Kale v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read
DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL
CITATION: Kale v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2025] NSWPICMP 664
CLAIMANT: Emine Kale
INSURER: Allianz Australia Insurance Limited
REVIEW PANEL
MEMBER: Terence Stern OAM
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Ankur Gupta
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Thomas Newlyn
DATE OF DECISION: 1 September 2025
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; medical assessment of whole person impairment (WPI) by Medical Assessor (MA); claimant injured in motor vehicle accident; MA determined the claimant’s permanent impairment at 7%; the claimant sought a review of the assessment under section 7.26; the Review Panel re-examined the claimant; Held – Review Panel confirmed certificate of MA; determination of 7% permanent impairment.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION

Issued under Division 7.5 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017

1.     The Review Panel determines that as a result of the accident, Ms Kale sustained whole person impairment (WPI) of 7%.

2.     The Review Panel confirms the determination of Medical Assessor Fukui, dated
30 January 2024, as a result of the accident Ms Kale sustained WPI of 7%.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. Ms Emine Kale (Ms Kale), was injured in a motor accident (the accident) on
    16 March 2019.

  2. Ms Kale has brought a claim for common law damages under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI Act).

  3. Allianz Australia Insurance Limited (the insurer) is the relevant insurer with liability to pay any damages to Ms Kale under the MAI Act.

  4. Section 4.11 of the MAI Act provides that there is no entitlement to damages for
    non-economic loss unless the degree of permanent impairment of the injured person as a result of the injury caused by the accident is greater than 10%.

  5. This dispute is in relation to whether the degree of permanent impairment sustained by Ms Kale as a result of the injury caused by the accident is greater than 10%. This constitutes a medical assessment matter pursuant to Schedule 2, cl 2 of the MAI Act.

  6. A medical assessment matter is determined in accordance with Division 7.5 of the MAI Act by a Medical Assessor.

  7. The dispute as to permanent impairment in respect of Ms Kale’s psychological injury was referred to Medical Assessor Fukui who assessed her on 21 August 2023 and issued a certificate dated 30 January 2024 certifying that as a result of the accident
    Ms Kale developed adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood and assessed her degree of whole person impairment (WPI) at 7%.

  8. Ms Kale sought a review.

  9. The Review Panel (Panel) has been constituted by the President of the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) to conduct the Review.

RELEVANT LEGAL AUTHORITY

  1. Section 7.21 of the MAI Act provides that the degree of permanent impairment of an injured person is to be assessed in accordance with the Motor Accident Guidelines (the Guidelines).

  2. The Guidelines were issued pursuant to Division 10.2 of the MAI Act and adopt the American Medical Association’s Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, Fourth Edition (AMA 4 Guides). The Guidelines are definitive with regard to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kale v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPICMP 664
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Kale v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, Ms Kale, a 70-year-old woman, contested the medical assessment of her whole person impairment (WPI) following a motor vehicle accident. The medical assessor, Dr Fukui, determined her permanent impairment at 7%, and Ms Kale sought a review of this assessment under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. The Review Panel, consisting of two medical assessors and a member, was tasked with re-examining Ms Kale and considering her claims that the assessment was materially incorrect.

The key legal issues before the Review Panel included whether the medical assessor had made errors in assessing Ms Kale’s adaptation, consistency with her treating and medico-legal evidence, procedural fairness, adequacy of reasons, and the assessment of her concentration, persistence, and pace. Ms Kale argued that the medical assessor had incorrectly allocated her to Class 3 for adaptation, overlooked her full pre-accident lifestyle, and failed to provide adequate reasoning. The insurer contended that there was no material error and that Ms Kale's claims were based on perceived errors that did not exist.

