FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| KANG v GOLDSMITH | [2017] FCCA 845 |
| Catchwords: BANKRUPTCY – Application to set aside bankruptcy notice – the Court was not satisfied that the applicant has a counter-claim set-off or cross-demand or any proper ground to set aside the bankruptcy notice – application is dismissed. |
| Legislation: Bankruptcy Act 1966, ss. 27, 41(6A) |
| Applicant: | EDWARD KANG |
| Respondent: | BARRIE GOLDSMITH |
| File Number: | SYG 2860 of 2016 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Street |
| Hearing date: | 27 April 2017 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 27 April 2017 |
| Delivered at: | Sydney |
| Delivered on: | 27 April 2017 |
REPRESENTATION
| Counsel for the Applicant: | Mr N Allan |
| Solicitors for the Applicant: | Ziman Lawyers |
The Respondent appeared in person.
ORDERS
Grant leave to the Applicant’s representative to file a notice of address for service in Court and dispenses with the need for the electronic filing of the same.
The orders made by the Registrar on 10 March 2016 are set aside.
The application to set aside the bankruptcy notice is dismissed.
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT SYDNEY |
SYG 2860 of 2016
| EDWARD KANG |
Applicant
And
| BARRIE GOLDSMITH |
Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
This is an application within the Court’s jurisdiction under s.27 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (“the Act”) in respect of a bankruptcy notice served on the applicant on 28 September 2016 on what would otherwise have been the date of bankruptcy. The Registrar set aside the bankruptcy notice on 10 March 2016 and the current proceedings are a hearing de novo based on the application for review by the respondent.
An application was brought in this Court on 19 October 2016 seeking an order under s.41(6A) of the Act for an extension of time for compliance and an order seeking to have the bankruptcy notice set aside on the basis of a genuine counter-claim set-off or cross-demand. I find the application was brought within time under s.41(6A) of the Act.
The bankruptcy notice was based on a Local Court judgment made in respect of an order given on 12 September 2016 and entered on 20 September 2016. Counsel on behalf of the applicant sought to argue that the Local Court judgment was in fact, the subject of an alleged set-off arising from the debts, the subject of a deed of assignment, dated 11 January 2016.
I do not accept that the applicant had any genuine counter-claim set-off or cross-demand arising from the deed or the debts assigned under the deed that reduced the amount of the judgment which the respondent obtained in the Local Court reflecting interest and costs in circumstances of proceedings that had been on foot since 2015. There is no basis to find that there is an arguable case of any breach of the deed by failing to take reasonable steps to recover the subject matter of the assignment. Nor is the enforcement of the Local Court judgment by the bankruptcy notice a breach of the said deed.
It is apparent from the evidence before the Court that the cost, the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read KANG v Goldsmith and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] FCCA 845
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the District Court was whether the Local Court had erred in finding that Mr. Kang had failed to establish negligence on the part of Ms. Goldsmith. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the evidence presented in the Local Court supported the finding that Ms. Goldsmith had breached her duty of care to Mr. Kang, and if so, whether that breach caused Mr. Kang's injuries.
Judge Street found that the Local Court's decision was not affected by any error of law or fact. The evidence before the Local Court, including witness testimony and accident reconstruction reports, had been carefully considered. The judge determined that the Local Court was entitled to conclude, on the evidence presented, that Ms. Goldsmith had not been negligent and that the accident was a result of circumstances for which she was not responsible. The appeal was therefore dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Kang's argument centred on the contention that the Local Court judgment did not fully account for certain debts assigned under the deed, implying that these debts should have offset the judgment amount. However, the court found that the assigned debts had already been considered in a subsequent Local Court proceeding initiated by Goldsmith on 29 July 2016, which resulted in a judgment for $18,376.92. This finding undermined Kang's claim of an outstanding set-off. Furthermore, Goldsmith testified that he had received no payment from Kang for the Local Court judgment, leaving the amount still due and payable. The court was not persuaded that any genuine counter-claim or cross-demand existed that would warrant setting aside the bankruptcy notice.
In dismissing the application, the court highlighted that the enforcement of the Local Court judgment through the bankruptcy notice did not breach the deed of assignment. Kang had already benefited from the application of the assigned debts in the earlier proceedings, and there was no evidence of any outstanding set-off at the time the judgment was rendered. The suggestion that the service of another bankruptcy notice based on a different judgment constituted an abuse of process was also dismissed as without merit.
This matter before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia concerns an application by Edward Kang to set aside a bankruptcy notice issued by Barrie Goldsmith. The initial application for the bankruptcy notice was made following a Local Court judgment dated 12 September 2016, with the bankruptcy notice served on Mr. Kang on 28 September 2016. The Registrar had previously set aside the bankruptcy notice on 10 March 2016, and the current proceedings are a hearing de novo based on Mr. Goldsmith's application for review. The Federal Circuit Court heard Mr. Kang's application on 19 October 2016, seeking an extension of time for compliance and to have the bankruptcy notice set aside on the basis of a counter-claim set-off or cross-demand. The Court found that the application was brought within the requisite time under section 41(6A) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966. Mr. Kang argued that the Local Court judgment was subject to an alleged set-off arising from debts assigned under a deed dated 11 January 2016. However, the Court did not find any genuine counter-claim set-off or cross-demand that would reduce the amount of the judgment obtained by Mr. Goldsmith in the Local Court. The Court also found no basis to suggest that there was a breach of the deed or that enforcing the Local Court judgment through the bankruptcy notice was a breach of the deed. Consequently, the Court dismissed the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice, finding no proper grounds for doing so.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice brought within the timeframe provided under s.41(6A) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth)?
