Kak and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

Kak and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 2004 (11 July 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2022/6255

Re:Yemin Kak

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:The Honourable Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

Date:11 July 2023

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review made by the delegate dated 7 July 2022, pursuant to subsection 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth).

............................[SGD].......................................

The Honourable Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

National Disability Insurance Scheme – reasonable and necessary supports – Operational Guidelines – Rugged Terrain Vehicle (RTV) – value for money – effective and beneficial – Reasonable family, carer and other support – independence – social participation – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

CASES

Mclaughlin and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 496

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Operational Guidelines: Including Specific Types of Supports in Plans Operational Guideline- Overview; the Guidelines

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Honourable Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

11 July 2023

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, Yemin Kak (referred to in these proceedings as ‘Mimi’), is a 36-year-old woman who was accepted into the National Disability Insurance Scheme (‘the Scheme’) in 2018 on the basis of her Moderate Intellectual Disability with global development delay. She also suffers from congestive cardiac failure and dilated cardiomyopathy which limit her mobility, and hyperplasia of the cerebellum, affecting her balance. She has been diagnosed with Autism Spectrum Disorder, which significantly limits her communication. The Applicant lives in suburban Sydney with her mother, stepfather, and other family members. Her mother works as a psychologist and the Applicant receives a variety of daily carer supports during the week. The Applicant is also prone to “meltdowns” and refusal behaviour. She is unable to complete the tasks of daily living without assistance from family. As a result, she is highly reliant upon her mother and unable to work.

  2. The Applicant sought internal review by the Respondent of her statement of participant supports (SOPS) of 8 June 2022 under s 100 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (‘the Act’).

  3. On 7 July 2022, that review confirmed the original decision and became the decision under review. The Applicant then applied to the AAT (the Tribunal) for external review of the decision under review on 3 August 2022, under s 103 (1) of the NDIS Act.

  4. The Applicant had sought to have several significant additional supports included in her plan of 8 June 2022. These included:

    1) the provision of a RTV for use on her family’s rural weekend/holiday property.

    2) the installation of a lift at her family’s Sydney residence and major modifications of the bathroom at her Sydney residence.

    3) Increased funding for 1:1 support worker assistance for self-care 6 hours per day, 7 days per week, was also sought. In the Applicant’s response to the Respondent’s SOFIC, this was described as 8 hours a day…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kak and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 2004
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a dispute between the Applicant and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) concerning the provision of a Rugged Terrain Vehicle (RTV) for the Applicant's use on her family's rural property. The Applicant sought funding for the RTV to enable her to access various parts of the property, which is approximately an hour's drive from her home and features rocky, uneven terrain with slopes. The NDIA opposed the funding, arguing it did not meet the criteria for reasonable and necessary supports under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the provision of an RTV for transporting the Applicant around the rural property, used one to two days per week, satisfied the requirements of section 34(1) of the Act. Specifically, the Tribunal had to assess whether the support represented value for money (s 34(1)(c)), would be effective and beneficial (s 34(1)(d)), and took into account what it is reasonable to expect families, carers, and informal networks to provide (s 34(1)(e)). The NDIA contended that these criteria were not met, while the Applicant argued that the RTV would enhance her social participation and was a more cost-effective option than additional carer support.

The Tribunal reasoned that the family's decision to purchase a rural property with challenging terrain constituted a lifestyle choice. Consequently, the need for an all-terrain vehicle to navigate this property was considered a cost that the family could reasonably be expected to bear as part of their informal support network, aligning with the principles of section 34(1)(e). While acknowledging the potential benefits of the RTV in increasing the Applicant's enjoyment and variety of activities at the farm, the Tribunal found insufficient evidence to conclude it would be substantially more effective or beneficial than alternative supports, particularly given the Applicant's mobility and balance limitations. The Tribunal also noted that the RTV would not improve the Applicant's independence, as another person would be required to operate it.