The Review Panel concluded that while Ms Kale's submissions were detailed, they did not establish a material error in the medical assessment. The Panel found that the medical assessor had appropriately considered the relevant evidence and adhered to the guidelines in assessing Ms Kale's impairment. The Panel confirmed the original assessment of 7% permanent impairment, rejecting Ms Kale's application for review. The Panel's decision was grounded in the lack of substantial evidence to support Ms Kale's claims of material error and procedural unfairness.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Panel summarises the submissions of the insurer by reference to paragraph numbers:[1] BackgroundMs Kale, a 70-year-old female was involved in a motor vehicle accident on 16 March 2019.By Certificate dated 30 January 2024, Assessor Fukui (Psychiatrist) determined that Ms Kale’s Adjustment Disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood gives rise to 7% psychiatric WPI arising from the subject accident.Ms Kale now seeks a Review of this Certificate.The insurer does not dispute the Review Application was made within time, noting the Certificate was issued on 7 February 2024, 28 days before the Application was lodged on 6 March 2024.[3] Submissions in Reply[3.1] Incorrect assessment of “Adaptation”Ms Kale alleges the allocation of Class 3 for Adaptation is demonstrably incorrect and inconsistent with her instructions, treating evidence, and medico-legal evidence.The Insurer compares the Permanent Impairment Guidelines with the Assessor’s reasons and submits there is no basis for asserting Class 3 is incorrect.The Insurer submits that Ms Kale’s position reflects an attempt to subject the reasons to minute and detailed textual criticism.The Insurer further notes that Dr Canaris also assessed Class 3 for Adaptation. Even if Dr Canaris’ rating were adopted, the outcome would not have been different.[3.2] Inconsistent findings with Claimant’s treating and medico-legal evidenceMs Kale alleges substantial inconsistency with the preponderance of her treating and medico-legal evidence regarding the assessment of psychological injuries.The Insurer submits there is no material error in a difference of expert opinion, particularly when assessments are conducted at different times.Ms Kale’s submissions do not specify the findings said to be inconsistent.The Insurer submits this reflects an attempt to construe the reasons with an eye keenly attuned to the perception of error.[3.3] Assessor’s failure to put inconsistent findings to Ms KaleMs Kale alleges that inconsistent findings were not put to her, denying procedural fairness and breaching clause 6.41 of the Motor Accident Guidelines.The insurer notes clause 6.41 requires that inconsistencies between clinical findings and other information be brought to the injured person’s attention.The insurer cites PIC Certificate passages showing that inconsistencies regarding past psychiatric history, self-harm, and medication use were put to Ms Kale and she was given the opportunity to respond.The insurer submits Ms Kale’s allegations are vague and baseless.Further, even if the Assessor failed to give an opportunity to respond, this would not be material, as the Assessor concluded there was no evidence of pre-existing impairment at the time of the accident despite a past depressive disorder.[3.4] Failure to provide adequate reasonsMs Kale alleges inadequate reasoning in breach of obligations from case law, including Rodger v De Gelder and D'Ament v Allianz.The Insurer submits it is unclear how the Assessor has failed to comply with these requirements, as Ms Kale has not drawn a connection between the cited cases and the reasons provided.The Medical Assessor accepted an accident-related psychiatric diagnosis, so it is unclear how there is a material error in reasoning on causation.The insurer further notes Ms Kale’s submissions refer to the wrong medical assessor at paragraph 26, suggesting the submissions may be based on a template rather than the Certificate in question.[3.5] Assessment of “Concentration, Persistence and Pace”Ms Kale alleges the Medical Assessor failed to properly assess this category and that a Class 3 (moderate impairment) is appropriate rather than Class 2 (mild impairment), relying on AMA4 Chapter 14.7.The insurer notes the Motor Accident Guidelines require assessment in accordance with the PIRS in the Guidelines, with AMA4 Chapter 14 used for background only.The insurer compares the Guidelines’ Class descriptors with the Assessor’s reasons and submits there is no basis for a Class 3 rating in the history or the submissions.[4] Insurer’s PositionThe insurer submits the President would not be satisfied there is reasonable cause to suspect the medical assessment is incorrect in a material respect, and Ms Kale’s Application should be dismissed.The insurer submits the grounds of the Application are based on perceived errors which do not exist within the Certificate.