JWR Productions Australia Pty Ltd v Duncan-Watt

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

JWR Productions Australia Pty Ltd v Duncan-Watt [2019] FCA 367

File number: NSD 266 of 2017
Judge: PERRY J
Date of judgment: 15 March 2019
Date of publication of reasons: 19 March 2019
Catchwords: PRIVILEGE – legal professional privilege – implied waiver – whether alleged unrestricted communications to a third party are inconsistent with the maintenance of privilege – relevance of fairness in determining whether privilege has been waived
Legislation: Copyright Act 1968 (Cth)
Cases cited:

AWB Limited v Cole (No 5) (2006) 155 FCR 30

Bennett v Chief Executive Officer, Australian Customs Service (2004) 140 FCR 101

British American Tobacco Australia Ltd v Secretary, Department of Health and Ageing (2011) 195 FCR 123

Cantor v Audi Australia Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 1391

College of Law Limited v Australian National University [2013] FCA 492

Cooper v Hobbs [2013] NSWCA 70

Domino’s Pizza Enterprises Limited v Precision Tracking Pty Ltd (No 3) [2017] FCA 1063

Mann v Carnell (1999) 201 CLR 1

Osland v Secretary, Department of Justice (2008) 234 CLR 275

Trade Practices Commission v Sterling (1978) 36 FLR 244

Date of hearing: 14 March 2019
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-Area: Copyright and Industrial Designs
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 35
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr H P T Bevan
Solicitor for the Applicants: Bird & Bird
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr M R Hall SC with Ms E Whitby
Solicitor for the Respondent: Banki Haddock Fiora
Table of Corrections
20 March 2019 In the second sentence of paragraph 29, “Gardiman” has been replaced with “Rockefeller”.

ORDERS

NSD 266 of 2017
BETWEEN:

JWR PRODUCTIONS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ABN 83 130 449 428)

First Applicant

JONATHAN ROCKEFELLER

Second Applicant

AND:

THOMAS DUNCAN-WATT

Respondent

JUDGE:

PERRY J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 MARCH 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Unless an application for a stay is made by the applicants to the proceeding on or before 4pm on Tuesday, 19 March 2019, leave is granted to the respondent to inspect and uplift the documents identified in the list of privileged documents produced by the applicants pursuant to the Notice to Produce dated 5 March 2019.

2.Any application for a stay pursuant to order 1 be supported by an affidavit and the requirement for an interlocutory application be dispensed with.

3.The applicants are to pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the objection to the Notice to Produce dated 5 March 2019 as agreed or assessed.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
(Revised from Transcript)

PERRY J:

1.               INTRODUCTION

  1. This matter is presently being heard by Thawley J, together with an action by the same applicants against Mr Neil Gooding in proceedings NSD 327 of 2017.  I understand that the parties have closed their respective cases and are in the process of preparing final submissions.  The respondent, Mr Thomas Duncan-Watt, and Mr Gooding are also co-plaintiffs with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JWR Productions Australia Pty Ltd v Duncan-Watt and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 367
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In JWR Productions Australia Pty Ltd v Duncan-Watt, the applicant, JWR Productions Australia Pty Ltd, sought to prevent the disclosure of certain communications on the basis that they were privileged. The respondent, Duncan-Watt, opposed the application on the basis that the privilege had been waived. The court had to decide whether the privilege had been lost due to the alleged waiver. The central legal issue was whether the applicant's conduct was inconsistent with the maintenance of the confidentiality of the advice, thereby resulting in an implied waiver of privilege.

The court considered the nature of legal professional privilege and the circumstances under which it may be waived. The court noted that disputes as to implied waiver usually arise from the need to decide whether particular conduct is inconsistent with the maintenance of the confidentiality which the privilege is intended to protect. The court held that considerations of fairness do not feature in the assessment of whether privilege has been waived, save insofar as they may bear upon the existence of the inconsistency between the client’s conduct and maintenance of the confidentiality of the advice.

In this case, the court found that the privilege did not attach to the communications identified in the list of privileged documents produced by the applicants. The court concluded that the respondent's application to access the privileged communications must be allowed with costs. The court found that the applicant's conduct was inconsistent with the maintenance of the confidentiality of the advice, thereby resulting in an implied waiver of privilege. The court held that the respondent's case put to the applicant that the applicant had used the copyright in the photographs as a weapon to launch a counterattack against the respondent was potentially relevant to the case. Therefore, the court held that the privilege had been waived.

The final orders of the court were that unless an application for a stay is made by the applicants, leave is granted to the respondent to inspect and uplift the documents identified in the list of privileged documents produced by the applicants. Any application for a stay must be supported by an affidavit, and the requirement for an interlocutory application is dispensed with. The applicants are to pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the objection to the Notice to Produce dated 5 March 2019 as agreed or assessed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Unless an application for a stay is made by the applicants to the proceeding on or before 4pm on Tuesday, 19 March 2019, leave is granted to the respondent to inspect and uplift the documents identified in the list of privileged documents produced by the applicants pursuant to the Notice to Produce dated 5 March 2019.

