also considered its duty to inquire into the matter, referencing the High Court's decision in *MIAC v SZIAI* regarding the limited general duty to obtain information.

The Tribunal found that the applicant had not been enrolled in a registered course from July 2016 until January 2017, thus breaching condition 8202(2). While acknowledging the applicant's unplanned pregnancy and caesarean section, the Tribunal gave limited weight to the medical certificates provided, finding they were not contemporaneous and did not establish a clear causal link between the medical events and an inability to study for the entire period. Furthermore, the Tribunal noted that independent evidence from the education provider did not substantiate the applicant's claims regarding her enrolment status or attempts to pay fees. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant had not provided sufficient proof of her inability to study and that the circumstances did not warrant the exercise of discretion to set aside the cancellation.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision to cancel the applicant's visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant’s visa should be affirmed. CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The issue in the present case is whether the applicant, as the holder of a student visa, has breached condition 8202 of Schedule 8 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations). If the applicant has breached that condition, under s.116(1) of the Act, the visa may be cancelled.Did the applicant comply with condition 8202? Condition 8202, as it applies in this case, is set out in the attachment to this decision. Relevantly, it requires that the applicant:·be enrolled in a registered course, or in limited cases, a full-time course of study or training: 8202(2)·has not been certified by his or her education provider, as not achieving satisfactory course progress as specified: 8202(3)(a), and·has not been certified by his or her education provider, as not achieving satisfactory course attendance as specified: 8202(3)(b). The background information to this matter insofar as it is relevant is as follows:·The applicant stated that she enrolled in a Diploma of Nursing which commenced on 27 January 2015. She completed two semesters of nursing from February to December 2015. ·The applicant was granted a deferment in her course of study from 25 January 2016 until 30 June 2016 (Tf: 116).·The applicant advised the Tribunal she was told enrolment could not be completed because the relevant clinical placement was not available before January 2017. At paragraph 30 of her written submission the applicant advised “…this period of non-enrolment [July 2016 until December2016/January 2017] coincided with the period of time in which Ms Kaur was advised by her education provider she could not re-enrol dud to the availability of course offerings organised by the education provider…” The Tribunal has considered this submission. The Tribunal notes that notwithstanding this assertion the education provider forwarded an application for enrolment in July 2016 for enrolment in a Diploma of Nursing and the applicant acknowledged receipt of same. The applicant did not complete this offer of enrolment. The Tribunal notes further the applicant had the opportunity at all relevant times to seek enrolment for a limited period or in a limited number of subjects relating to clinical placement at other institutions in the medical field. The Tribunal notes the applicant at all relevant times had the opportunity to progress her studies in other subjects that would be covered by later enrolment in a Diploma or Bachelor degree. The Tribunal gives minor weight to this assertion of the applicant.·The applicant advised the Tribunal she attended her GP on 19 May 2016. The applicant provided a copy of a medical certificate dated 19 May 2016 that stated “[the applicant] is pregnant and awaiting to deliver her baby on 26/05/2016. She feels that mentally and physically she will not be able to start her studies by July and also she planning to exclusively breast feed her baby.” The Tribunal turns to consider this claim and consequent comment by the medical practitioner. The Tribunal notes the applicant advised her medical practitioner as early as May 2016 that she would not be able to start her studies by July 2016. The medical practitioner did not state she would not be able to start her studies. The medical practitioner repeated the comments of the applicant. The medical practitioner did not outline or confirm the applicant’s comments that she was “medically and physically” [unable] to start her studies by July. The medical certificate did not state the applicant would be unfit for any reason to commence her studies in July 2016. The Tribunal is unable to give this medical certificate much weight.·The applicant gave birth to her child on 30 May 2016 following a caesarean section. She provided a medical certificate dated 6 February 2017 (Tf: 114). This medical certificate stated she had a caesarean section and wound infection and attended for care for this on 4 July [no year given]. The medical certificate stated this “made her recovery delayed-and prevented her from attending usual studies from July. She breast fed her child and couldn’t attend the study from July till December for the above reasons”. The Tribunal turns to consider this medical certificate. The medical practitioner does not provide his or her reasons as to why her recovery was delayed. The medical certificate does not draw a causal relationship between her attendance on 4 July and delayed recovery to such an extent that it prevented her from studying for a period of more than 6 months. The medical certificate is dated 6 February 2017 almost 7 