Kaur and Australian Skills Quality Authority (Practice and procedure)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Kaur and Australian Skills Quality Authority (Practice and procedure) [2025] ARTA 491 (2 May 2025)

Applicant:Sandeep KAUR

Respondent:  AUSTRALIAN SKILLS QUALITY AUTHORITY

Tribunal Number:                2024/10803

Tribunal:General Member Darian-Smith

Place:Sydney

Date:2 May 2025  

Decision:1. The Tribunal refuses the Applicant’s application for an order under s.32(2) of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth) staying the operation or implementation of the decision of the Respondent dated 13 December 2024.

2. The interim stay order made on 23 December 2024 is discharged.

..............................[SGD]..........................................

General Member Darian-Smith

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for stay of decision to cancel a VET provider’s qualifications obtained from a deregistered RTO – factors relevant to the grant of a stay – prospects of success – consequences for applicant of refusal of a stay – the public interest – application for stay order refused.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s.41
Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth) s. 32
Education Services of Overseas Students Act 2000 (Cth) s.83
National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (Cth) ss. 36, 39, 56, 58, 199

Cases

Bayahow and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2025] ARTA 176
Beezley v Repatriation Commission (2015) 68 AAR 23
Birdseye and Tax Practitioners Board [2020] AATA 1250
Ekeh and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2025] ARTA 264
Greenfield Education Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2018] AATA 4210
McNamara; Secretary, Department of Social Services [2016] AATA 189
Rozario and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2025] ARTA 241
Scott and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798
Site Skills Group and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2019] AATA 1870

Statement of Reasons

  1. The Applicant (Ms Kaur) is a former student of Gills College Australia Pty Ltd (Gills College), which during the time she was a student was a registered vocational education and training (VET) provider under the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act2011 (Cth) (NVR Act).

  2. Ms Kaur obtained the qualification CHC 43015 Certificate IV in Ageing Support (Qualification) from Gills College, issued in 2023.

  3. On 20 November 2024, the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the Respondent (ASQA), acting in her role as the National VET Regulator, made the decision to cancel Gills College’s registration as a VET provider, under ss. 36(2)(f) and 39 of the NVR Act,[1] and as an overseas provider under section 83(3)(c) of the Education Services of Overseas Students Act 2000 (Cth)[2], effective from 21 November 2024.

    [1] T7, T-documents, pages 51 – 57.

    [2] T8, T-documents, pages 58 - 62.

  4. On 16 December 2024, the CEO of ASQA, acting in her role as the National VET Regulator, made the decision to cancel the Qualification, under s.56 of the NVR Act, effective on 20 December 2024 (Reviewable Decision).[3]

    [3] T2, T-documents, pages 16 - 27.

  5. The Reviewable Decision was based on findings, and evidence, that Gills College had not provided the training and assessment necessary to ensure that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kaur and Australian Skills Quality Authority (Practice and p... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 491
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Ms Kaur, sought a stay of the decision by the Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA) to cancel her vocational education and training (VET) provider’s qualifications obtained from a deregistered Registered Training Organisation (RTO). The matter was heard and determined by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The crux of the dispute was whether the Tribunal should grant a stay of the decision to cancel Ms Kaur's qualifications, which would effectively halt the implementation of the decision until the merits of the review were determined. This decision would have significant implications for Ms Kaur's employment and livelihood, as she had expressed concerns about losing her job if the qualifications were revoked.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were centered on the factors relevant to the grant of a stay, as outlined by Downes J. in Scott. These factors included the prospects of success on the merits, the consequences for Ms Kaur of a refusal of a stay, the public interest, and other relevant matters. The Tribunal had to assess whether Ms Kaur had provided sufficient evidence to satisfy these criteria and whether a stay was desirable for ensuring the effectiveness of the review. The Tribunal needed to consider whether the applicant had demonstrated a reasonable chance of success in the review, the potential impact on Ms Kaur’s employment and personal circumstances if the stay was not granted, and the broader public interest in upholding the integrity of the VET sector.

