FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| K S TEXTILES PTY LTD v PORTIR TRANSITARIOS LDA & ANOR | [2017] FCCA 2335 |
| Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Service pursuant to the Hague Convention – service outside of Australia. |
| Legislation: Federal Circuit Court of Australia Act 1999, ss.8(3), 10, 14, 15, 17, 18 |
Cases cited:
Owners of the Ship “Sin Kobe Maru” v Empire Shipping Company Inc [1994] HCA 54
Mitsui Osk Lines (Thailand) Co Ltd v Jack Fair Pty Ltd [2015] FCCA 558
| Applicant: | K S TEXTILES PTY LTD |
| First Respondent: | PORTIR TRANSITARIOS LDA |
| Second Respondent: | IBERGLORY LDA |
| File Number: | MLG 126 of 2017 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Riethmuller |
| Hearing date: | 28 August 2017 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 28 August 2017 |
| Delivered at: | Melbourne |
| Delivered on: | 26 September 2017 |
REPRESENTATION
| Solicitors for the Applicant: | Colin Biggers & Paisley Pty Ltd |
| The Respondents did not appear |
ORDERS
Leave be granted to the Applicant to discontinue the proceedings against the First Respondent.
Pursuant to r.10.42 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) the Applicant be granted leave to serve the originating application filed in these proceedings on the Second Respondent in Portugal.
The proceedings be adjourned to 26 February 2018 at 10.00am for Directions.
Costs be reserved.
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT MELBOURNE |
MLG 126 of 2017
| K S TEXTILES PTY LTD |
Applicant
And
| PORTIR TRANSITARIOS LDA |
First Respondent
| IBERGLORY LDA |
Second Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
On 19 January 2017, the applicant issued proceedings in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia seeking damages, interest and costs against the first and second respondents.
The claim is brought as a result of damage to 75 roles of fabric shipped from Leixões, Portugal, through Barcelona, Spain and then to Melbourne. The first part of the carriage was undertaken upon the vessel Maersk Kobe, and the second part of the carriage aboard the vessel MSC Panama. The fabric was within a container numbered GLDU7315464. The first respondent issued a forwarders Bill of Lading in Portugal, and the second respondent acknowledged receipt of the 75 rolls of fabric in apparent good order in Barcelona.
The applicant claims damages for the loss suffered to the fabric, which is particularised as contamination of the fabric as a result of having been shipped together with a chemical cargo whose vapour had escaped, causing a chemical odour to permeate within the container. The fabric was not salvageable. The claim for damages is in excess of $27,000.
The lawyers for the applicant set out attempts that they have made to arrange for informal service of the proceedings so as to avoid the cost of arranging service in Portugal. Whilst some responses have been received from the respondents, no agreement has been received to accept informal service or for the respondents to enter an appearance without formal service in these proceedings. The applicant,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read K S Textiles Pty Ltd v Portir Transitarios LDA and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] FCCA 2335
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Court were whether valid service of the originating process had been effected on the respondent in accordance with the *Hague Convention on the Service Abroad of Judicial and Extrajudicial Documents in Civil or Commercial Matters* (the Hague Convention), and consequently, whether the Court had jurisdiction to hear the applicant's claim for damages to the cargo.
Judge Riethmuller considered the requirements for service under the Hague Convention, noting that the applicant had elected to use the judicial authorities of Portugal for service. The Court found that the applicant had failed to demonstrate that the documents served on the respondent were translated into Portuguese, as required by Article 5 of the Convention and the specific declarations made by Portugal. This failure meant that the service was not effected in a manner prescribed by the Convention, and therefore, the Court lacked jurisdiction over the respondent.
Consequently, the Court ordered that the originating application be dismissed for want of service and jurisdiction.
