Karnaghan and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

Administrative

Appeals

Tribunal

 

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2004] AATA 1275

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No A2002/436

VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION )
Re MITCHELL KARNAGHAN

Applicant

And

MILITARY REHABILITATION AND COMPENSATION COMMISSION

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal Mr S. Webb, Member

Date1 December 2004

PlaceCanberra

Decision

The decision under review is set aside and in substitution thereof the Tribunal decides that the liability of the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission to pay Mr Karnaghan compensation in relation to his previously accepted thoracolumbar and psychiatric injuries did not cease on 17 July 2002 and is presently ongoing. 

Mr Karnaghan is not entitled to payment of compensation for permanent impairment in relation to his thoracolumbar or psychiatric injuries at this time.

The Commission is to pay 50 percent Mr Karnaghan’s reasonable costs in these proceedings as agreed or taxed.

The matter is remitted to the Respondent to determine the amount of compensation, if any, that is payable to Mr Karnaghan consistent with these reasons.

..............................................

Mr S. Webb, Member

That determination denied liability for degenerative changes at the L1-L2 level in Mr Karnaghan’s lumbar spine.  However, on 1 August 2001, a delegate of the Commission determined to accept liability for those degenerative changes arising from or in the course of his military service (T56).

9.      On 27 September 2001 Mr Karnaghan lodged a claim for compensation in relation to “a depressive episode”, referred to as “Dysthymia with suicidal ideation” (T75).  On 29 January 2002 a delegate of the Commission determined to accept liability for dysthymic disorder arising out or or in the course of Mr Karnaghan’s military service (T87).

10.     Dr Whittaker examined Mr Karnaghan in May 2002 and diagnosed Mr Karnaghan to be suffering from a thoracocolumbar kyphoscoliosis that was unrelated to his military service (T104 and T105).

11.     On 17 July 2002 a delegate of the Commission determined to deny Mr Karnaghan’s claim for permanent impairment compensation in relation to his back and psychiatric conditions and also determined that “liability for your back and psychiatric conditions have now been ceased” (T106).

12.     On 26 August 2002 the Commission conducted an own motion reconsideration of the determination and decided to revoke that part of the determination which ceased liability in relation to dysthymic disorder (T109).

13.     On 8 November 2002, by request of Mr Karnaghan, the Commission reconsidered and decided to affirm the 17 July 2002 determination.  A reviewable decision was issued to that effect (T121).

14.     On 16 November 2002 Mr Karnaghan applied for review of the reviewable decision (T1).

issues for determination

15.     The Commission conceded and it was agreed that the primary determinations concerning the Commission’s acceptance of liability in relation to posterior facet joint degeneration at the T4-T12 and L1-L2 levels, ossification of the ligamenta flava, especially at T4/5, T5/6 and T8/9 and chronic thoracolumbar pain (“the compensable injuries”) (T46 and T56) were not in issue in these proceedings.  This Tribunal has no jurisdiction in relation to those determinations (see Comcare…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Karnaghan and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] AATA 1275
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Mr Karnaghan, sought to have the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (the Commission) pay him ongoing compensation for injuries he sustained during his military service, which the Commission had already accepted. The Commission denied his claim for ongoing compensation for thoracolumbar back conditions and dysthymic disorder, prompting Mr Karnaghan to appeal to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The AAT upheld the Commission's decision to deny liability for the back conditions and rejected Mr Karnaghan's claim for compensation for permanent impairment. The Federal Court reviewed the AAT's decision.

The central legal issue was whether the Commission was liable for ongoing compensation for Mr Karnaghan's injuries, which included both thoracolumbar back conditions and dysthymic disorder, and whether Mr Karnaghan was entitled to compensation for permanent impairment. The Court had to consider the appropriateness of the AAT's decision in light of the conflicting medical evidence and the principles governing compensable injuries under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988.

The Court found that the AAT had erred by concluding that the continuing effects of compensable injuries had ceased, and by failing to adequately consider the interplay between Mr Karnaghan's physical and psychiatric conditions. The Court observed that Mr Karnaghan's pain symptomatology had increased due to his psychiatric condition and that the effects of his compensable injuries had not ceased. The Court also determined that the AAT had correctly decided that Mr Karnaghan was not entitled to compensation for permanent impairment as the evidence did not support that his impairment was permanent. The Court set aside the AAT's decision regarding the denial of ongoing liability for the thoracolumbar back conditions and remitted the matter to the Commission to determine the amount of compensation payable.

The Court's orders were that the AAT's decision to deny ongoing compensation for Mr Karnaghan's thoracolumbar and psychiatric injuries was set aside. The Court found that the Commission's liability to pay compensation for these injuries was ongoing. The Court also confirmed that Mr Karnaghan was not entitled to compensation for permanent impairment. The Commission was ordered to pay 50% of Mr Karnaghan's costs in these proceedings, and the matter was remitted to the Commission to determine the amount of compensation, if any, that was payable to Mr Karnaghan.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision under review is set aside and in substitution thereof the Tribunal decides that the liability of the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission to pay Mr Karnaghan compensation in relation to his previously accepted thoracolumbar and psychiatric injuries did not cease on 17 July 2002 and is presently ongoing.

Mr Karnaghan is not entitled to payment of compensation for permanent impairment in relation to his thoracolumbar or psychiatric injuries at this time.

The Commission is to pay 50 percent Mr Karnaghan’s reasonable costs in these proceedings as agreed or taxed.

The matter is remitted to the Respondent to determine the amount of compensation, if any, that is payable to Mr Karnaghan consistent with these reasons.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established