The Tribunal found that while Ms Kaur had provided some evidence of her employment and personal circumstances, the weight of the evidence suggested that the cancellation of her qualifications was justified based on the deficiencies in the training and assessment practices at Gills College. The Tribunal noted that the findings against Gills College were systemic and not specific to Ms Kaur. Furthermore, the evidence indicated that Ms Kaur’s current employers would not be significantly impacted by the cancellation of her qualifications. The Tribunal concluded that the public interest in maintaining the standards of VET providers and ensuring that qualifications reflect the required skills and knowledge outweighed Ms Kaur's personal circumstances and the potential consequences of a refusal of a stay. Consequently, the Tribunal determined that a stay was not desirable in this case.

In light of the above, the Tribunal refused the application for a stay of the decision to cancel Ms Kaur's qualifications. The Tribunal found that the prospects of success on the merits were low, the consequences for Ms Kaur were not significant enough to warrant a stay, and the public interest in upholding the standards of VET qualifications was paramount. The Tribunal's decision was based on a balanced consideration of all relevant factors and the evidence presented by both parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The 6 factors listed by Downes J. in Scott are as follows: (a) The prospects of success. (b) The consequence for the applicant of the refusal of a stay. (c) The public interest. (d) The consequences for the respondent in carrying out its functions depending upon whether a stay is granted or not. (e) Whether the application for review would be rendered nugatory if a stay were not granted; and (f) Other matters that are relevant.[10][10] [2009] AATA 798, [4].EVIDENCE AND SUBMISSIONS AT HEARING In exercising its discretion when determining whether a stay is desirable for ensuring the effectiveness of the review, the Tribunal must have a proper evidentiary basis for being satisfied that a stay is “desirable”. The explanation for this requirement is to be found in Beezley v Repatriation Commission[11], where the Full Court of the Federal Court stated: “In any case before a merits review tribunal (or a first instance decision-maker), a decision can only be made on the basis of relevant and probative material. The material must be probative of the matters for which the statute provides: see Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Pochi (1980) 44 FLR 41 per Deane J. If an applicant does not provide evidence and information sufficient to meet the statutory requirements, an applicant is unlikely to have the statutory power exercised in her or his favour. And unless and until a decision-maker is satisfied, or persuaded, that the requirements are met, then no occasion to exercise the power in favour of an applicant arises. In that sense, as a practical matter, it is not incorrect to say that a person “must satisfy” the requirements in the statute.”[12][11] (2015) 68 AAR 23.[12] (2015) 68 AAR 23, [68]. While Ms Kaur does not bear a formal legal burden of proof to adduce the evidence necessary to support her stay application, the authorities point to the fact that it is the applicant who bears the practical burden of proof if the Tribunal is to exercise its power to grant a stay order.[13][13] See for example McNamara v Secretary, Department of Social Services [2016] AATA 189, [12]. In her Request for a Stay Order, Ms Kaur included a ground for the request in the following terms: “If the decision comes into effect on 20 December 2024 and my qualification is revoked, I risk losing my job and livelihood at a time of year where finding a new job is impossible.”[14][14] T1, T-documents, page 12. In the event, Ms Kaur’s worst fears in respect of her paid employment were not realised. She remains in paid employment but has provided very limited evidence herself to the Tribunal as to the impact of the Reviewable Decision upon her employment situation. The Sibley Affidavit has a series of exhibits in which the evidence identified or obtained by ASQA’s solicitors which is relevant to Ms Kaur’s employment has been assembled. The Tribunal notes the following points: (a) Ms Kaur confirms on 21 January 2025 that she is employed at an aged care facility, Frank Whiddon Masonic Homes of NSW (Whiddon). Ms Kaur says that the Qualification is “crucial for this field of employment.” Ms Kaur states that her personal circumstances, being a single mother with 2 children, makes it very difficult for her to re-do the certificate study and the cancellation of the Qualification has added to her stress. Ms Kaur also refers to her certificate work placement of 120 hours, and some ongoing employment at the Royal Freemasons Benevolent Institute Bathurst Masonic Village (Royal).