~
~ -,~JO
IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Sydney No S47 of 1989 B e t w e e n -
ANDREW PETER KALAJZICH
Applicant
and
THE QUEEN
Respondent
Office of the Registry
Sydney No S48 of 1989 B e t w e e n -
KERRY NEIL ORROCK
Applicant
and
THE QUEEN
Respondent
Kalajzich Applications for special leave
to appeal
MASON CJ
BRENNAE·J
TOOHEY J. DAWSON J
McHUGH J
C2T32/l/HS 1 8/11/89 TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT CANBERRA ON WEDNESDAY, 8 NOVEMBER 1989, AT 12.03 PM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
MR C.A. PORTER, QC: May it please Your Honours, in this matter
I appear with my learned friends, MR B.T. STRATTON, QC
and MR R.A. BAKER, for the applicant KalaJztch.(instructed by John Webb Symons & Co)
MR K. MASON, QC, Solicitor-General for the State of New South
Wales: I appear with my learned friend, MR D.C. FREARSON, for the Crown. (instructed by the
Crown Sol1c1tor for New South Wales)
MR M.C. RAMAGE: If it please Your Honours, I appear for the applicant Orrock. (instructed by Newman Freeman)
MASON CJ: You again appear for the respondent. MR MASON: Yes, Your Honour. MASON CJ: Yes, Mr Porter. MR PORTER: May I hand up my outline of argument. MASON CJ: We have not granted special leave in this case already, have we, Mr Porter?
MR PORTER:
I know, if Your Honour pleases, but the reasons for seeking special leave are, I was going to say, set out
quite clearly in the affidavit in support of that
which appears at page 1583 of the last volume of the
application book. I am not too sure of the extent to which Your Honours may or may not have read the
judgment of the Court of Criminal Appeal.
MASON CJ: Yes, we have read the judgment in the Court of Criminal Appeal.
MR PORTER:
Then Your Honours will be aware from that that it was a case, so far as my client was concerned, turning entirely on the evidence of Elkins and Vandenberg, both of whom were accomplices and there was no possible
suggestion they were not accomplices and the question, and the only question, which we raise is the question of the sufficiency of the directions with regard to
C2T32/2/HS 2 8/11/89 Kalajzich
corroboration of those accomplices. Your Honours, we do not seek to raise before this Court the ground
of appeal that the verdicts were unsafe and
unsatisfactory. We simply raise the question, if Your Honours please, that, in our submission, as is
pointed out in paragraphs 3 and 4 of the affidavit
in support of the application for special leave,important questions arose as to what is in law
corroboration, questions which have arisen in the
past concerning which the superior courts of Australia
have given conflicting decisions which we point out
at page 6 and we say in effect that, having regard
to the enormous number of these cases at the present
time,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kalajzich v The Queen; Orrock v The Queen and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1989] HCATrans 269
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the High Court concerned the sufficiency of directions given by the trial judge regarding corroboration of accomplice evidence. Specifically, the applicants sought to argue that the corroborative evidence relied upon by the Crown was insufficient because its significance and force depended entirely on the evidence of the accomplices themselves. Furthermore, they contended that the corroborative evidence was merely "a straw in the wind" and not sufficiently significant or substantial to meet the legal requirements for corroboration.
The applicants argued that the Court of Criminal Appeal's judgment, if allowed to stand, would render traditional judicial precautions regarding accomplice evidence a "hollow sham." They submitted that there were conflicting decisions from superior courts across Australia on what constitutes valid corroboration, and that their application sought a definitive ruling on this important aspect of criminal law. The applicants' counsel emphasised that they were not merely arguing that the trial judge had wrongly identified certain items as corroboration, but rather were seeking to establish a principle regarding the nature and quality of evidence required to corroborate accomplice testimony.
Background
Background to the litigation
Kalajzich's case involved allegations of conspiracy to commit murder. The trial judge had directed the jury that certain pieces of evidence could corroborate the accomplices' testimonies. Kalajzich argued that the evidence did not sufficiently corroborate the accomplices' evidence and thus should not have been admitted. The applicants for Kalajzich submitted that the appropriate test for corroboration should be whether the evidence is truly independent of the accomplice's evidence.
Orrock's case also involved conspiracy to commit murder. The Court of Criminal Appeal had refused leave to appeal on the basis of Rule 4 of the Criminal Appeal Rules. Orrock argued that Rule 4 was ultra vires and that the Court of Criminal Appeal should have reviewed the trial judge's findings regarding the admissibility of his record of interview.
The High Court refused special leave in both cases. For Kalajzich, the Court found that the attack on the corroborative nature of the evidence did not engender sufficient doubt to justify special leave. For Orrock, the Court held that the point regarding Rule 4 was not taken in the Court of Criminal Appeal and that the application did not raise a question of general principle or public importance.
