Kanochkin v Stark Investments Pty Ltd & Anor [2001] NTSC 81
PARTIES ANTHONY KANOCHKIN
v
STARK INVESTMENTS PTY LTD
and
ANOR
TITLE OF COURT SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA
JURISDICTION Interlocutory Application
FILE NUMBER 45/01(20102745)
DELIVERED 13 September 2001
HEARING DATE 30 August 2001
REASONS OF The Master
CATCHWORDS
PRACTICE – Northern Territory – subpoenas duces tecum – return date not a date for trial or a hearing – not necessary – not an appropriate stage of the proceeding
CASES REFERRED TO
FCT ex parte Swiss Aluminium 68 ALR 587
Giblin v Beach (unreported, Bailey J 2 August 2001)
Greyhound v Deluxe Coachlines 67 ALR 93
Lucas Industries v Hewitt 18 ALR 555
Mamone v Gagliadi (2000) NTSC 1967
REPRESENTATION
Counsel:
Plaintiff Mr Priestley
1st Defendant Mr McConnel
2nd Defendant Mr Grove
Solicitors:
Plaintiff Priestleys
1st Defendant Morgan Buckley
2nd Defendant Ward Keller
Judgment category classification
Judgment ID number mas021
Number of pages 3
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN
45/01(20102745)
Between:
ANTHONY KANOCHKIN
Plaintiffand
STARK INVESTMENTS PTY LTD
and
BOVIS LEND LEASE PTY LTD
Defendants
MASTER COULEHAN: REASONS FOR DECISION
(Delivered 13 September 2001)
[1] In this proceeding the plaintiff claims damages for personal injuries suffered as a result of a fall. He claims to have suffered injuries to various parts of the body, but the statement of claim contains no particulars of these injuries. The second defendant has joined issue as to the allegations of injury. The first defendant has not filed a defence. There does not appear to have been discovery of documents.
[2] The second defendant has filed and served subpoenas directed to the Territory Health Service, the Work Health Authority and St John Ambulance to produce medical records relating to the plaintiff and the accident the subject of this proceeding. Documents have been delivered into the custody of the Court in each case and the parties seek inspection. The plaintiff does not object to the defendants inspecting the documents, presumably, subject to any claims for privilege.
[3] O.42.02 provides:
“(1) In a proceeding the Court may, by subpoena, order that a person named attend at the trial or any other stage of the proceeding for the purpose of giving evidence or of producing a document or thing for evidence, or for both purposes.”
[4] In Giblin v Beach, an unreported decision of Bailey J dated 2 August 2001, subpoenas had been issued for the production of medical records. Bailey J held that the express terms of O.42.02 did not confine the return date for a subpoena to a date fixed for trial or a hearing. His Honour found that there was no issue as to whether the persons to whom the subpoenas were addressed were in possession of relevant records relating to the plaintiff and that the proceedings were at an advanced stage. He also found that the defendants were not…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kanochkin v Stark Investments Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] NTSC 81
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issue before the court was whether the subpoenas duces tecum, issued to the Territory Health Service, the Work Health Authority, and St John Ambulance, were necessary and appropriate at the stage of the proceedings. The court considered whether the subpoenas were justified under the circumstances and whether they were necessary to secure evidence relevant to the pleadings. The court also examined the precedents and principles governing the issuance of subpoenas for the production of documents, particularly in relation to medical records.
The court, represented by Master Coulehan, concluded that the subpoenas were not necessary at this stage of the proceeding. The court found that the proceeding had not reached an advanced stage where the issue of the subpoenas would be appropriate. There was no apparent necessity for the inspection of the plaintiff's medical records, as there was no dispute regarding the nature or effects of the plaintiff's injuries. The court emphasized that the use of subpoenas should be allowed only when clearly necessary and should not unduly burden third parties. Consequently, the court ordered that the subpoenas be dismissed and that the documents produced be returned.
The court's final order was that the subpoenas issued to the Territory Health Service, the Work Health Authority, and St John Ambulance be dismissed, and that the documents produced in response to these subpoenas be returned to the respective entities. This decision highlights the court's cautious approach to the use of subpoenas for the production of medical records, ensuring that such measures are reserved for cases where they are genuinely necessary and appropriate.
Background
Background to the litigation
In an effort to gather evidence, the second defendant issued subpoenas duces tecum to the Territory Health Service, the Work Health Authority, and St John Ambulance, demanding the production of medical records related to the plaintiff and the accident. These records, which include notes, correspondence, x-ray reports, and diagnostic records, pertain specifically to injuries on the plaintiff's right side, involving his right hand and wrist, right shoulder, right hip, right back, and right ankle, dated around 24 February 1998. The plaintiff does not object to the defendants inspecting these documents, subject to any claims for privilege.
The subpoenas were issued despite the proceeding not being at a stage typically deemed appropriate for such an order, according to Order 42.02 of the Supreme Court Rules. In a similar case, Giblin v Beach, Bailey J allowed the issuance of subpoenas for medical records, finding that the proceedings were at an advanced stage and the defendants were not attempting to circumvent discovery provisions. However, the Master in the current case found that the necessity for the subpoenas was not evident, particularly given the lack of dispute over the nature or effects of the plaintiff's injuries. The Master concluded that the subpoenas were not necessary and ordered their dismissal, with the produced documents to be returned.
