QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CITATION:
Katiza v Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes [2025] QCAT 305
PARTIES:
SARAH REBECCA KATIZA
(applicant)
v
MURPHY BUILDERS QLD PTY LTS T/AS MURPHY HOMES (respondent)
APPLICATION NO/S:
BDL277-20
MATTER TYPE:
Building matters
DELIVERED ON:
11 August 2025
HEARD AT:
Brisbane
DECISION OF:
Member Carrigan
ORDERS:
1. The Tribunal agrees to an extension of time in accordance with the Application for miscellaneous matters filed by Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes and directs that the time for filing of any Applications and/or submissions for costs in these proceedings is extended to 4 March 2025.
2. The Tribunal makes the following Orders in respect of the rectification works;
(a) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is responsible for carrying out and completing the rectification works in accordance with the contractual documents between the parties including the Geotechnical Report from Mr Andrew Middleton of 19 December 2022;
(b) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is to commence rectification work for the Geotechnical issues on the northern and southern batters and the architraves and windows within four (4) weeks of the date of these Orders and will complete all of those rectification works within a further period of four (4) weeks.
(c) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is to obtain and retain the services of Mr Andrew Middleton prior to commencement of the rectification work and also in accordance with these terms;
(i) the services provided by Mr Andrew Middleton are to supervise and to provide certification of compliance by Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes in undertaking and completing the rectification works in accordance with the contract between the parties including all relevant geotechnical and engineering requirements.
(ii) the services to be provided by Mr Andrew Middleton are at Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes sole cost. Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is solely responsible for all costs, fees and charges of Mr Andrew Middleton relating to his engagement and performance of duties in carrying out and discharging the obligation to provide supervision and certification of compliance with the rectification work.
(iii) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is to obtain an appropriate certificate of compliance (in a form to be decided by Mr Andrew Middleton) showing that the rectification work has been completed and that there is compliance with the contractual requirements and with relevant geotechnical and engineering requirements.
(iv) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is to obtain a certificate in respect of the completion of the rectification works to the architraves and window that require the rectification.
(v) any certificate issued by Mr Andrew Middleton shall be final and conclusive proof of compliance with the rectification works and has binding legal effect on Sarah Rebecca Katiza and Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes.
(vi) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is to give to Mr Andrew Middleton…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Katiza v Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] QCAT 305
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Tribunal included determining whether Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes was liable for the building defects, and if so, what specific rectification works were required under the contract. Additionally, the Tribunal had to address procedural matters, such as the extension of time for filing applications and submissions, and the costs associated with the proceedings.
The Tribunal found that Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes was responsible for the building defects and ordered the company to undertake specific rectification works. The Tribunal issued detailed directions regarding the rectification process, including timelines, the engagement of a geotechnical expert, and the terms under which the rectification works must be carried out. Furthermore, the Tribunal extended the time for filing applications and submissions and dismissed the applications for costs by both parties.
In summary, the Tribunal ruled that Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes must complete the necessary rectification works within specified timelines, engage the services of a geotechnical expert, and adhere to strict procedural requirements for carrying out the works. The Tribunal also dismissed the applications for costs from both parties, thereby concluding the proceedings on the terms outlined in the orders.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The Tribunal agrees to an extension of time in accordance with the Application for miscellaneous matters filed by Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes and directs that the time for filing of any Applications and/or submissions for costs in these proceedings is extended to 4 March 2025.
2. The Tribunal makes the following Orders in respect of the rectification works;
(a) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is responsible for carrying out and completing the rectification works in accordance with the contractual documents between the parties including the Geotechnical Report from Mr Andrew Middleton of 19 December 2022;
(b) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is to commence rectification work for the Geotechnical issues on the northern and southern batters and the architraves and windows within four (4) weeks of the date of these Orders and will complete all of those rectification works within a further period of four (4) weeks.
(c) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is to obtain and retain the services of Mr Andrew Middleton prior to commencement of the rectification work and also in accordance with these terms;
(i) the services provided by Mr Andrew Middleton are to supervise and to provide certification of compliance by Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes in undertaking and completing the rectification works in accordance with the contract between the parties including all relevant geotechnical and engineering requirements.
(ii) the services to be provided by Mr Andrew Middleton are at Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes sole cost. Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is solely responsible for all costs, fees and charges of Mr Andrew Middleton relating to his engagement and performance of duties in carrying out and discharging the obligation to provide supervision and certification of compliance with the rectification work.
(iii) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is to obtain an appropriate certificate of compliance (in a form to be decided by Mr Andrew Middleton) showing that the rectification work has been completed and that there is compliance with the contractual requirements and with relevant geotechnical and engineering requirements.
(iv) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is to obtain a certificate in respect of the completion of the rectification works to the architraves and window that require the rectification.
(v) any certificate issued by Mr Andrew Middleton shall be final and conclusive proof of compliance with the rectification works and has binding legal effect on Sarah Rebecca Katiza and Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes.
(vi) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is to give to Mr Andrew Middleton a copy of these Directions prior to the commencement of the rectification works.
(vii) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is to give written notice to Sarah Rebecca Katiza prior to the commencement of the rectification works that it has secured the retention of Mr Andrew Middleton for the purposes of these rectification works on the basis set out above.
(viii) in the event that the services of Mr Andrew Middleton are not able to be obtained or retained to provide the services referred to above, then both parties have liberty to apply to the Tribunal for the appointment of an appropriate person as an independent expert to carry out the services referred to above in lieu of Mr Andrew Middleton.
(d) all rectification work is to be undertaken between the hours of 9.00 am and 5.00 pm Monday to Friday (inclusive). (the Work Hours) No other rectification work outside of those hours should be undertaken.
(e) access to Sarah Rebecca Katiza’s property for carrying out rectification work is on these terms;
(i) subject to the Work Hours terms, Sarah Rebecca Katiza is to allow Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes including its employees, workmen and contractors access to those parts of Sarah Rebecca Katiza’s property required for rectification work and which access is to include access roads and areas for setting up for the rectification work, an area for stock piling any materials or parking of vehicles and or machinery necessary for the works and any other necessary ancillary area to undertake rectification work.
(ii) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes, it’s employees, workmen and contractors directly associated with the rectification works are only to access those areas of Sarah Rebecca Katiza’s property required for the rectification works during the Work Hours terms for the period of the rectification works. There should be no unauthorised entry to those areas of the Applicants property which are not directly or indirectly required for the rectification work.
(iii) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes must give prior written notification to Sarah Rebecca Katiza of the dates on which it will commence rectification works and will also give prior written notice when Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes, it’s employees, workmen or contractors will be on site including identifying the individual persons involved by name.
(iv) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes must give prior written notice to Sarah Rebecca Katiza details of the foreman on site or other responsible person for supervision of the rectification works and who is to be the contact person of Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes while the rectification works are taking place. That written notification is to include the name of the foreman or the responsible person including contact details such the email address of that person for the purposes of the rectification work.
(f) Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is to comply with the insurance provisions, if any, in the contract between the parties during the period of the rectification works.
(g) On completion of the rectification work, Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes is to “Make Good” the site of the rectification works and any other areas of Sarah Rebecca Katiza’s property used in the course of the rectification works.
3. Pursuant to s 77 of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) the Tribunal will make no order as to costs other than to dismiss the Application for costs by Sarah Rebecca Katiza and by Murphy Builders Qld Pty Ltd t/as Murphy Homes.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.