Kartinyeri v Woolworths (South Australia) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Civil)

KARTINYERI v WOOLWORTHS (SOUTH AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Perry, The Honourable Justice Bleby and The Honourable Justice Gray)

9 June 2004

TORTS - NEGLIGENCE - ESSENTIALS OF  ACTION FOR NEGLIGENCE - DUTY OF CARE - REASONABLE FORESEEABILITY OF DAMAGE - PARTICULAR CASES - DUTY OF OCCUPIER

TORTS - NEGLIGENCE - ESSENTIALS OF  ACTION FOR NEGLIGENCE - STANDARD OF CARE - PARTICULAR PERSONS AND SITUATIONS

The appellant, a customer in the respondent's supermarket, was injured when she slipped on foodstuffs which had been spilled on the floor - her claim for damages in the District Court was dismissed - held on appeal that the respondent was negligent in failing to take adequate measures to prevent spillage of foodstuffs and in failing to provide matting or take other steps to prevent customers from slipping - observations as to duty of care owed by occupiers of premises - appeal allowed.

Brady v Girvan Bros Pty Ltd (1986) 7 NSWLR 241; Drakos v Woolworths (SA) Ltd (1991) 56 SASR 431; Kelly v Lease Retail Pty Ltd (1993) Aust Torts Reports 81-216; Griffin v Coles Myer (1991) Aust Torts Reports 68,997; Drotem Pty Ltd v Manning [2000] NSWSC 320; Tubemakers of Australia Ltd v Fernandez (1976) 10 ALR 303; Chapman v Hearse (1961) 106 CLR 112; Fitzgerald v Penn (1954) 91 CLR 208, considered.

LIMITATION OF ACTIONS - CONTRACTS, TORTS AND PERSONAL ACTIONS - THE PERIOD OF LIMITATION

The appellant's proceedings were issued out of time - pursuant to s 48 of the Limitation of Actions Act 1936 (SA) she sought an extension of the applicable 3 year limit - the trial judge held that her receipt of a medical report furnished within a year before the institution of the proceedings disclosing a 20 per cent permanent loss of function of the lumber spine, constituted the ascertainment of a material fact within the meaning of the section and the discretion to extend time should be exercised in her favour - on appeal, consideration of the relevant principles - notice of cross-contention challenging the extension of time dismissed.

Limitation of Actions Act 1936 (SA) s 48(3)(b), referred to.
Pomeroy v Thwaites Witham Pty Ltd (2001) 79 SASR 489; Henrick v Agnew (1998) 26 MVR 277; Sydney City Council v Zegarac (1997-98) 43 NSWLR 195; Mason v Murray's Charter Coaches and Travel Services Pty Ltd (1998) 159 ALR 45; Paramasivam v Flynn (1999) 160 ALR 203; Kinnas v Petricca (1999) 28 MVR 539; Holt v Wynter (1999-2000) 49 NSWLR 128; Napolitano v Coyle (1997) 15 SASR 559, considered.

KARTINYERI v WOOLWORTHS (SOUTH AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD
[2004] SASC 172

Full Court:      Perry, Bleby and Gray JJ

  1. PERRY J               The relevant facts are set out in the reasons for judgment of Gray J.

  2. I agree with the conclusion reached by him on the issue of liability, for substantially the reasons which he…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kartinyeri v Woolworths (South Australia) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SASC 172
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Kartinyeri v Woolworths (South Australia) Pty Ltd, the appellant, Ms Kartinyeri, sought damages for injuries she sustained in a supermarket operated by the respondent, Woolworths. Ms Kartinyeri slipped on foodstuffs that had been spilled on the floor, leading to her claim for damages, which was initially dismissed by the District Court. On appeal, the court found that Woolworths was negligent in not taking sufficient measures to prevent the spillage of foodstuffs and in not providing matting or other steps to prevent customers from slipping. The court's decision addressed the standard of care owed by occupiers of premises and the particular circumstances of the case.

The legal issues before the court involved the essentials of the action for negligence and the standard of care owed by Woolworths in this specific situation. The court had to determine whether Woolworths breached their duty of care by not taking adequate measures to prevent the spillage and subsequent slipping hazard. The court also needed to consider the extent to which the loss of Woolworths' file and the unavailability of sweep logs prejudiced their ability to defend the claim.

The court's reasoning focused on the duty of care owed by Woolworths as occupiers of the premises. It was established that Woolworths was aware of the potential risk posed by foodstuffs on the floor and had systems in place to address such issues. However, the court found that these measures were not sufficient to prevent the incident from occurring. The court also considered the prejudice to Woolworths due to the loss of their file and the unavailability of sweep logs. Despite these factors, the court found that the justice of the case required the grant of an extension of time, allowing Ms Kartinyeri to pursue her claim.

