Kadkhudayan v British American Tobacco (Australia) Services Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

KADKHUDAYAN & ANOR v BRITISH AMERICAN TOBACCO (AUSTRALIA) SERVICES LTD

[2009] SASC 389

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle, The Honourable Justice Duggan and The Honourable Justice Nyland)

21 December 2009

ESTOPPEL - FORMER ADJUDICATION AND MATTERS OF RECORD OR QUASI OF RECORD - FORMER ADJUDICATION - JUDGMENT INTER PARTES

Appellants commenced proceedings against the respondent in Federal Court seeking damages for breaches of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – claim dismissed at first instance - dismissal upheld on appeal to the Full Court – appellants commenced proceedings in the District Court of South Australia seeking damages for breach of contract – damages sought were the same in both proceedings - claim in contract not pleaded in proceedings in Federal Court – District Court Judge struck out appellants’ claim on the basis of an issue estoppel arising out of the Federal Court proceedings, and on the basis of an Anshun estoppel precluding a subsequent contractual claim - appeal against order of Judge.

HELD:  Although the Federal Court proceedings gave rise to no issue estoppel relevant to the District Court proceedings, having regard to the risk of conflicting judgments, the commonality of the underlying substratum of facts and the losses claimed in both proceedings, it was unreasonable for the appellants not to have pursued their claim in contract in the Federal Court proceedings and an Anshun estoppel arose – appeal dismissed.

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) 45, 48, 96(3)(b), referred to.
Port of Melbourne Authority v Anshun Pty Ltd (1981) 147 CLR 589; Zavodnyik v Alex Constructions Pty Ltd (2005) 67 NSWLR 457, applied.
Blair v Curran (1939) 62 CLR 464 ; British American Tobacco (Australia) Services Ltd v Kadkhudayan [2009] SADC 25; Kadkhudayan v W D & H O Wills (Aust) Ltd [2002] FCAFC 110; Wong v Minister of Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (2004) 146 FCR 10, discussed.

KADKHUDAYAN & ANOR v BRITISH AMERICAN TOBACCO (AUSTRALIA) SERVICES LTD
[2009] SASC 389

Full Court:      Doyle CJ, Duggan and Nyland JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ:          I would dismiss the appeal.  I agree with the reasons given by Nyland J.

  2. DUGGAN J:         In my view the appeal should be dismissed for the reasons given by Nyland J.  I agree with the orders proposed by Nyland J.

  3. NYLAND J:          The appellants, who are husband and wife, previously conducted a business which included the wholesale and retail supply of cigarettes and tobacco products.  The respondent (previously conducting business under the name of W.D. & H.O. Wills Australia Limited) carried on the business of a manufacturer and wholesale supplier of cigarettes and tobacco products. 

  4. In the early stages of their business, the appellants purchased tobacco supplies from various of the respondent’s wholesalers.  In about 1991 they were able to purchase direct from the respondent and sell to other retailers or directly to the public.  As wholesalers in particular, the appellants received from the respondent various incentive payments in the form…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kadkhudayan v British American Tobacco (Australia) Services... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 389
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal before the South Australian Supreme Court was brought by the appellants, Kadkhudayan, against the respondent, British American Tobacco (Australia) Services Ltd. The appellants originally brought proceedings against the respondent in the Federal Court, seeking damages for breaches of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The dismissal of these proceedings was upheld on appeal to the Full Court. Subsequently, the appellants commenced new proceedings in the District Court of South Australia seeking damages for breach of contract. The damages sought in both proceedings were the same. The claim in contract was not pleaded in the Federal Court proceedings. The District Court judge struck out the appellants’ claim on the basis of an issue estoppel arising out of the Federal Court proceedings, and on the basis of an Anshun estoppel precluding a subsequent contractual claim. The appellants appealed against the order of the District Court judge.

The court was required to decide whether the doctrine of issue estoppel applied to the situation where the Federal Court proceedings gave rise to no issue estoppel relevant to the District Court proceedings. The court was also required to determine whether, having regard to the risk of conflicting judgments, the commonality of the underlying substratum of facts and the losses claimed in both proceedings, it was unreasonable for the appellants not to have pursued their claim in contract in the Federal Court proceedings and an Anshun estoppel arose.

The court held that although the Federal Court proceedings gave rise to no issue estoppel relevant to the District Court proceedings, having regard to the risk of conflicting judgments, the commonality of the underlying substratum of facts and the losses claimed in both proceedings, it was unreasonable for the appellants not to have pursued their claim in contract in the Federal Court proceedings and an Anshun estoppel arose. The court found that the District Court judge correctly found that it was unreasonable for the appellants not to have included the claim arising out of the 1994 contract in their initial proceedings. The appeal was dismissed. The court made an order that District Court Action Number DCCIV-04-1555 be dismissed and that there be judgment for the respondent in the action.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In Blair v Curran Dixon J, in discussing the problem of conflicting judgments, pointed out that estoppel is not confined to the final legal conclusion expressed in the judgment decree or order. He said[12]In the phraseology of Coleridge J in R v Inhabitants of the Township of Hartington Middle Quarter, the judicial determination concludes, not merely as to the point actually decided, but as to a matter which it was necessary to decide and which was actually decided as the groundwork of the decision itself, though not then directly the point at issue. Matters cardinal to the latter claim or contention cannot be raised if to raise them is necessarily to assert that the former decision was erroneous.[12] Ibid at p 532.Conclusion The District Court judge found that the doctrine of issue estoppel prevented the appellants from asserting in these proceedings that they had a contractual right to receive incentive payments and that their asserted losses were as a result of an alleged breach of contract in view of the Federal Court ‘finding’ as to a lack of contractual entitlement[13]. [13] British American Tobacco (Australia) Services Ltd v Kadkhudayan & Anor [2009] SADC 25 at [57]. I however agree with the submission made by the appellant that the statement made by the Full Federal Court as to the appellant’s lack of contractual entitlement to receive payments does not amount to a specific finding by that court that a contract did not exist, which would thereby give rise to issue estoppel. That was simply an observation made by the court when discussing the factual background to the dispute between the parties. In my opinion however, the principles enunciated in Anshun apply to the circumstances of this case. The ‘groundwork’ or underlying substratum of facts in each set of proceedings is essentially the same and there is a substantial overlap between the two sets of proceedings. To permit the appellants to pursue the claims now contained in the District Court proceedings creates a risk of conflicting judgments. In my opinion, the District Court Judge correctly found that it was unreasonable for the appellants not to have included the claim arising out of the 1994 contract in their initial proceedings. I would therefore dismiss the appeal. I would however vary the order of the District Court Judge that the proceedings be struck out and in lieu thereof make an order that District Court Action Number DCCIV-04-1555 be dismissed and that there be judgment for the respondent in the action.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established