This case involved applications for special leave to appeal from the decisions of the Court of Criminal Appeal of New South Wales in two separate cases: Kalajzich v The Queen and Orrock v The Queen. The applicants sought special leave to appeal to the High Court on the basis that the Court of Criminal Appeal had erred in its handling of the applications. In Kalajzich v The Queen, the applicant argued that the Court of Criminal Appeal erred in its assessment of the sufficiency of corroborative evidence in a case that relied heavily on the evidence of accomplices. In Orrock v The Queen, the applicant argued that the Court of Criminal Appeal erred in applying rule 4 of the Criminal Appeal Rules, which requires objection at trial to be taken to any direction, omission, or decision of the trial judge in order for it to be raised on appeal. The High Court heard arguments from both applicants and the Solicitor-General for the Crown before declining to grant special leave to appeal in both cases. In Kalajzich, the Court found that while the issues raised were important, they did not give rise to sufficient doubt about the decision of the Court of Criminal Appeal to warrant special leave. In Orrock, the Court found that the argument that rule 4 was ultra vires the Criminal Appeal Act was not properly before the Court as it had not been raised in the Court of Criminal Appeal. The Court also found that the other grounds for appeal did not raise questions of general principle or public importance sufficient to warrant special leave.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What is the appropriate standard for corroborative evidence in criminal cases, particularly when the evidence depends significantly on the testimony of an accomplice?
2. Does the evidence presented meet the standard of corroboration required by law, particularly in the context of the alleged crime and the role of the accused?
3. Whether Rule 4 of the Criminal Appeal Rules is valid and applicable in this case, given that the issue was not raised in the Court of Criminal Appeal.
4. Whether the Court of Criminal Appeal erred in not allowing an appeal on the admissibility of the record of interview, particularly when the voluntary nature of the interview is in dispute.
5. Whether the Court of Criminal Appeal should have examined the facts of the case itself, particularly the voluntariness of the record of interview, rather than relying solely on the trial judge's findings.
Held
1. The court concluded that the questions raised regarding the standard of corroborative evidence in criminal cases, particularly when the evidence depends significantly on the testimony of an accomplice, are important. However, the court found that the attack on the corroborative nature of the specific pieces of evidence in this case did not have sufficient merit to engender a misgiving of a miscarriage of justice. Therefore, the application for special leave was refused.
2. The court determined that the evidence presented in the case met the standard of corroboration required by law, given the context of the alleged crime and the role of the accused. The application for special leave was refused.
3. The court held that Rule 4 of the Criminal Appeal Rules is not ultra vires the Criminal Appeal Act. The court declined to entertain the application for special leave as the point regarding the validity of Rule 4 was not raised in the Court of Criminal Appeal, and the High Court did not have the benefit of the Court of Criminal Appeal's consideration of the question. The application for special leave was refused.
4. The court found that the Court of Criminal Appeal did not err in not allowing an appeal on the admissibility of the record of interview. The court determined that the application for special leave raised no question of general principle or public importance, as the point was not taken at the trial and the Court of Criminal Appeal was entitled to exercise its discretion not to entertain the point. The application for special leave was refused.
5. The court concluded that this case was not a suitable vehicle for considering the role of a Court of Criminal Appeal in reviewing findings made by a trial judge in determining the admissibility of confessional evidence. There was no other point justifying the grant of special leave, and the application for special leave was refused.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Kalajzich v The Queen and Orrock v The Queen, the High Court declined to grant special leave to appeal. The applicants raised several issues concerning the appropriate standard for corroborative evidence in criminal cases, the admissibility of certain evidence, and the validity and application of Rule 4 of the Criminal Appeal Rules.
The court began by considering the appropriate standard for corroborative evidence, particularly when it significantly depends on the testimony of an accomplice. The applicants argued that the evidence relied upon as corroborative evidence in the Court of Criminal Appeal did not meet the required standard. However, the High Court found that the applicants had not demonstrated sufficient doubt in the Court of Criminal Appeal's decision to warrant the grant of special leave.
Next, the court addressed the validity and application of Rule 4 of the Criminal Appeal Rules. The applicants argued that Rule 4 was ultra vires and could not be used to block an appeal on a question of law. The High Court found that the issue of Rule 4's validity was not raised in the Court of Criminal Appeal, and therefore, the Court did not have the benefit of the Court of Criminal Appeal's consideration of the question. Additionally, the High Court found that the applicants' challenge to the refusal of leave under Rule 4 did not raise a question of general principle or public importance.
The court also considered whether the Court of Criminal Appeal erred in not allowing an appeal on the admissibility of the record of interview, particularly when the voluntary nature of the interview was in dispute. The High Court found that the applicants' challenge did not raise a question of general principle or public importance and that the Court of Criminal Appeal was entitled to exercise its discretion not to entertain the point.
Finally, the court examined whether the Court of Criminal Appeal should have examined the facts of the case itself, particularly the voluntariness of the record of interview, rather than relying solely on the trial judge's findings. The High Court found that the case was not a suitable vehicle for considering the role of the Court of Criminal Appeal in reviewing findings made by a trial judge in determining the admissibility of confessional evidence.
In summary, the High Court refused to grant special leave to appeal in both cases, finding that the applicants had not demonstrated sufficient doubt in the Court of Criminal Appeal's decisions or raised questions of general principle or public importance. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the High Court will not grant special leave to appeal unless the applicant can demonstrate that the Court of Criminal Appeal's decision was attended with sufficient doubt or that the case raises a question of general principle or public importance.