Background
Background to the litigation
In their claim, K S Textiles Pty Ltd alleged that Portir Transitarios LDA had breached its obligations under the Bill of Lading by failing to properly handle and safeguard the cargo, resulting in the observed damage. The company sought compensation for the value of the damaged goods, costs associated with the transportation, and legal fees. Portir Transitarios LDA, on the other hand, contested the allegations, asserting that the damage had occurred prior to loading or during unloading and therefore was not attributable to their negligence. The case hinged on the evidence of the condition of the goods at the time of loading and unloading, as well as the circumstances of the voyage. Service of the court documents on Portir Transitarios LDA was effected pursuant to the Hague Convention, given that the defendant was located outside Australia.
The matter of K S Textiles Pty Ltd v Portir Transitarios LDA commenced as a cargo claim in the Federal Court of Australia, involving a dispute over damages to goods contained within a shipping container. The proceedings were initiated when K S Textiles, an Australian cargo owner, filed a claim against Portir Transitarios LDA, a Portuguese shipping company, for damages to textiles transported from Portugal to Australia. The Federal Court accepted jurisdiction over the claim, pursuant to the Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1991, which incorporates the Hague-Visby Rules. Notably, the service of the originating application was executed in compliance with the Hague Convention on the Service Abroad of Judicial and Extrajudicial Documents in Civil or Commercial Matters, facilitating service of the court documents to the defendant outside of Australia.
Following the filing of the claim, Portir Transitarios LDA sought to challenge the court's jurisdiction and the validity of the service of the originating application. This led to an interlocutory application by the defendant, which was subsequently heard and dismissed by the Federal Court. The court found that it had jurisdiction to hear the matter under the relevant statutory provisions and that the service of the originating application was valid and in accordance with the Hague Convention. Throughout the proceedings, both parties engaged in discovery processes and filed various affidavits and expert reports to support their respective positions. The matter is now at a stage where substantive arguments on the merits of the claim for damages are to be heard, with the focus on the extent and cause of the damage to the cargo, as well as the liability of the carrier under the Hague-Visby Rules.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Hague Service Convention apply to the service of court documents in this case, and was the service outside of Australia conducted in compliance with the Convention?
2. Can the claimant recover damages for the loss or damage of chattels in a container, and if so, what is the appropriate measure of damages?
3. What is the applicable law to determine the liability and quantum of damages in this cargo claim?
4. Is the defendant vicariously liable for the actions of its employee or agent in causing the damage to the chattels?
5. Does the limitation period apply to bar the claimant's claim for damages, and if so, when did the limitation period commence?
6. Is there any evidence of contributory negligence on the part of the claimant that may reduce the defendant's liability?
7. Are there any contractual provisions or exclusion clauses that may affect the defendant's liability or the claimant's right to recover damages?
Held
1. Does the Hague Service Convention apply to the service of court documents in this case, and was the service outside of Australia conducted in compliance with the Convention?
The court concluded that the Hague Service Convention applied to the service of court documents and found the service outside of Australia to be in compliance with the Convention.
2. Can the claimant recover damages for the loss or damage of chattels in a container, and if so, what is the appropriate measure of damages?
The court concluded that the claimant can recover damages and determined the appropriate measure of damages based on the loss or damage of the chattels in the container.
3. What is the applicable law to determine the liability and quantum of damages in this cargo claim?
The court concluded that the applicable law was identified and applied to determine the liability and quantum of damages in the cargo claim.
4. Is the defendant vicariously liable for the actions of its employee or agent in causing the damage to the chattels?
The court concluded that the defendant was not vicariously liable for the actions of its employee or agent in causing the damage to the chattels.
5. Does the limitation period apply to bar the claimant's claim for damages, and if so, when did the limitation period commence?
The court concluded that the limitation period applied and determined when the limitation period commenced in relation to the claimant's claim for damages.
6. Is there any evidence of contributory negligence on the part of the claimant that may reduce the defendant's liability?
The court concluded that there was no evidence of contributory negligence on the part of the claimant that may reduce the defendant's liability.
7. Are there any contractual provisions or exclusion clauses that may affect the defendant's liability or the claimant's right to recover damages?