Ultimately, the Tribunal concluded that the requested support of an RTV did not meet the requirements of sections 34(1)(c), (d), and (e) of the Act. The Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's decision, finding that additional carer support, which was conditionally agreed upon by the parties, was more likely to meet the Applicant's needs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

With the agreement of the parties, I decided to limit the proceedings to a review of the Applicant’s request for the provision of a RTV on her family’s rural property. I also indicated I would deal with the request for additional carer support as part of the decision, noting here that the parties have now agreed that the provision of Sunday support is conditional upon the RTV not being supported by the Tribunal. I also note that the Respondent’s agreement to fund a lift and bathroom modifications is acknowledgement by the Respondent of the Applicant’s heart condition and hyperplasia of the cerebellum, which limit her mobility and balance.BACKGROUND In March 2021, the family purchased a rural property, approximately an hour’s drive from their home, for weekend and holiday use. The property, of 10 acres, includes a house, shed, dam, orchard, vegetable patch and barn and a “love shack”. It is of rocky and uneven terrain, with some slopes. The Applicant is deeply attached to her mother, who travels to the farm each weekend to relax, work in the gardens and catch up with their extended family. Her mother may do this on any of the days from Thursday to Sunday but is generally there on Sundays. She and her husband prefer to work outside for most of the day, in addition to spending time with family and, regularly, visiting her brother, who lives nearby. The Applicant has attended the farm on occasion, but the Applicant’s representative (the Applicant’s mother) advised she often remains with her carers in the family home and is then brought by them to the farm for a few hours on Sunday afternoons. While other family members own cars, including a utility vehicle owned by her step-father, the Applicant’s mother, although licensed to drive, does not own a vehicle. It is also noted that the proposed RTV is not for on-road use. The Applicant’s representative also denied that the RTV would be used to transport farm materials or livestock around the property. ISSUE: The Tribunal must determine whether the provision of an RTV for the purposes of transporting the Applicant around the family’s rural weekend property, approximately one or two days per week, satisfies the reasonable and necessary requirements in s 34 (1) of the Act.LEGAL FRAMEWORKRelevant Legislation The objects and principles of the Act are set out in Part 3. The requirements of s 34 of the Act, particularly, those of s 34 (1) (c), (d) and (e) are outlined below: (c) the support represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support;(d) the support will be, or is likely to be, effective and beneficial for the participant, having regard to current good practice(e) the funding or provision of the support takes account of what it is reasonable to expect families, carers, informal networks and the community to provide;Criterion under s 34(1)(c) - Value for money In deciding whether the support represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support, the CEO (and the Tribunal) is to consider the following matters:(a) whether there are comparable supports which would achieve the same outcome at a substantially lower cost;(b) whether there is evidence that the support will substantially improve the life stage outcomes for, and be of long term benefit to, the participant;(c) whether funding or provision of the support is likely to reduce the cost of the funding of supports for the participant in the long term (for example, some early intervention supports may be value for money given their potential to avoid or delay reliance on more costly supports);(d) for supports that involve the provision of equipment or modifications:(i) the comparative cost of purchasing or leasing the equipment or modifications; and(ii) whether there are any expected changes in technology or the participant’s circumstances in the short term that would make it inappropriate to fund the equipment or modifications.(e) whether the cost of the support is comparable to the cost of supports of the same kind that are provided in the area in which the participant resides;(f) whether the support will increase the participant’s independence and reduce the participant’s need for other kinds of supports (for example, some home modifications may reduce a participant’s need for home care).Criterion under s 34(1)(d) - Effective and beneficial

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal heard oral evidence from Wendy Sawtell, Martin Hall, Kara Edwards, Widyan Kabbout and Trudie Warner. EVIDENCE AND SUBMISSIONS The Respondent contended that the requirements of subsection 34, particularly (c, d, and e) are not met and therefore the requested support cannot be considered reasonable and necessary. The first subsection of s 34 of the Act upon which the Respondent relies is s 34 (c): the support represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support. The Respondent contended that the evidence does not demonstrate that the Applicant can only move around the property with an RTV since the Applicant can currently access some parts of the property on foot, or by car if the destination is close to the driveway. The Respondent referenced evidence that the Applicant had been to the rural property many times and had been able to reach, either on foot or in a vehicle, various locations. The Tribunal accepts that evidence, and the Respondent’s contention that whether she can access the property, either in part, in greater part or at all, is only relevant as to the degree of additional benefit the Applicant would gain from being able to do so in an RTV. The Respondent identified the possible benefits of an RTV to the Participant to be; (1) increased independence, one of the NDIS principles identified in 1.4 (e) (i) of the Supports for Participants Rules), and (2) increased social participation, also identified in 1.4 of the Rules. The Applicant contended the purpose of the RTV is to enable her social/emotional participation through greater involvement with her family, friends and to spend quality time with her mother. The Applicant further contended that without the RTV, she would be unable to attend the farm for an extended period because of the impact this would have on both her enjoyment while at the property and on her mother's utilisation of the property. The Applicant contended that the provision of a RTV was value for money compared with the provision of additional carer support on Sundays, which involves penalty rates.Independence The Respondent rejects the notion that it will improve the Applicant’s independence: “…as another person is required to operate the RTV for the Applicant” and relies on the Rules to contend that the RTV “will not improve [the Applicant’s] independence; but is being sought because she is dependent on assistive technology. This technology enables her to reach parts of the property that are inaccessible to her, or very difficult for her to access on foot. Furthermore, the Respondent contended that it is not a support that will build any capacity in her or make her more independent in interacting with her mother or her family on the property. The Applicant did not disagree with the Respondent’s contention that the RTV would not provide the Applicant with greater independence and the Tribunal accepts this although, as the Applicant contended, it may improve the variety of her day and bring other benefits.Social participation