months after the relevant appointment. This date in time is significant as it is not contemporaneous with the medical visit and does not refer to medical notes or file notes from the then treating medical practitioner stating she should or could not attend for studies in this period. The Tribunal notes the medical certificate provided by the applicant does not state the applicant would not be able to commence her studies in July 2016 because of her caesarean section and subsequent wound infection or for any other reason. The medical certificate did not outline the period of the “recovery delayed”. A medical certificate is generally based upon a patient’s medical history. The Tribunal expressly asked the applicant if she could provide any contemporaneous medical opinion or medical notes that advised the after effects of her operation might cause her to be unfit or unable to study in the second half of 2016. In evidence the applicant advised the Tribunal she could not. The documents provided by the applicant from Northern Hospital relating to her pre-birth, birth and post birth recommendations for treatment did not address an inability to study in the second half of 2016. ·The medical certificate of 6 February 2017 is not a contemporaneous document. It suffers from the shortcomings or deficiencies outlined immediately above. The Tribunal notes further at paragraph 34 below it has provided a summary of medical evidence provided pre-birth, at birth and post-birth and that this medical evidence was provided to Ms Kaur’s general practitioner on 6 June 2016. The records show that following her discharge, the applicant was visited by hospital staff on 3 June 2016 and 5 June 2016. Notes from these visits showed that the staff discussed a variety of matters relating to the health and welfare of the applicant and her child including ongoing education, treatment and care on matters such as pain relief, breastfeeding, diet and hygiene. ·This medical information does not record that Ms Kaur was advised to pause or cease her studies by hospital staff. The Tribunal is concerned the applicant has not provided a contemporaneous medical certificate issued between July 2016 and December 2016 relating to her caesarean section and subsequent wound infection that states she was unfit for study for a period of time up to seven months after the birth of her child. ·The Tribunal gives the medical certificate of 6 February 2017 some minor weight. It does this because it is not contemporaneous and not supported by other relevant medical evidence provided to the Tribunal by the applicant post the hearing.·The applicant advised she applied for a second deferment on 25 May 2016 (Tf: 66) and followed up this application for deferment via email and phone on 28 June 2016. The applicant advised her second application for deferment was rejected on 5 July 2016 as she did not have a current valid enrolment. Her education provider advised it was her responsibility to contact the Department and advise them of this development (Tf: 34). ·The applicant followed up this advice by trying to contact her education provider (Tf: 68, 117-122, 130) on several occasions. The applicant provided a copy of an application form dated 15 July 2016 for enrolment in a Diploma of Nursing in February 2017 and a Bachelor of Nursing in January 2018 (Tf: 69). The applicant advised she received a letter of offer from her education provider in August 2016 but she “accidentally deleted it” (Tf: 130). Following the making of further inquiries by the Tribunal (see below at paragraphs 26 and 27) a letter of offer addressed to the applicant dated 9 August 2016 was provided to the Tribunal (Tf: 106-108). The letter of offer set out conditions related to acceptance of the offer of enrolment. The applicant did not comply with these conditions relating to acceptance of the offer. Hence there was no acceptance of the offer of enrolment.·The Tribunal has considered the claim of the applicant that she attempted to enrol in July 2016 and continued this attempt in August/September 2016. See immediately below.·The applicant advised she attempted to pay her fees in August/September 2016 but was told by education provider officials she was an existing student and did not have to worry, and to come back in January 2017 to pay the fees and get a new COE (Tf: 129). The Tribunal attempted to obtain a statement from the relevant education provider officials that might confirm this assertion of the applicant (see paragraphs 22 to 27 below). The education provided responded to the Tribunal request in writing and provided “…a record of Ms Kaur’s interactions and request for deferral of studies for 2016”. In addition the education provider attached relevant supporting documentation for the period 15 July 2016 until 29 March 2017 (see paragraph 27 below). This independent evidence provided to the Tribunal by the education provider did not substantiate the claims of the applicant. The applicant did not pay course fees and a new COE was not issued by the education provider. The applicant advised the Tribunal she was told by two education provider officials in September 2016 when she visited campus “was an existing student” (Tf: 129) and the same education provider wrote to her on 15 July 2016 and advised she did not have a “valid enrolment for 2016” (Tf: 34). The Tribunal has considered in detail these two applicant claims of being an “existing student” and not having a “valid enrolment for 2016”. The Tribunal wrote to the education provider on 11 September 2019 at the request of the applicant seeking confirmation of these matters. The education provider provided a “record of Ms Kaur’s interactions” and relevant supporting documentation. This material did not provide any material that addressed the applicant’s claims of being an existing student. The Tribunal is concerned at the failure of the education provider to provide any evidence that substantiates the claim of the applicant that she was an existing student.