The matter before the court is an interlocutory application concerning subpoenas filed by the second defendant, Bovis Lend Lease Pty Ltd, seeking the production of medical records relating to the plaintiff, Anthony Kanochkin. The plaintiff claims damages for personal injuries sustained from a fall, but the specifics of these injuries are not detailed in the statement of claim. The second defendant has joined issue on the allegations of injury, while the first defendant, Stark Investments Pty Ltd, has not filed a defence. The plaintiff does not object to the defendants inspecting the documents, subject to any claims for privilege. The court referenced Giblin v Beach in determining that subpoenas can be issued at an advanced stage of the proceeding, but only if it is appropriate. The court found that the subpoenas in this case were not necessary at this stage of the proceeding, and therefore ordered that the subpoenas be dismissed and the documents produced be returned.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the return date for a subpoena restricted to a date fixed for trial or a hearing under O.42.02 of the Supreme Court Rules?
2. Are the subpoenas directed at securing evidence relevant to the pleadings, or are they being used to circumvent the provisions for discovery from non-parties under O.32?
3. Are the documents sought by the subpoenas relevant to the specific injuries and incident in question, or are they overly broad in scope?
4. Is it necessary to inspect the plaintiff's medical records at this stage of the proceeding, given that there is no apparent dispute about the nature or effects of the plaintiff's injuries?
5. Should the subpoenas be dismissed and the documents produced be returned, considering the potential inconvenience and expense to third parties not involved in the proceeding?
Held
1. The court concluded that the return date for a subpoena is not restricted to a date fixed for trial or a hearing under O.42.02 of the Supreme Court Rules. The result was that the subpoenas could be issued at an appropriate stage of the proceeding.
2. The court determined that the subpoenas were not being used to circumvent the provisions for discovery from non-parties under O.32. The result was that the subpoenas were considered appropriate in securing evidence relevant to the pleadings.
3. The court found that the documents sought by the subpoenas may be overly broad in scope, as they were not limited to records specifically related to the injuries and incident in question. The result was that the subpoenas did not meet the necessary relevance criteria.
4. The court held that inspecting the plaintiff's medical records at this stage of the proceeding was not necessary, as there was no apparent dispute about the nature or effects of the plaintiff's injuries. The result was that the subpoenas were deemed inappropriate at this stage.
5. Considering the potential inconvenience and expense to third parties not involved in the proceeding, the court ordered that the subpoenas be dismissed and the documents produced be returned. The result was the dismissal of the subpoenas and the return of the documents.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Master in Kanochkin v Stark Investments Pty Ltd & Anor considered the propriety of the subpoenas issued by the second defendant, focusing on several key issues. Firstly, the Master addressed the scope of the return date for a subpoena under O.42.02 of the Supreme Court Rules, determining that it was not restricted to a date fixed for trial or a hearing. This conclusion was based on the decision in Giblin v Beach, where Bailey J held that the terms of O.42.02 were broad enough to permit the issuance of subpoenas at various stages of a proceeding, not solely at the trial stage.
Secondly, the Master examined whether the subpoenas were aimed at securing evidence relevant to the pleadings or if they were being used improperly to circumvent the provisions for discovery from non-parties under O.32. The Master found that the defendants were not using the subpoenas to circumvent the discovery process, as evidenced by the absence of a discovery process in the case. This finding was reinforced by the similarity between the present case and Mamone v Gagliadi, where the subpoenas were considered appropriate for securing relevant evidence.
Thirdly, the Master scrutinized the specificity of the documents sought by the subpoenas. The subpoenas were broad, seeking all medical records concerning the plaintiff's injuries and not limited to those directly relevant to the specific injuries and incident in question. The Master noted that if the subpoenas sought records not pertinent to the proceeding, it could be seen as an unnecessary burden on third parties.
Fourthly, the Master questioned the necessity of inspecting the plaintiff's medical records at this stage of the proceeding. The plaintiff did not dispute the nature or effects of his injuries, suggesting that the subpoenas might not be necessary. The Master concluded that the subpoenas were not required at this juncture in the proceeding.
Lastly, considering the potential inconvenience and expense to third parties not involved in the proceeding, the Master ruled that the subpoenas were not necessary and should be dismissed. This decision aligned with several precedents that emphasized the need for subpoenas to be issued only when clearly necessary, as seen in cases such as Lucas Industries v Hewitt, Greyhound v Deluxe Coachlines, FCT ex parte Swiss Aluminium, and Queensland Trustees v White and Gardiner.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that subpoenas for the production of documents are permissible under O.42.02 of the Supreme Court Rules at various stages of a proceeding, provided they are relevant and necessary. However, the court will dismiss such subpoenas if they are overly broad, issued at an inappropriate stage of the proceeding, or if they impose unnecessary inconvenience and expense on third parties not involved in the litigation.