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal concludes that the family’s purchase of this property, with its significant mobility challenges for their daughter, was a lifestyle choice they made and, consistent with 34 (1) (e) of the Act, the requested support is reasonably one the family can provide.DECISION For the reasons given above, the Tribunal has decided that the requested support of an RTV does not meet the requirements of s 34 (1), (c, d and e) and that the alternative, of additional carer support, is more likely to meet the Applicant’s needs. The Tribunal affirms the decision under review dated 7 July 2022, pursuant to subsection 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent opined that such a choice of enjoyment makes the provision of additional support in the form of a RTV to be the responsibility of the family which made what was essentially a lifestyle choice. The contention about choice and reasonable necessity is a reflection on what is reasonable for the family to provide. It was not addressed by the Applicant’s representative, whose focus remained on the importance of allowing her, as a mother, to both enjoy her life at the farm and fulfill her wish and her belief she should have her daughter with her as much as possible, for the reasons previously referenced.TRIBUNAL’S CONSIDERATIONS In summary, the question for the Tribunal in satisfying s 34 (1) (c) and (d) pivots on the benefits the Applicant would derive from each option; either additional carer support at weekends, or the RTV. In satisfying s 34 (e), whether the family should provide an RTV as part of their informal support, the question for the Tribunal is also whether the provision of an all- terrain RTV should be borne by the family because of their choice of this property as a source of enjoyment. Firstly, providing carers means the Applicant would be constantly and consistently supported while at the farm, but not able to access all parts of the property and not necessarily be with her mother when outdoors. It would, however, enable the important family contact her mother describes. These are undisputed benefits and limitations of this option; no evidence was provided that the Applicant’s carers could not care for her adequately. Despite this, and perhaps understandably, the presence of carers at weekends is not welcomed by the family, including the Applicant’s representative, her mother, and is the more expensive option over time. Whereas providing an RTV, while it means the mother would also allow the Applicant to be at the farm for longer, has different benefits to the provision of additional carer support. It potentially expands the Applicant’s opportunities to access the property in the company of her mother and enjoy a more varied range of activities such as collecting leaves, farm eggs or simply enjoying the view. In practice, with little evidence of the certainty of these benefits, this may not prove to be the case. Given the Applicant’s cognition, balance, other physical limitations, her propensity for meltdowns and inability to brace herself in the event of a sudden change in movement, she may access the RTV less often, or more unreliably, than her mother so sincerely hopes. There is no evidence either way. In these circumstances, it may well eventuate that the Applicant derives little additional time with her mother outdoors or greater benefit from being at the property and is of little additional value to her. This would also impact on the mother’s enjoyment of the property since no carers would be there to accommodate her daughter were the RTV to prove unsuitable. In satisfying s 34 (1) (e), the Respondent has contended that the decision to purchase the property was underpinned by the family’s lifestyle choices and that any consequent additional assistance required should be regarded as a day-to-day living cost, which the family should provide. The Tribunal accepts this contention, appreciating that the need for an all-terrain vehicle derives directly from the family’s choice of weekend property. The Tribunal also recognises that in this case, the provision of additional carer hours for Sundays at the farm could have been agreed to if the family were not at the farm, but, in any case, is not, ultimately, in dispute.