Kahn v Board of Examiners (Vic)

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read
62 CLR 422

THE BOARD OF EXAMINERS (VICT.)

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Barrister and Solicitor-Admission to practise in Victoria-Alien-British prac-

titioner-Rules of Council of Legal Education-Certificate that applicant is natural-born or naturalized British subject required-Validity of rule Discretion MELBOURNE,

of judges of Supreme Court-Oath of allegiance, Whether alien can take- May 15, 16;

Jurisdiction of High Court to entertain appeal-Legal Profession Practice Act July 21.

1928 (Vict.) (No. 3715), secs. 5 (2), 21-Rules of the Council of Legal Education 1932-1937 (Vict.), rr. 36, 42; Schedule G.

The Legal Profession Practice Act 1928 (Vict.) provides, by sec. 5 (2), that " every person shall before he is admitted and enrolled as a barrister and solicitor take the oath of allegiance," and, by sec. 21, that the Council of Legal Education constituted under the Act shall have power

rules regulating the admission to practise in Victoria as barristers and solicitors of persons duly admitted and entitled to practise

legal practitioners

of the superior courts of England, Scotland, or Ireland

subject to any conditions (either general or applicable to particular places or persons only) that seem expedient."

Rule 36 of the Rules of the Council of Legal Education 1932-1937 (Vict.) requires that any person duly admitted and qualified to practise as a legal. practitioner of the superior courts of England, Scotland, Northern Ireland or the Irish Free State who applies to be admitted to practise in Victoria as. a barrister and solicitor shall cause to be delivered to the secretary of the Board of Examiners a certificate signed by two barristers and solicitors of the Supreme Court stating (inter alia) that they believe him to be a natural- born or naturalized British subject. The applicant was a German nationali who had been admitted to practice as an English barrister but who failed to. produce to the Board of Examiners the certificate required by rule 36.

62 CLR 423

Held, by Latham C.J., Rich, Starke and McTiernan JJ. (Evatt J. dissenting), that the rule was intra vires of the Council of Legal Education and that the judges of the Supreme Court were justified in the exercise of their discretion in refusing to dispense with compliance with the rule.

The jurisdiction of the High Court to hear and determine an appeal from a decision of the judges of the Supreme Court of Victoria on an appeal from the Board of Examiners under rule 40 of the Rules of the Council of Legal Education 1932-1937 considered,

Capacity of an alien to take the oath of allegiance considered. Special leave to appeal from decisions of the Supreme Court of Victoria and the judges thereof In re Kahn, (1939) V.L.R. 273, refused.

APPLICATION for special leave to appeal from the Supreme Court of Victoria.

The applicant, Rudolf Ernst Kahn, who was a person duly admitted and entitled to practise as a barrister in the Superior Courts of England applied for admission to practise as a barrister and solicitor of the Supreme Court of Victoria. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kahn v Board of Examiners (Vic) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1939] HCA 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Rudolf Ernst Kahn, a German national and a barrister admitted to practice in England, sought admission to practise as a barrister and solicitor in Victoria. The Board of Examiners refused to grant him a certificate of compliance with the rules of the Council of Legal Education, specifically rule 36, which required a certificate stating the applicant was a natural-born or naturalized British subject. Kahn appealed this decision to the judges of the Supreme Court of Victoria, who dismissed his appeal and refused to dispense with the requirement under rule 42. Kahn then sought special leave to appeal to the High Court of Australia.

The primary legal issue before the High Court was whether rule 36 of the Rules of the Council of Legal Education was valid and intra vires the powers granted to the Council under the *Legal Profession Practice Act 1928* (Vic.). A related issue was whether the judges of the Supreme Court were justified in refusing to exercise their discretion to dispense with compliance with this rule. The Court also considered the jurisdiction of the High Court to hear an appeal from a decision made by judges of the Supreme Court acting under the Council's rules, and the capacity of an alien to take the oath of allegiance required by the Act.

The High Court, by a majority, held that rule 36 was intra vires the Council of Legal Education. The Court reasoned that section 21 of the *Legal Profession Practice Act 1928* granted the Council broad powers to make rules regulating the admission of British practitioners, subject to "any conditions (either general or applicable to particular places or persons only) that seem expedient." The majority found that requiring evidence of British nationality was a reasonable condition within this wide grant of power, particularly given the historical practice in Victoria and other Australian states. The Court also held that the judges of the Supreme Court were justified in refusing to dispense with the rule, as they were reluctant to substitute their discretion for that of the Supreme Court unless the discretion had been exercised on a wrong or unascertainable basis. The Court noted that while the capacity of an alien to take the oath of allegiance was a complex issue, it was not determinative of the appeal, and that the rule-making power was sufficiently broad to encompass the nationality requirement.

Special leave to appeal was refused. The Court found that the order refusing dispensation from rule 36 was an order of the Supreme Court, thus establishing jurisdiction for the High Court to hear an appeal from that specific order. However, based on the merits of the case, the application for special leave was dismissed. The Court also indicated that it was not prepared to hold that an alien could not take the oath of allegiance, nor that an alien could not be admitted as a barrister and solicitor, but these points were not essential to the decision on the application for special leave.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established