Karamaroudis v Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld)
Link copied
CaseCopied
31 min read
Full text
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Karamaroudis v Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld) [2023] QCA 42
PARTIES:
TASO KARAMAROUDIS (appellant) v DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS (QLD) (respondent)
FILE NO/S:
Appeal No 10906 of 2022 SC No 9603 of 2022
DIVISION:
Court of Appeal
PROCEEDING:
General Civil Appeal
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court at Brisbane – Unreported, 18 August 2022 (Cooper J)
DELIVERED ON:
17 March 2023
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
22 November 2022
JUDGES:
Mullins P and Morrison and Dalton JJA
ORDERS:
1. The applications filed on 26 September 2022, 19 October 2022, 24 October 2022, 26 October 2022 and 18 November 2022, for leave to adduce further evidence and to rely on further affidavits, are refused.
2. Appeal dismissed.
CATCHWORDS:
CRIMINAL LAW – PROCEDURE – BAIL – REVOCATION, VARIATION, REVIEW AND APPEAL – where the appellant was charged with the unlawful stalking of the complainant – where the appellant was on bail in relation to that charge – where, at the time of the alleged offending, the appellant had lived in the same street as the complainant – where the complainant remained living in that street – where the special conditions of the appellant’s bail had been varied by a Magistrate to include a 300 metre exclusion zone around that street – where the appellant applied to the Supreme Court to have that special condition removed – whether the primary judge erred in finding that the appellant had not demonstrated that the bail condition was more onerous than is required to reduce the relevant risks under the Bail Act 1980 (Qld) to an acceptable level – whether the primary judge had applied the wrong section of the Bail Act 1980 (Qld) – whether the primary judge had failed to consider relevant evidence in assessing the appellant’s application – whether the appellant had been denied procedural fairness, natural justice and reasonableness due to actions of the primary judge
Bail Act 1980 (Qld), s 11(2), s 11(5), s 16, s 19B
The appellant appeared on his own behalf C W Wallis for the respondent
SOLICITORS:
The appellant appeared on his own behalf Director of Public Prosecutions (Queensland) for the respondent
MULLINS P: I agree with Morrison JA.
MORRISON JA: The appellant is presently charged with one count of unlawful stalking between 1 February 2018 and 25 March 2021. During a period of the alleged offending, the appellant lived at Duke Street in Cannon Hill.
The complainant also lived in that street and continues to do so.
The appellant was initially granted bail on 12 April 2021. That bail was granted subject to a number of conditions. One was that he have no contact with residents of Duke Street. Another was that he reside at a specified address in New Farm. Yet another was that he not attend the suburb of Cannon Hill.
On 22 April…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Karamaroudis v Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld) and more:
The appellant, Karamaroudis, appealed against the decision of the primary judge, who dismissed his application to have a 300-metre exclusion zone around his former street removed from his bail conditions. The appellant was charged with stalking and was on bail, with the special conditions including the exclusion zone. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The central legal issue was whether the primary judge erred in upholding the exclusion zone, finding that the appellant had not demonstrated that the bail condition was more onerous than required to reduce relevant risks under the Bail Act 1980 (Qld) to an acceptable level.
The court considered several arguments put forward by the appellant. Firstly, the appellant argued that he was denied procedural fairness due to the absence of certain USB sticks containing relevant material at the commencement of the hearing. However, the court found no error in the primary judge's handling of the material. The appellant had been informed that the material would be provided by the Magistrates Court and was given the opportunity to object and seek an adjournment. While some material was eventually provided, the appellant did not establish that this affected the outcome. The court held that there was no error of the kind that would allow the court to intervene.
The court also reviewed the appellant's arguments that the primary judge had applied the wrong section of the Bail Act 1980 (Qld) and had failed to consider relevant evidence. The court found that the primary judge had correctly applied the relevant sections of the Act and had adequately considered all the evidence presented. Additionally, the court rejected the appellant's claims of bias and procedural unfairness, finding no basis for these allegations.
Ultimately, the court dismissed the appeal, holding that the primary judge's decision was correct and that there were no grounds for the Court of Appeal to intervene. The applications for leave to adduce further evidence and to rely on further affidavits were also refused. The primary judge's decision to maintain the 300-metre exclusion zone around the appellant's former street as a condition of his bail was upheld.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The applications filed on 26 September 2022, 19 October 2022, 24 October 2022, 26 October 2022 and 18 November 2022, for leave to adduce further evidence and to rely on further affidavits, are refused.