2. Any application for a stay pursuant to order 1 be supported by an affidavit and the requirement for an interlocutory application be dispensed with.

3. The applicants are to pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the objection to the Notice to Produce dated 5 March 2019 as agreed or assessed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Finally, a copy of the two communications in respect of which privilege was claimed was marked for identification and provided to me at the hearing to consider in determining the applicants’ objection to the notice to produce, but was not at that time provided to the respondent or his legal representatives. 3. BACKGROUND In summarising the background and otherwise making findings necessary to dispose of the limited issue before me, I emphasise that I have not made any findings as to the substantive issues in dispute between the parties. Among other causes of action, the statement of claim alleges that:(1)Dario Gardiman, an Australian citizen, is the author of photographs depicting (among other things) Mr Duncan-Watt with puppets from the stage show “Thank You for Being a Friend”;(2)the photographs were made by Mr Gardiman pursuant to an agreement for valuable consideration with the applicants pursuant to which Mr Gardiman was to take photographs in a variety of compositional combinations of Mr Rockefeller, Mr Duncan-Watt, and/or the “Thank You for Being a Friend” puppets;(3)the applicants are the owner of the copyright in the photographs, particulars of which are the “Letter of confirmation of assignment from Dario Gardiman dated 21 December 2016”; and(4)the respondent has reproduced and communicated the photographs to the public on his website without the licence or authority of the applicants, thereby infringing their copyright. Mr Rockefeller and Mr Duncan-Watt are the co-authors of a stage show, “Thank You for Being a Friend”, which is apparently a parody of the 1980s and 1990s American television sitcom, “The Golden Girls”. In his defence, Mr Duncan-Watt pleads that he does not know and cannot admit the alleged agreement pursuant to which the photographs were taken, admits that the applicants are the owner of copyright in the photographs, and denies that the reproduction and communication of the photographs by him was without the licence or authority of the applicants. Rather, Mr Duncan-Watt alleges at [26] of his defence that:a)the Applicants provided an express license to the Respondent to reproduce and communicate the Photographs to the public; andb)the licence provided to the Respondent by the Applicant was irrevocable; orc)in the alternative, the licence provided to the Respondent by the Applicant was revoked on 20 December 2016. The particulars of paragraph [26] of the defence are that the licence was oral and was provided in a conversation between Mr Rockefeller and Mr Duncan-Watt on or about January 2015. The particulars also refer to a letter from the applicants’ solicitors dated 20 December 2016. The photographs in question were taken on 12 December 2014. Mr Rockefeller alleges that Mr Gardiman did not charge him for the photographs as he took them as a personal favour to him. Mr Rockefeller alleges that, on or about 2 December 2014, Mr Duncan-Watt agreed to pay $1000 for Mr Gardiman to take the photographs as they were for Mr Duncan-Watt’s press and website, as well as half of the related expenses and fees for the usage of the photographs. Mr Rockefeller also alleges that following the photoshoot, he had a conversation with Mr Duncan-Watt in which Mr Rockefeller said that Mr Duncan-Watt could use the photographs once he had paid his share. As Mr Duncan-Watt has not made these payments, Mr Rockefeller therefore alleges that Mr Duncan-Watt had no authorisation to publish the photographs on his website. Mr Rockefeller gave evidence at the trial that the alleged arrangement was made and was cross-examined to the effect that it was not, in the course of which it was put to him that his evidence was false.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the reasons given below, I consider that any legal professional privilege in the communications has been impliedly waived.2. EVIDENCE The applicants relied upon the affidavit of Ms Lynne Elizabeth Anne Lewis, solicitor, sworn 13 March 2019. Ms Lewis has acted for the applicants since on or around 10 November 2006, first as a partner of MinterEllison and subsequently as a partner of Bird & Bird. In addition, a bundle of documents entitled “Documents re privilege claim” was received in evidence, together with a letter dated 21 December 2016 from Mr Gardiman to Mr Rockefeller which was attached to an email from Mr Gardiman to Mr Rockefeller bearing the same date, and is relied upon by Mr Rockefeller at trial to establish ownership of the copyright in the photographs. Finally, a copy of the two communications in respect of which privilege was claimed was marked for identification and provided to me at the hearing to consider in determining the applicants’ objection to the notice to produce, but was not at that time provided to the respondent or his legal representatives. 