[15] (b) A letter of employment from the Royal dated 7 February 2023, confirms that Ms Kaur completed 120 hours placement at the Royal as part of her obtaining the Qualification and that she has been a casual employee at the Royal since 7 August 2023. There is also a payslip from Whiddon dated 20 February 2025 confirming her total gross pay for the financial YTD as being $51,437.08.[16] (c) Ms Kaur confirms that she is the sole provider for a family of 5, that her mother who was living with them has had to return to India to satisfy her visa conditions, that caring for her children in the absence of her mother and going to work leaves her unable to re-do the Qualification and she has been “very stressed” by the Reviewable Decision.[17] (d) Two file notes of telephone discussions between Mr Duldig (employed by Clayton Utz, ASQA’s solicitors) and Ms Paige Kildare of Royal confirm that Ms Kaur works a maximum of once a month at the Royal and that this casual employment would need to cease if the Qualification was cancelled, as the Royal requires its employees to hold at least a Certificate III qualification.[18] and (e) A file note of a telephone discussion between Mr Duldig and Ms Sharnie Leeson of Whiddon in which Ms Leeson confirms that Ms Kaur will be able to continue her current employment even if she did not hold the Qualification and that there were no issues with her performance in her current role.[19][15] Sibley Affidavit, annexure “CGS-1”.[16] Sibley Affidavit, annexure “CGS-2”.[17] Sibley Affidavit, annexure “CGS-5”.[18] Sibley Affidavit, annexures “CGS-6” and “CSG-7”.[19] Sibley Affidavit, annexure “CGS-8”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 16 December 2024, the CEO of ASQA, acting in her role as the National VET Regulator, made the decision to cancel the Qualification, under s.56 of the NVR Act, effective on 20 December 2024 (Reviewable Decision).[3][3] T2, T-documents, pages 16 - 27. The Reviewable Decision was based on findings, and evidence, that Gills College had not provided the training and assessment necessary to ensure that students at Gills College, including Ms Kaur, had the skills and knowledge necessary to be awarded a VET qualification. The findings, and evidence, in question were: “(a) Gills College did not implement a training and assessment strategy to enable each student to meet the requirements for each unit of competency in which they enrolled. (b) Gills College did not have sufficient facilities, whether physical or virtual, and equipment to accommodate and support the number of learners undertaking the training and assessment at each delivery location. (c) Gills College did not demonstrate it had a system in place to ensure all trainers and assessors were suitable qualified or experienced. (d) Gills College did not implement an assessment system that ensured assessment complied with the requirements of the relevant training package and is conducted in accordance with the principles of assessment and rules of evidence. (e) Gills College did not conduct adequate assessment or ensure that only students who have fully demonstrated competence against all training package requirements have been issued with certification and captured consistent and accurate information about students and training outcomes. In addition: (f) Students had been issued certification via recognition of prior learning (RPL) although the provider denied having conducted any RPL assessment during the period of issuance. (g) Students denied they had studied with the provider at all, although the provider’s student management system said it had issued certification to the students. (h) Students completed qualifications via RPL and said they had not attended classes or undertaken a work placement and were told by the provider it was not necessary to attend classes.”[4][4] T2, T-documents, pages 22 - 27. The findings and evidence in sub-paragraphs (f), (g) and (h) were generic to the body of Gills College students who had been awarded VET qualifications and were not said by ASQA to necessarily be applicable in Ms Kaur’s case. On 23 December 2024, Ms Kaur applied for review of the Reviewable Decision.[5] She also applied for a stay of the Reviewable Decision under s.32(2) of the Administrative ReviewTribunal Act 2024 (Cth) (ART Act).[6][5] T1, T-documents, pages 1 - 10. The Reviewable Decision is a reviewable decision under s. 199 of the NVR Act.[6] T1, T-documents, pages 11 - 14. On 23 December 2024, the Tribunal ordered that the Reviewable Decision be stayed on an interim basis until 17 January 2025 (interim stay order). The interim stay order was extended on 17 January 2025 until 30 January 2025. It was further extended on 30 January 2025 until 15 April 2025 and on 15 April 2025 until the date of the publication of Reasons for Decision on the stay application, or until further order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.