2. Appeal dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Nothing has been shown that would lead to the conclusion that error of the kind in House v The King[34] affected that decision. There is no basis for this Court to intervene.[34](1936) 55 CLR 499; [1936] HCA 40.Applications to adduce further evidence and other affidavits Adopting the list of affidavits set out in paragraph [13] above, the contents of the affidavits can be summarised as follows:(a)in the Wynnum Magistrates Court: 17 September 2021; the appellant’s version of events concerning the stalking charge; submissions as to what the watchhouse video shows; allegations of police corruption; submissions about the complainant’s conduct; and complaints he made about police conduct;(b)in the Brisbane Magistrates Court:(i)10 November 2021; matters concerning a bail variation hearing on 1 November 2021; what the video footage shows of his arrest at the house, in the car on the way to the watchhouse and at the watchhouse; allegations of police corruption; (ii)21 January 2022; matters concerning a bail variation hearing on 1 November 2021; allegations of police corruption in bringing the charge, in court proceedings and in dealing with the appellant’s complaints; arguments about the significance of a statement in the stalking proceeding; arguments as to the lack of any basis to charge the appellant; allegations of misconduct by solicitors;(iii)25 March 2022; much the same sort of content as in the previous subparagraph; additionally, allegations of prosecutorial misconduct, and misconduct by other solicitors; further allegations of police corruption in relation to a different charge;(iv)11 April 2022; more argumentative allegations of police corruption; allegations as to unfairness by the Magistrates Court, and denial of procedural fairness; argumentative submissions as to what emails revealed about the complainant’s conduct; allegations about the conduct of the complainant and her husband; arguments about the committal;(v)30 May 2022; dealings between the appellant and the CCC; more allegations of police corruption; argumentative submissions about the basis for the stalking charge, and the complainant’s acts;(c)in the District Court: 4 April 2022; this affidavit was filed in proceedings the appellant brought against the Queensland Police Service, No. 768/22; the proceeding was an appeal from a Magistrate’s decision; the affidavit concerns the hearing before the Magistrate, and the appellant’s efforts to get information about what occurred and how to challenge the order; arguments as to the need for further applications by the appellant in relation to material allegedly withheld by police; allegations as to police corruption and the CCC response;(d)in the Supreme Court: (i)28 June 2022; this affidavit was filed in proceedings No. 7546/22 in the Supreme Court; the respondents in that proceeding are the Magistrates Court and the Queensland Police Service; it contains argumentative submissions as to: (i) the charge laid; (ii) alleged police corruption; (iii) allegations that the arresting officer was a criminal; (iv) the contents of the video footage at the watchhouse; (v) alleged misconduct by the Magistrate hearing the committal; and (vi) complaints about other proceedings before the Magistrates Court;(ii)23 September 2022; directed to the proceedings before the learned primary judge, and the material (USB sticks) missing from the file before the learned primary judge; allegations of fraud in that evidence was withheld from the court and the Magistrates Court; exhibited the material from the USB sticks and transcripts from previous hearings to vary the bail conditions; arguments about bias by a Magistrate, and “procedural fraud” in various courts;(iii)12 August 2022; this is an affidavit in support of the application for the bail review before the learned primary judge; it referred to and relied upon some of the affidavits filed in the Magistrates Court (subparagraphs (b)(i)-(v) above); set out the bail history and applications; lengthy arguments going to police misconduct in laying the charge and in the court proceedings thereafter; arguments as to the involvement of the CCC; arguments as to the quality of the evidence on which the charge were based;(iv)15 August 2022; this is an affidavit in support of the application for the bail review before the learned primary judge; it relied on the affidavit filed 12 August 2022 (subparagraph (iii) above); it exhibited an undertaking as to bail;(v)18 October 2022; exhibits a transcript of proceedings before a Magistrate on an application to vary the bail conditions;(vi)24 October 2022; exhibited the committal transcript and the USB sticks containing audio and video files concerned with the basis of the stalking charge;(vii)18 November 2022; directed to the conduct of committal proceedings against him in the Magistrates Court; complaints that a particular Magistrate has a bias against the appellant; his intention to file a complaint against that Magistrate; allegations of fraud by various persons in the court system; and assertions of a conspiracy against him;(e)the affidavits