3. BACKGROUND In summarising the background and otherwise making findings necessary to dispose of the limited issue before me, I emphasise that I have not made any findings as to the substantive issues in dispute between the parties. Among other causes of action, the statement of claim alleges that:(1)Dario Gardiman, an Australian citizen, is the author of photographs depicting (among other things) Mr Duncan-Watt with puppets from the stage show “Thank You for Being a Friend”;(2)the photographs were made by Mr Gardiman pursuant to an agreement for valuable consideration with the applicants pursuant to which Mr Gardiman was to take photographs in a variety of compositional combinations of Mr Rockefeller, Mr Duncan-Watt, and/or the “Thank You for Being a Friend” puppets;(3)the applicants are the owner of the copyright in the photographs, particulars of which are the “Letter of confirmation of assignment from Dario Gardiman dated 21 December 2016”; and(4)the respondent has reproduced and communicated the photographs to the public on his website without the licence or authority of the applicants, thereby infringing their copyright. Mr Rockefeller and Mr Duncan-Watt are the co-authors of a stage show, “Thank You for Being a Friend”, which is apparently a parody of the 1980s and 1990s American television sitcom, “The Golden Girls”. In his defence, Mr Duncan-Watt pleads that he does not know and cannot admit the alleged agreement pursuant to which the photographs were taken, admits that the applicants are the owner of copyright in the photographs, and denies that the reproduction and communication of the photographs by him was without the licence or authority of the applicants. Rather, Mr Duncan-Watt alleges at [26] of his defence that:a)the Applicants provided an express license to the Respondent to reproduce and communicate the Photographs to the public; andb)the licence provided to the Respondent by the Applicant was irrevocable; orc)in the alternative, the licence provided to the Respondent by the Applicant was revoked on 20 December 2016.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further and in any event, I accept the respondent’s submission that the communications are potentially relevant to the case on which Mr Duncan-Watt opened at trial and upon which he cross-examined Mr Rockefeller, insofar as Mr Duncan-Watt contends that the bringing of these proceedings is collateral to the New York proceedings and seeks to challenge the applicants’ motivations in pursuing the litigation (see above at [24]).6. CONCLUSION As I have found that privilege did not attach to the communications identified in the list of privileged documents produced by the applicants pursuant to the Notice to Produce dated 5 March 2019, and identified as MFI-A2 on this application, the application by the respondent to access the privileged communications must be allowed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Importantly in this regard, as the respondent submits, considerations of fairness do not feature in the assessment of whether privilege has been waived save insofar as they may bear upon the existence of the inconsistency between the client’s conduct and maintenance of the confidentiality of the advice. As the plurality held in Carnell:29. Disputes as to implied waver usually arise from the need to decide whether particular conduct is inconsistent with the maintenance of the confidentiality which the privilege is intended to protect. When an affirmative answer is given to such a question, it is sometimes said that waiver is “imputed by operation of law”. This means that the law recognises the inconsistency and determines its consequences, even though such consequences may not reflect the subjective intention of the party who has lost the privilege. … What brings about the waiver is the inconsistency, which the courts, where necessary informed by considerations of fairness, perceive, between the conduct of the client and maintenance of the confidentiality; not some overriding principle of fairness operating at large.(emphasis added; citations omitted)5. HAS LEGAL PROFESSIONAL PRIVILEGE IN THE COMMUNICATIONS BEEN LOST? The respondent seeks production of the allegedly privileged communications from Mr Rockefeller in the context of a case put by the respondent explained by senior counsel for the respondent in the following terms:The dispute broke out in 2016 and the proceedings in New York commenced in September 2016. Mr Rockefeller, on our case, then went looking around for weapons that he could throw at Mr Duncan-Watt in Australia, and he decided that these photographs – or the copyright in them, we say – was one of the ways that he could launch a counterattack. What is not controversial is that he got back in touch at that stage with a photographer, Mr Gardiman, to try to bring in the copyright. No doubt with a view to then enforcing that copyright against Mr Duncan-Watt … In relation to this aspect of the respondent’s case, the respondent referred first to the email exchange between Mr Rockefeller and Mr Gardiman in which Mr Gardiman sent Mr Rockefeller the letter of 21 December 2016 “confirming” the assignment of copyright in the photographs to Mr Rockefeller. Secondly, the respondent referred to his cross-examination of Mr Rockefeller about the letter in the course of which Mr Rockefeller gave evidence that:(1)he got back in touch with Mr Gardiman in the closing days of 2016 by phone first;(2)he followed up the phone conversation with an email entitled “Usage of Golden Girls photography”;(3)Mr Gardiman had prepared the first draft;(4)this led to a new draft being prepared by a lawyer acting for Mr Rockefeller at MinterEllison which was sent by Mr Rockefeller to Mr Gardiman under cover of an email titled “Usage of Golden Girls photography”; and(5)Mr Gardiman then “tweaked it”, put it on his letterhead, signed it, and returned it.