Karamanlidis v Nominal Defendant & Motor Accident Commission (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

District Court of South Australia

(Civil)

KARAMANLIDIS v NOMINAL DEFENDANT & MOTOR ACCIDENT COMMISSION  (No 2)

[2009] SADC 118

Judgment of His Honour Judge Beazley (ex tempore)

23 October 2009

PROCEDURE - COSTS

Costs - Motor vehicle accident - Plaintiff successful in proceedings against both defendants - finding that plaintiff unimpressive witness on issue of damages - procedural irregularities involving two sets of proceedings - Plaintiff seeks order for costs of action on party and party basis - Defendants submit that the plaintiff ought receive only a proportion of his costs to reflect procedural irregularities and issues upon which the plaintiff failed, or alternatively costs on the Magistrates Court scale to reflect the fact that eventual award less than half the jurisdiction limit of the Magistrates Court - Plaintiff entitled to costs of action on party and party basis on the District Court scale.

District Court Act 1991 s 42(1), referred to.
Cretazzo v Lombardi (1975) 13 SASR 4; Duke Group Ltd (in Liquidation) v Pilmer (No 8) (1998) SASC 6699; Robinson v Australian Association of Social Workers Limited (2000) 210 LSJS 73; Burnie Port Corporation Pty Ltd v Bank of Western Australia (No 3) (2003) 12 Tas LR 325; Ewins v BHP Billiton Ltd (No 2) [2005] SASC 164, applied.

KARAMANLIDIS v NOMINAL DEFENDANT & MOTOR ACCIDENT COMMISSION  (No 2)
[2009] SADC 118

Introduction

  1. On 16 October 2009 I published my reasons with respect to the issues of liability and quantum, and entered judgment for the plaintiff, in the sum of $38,804.64.

  2. I reserved the question of costs.

  3. The plaintiff now seeks an order that the defendants pay to him the costs of the action on a party/party basis. Mr Warren, who appeared as counsel for the plaintiff, acknowledged that there were some unusual procedural matters which might be best considered by a taxing Master in the event that the quantum of costs could not be agreed.  He identified those as:

    ·The fact that two sets of proceedings were issued, and that this may arguably have increased the initial costs of the defendants, and

    ·That potential conflicts for the plaintiff’s initial solicitors became apparent at an early stage, because they could not act for both the plaintiff and his wife.

    Additional evidentiary material

  4. The defendants tendered by consent an affidavit sworn by John Michael Ward on 22 October 2009. Mr Ward is the solicitor representing the Nominal Defendant.  In that detailed affidavit, he deposed to the history of the action, and set out in a chronological form, the relevant events since the date of the accident on 16 September 2003.

    Defendants submissions

  5. In their respective submissions, Mr Austin and Mr James counsel for the defendants. submitted that no general order for party/party costs ought to be made. Their submissions were wide ranging however can be distilled to four principal arguments.

    ·The first ground related to the fact that two sets of proceedings were issued.  The first set of proceedings was issued by the plaintiff and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Karamanlidis v Nominal Defendant & Motor Accident Commission... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SADC 118
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Karamanlidis v Nominal Defendant & Motor Accident Commission (No 2), the plaintiff, Karamanlidis, was successful in his proceedings against both the nominal defendant and the Motor Accident Commission. The dispute arose out of a motor vehicle accident, and the court was required to determine the appropriate award of damages as well as the costs associated with the proceedings. The Court of Appeal was tasked with deciding whether the plaintiff was entitled to the full costs of the action on a party and party basis or if the costs should be reduced due to procedural irregularities and the plaintiff's failure on certain issues.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff, Karamanlidis, was entitled to the full costs of the action on a party and party basis, considering the procedural irregularities and the finding that he was an unimpressive witness on the issue of damages. The defendants argued that the plaintiff should only receive a proportion of his costs due to the procedural irregularities and the fact that he failed on certain issues. Alternatively, the defendants submitted that the plaintiff should receive costs on the Magistrates Court scale, reflecting the fact that the eventual award was less than half the jurisdiction limit of the Magistrates Court.

The Court of Appeal held that the plaintiff was entitled to the full costs of the action on a party and party basis on the District Court scale. The court found that while there were procedural irregularities in the proceedings, these did not warrant a reduction in the plaintiff's costs. Furthermore, the court held that the plaintiff's credibility as a witness did not affect his entitlement to costs. The court also dismissed the defendants' argument that the plaintiff should receive costs on the Magistrates Court scale, finding that the District Court scale was more appropriate given the nature of the proceedings.

As a result of the court's decision, the plaintiff, Karamanlidis, was entitled to the full costs of the action on a party and party basis on the District Court scale. The court did not order any reduction in the plaintiff's costs due to procedural irregularities or the plaintiff's credibility as a witness. The defendants were ordered to pay the plaintiff's full costs of the action.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established