Karpany v Aboriginal Housing Authority No. Dcadd-03-231

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

KARPANY V ABORIGINAL HOUSING AUTHORITY
[2003] SADC 123

Judge Trenorden
Civil

  1. The appellant has appealed against the order of the Residential Tenancies Tribunal (the Tribunal) made on 2 May 2003.  By that order, the respondent was entitled to possession of the premises at 89 Illyarrie Avenue, Surrey Downs on Friday 9 May 2003 subject to the condition that if the appellant failed to give up possession the order could be enforced by the Tribunal bailiff.

  2. The appellant seeks an order that “the order of the Residential Tenancies Tribunal made on 2 May 2003 be stayed, set aside or varied”.

  3. The appellant was neither present nor represented at the Tribunal hearing on 2 May 2003.  He did not receive notice of the order of the Tribunal until after 10am on Friday 9 May 2003.  On Monday 12 May 2003 the Tribunal’s order was enforced by the Tribunal bailiff, when the latter changed the locks on the premises.

  4. The appellant’s possessions remain at the premises and on 14 May 2003 it was agreed between the parties that the appellant’s possessions would not be removed from the premises until such time as the appeal had been resolved.

    Background

  5. One of the grounds of appeal was that the appellant did not receive notice of the Tribunal hearing on 2 May 2003 and therefore did not have an opportunity to be heard before the Tribunal made its order on that date.  The facts leading up to the hearing by the Residential Tenancies Tribunal appear to be as follows:

    ·The appellant together with Danelle Woods visited the offices of the respondent and spoke with Stephen Charles Callaghan there, on 14 March 2003.  At that stage the appellant had accumulated arrears of rent and maintenance fees of over $5,000.

    ·On 19 March 2003, Callaghan recommended eviction of the appellant from the premises, providing the following debt background details:

    “Mr Karpany has been continually in arrears.  Many arrangements have been made but not kept.  Mr Karpany did not attend the Debt Tribunal on 13/12/02.  He has failed to keep the Debt Tribunal Arrangement.  The Debt Tribunal now recommends eviction.”

    The amount of the current debt was shown as $5,264.75 as at 17/03/03 with the last payment of rent being shown as $100 on 7/03/03.

    ·The general manager of the respondent endorsed eviction on a date that appears, at first glance, to be 28 March 2003, but may be 20/3/03.

    ·A “notice to remedy breach of agreement and notice of termination” was sent to the appellant at the premises signed by the supervising recovery officer “for and on behalf of the Aboriginal Housing Authority” and dated 24 March 2003. 

    ·Between 20 March and about 25 March 2003, the appellant, in company with Danelle Woods and his mother Christine Abdulla visited the offices of the respondent and spoke with William Wade Allan (Allan) to discuss tenancy arrangements with respect to the premises and the respondent’s house in which Danelle Woods was a tenant.

    ·At this meeting Allan informed the appellant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Karpany v Aboriginal Housing Authority No. Dcadd-03-231 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SADC 123
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Karpany v Aboriginal Housing Authority[2003] SADC 123 was brought by the appellant, Karpany, against the order of the Residential Tenancies Tribunal (Tribunal) dated 2 May 2003, which entitled the respondent, Aboriginal Housing Authority, to possession of the premises at 89 Illyarrie Avenue, Surrey Downs on 9 May 2003. The appellant sought an order to stay, set aside, or vary the Tribunal’s order. The appellant did not attend or receive notice of the Tribunal hearing on 2 May 2003, and only received notice of the Tribunal's order after 10am on 9 May 2003. On 12 May 2003, the Tribunal’s order was enforced by the Tribunal bailiff, who changed the locks on the premises. The appellant's possessions remained at the premises, and on 14 May 2003, it was agreed between the parties that the appellant’s possessions would not be removed from the premises until the appeal had been resolved.

The main legal issues the court had to decide were whether the appellant's right to natural justice was violated by the Tribunal's failure to provide proper notice of the hearing and whether the appellant had a legitimate expectation that he would be personally notified of the Tribunal hearing. The court found that the notice of the Tribunal hearing was properly served according to the Residential Tenancies Act and the Rules, and that the appellant's claim of non-receipt did not prove non-delivery. The court also concluded that the appellant did not have a legitimate expectation that he would be personally notified of the Tribunal hearing, as the respondent's agent had merely conveyed information about the course the matter would take, without making any assurances.

The court dismissed the appeal, finding that there was no basis for setting aside the decision of the Tribunal and the orders made by it. The court emphasized that the appellant's evidence of non-receipt of a letter from the Tribunal advising of the hearing date did not amount to proof of non-delivery, and that the appellant did not have a case to put forward as he was unsure of the arrears he owed and the validity of the Notice of Termination/Notice to Remedy Breach of Agreement. The court also distinguished the case from Timms v SAHT, as the circumstances in this case were different, with notice being addressed to the appellant by his name at the subject premises.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established