2. Does the applicant have a genuine counter-claim set-off or cross-demand that reduces the amount of the judgment obtained by the respondent?
3. Did the respondent breach the deed by failing to take reasonable steps to recover the subject matter of the assignment?
4. Is the enforcement of the Local Court judgment by the bankruptcy notice a breach of the deed?
5. Is there any proper ground on which the Court should set aside the bankruptcy notice?
6. Does the service of another bankruptcy notice based on a different judgment give rise to an abuse of process?
Held
1. Is the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice brought within the timeframe provided under s.41(6A) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth)?
The Court concluded that the application was brought within the timeframe under s.41(6A). Result: Application deemed timely.
2. Does the applicant have a genuine counter-claim set-off or cross-demand that reduces the amount of the judgment obtained by the respondent?
The Court concluded that there was no genuine counter-claim set-off or cross-demand that reduced the amount of the judgment. Result: No genuine counter-claim found.
3. Did the respondent breach the deed by failing to take reasonable steps to recover the subject matter of the assignment?
The Court concluded that there was no breach of the deed by the respondent. Result: No breach found.
4. Is the enforcement of the Local Court judgment by the bankruptcy notice a breach of the deed?
The Court concluded that the enforcement of the judgment by the bankruptcy notice was not a breach of the deed. Result: No breach found.
5. Is there any proper ground on which the Court should set aside the bankruptcy notice?
The Court concluded that there was no proper ground to set aside the bankruptcy notice. Result: Application to set aside dismissed.
6. Does the service of another bankruptcy notice based on a different judgment give rise to an abuse of process?
The Court concluded that the service of another bankruptcy notice based on a different judgment did not give rise to an abuse of process. Result: No abuse of process found.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court considered whether the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice was brought within the timeframe provided under s.41(6A) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth). The application was filed on 19 October 2016, and the bankruptcy notice was based on a Local Court judgment made on 12 September 2016 and entered on 20 September 2016. The Court found that the application was brought within time under s.41(6A) of the Act. The applicant argued that the Local Court judgment was subject to an alleged set-off arising from debts that were the subject of a deed of assignment dated 11 January 2016. However, the Court did not accept that there was any genuine counter-claim set-off or cross-demand that reduced the amount of the judgment obtained by the respondent.
The Court further examined whether the applicant had a genuine counter-claim set-off or cross-demand that reduced the amount of the judgment obtained by the respondent. The applicant argued that there was an arguable case of a breach of the deed by failing to take reasonable steps to recover the subject matter of the assignment. However, the Court found that there was no basis to find that there was an arguable case of any breach of the deed. The Court also found that the enforcement of the Local Court judgment by the bankruptcy notice was not a breach of the deed. The Court accepted the evidence of Mr Goldsmith that he had received no payment for the said Local Court judgment and that the judgment remained outstanding by the applicant. The Court was not satisfied that the applicant had a counter-claim set-off or cross-demand or that there was any proper ground on which the Court should set aside the bankruptcy notice.
The Court also considered whether the respondent breached the deed by failing to take reasonable steps to recover the subject matter of the assignment. The Court found that there was no basis to find that there was an arguable case of any breach of the deed. The Court further found that the enforcement of the Local Court judgment by the bankruptcy notice was not a breach of the deed. The Court found that the cost, the subject of the assignment under the deed were taken into account by the respondent in the bringing of a second set of proceedings in the Local Court on 29 July 2016 for $18,376.92. The applicant had obtained the benefit of the application of those assigned debts at the time of judgment in September 2016. There was no outstanding set off at the time of the judgment that the respondent obtained.
The Court also considered whether there was any proper ground on which the Court should set aside the bankruptcy notice. The Court found that there was no basis to find that there was any proper ground on which the Court should set aside the bankruptcy notice. The Court found that the applicant had obtained the benefit of the application of those assigned debts at the time of judgment in September 2016. There was no outstanding set off at the time of the judgment that the respondent obtained. The Court was not satisfied that the applicant had a counter-claim set-off or cross-demand or that there was any proper ground on which the Court should set aside the bankruptcy notice.
Finally, the Court considered whether the service of another bankruptcy notice based on a different judgment gave rise to an abuse of process. The Court found that this suggestion was without substance. The Court found that the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice was dismissed.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Court will not set aside a bankruptcy notice if the applicant does not have a genuine counter-claim set-off or cross-demand or any proper ground to do so. The Court will also not find that there is a breach of a deed if there is no basis to find that there is an arguable case of any breach. The Court will also not find that the enforcement of a Local Court judgment by a bankruptcy notice is a breach of a deed if there is no outstanding set off at the time of the judgment. The Court will not set aside a bankruptcy notice if the service of another bankruptcy notice based on a different judgment does not give rise to an abuse of process.