In conclusion, the appeal was allowed, and the decision of the District Court was overturned. The court found that Woolworths was negligent in failing to take adequate measures to prevent the spillage of foodstuffs and in not providing matting or other steps to prevent customers from slipping. The court's decision highlighted the importance of the duty of care owed by occupiers of premises and the need for adequate measures to prevent accidents in such situations.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ms Kartinyeri, a customer of Woolworths supermarket, was injured when she slipped on foodstuffs that had spilled on the floor. She reported the incident to Mr Robertson, the store manager, on an unspecified date prior to 24 November 1995. Woolworths subsequently made a computer entry about the incident on 24 November 1995, and it is probable that an injury notification form was attached to the computer record. Woolworths' practice was to keep the claim file open for three years after the date of the incident, and if nothing further had been heard, to then close the file. The file was to be retained for seven years. In the present case, Woolworths followed this practice. However, the system of retention of the closed files was inadequate. The files were stored in large cardboard boxes at warehouse premises, and a disaster occurred when the weight of the upper boxes caused the lower boxes to collapse. Files spilled, and not everything was neatly in place when an attempt was made to re-pack the files. Some files were broken up and not all files were found.

On receipt of a second letter of demand from Ms Kartinyeri's solicitor on 20 November 2001, a search was made for the old file but it could not be located. The precise date of the incident was not known, and it is probable that the relevant sweep logs had been subsequently misplaced or destroyed. Woolworths contended that it was prejudiced by the lack of sweep log records or records of investigations, the loss of its file due to delay in initiating proceedings, and the lack of any discernable date of the incident. It was asserted that had the time and date of the incident been known, the relevant sweep log might have indicated that the floor surrounding the salad bar area had been cleaned only moments earlier. However, the judge found that there was no prejudice to Woolworths in standing or falling on the evidence available from Mr Robertson, who was clear and definite about the systems in place.

The case of Kartinyeri v Woolworths (South Australia) Pty Ltd originated in the District Court of South Australia, where Ms Kartinyeri, a customer who slipped on foodstuffs spilled on the floor of Woolworths' supermarket, filed a claim for damages against the respondent. The District Court dismissed her claim, leading to an appeal to the Supreme Court of South Australia. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, finding that Woolworths was negligent in failing to take adequate measures to prevent the spillage of foodstuffs and in not providing matting or other steps to prevent customers from slipping. The case was further appealed to the Full Court of the Supreme Court, which upheld the appeal and confirmed the findings of negligence by Woolworths. Key procedural steps included the initial application to extend the limitation period, which was granted by the District Court judge, and subsequent appeals to the Supreme Court and Full Court. Throughout the appeals, the central issue remained the standard of care owed by Woolworths as an occupier of the premises, particularly in preventing spillages and ensuring customer safety.

Decision

Reasons for decision

PERRY J BLEBY J GRAY J
In Pomeroy v Thwaites Witham Pty Ltd[15] reference was made by this Court to the guidance provided by the High Court as to the test to be applied when considering extensions of time. The differing approaches of members of the court were then identified and discussed in detail. It was then observed:The decision in Brisbane South Regional Health Authority has been the subject of considerable judicial discussion. Attention has been drawn repeatedly to the different tests formulated by the court. At times, a preference for one or other test has been expressed. However the correct approach has not been settled. Most decisions since Brisbane South Regional Health Authority have reached the same conclusion on the application of either test. The remarks in Brisbane South Regional Health Authority were directed towards the Queensland legislation. It is important to address the legislation in question in any subsequent case.…the application of either test leads to the same conclusion in this matter. Although this is not the occasion to express a concluded view about the correct approach, I consider that when dealing with an application to extend time the overriding enquiry should be – can there be a fair trial? The South Australian legislative scheme supports such an approach as it leaves the court with an unfettered discretion once an applicant has met the qualifying condition.The ultimate question is – can there be a fair trial?[15] (2001) 79 SASR 489 at 506-507The Judge’s Conclusion The judge granted Ms Kartinyeri’s application. It was found that facts materially relevant to her case were not ascertained by her until some point of time occurring after the expiration of the period of limitation and that her action was instituted within twelve months after the ascertainment of those facts. These conclusions were not challenged on appeal. The judge then found that on balance, the justice of the case required the grant of an extension of time:The plaintiff has (or had) an arguable claim in respect of significant injury. If she is not permitted to pursue it, the hardship to her is obvious. Perhaps, if she cannot proceed here, she may be able to effect recovery from her first solicitor. It is not unlikely, but I do not know how the claim came to get out of time, though there is no evidence that it was attributable to fault of the plaintiff. From the defendant’s point of view, having to meet a claim it thought it had escaped is not relevant. I have found that the proved loss of its file, which might have contained relevant evidence or suggested avenues of inquiry, did not, on the facts of this case, give rise to prejudice. The passage of time and the fading of memories is not, in the absence of some special circumstance, a relevant prejudice. No known witness has forgotten, died, or gone missing. In the exercise of my judicial discretion, I think it just to extend time, and do so to the extent necessary.Submissions of Counsel In its notice of alternative contentions, Woolworths challenged this conclusion. It was asserted that the judge erred in evaluating the prejudice to Woolworths when allowing the application. Counsel submitted that sweep log records and other relevant material could not be located by Woolworths as it was unaware of the precise date of the incident and that the relevant sweep logs had been subsequently misplaced or destroyed. It was contended that Woolworths was prejudiced by the lack of sweep log records or records of investigations, the loss of its file due to delay in initiating proceedings and the lack of any discernable date of the incident. It was said that had the time and date of the incident been known, the relevant sweep log might have indicated that the floor surrounding the salad bar area had been cleaned only moments earlier.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: PERRY J, BLEBY J, GRAY J