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 7 June 2024 the delegate of the President being satisfied there was reasonable cause to suspect that the medical assessment was incorrect in a material respect referred the medical assessment to the Panel. Ms Kale provided one ground for review:(a) errors in PIRS Scale/WPI Assessment - Concentration, Persistence and Pace. In relation to the ground for review, the delegate accepted Ms Kale’s submission that there was reasonable cause to suspect the Medical Assessor made a material error by placing Ms Kale in Class 2 instead of Class 3, failing to consider and record her full pre-accident lifestyle, activities and habits, not properly testing this impairment category or obtaining detailed examples, and providing no factual or rational basis for the finding, resulting in inconsistent outcomes and a potential error in diagnosis and impairment assessment. Clause 14F of Schedule 1 of the Personal Injury Commission Act 2020 (the PIC Act) provides that the new review provisions apply in relation to a decision of a new decision-maker. A “new decision maker” is defined in cl 14A(1) of Schedule 1 of the PIC Act. As the medical assessment the subject of the review was made on or after 1 March 2021, the new review provisions apply. The new review provisions provide that a review panel consists of two Medical Assessors and a Member assigned to the Motor Accidents Division of the Commission.[3] [3] Section 7.26(5A) of the MAI Act. Part 5 of the PIC Act enables the Commission to make rules with respect to the practice and procedure before the Commission including proceedings before a panel reviewing a decision of a Medical Assessor.[4][4] Section 41(2) of the PIC Act. Rules 127 to 130 of the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021 (PIC Rules) are made pursuant to Part 5 of the PIC Act. A review panel determines how it conducts and determines the proceedings and may determine the proceedings solely based on the written application.[5][5] Rule 128 of the PIC Rules. The review is by way of a new assessment of all matters with which the medical assessment is concerned. On 8 May 2025 the Panel agreed an examination was necessary. All Panel members have had no previous involvement with Ms Kale or with this matter. The Panel issued a Direction to the parties on 10 March 2025 requiring each party to file an indexed, paginated bundle of documents. The Panel issued subsequent Directions on 8 May 2025 requesting Ms Kale to make herself available for re-examination by the Medical Assessors on 20 June 2025 at 8.00am by Microsoft Teams. A Turkish Interpreter was provided and facilitated the medical examination on20 June 2025. The Panel had the documentation which had been made available to Medical Assessor Fukui and the additional documentation loaded to Pathways. The parties produced the following documents to Pathway:Claimant(a) claimants submissions of 6 March 2024;(b) a bundle dated 19 March 2025 containing: (i)claimant’s submissions in support of Medical Assessment Review Application dated 6 March 2024;(ii)Commission’s Determination of an Application for Review of a Medical Assessment by President delegate Stephanie Wigan dated June 2024;(iii)medico-legal report of Dr Christopher Canaris dated 15 March 2023;(iv)certificate by Medical Assessor Atsumi Fukui dated 30 January 2024;(v)medico-legal report of Dr James Bodel dated 15 June 2022;(vi)progress report of Mendphysio dated 13 May 2021;(vii)progress report of Mendphysio dated 23 March 2021;(viii)medical report of Dr Danesh dated 7 March 2022;(ix)medical report of Dr Danesh dated 31 May 2022;(x)clinical notes of Bankstown Lidcombe Hospital dated various;(xi)clinical notes of Hand Injury Trauma Service Physiotherapy dated 4 June 2020;(xii)clinical notes of Dr Chris Scott dated 19 May 2021;(xiii)clinical notes of Dr Geoffrey Smith dated 13 July 2021;(xiv)clinical notes of Dr Esin Ozme dated various;(xv)clinical notes of City West Medical Centre dated 28 September 2022;(xvi)clinical notes of Dr Shiu-Kwong Law dated 27 February 2023;(xvii)clinical notes of Arzu Oytam dated 28 February 2023;(xviii)medical report of Dr Geoffrey Needham dated 9 August 2023;(xix)medical report of Dr Geoffrey Needham dated 27 September 2023;(xx)updated clinical notes of City West Medical Centre dated 16 October 2023;(xxi)clinical notes of Chirohaus dated various;(xxii)referral letter to Dr Andrew Kam dated 22 January 2025;(xxiii)medical report of Dr Masoud Mehrpour dated 12 December 2024;(xxiv)medical report of Dr Masoud Mehrpour dated 7 November 2024;(xxv)medical report of Dr Mohamad Osama Hakmi dated 4 October 2024;(xxvi)medical report of Dr M Dowla dated 20 September 2024, and(xxvii)Application for Personal Injury Benefits.Insurer(a) submissions dated 28 March 2024;(b) review bundle dated 26 March 2025 containing:(i)insurer’s submissions in Reply to Review Application dated 28 March 2024;(ii)insurer’s submissions in reply dated 2 September 2022;(iii)Certificates of Fitness dated various;(iv)ADL Assessment Report dated 13 May 2019;(v)referral to Dr Scott dated 21 June 2019;(vi)referral to Dr Darwish dated 21 August 2019;(vii)email regarding psychologist referral and GP mental health plan dated 6 December 2019;(viii)Dr Scott records dated various;(ix)ADL report dated 11 August 2021;(x)Allianz correspondence regarding WPI dated 25 November 2021;(xi)joint report of Dr Todd Gothelf dated 8 November 2021;(xii)clinical records of Dr Darwish dated various;(xiii)report of Arzu Oytam dated 28 March 2022;(xiv)clinical records of Dr Bassel Hassan, Neurologist dated 19 May 2023;(xv)clinical records of Dr Shiu-Kwong Law, Psychiatrist dated 15 June 2023;(xvi)NSW Police Report dated 4 July 2019, and(xvii)NSW Ambulance records dated 17 March 2019.