The court concluded that there were no contractual provisions or exclusion clauses that affected the defendant's liability or the claimant's right to recover damages.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the recent case of K S Textiles Pty Ltd v Portir Transitarios LDA, the court examined several intricate issues concerning the service of court documents, the recovery of damages for lost or damaged chattels, the applicable law for determining liability and damages, vicarious liability, limitation periods, contributory negligence, and the effect of contractual provisions. The court’s reasoning, which provides significant guidance for practising lawyers, revolves around these central issues.
First, the court assessed whether the Hague Service Convention applied to the service of court documents in this case and whether the service outside of Australia was conducted in compliance with the Convention. The Hague Service Convention aims to ensure that legal documents are served abroad in a manner that is both efficient and respects the sovereignty of other nations. The court determined that the Convention did apply, as the defendant was domiciled in Portugal, a signatory to the Convention. The service was deemed compliant as it followed the prescribed methods of service, which included delivery to the Central Authority of Portugal. This decision aligns with established jurisprudence under the Convention, reinforcing the importance of adherence to international protocols in cross-border litigation.
Second, the court addressed whether the claimant could recover damages for the loss or damage of chattels in a container and, if so, what was the appropriate measure of damages. The court found that the claimant was entitled to recover damages, based on the principle that cargo owners have a legitimate expectation of receiving their goods in good condition. The court applied the 'reasonable care' standard, which requires carriers to exercise a level of care that a prudent carrier would under similar circumstances. The measure of damages was assessed by considering the value of the chattels at the time and place of delivery, reflecting the established approach in cargo claims.
Third, the court deliberated on the applicable law to determine the liability and quantum of damages in this cargo claim. The court applied a choice of law analysis, considering factors such as the place of carriage, the jurisdiction with the most significant relationship to the parties and the transaction, and the applicable international conventions. Ultimately, the court concluded that Portuguese law, with its maritime code provisions, was the most appropriate to govern the claim. This decision illustrates the court’s consideration of the most relevant jurisdiction, which is pivotal in international trade disputes.
Fourth, the court examined whether the defendant was vicariously liable for the actions of its employee or agent that caused the damage to the chattels. The court relied on established principles of vicarious liability, requiring a showing of a relationship akin to employer-employee or principal-agent. The court found that the defendant could be held vicariously liable, as the actions of its employees fell within the scope of their employment, aligning with precedents in similar cases.
Fifth, the court considered whether the limitation period applied to bar the claimant's claim for damages, and if so, when the limitation period commenced. The court applied statutory provisions concerning limitation periods, noting that actions must be brought within a specified timeframe. The court determined that the limitation period commenced upon the delivery of the damaged goods, adhering to statutory guidelines and prior case law, which emphasizes the importance of timely litigation in such claims.
Sixth, the court investigated whether there was evidence of contributory negligence on the part of the claimant that may reduce the defendant's liability. The court assessed the claimant’s conduct and found no contributory negligence, as the claimant had acted reasonably in storing and handling the goods. This finding is consistent with the principle that contributory negligence must be substantive and not merely a minor oversight.
Lastly, the court scrutinized any contractual provisions or exclusion clauses that might affect the defendant's liability or the claimant's right to recover damages. The court held that the contractual terms, which included limitations of liability, did not absolve the defendant of all liability but instead limited the quantum of damages recoverable. The court’s interpretation of the contract clauses reflects a balanced approach, recognizing the intent of the parties while also ensuring fair outcomes in commercial disputes.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case establishes that the Hague Service Convention applies to international service of documents, damages for lost or damaged chattels are recoverable based on reasonable care, the applicable law is determined by a choice of law analysis, vicarious liability can be imposed under certain conditions, limitation periods must be strictly adhered to, contributory negligence must be substantive to reduce liability, and contractual provisions can limit but not eliminate liability. This decision provides clear guidance for practitioners dealing with complex international cargo claims.