·The Tribunal is satisfied the applicant attempted to some limited extent to pursue enrolment in the period 30 June 2016 until 18 January 2017. The applicant was not successful in those attempts. ·The Tribunal does not accept the applicant has provided sufficient proof of inability to study in the period July 2016 until December 2016. The Tribunal finds the applicant was not granted a deferment in her course of study from July 2016 until January 2017. The Tribunal finds the applicant was not enrolled in a course of study from July 2016 until January 2017.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Considering the circumstances as a whole, the Tribunal concludes that the visa should be cancelled.DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision to cancel the first named applicant’s Class TU visa. The Tribunal has no jurisdiction with respect to the other applicants.Mark BishopMemberATTACHMENTMigration Regulations 1994…Schedule 88202(1) The holder (other than the holder of a Subclass 560 (Student) visa who is an AusAID student or the holder of a Subclass 576 (AusAID or Defence Sector) visa) must meet the requirements of subclauses (2) and (3).(2)A holder meets the requirements of this subclause if:(a)the holder is enrolled in a registered course; or(b)in the case of the holder of a Subclass 560 or 571 (Schools Sector) visa who is a secondary exchange student — the holder is enrolled in a full time course of study or training.(3)A holder meets the requirements of this subclause if neither of the following applies:(a)the education provider has certified the holder, for a registered course undertaken by the holder, as not achieving satisfactory course progress for:(i)section 19 of the Education Services for Overseas Students Act 2000; and(ii)standard 10 of the National Code of Practice for Registration Authorities and Providers of Education and Training to Overseas Students 2007;(b)the education provider has certified the holder, for a registered course undertaken by the holder, as not achieving satisfactory course attendance for:(i)section 19 of the Education Services for Overseas Students Act 2000; and(ii)standard 11 of the National Code of Practice for Registration Authorities and Providers of Education and Training to Overseas Students 2007(4)In the case of the holder of a Subclass 560 visa who is an AusAID student or the holder of a Subclass 576 (AusAID or Defence Sector) visa — the holder is enrolled in a full-time course of study or training.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On the evidence before the Tribunal, the applicant was not enrolled in a registered course. Accordingly, the applicant has not complied with condition 8202(2).Consideration of the discretion to cancel the visaCondition 8202, as it applies in this case, is set out in the attachment to this decision. Relevantly, it requires that the applicant:·be enrolled in a registered course, or in limited cases, a full time course of study or training: 8202(2)·has not been certified by his or her education provider, as not achieving satisfactory course progress as specified: 8202(3)(a), and·has not been certified by his or her education provider, as not achieving satisfactory course attendance as specified: 8202(3)(b). In the present case, the applicant’s visa was cancelled on the basis the applicant was not enrolled in a registered course. The applicant provided a written submission that outlined the grounds of review as follows:·The applicant’s non-study period post cancellation cannot be held against her as she has held a visa without study rights (Tf: 73 [12]-[13])·When considering the applicant’s non-enrolment the fact that she was previously enrolled in a full-time course until she sought a deferment for medical reasons is a relevant factor (Tf: 73 [18])·The following factors are relevant to considering cancellation according to Ministerial Direction No. 61 (Tf: 73 [19]):a.The applicant’s education provider was accurately monitoring her course progress, was aware of her deferral and of her second deferral attempt; b.The applicant received an offer in July 2016. The letter of offer was not accepted. The appropriate COE was not issued.c.The applicant was issued with a letter of offer prior to receiving the NOICC;d.Exceptional circumstances affected the applicant’s study, including an unplanned pregnancy, birth, infection and post-infection as well as post-natal depression. The Tribunal notes the applicant did not provide any contemporaneous medical opinions, advice or notes that confirmed she suffered from post-natal depression after the birth of her child. The Tribunal notes further that the material provided pursuant to a Freedom of Information (FOI) request and summarised at paragraph 35 below does not contain any reference to post-natal depression;e.The applicant wishes to complete her studies in Australia. ·The Tribunal is able to consider any claims put forward by the applicant, is not bound by the Department’s Procedures Advice Manual and is able to go beyond these factors in the exercise of its discretion (Tf: 72 [21]-[22]).Duty to inquire In MIAC v SZIAI (2009) 259 ALR 429 the High Court of Australia (HCA) gave consideration to the duty of the Tribunal to make further inquiries. The HCA observed the Tribunal is under no general duty to obtain information and as a general principle it is difficult to see any basis upon which a failure to inquire could constitute a breach of procedural fairness, at: [25]-[26]. The Tribunal may ordinarily decide a review on what the applicant puts forward.