in support of leave to adduce further evidence, in the Supreme Court:(i)26 September 2022; refers to and urges receipt of the affidavit filed 23 September 2022 (subparagraph (d)(ii) above);(ii)18 October 2022; arguments as to proceedings in the Magistrates Court which might assist the Court of Appeal “in the event that it decides to consider or explore the handling of the application to strike a bail condition by the Magistrates Court on 4 August 2022”; much the same arguments as in subparagraph (iv) below;(iii)24 October 2022; seeks to rely on an affidavit going to “A Conspiracy to prejudice - a continuation of demonstrated Actual and apprehended bias against me, denial of procedural fairness, alleged protection of allegedly corrupt police officers, comments referring to non-existent statutes, comments referring to bizarre fictional legal principles and practices”; much the same content as in subparagraph (iv) below;(iv)18 November 2022; seeks to rely on the affidavit of 18 October 2022; arguments as to proceedings in the Magistrates Court which might assist the Court of Appeal “in the event that it decides to consider or explore the handling of the application to strike a bail condition by the Magistrates Court on 4 August 2022”; arguments as to a conspiracy and bias against him in the Magistrates Court; repeated arguments as to “procedural fraud” and a conspiracy by police to withhold evidence; lengthy repeated arguments as to proceedings before a Magistrate headed “A Conspiracy to prejudice - a continuation of demonstrated Actual and apprehended bias against me, denial of procedural fairness, alleged protection of allegedly corrupt police officers, comments referring to non-existent statutes, comments referring to bizarre fictional legal principles and practices”; urges that this Court rely on the USB sticks.
Decision
Reasons for decision
The third is found in s 19B, which was invoked by the appellant’s formal application before the learned primary judge. It relevantly provides:“19B Review of particular decisions(1)This section does not apply to the following decisions about release under this part—(a)a decision by the Supreme Court;(b)a decision under section 10(2);(c)a decision by a magistrate acting as a reviewing court under this section.(2)If a decision has been made about release under this part or the Youth Justice Act 1992, part 5, for a defendant, the defendant, complainant or prosecutor or a person appearing on behalf of the Crown may apply to the reviewing court for a review of the decision.(3)The reviewing court is—(a)for a decision by a police officer or justice who is not a magistrate—a Magistrates Court constituted by a magistrate; or(b)for any other decision—the Supreme Court constituted by a single judge.…(6)On the review, additional or substitute evidence or information may be given and the reviewing court may make any order it considers appropriate.(7)However, the orders that may be made under subsection (6) are limited by sections 13 , 16 , 16A and 17(1A) and, if the defendant is a child, the Youth Justice Act 1992, sections 48, 48AAA, 48AE and 48A.(8)The person or court that made the decision under review must give the reviewing court any documents in the person’s or court’s possession that may be relevant to the review.(9)The reviewing court must decide an application under this section as soon as is reasonably practicable.”Consideration It is convenient to consider the points advanced by the appellant in sequence, making reference where necessary to the applications to adduce further material or upon which reliance was placed by the appellant.Denial of procedural fairness – missing affidavit material The appellant contended that he was denied procedural fairness in the way the hearing was conducted before the learned primary judge. The central submission was, in summary:(a)the evidence on which the appellant was relying was not, in breach of statute, brought before the court for the commencement of the hearing;(b)when he objected, an adjournment was ordered, and at the re-commencement of the proceeding, some material was provided to the court by the Magistrates Court and marked as exhibits 1–6; however, the material did not include USB sticks which contained the relevant material on which he would be relying;(c)the appellant was not included as a party to receive the material, so he did not know when the hearing re-commenced, nor, during the course of the hearing, that the USB sticks were missing from the provided affidavits now marked as exhibits 2 and 3. At the commencement of the hearing below, it became apparent that affidavits upon which the appellant wished to rely were referred to in his affidavit in support of the bail review, but were not actually attached. The appellant explained to his Honour that:[7]“I was told that the registry - that they would be brought over from the Magistrates Court, and there is provision in the law for that to happen, I believe under - in the Bail Act there is provision for - for - it's actually law that such material be provided by, in this case, the Magistrates Court to the Supreme Court.”[7]AB 924 lines 9–13.