Counsel for Ms Kartinyeri submitted that the justice of the case supported the extension order. There was a fair trial. The judge’s exercise of discretion was made having full regard to all relevant matters. Counsel further submitted that any records kept may have disclosed that the floor had not been cleaned for a substantial period. In the circumstances it was appropriate for the judge to attach little weight to this complaint.Consideration of the Issue The judge thoroughly reviewed the relevant facts. They can be summarised as follows. At an unspecified date prior to 24 November 1995 Ms Kartinyeri made a report about the incident to the store manager Mr Robertson. As a consequence Mr Robertson on 24 November 1995 made a computer entry about the incident. The judge concluded that it was probable Ms Kartinyeri made a report in writing to Woolworths on a company form with the assistance of Mr Robertson “wielding the pen”. The computer record indicated that Ms Kartinyeri had informed Mr Robertson that the incident occurred on 25 October 1995. The judge found that in accordance with Woolworth’s practice it was probable that an injury notification form would have been attached to the computer record. The judge concluded that a file would have been opened as the computer record generated a claim number. Records of Woolworths indicated that no payment had been made to an insurance assessor to investigate the claim. The judge concluded that it was probable that no assessor had been appointed. A solicitor representing Ms Kartinyeri wrote a letter of demand. This letter was met with a written denial from Woolworths on 13 October 1997. Nothing further happened for more than four years. On 20 November 2001 a further letter of claim was received from another solicitor acting for Ms Kartinyeri. In the meantime Woolworths had closed its file on 22 March 1999. Woolworth’s practice was to keep the claim file open three years after the date of the incident and if nothing further had been heard to then close the file. It was then the practice for those files to be retained for seven years. In the present case Woolworths followed this practice. However the system of retention of the closed files was inadequate. The judge concluded:In this case, the bulk of files became too much and it was decided to store the archive boxes in large cardboard furniture removalists’ boxes. These boxes had a note on the outside of the files they contained. They were then stored, several layers high, at warehouse premises. Inevitably, there was a disaster. The weight of the upper boxes caused the lower boxes to collapse. Files spilled. When, eventually, an attempt was made to sort out the mess and to re-pack files, not everything was neatly in place. Files were broken up and not all files were found.On receipt of the second solicitor’s letter of demand on 20 November 2001 a search was made for the old file but it could not be located. The judge then reasoned:If an exact time for the incident were known, the relevant sweep log might indicate that the floor was cleaned only moments earlier, which could be very relevant. It might record someone cleaning it up. In this case, the defendant’s computer record does not record a time, perhaps because that part of the claim/notification was not completed.But, of greater importance, there is great doubt whether the defendant even had the right day. Its original record was of 25.11.1995. The first solicitor’s letter, dated 2.10.1997, referred to an incident “on or about 20th August 1995”. At that time the sweep logs for August 1995 may have been obtainable, though that is not certain.The plaintiff’s second solicitor referred to that date when re-opening the claim by letter of 20.11.2001. It was at that stage that it was ascertained that the file was lost. Proceedings issued on 20.12.2001 again referred back to that date. Only in the course of the trial was application made to amend it to 6th October 1995.That date is a reconstruction. Neither the plaintiff, nor Ms Rigney actually recall the date. It is based on their shared recollection that the plaintiff gave her son a party on his second birthday on 20.9.1995. For that party, the plaintiff put up streamers and balloons, an activity she says she could not have performed in the months after the incident. Obviously, no sweep logs are available now for that date.…However, insofar as an inference adverse to the defendant might be open if it failed to call evidence available to it that its cleaning system was, in detail, actually in efficient operation, in the sense of proving specific sweepers and sweepings around the time of the incident, I find that that evidence is not reasonably available to it and will not make any adverse finding on that basis.The relevant evidence is evidence available from Mr Robertson, who was clear and definite about the systems in place. There is no prejudice to the defendant in standing or falling on that evidence.