Justin Antony Firth v Virginia Read

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

CITATION: Justin Antony Firth v Virginia Read [2023] NTLC 23

PARTIES:  Justin Anthony FIRTH
v
Virginia READ

TITLE OF COURT: LOCAL COURT

JURISDICTION: CRIMINAL

FILE NO: 22227595

DELIVERED ON: 7 November 2023

DELIVERED AT:  Darwin
HEARING DATES:  6, 10 and 14 November 2023
JUDGEMENT OF:  Acting Judge Neill
CATCHWORDS: 

Assault – when physical contact justified – elements of arrest – lawfulness of arrest

Police General Order Arrest

Mole v Prior [2016] NTCA 2 paragraphs [42] to [48]

Criminal Code Act sections 1A, 27, 187, 188(1) and (2), 208E and 208F

Police Administration Act sections 123, 127, 134 and 148B

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Complainant:  Ms McKay
Defendant:  Mr O’Brien-Hartcher

Solicitors:

Complainant:  DPP
Defendant:  Mr O’Brien-Hartcher

Page | 1

Judgement category classification: B

Judgement ID number:  [2022] NTLC 23
Number of paragraphs:  130

Page | 2

IN THE LOCAL COURT
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN

TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 22227595

BETWEEN

Justin Anthony FIRTH

Complainant

AND

Virginia READ

Defendant

REASONS FOR JUDGEMENT

(Delivered 17 November 2023)

ACTING JUDGE NEILL

1. The Defendant Virginia Read was born on 19 May 1967 and she is currently 56 years of age.

2. The Defendant is charged with the following offence:

“On the 17th July 2022

at Adelaide River in the Northern Territory of Australia,

1. unlawfully assaulted Skye-lee ANDERSON:

Contrary to Section 188(1) of the Criminal Code

AND THAT the said unlawful assault involved the following circumstances of aggravation, namely:

(i) That the said Skye-lee ANDERSON suffered harm:

Contrary to section 188(2) of the criminal code”.

3. The Defendant has defended this charge and the matter was heard before me for three days

being 6, 10 and 14 November 2023.

4. The prosecution was not required by the defence at any stage before the hearing to provide formal particulars of the precise conduct of the Defendant which was alleged to constitute the charged assault. This meant that the prosecution was not limited in its case at the hearing to any particular conduct of the Defendant. The prosecution can identify and rely on any conduct of the Defendant established by the evidence as constituting the assault.

Page | 3

5. Ms McKay for the prosecution opened her case at the hearing on the limited basis that the

Defendant had “pushed” Ms Anderson. Notwithstanding this, I am satisfied that the defence was

not taken by surprise nor otherwise prejudiced by the prosecution’s additional reliance in the

course of the hearing on some different conduct by the Defendant as constituting the assault.

THE BACKGROUND

6. At the time of the alleged offence on 17 July 2022 the Defendant was a Superintendent in the Northern Territory Police Force. 17 July 2022 was a Sunday and the Defendant was returning from Katherine to Darwin driving north along the Stuart Highway.

7. The Defendant had been in Katherine on a mixture of personal business and Police business
and she was driving a Police motor vehicle – Exhibit P8 entry for 0800. This was not a standard
Police vehicle. Rather, it…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Justin Antony Firth v Virginia Read and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NTLC 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Local Court at Darwin, Virginia Read was charged with unlawfully assaulting Skye-lee Anderson on 17 July 2022, with the aggravating circumstance that Anderson suffered harm. Read, a Superintendent in the Northern Territory Police Force, was driving a police recruitment sedan when she pulled over Anderson, who was driving at 140 km/h in a 130 km/h zone. Anderson recorded the interaction, and later complained to police that Read had pushed her and taken her car keys. The central issue was whether Read's physical contact with Anderson, if any, was justified under the law as part of a lawful arrest.

The court found that Read had lawfully arrested Anderson for failing to provide her residential address, a requirement under the Police Administration Act. Read had warned Anderson that she could be arrested if she did not comply, and Anderson had refused to provide the address despite multiple requests. The court ruled that Read's action of placing her hand on Anderson's arm and saying "Guess what?" was a sufficient indication of arrest, fulfilling the common law requirement to inform the person they are under arrest. The court also found that the arrest was justified as Read was concerned for public safety due to Anderson's reckless driving.

The prosecution argued that Read's arrest was unlawful because it was not a last resort and did not follow the police general order on arrest. However, the court held that the general order could not override the statutory power of arrest and that Read was justified in arresting Anderson to ensure she could be served with an infringement notice or located for future legal proceedings. The court concluded that Read's physical contact with Anderson was justified as part of a lawful arrest, and therefore not an assault. Consequently, the court found Read not guilty of the charge.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.