Jurd v Commissioner of Stamp Duties

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND

Application No. 487 of 1995

Brisbane

Before the Hon. Justice Williams

[Jurd v. Commissioner of Stamp Duties]

BETWEEN:

ALAN JEFFREY JURD

(Applicant)

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF STAMP DUTIES

(Respondent)

JUDGMENT - GN WILLIAMS J

Judgment delivered 09/10/1995

CATCHWORDS      JUDICIAL REVIEW - decisions of Commissioner of Stamp Duties - whether decision within power - case stated procedure not appropriate - application not summarily dismissed as having no reasonable basis.

Counsel:Gotterson QC and Alexander for applicant-respondent.

Clarke for respondent-applicant.

Solicitors:Crown Solicitor for applicant-respondent.

Cleary Hoare for respondent-applicant.

Hearing Date:   22 August 1995

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND

Application No. 487 of 1995

BETWEEN:

ALAN JEFFREY JURD

(Applicant)

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF STAMP DUTIES

(Respondent)

DRAFT JUDGMENT - GN WILLIAMS J

Judgment delivered 09/10/1995

The applicant, Alan Jeffrey Jurd, seeks to have certain decisions of the Commissioner for Stamp Duties, the respondent, reviewed pursuant to the provisions of the Judicial Review Act 1991. Three separate decisions are specified in the application, namely:

1.The decision made on 11 October 1994 to mark a Deed of Variation of Trust dated 18 April 1994 with the notation "No Duty Payable";

2.A decision on 24 March 1995 to assess that Deed of Variation to stamp duty of $6,126.50 under the heading "Settlement Deed of Gift or Voluntary Conveyance" in the First Schedule to the Stamp Act;

3.A decision on 16 June 1995 to disallow the Notice of Objection lodged by the applicant dated 21 April 1995.

The motion now before me was brought by the respondent seeking to have the application dismissed pursuant to ss. 12(b), 13 or 48 of the Judicial Review Act.  The respondent also submitted that the application was out of time particularly in so far as it sought a review of the first and second decisions, and it was further contended that no extension of time was warranted.
           The circumstances in which the assessment of duty (the second decision) was made were somewhat unusual and in consequence it is necessary to refer to the background to the making of the three decisions in question.
           On 18 April 1994 the applicant executed a document entitled "Deed of Variation".  If one ignores cl. 5 thereof it is clearly arguable that that document varies in some significant respects a Deed of Settlement dated 28 February 1987 which created the AM Jurd Family Trust.  Cl. 5 of the Deed of 18 April 1994 was in these terms:

"It is a condition precedent to this Deed having any operation that it be stamped under the Stamp Act with the stamp "No Duty Payable" or equivalent notation so that, until it is so stamped, it has no effect.  In the event of it being stamped with any other notation other than "No Duty Payable", the Trustee may, by resolution, or, in the case of a Trustee being a company, by a resolution of its directors, determine whether that notation is an equivalent notation to "No Duty Payable".  Upon…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jurd v Commissioner of Stamp Duties and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] QSC 249
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of Queensland heard an application by Alan Jeffrey Jurd against the Commissioner of Stamp Duties. Jurd sought a review of three decisions made by the Commissioner, two of which were time-barred. The first decision marked a Deed of Variation of Trust with the notation "No Duty Payable." The second decision assessed the Deed of Variation for stamp duty. The third decision disallowed Jurd's Notice of Objection to the second decision. The Commissioner moved to dismiss the application, arguing it had no reasonable basis and was out of time. Justice Williams held that the application was not out of time concerning the third decision and that it was not appropriate to summarily dismiss the application. The Court found that the application raised substantial matters that should be reviewed under the Judicial Review Act.

The central legal issues in this case were whether the Court should extend the time for making the application to review the decisions of 11 October 1994 and 24 March 1995, and whether the application had a reasonable basis. The Court needed to determine if the Commissioner had the power to mark the Deed of Variation "No Duty Payable" to satisfy a condition precedent and whether this conduct was within power. The Court also needed to decide if the application could be conveniently raised under the Stamp Act or if it required review under the Judicial Review Act.

Justice Williams concluded that the time for making the application to review the decisions of 11 October 1994 and 24 March 1995 should be extended to 17 July 1995. The Court found that the application raised substantial matters that should be reviewed under the Judicial Review Act. The Commissioner's failure to communicate the decision of 11 October 1994 prevented Jurd from seeking a review within time. The Court dismissed the Commissioner's notice of motion with costs. The Court did not comment on the ultimate merits of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

Alan Jeffrey Jurd executed a "Deed of Variation" on 18 April 1994, which was intended to vary the AM Jurd Family Trust established by a Deed of Settlement on 28 February 1987. Clause 5 of the Deed of Variation stipulated that the document would only have effect if it was stamped under the Stamp Act with the notation "No Duty Payable" or an equivalent notation. On 3 May 1994, Jurd's solicitors submitted the Deed of Variation to the Commissioner of Stamp Duties for assessment. The Commissioner initially marked the Deed with "No Duty Payable" on 11 October 1994, but this decision was not communicated to Jurd's solicitors. Subsequently, on 24 March 1995, the Commissioner assessed the Deed for stamp duty at $6,126.50. Jurd lodged a Notice of Objection on 21 April 1995, which was disallowed by the Commissioner on 16 June 1995. Jurd filed an application for judicial review on 17 July 1995.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of Queensland as an application for judicial review of decisions made by the Commissioner of Stamp Duties. The respondent, the Commissioner of Stamp Duties, sought to have the application dismissed under sections 12(b), 13, and 48 of the Judicial Review Act 1991, arguing that the application was out of time and lacked a reasonable basis. The applicant, Alan Jeffrey Jurd, argued that the Commissioner's decisions to mark the Deed of Variation with "No Duty Payable" on 11 October 1994, to assess the deed for stamp duty on 24 March 1995, and to disallow the Notice of Objection on 16 June 1995, should be reviewed. The application was initially considered out of time regarding the first two decisions but timely concerning the third decision. The court had to determine whether the application could proceed despite the time constraints and whether there was a reasonable basis for the review.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Commissioner had the authority to mark the Deed of Variation with "No Duty Payable" without communicating this decision to Jurd, and if such conduct was within the power of the Commissioner under the Stamp Act.
2. Whether the Commissioner's decision on 11 October 1994 was merely an acknowledgment that no duty was payable or if it was intended to ensure that the condition in Clause 5 was fulfilled, thereby attracting duty.
3. Whether the applicant is entitled to have the Court review the decisions made by the Commissioner concerning the Deed of Variation.

Held
1. The court held that the time for making an application to review the decisions of the Commissioner of 11 October 1994 and 24 March 1995 should be extended to 17 July 1995.
2. The court dismissed the notice of motion of the Commissioner seeking to have the application summarily dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the arguments presented by the Commissioner for summary dismissal of the application, which included the adequacy of review under the Stamp Act and the lack of reasonable basis for challenging the decisions. However, the court found that the application raised substantial issues that could not be conveniently addressed under a case stated procedure. Specifically, the court identified the potential breach of natural justice due to the failure to communicate the decision of 11 October 1994 to the applicant, as well as the issue of whether the Commissioner had the power to mark the Deed of Variation with "No Duty Payable" without communicating this decision to the applicant. The court noted that these issues could not be adequately addressed under the provisions of the Stamp Act, and thus, it was in the interest of justice for the Court to review these decisions under the Judicial Review Act. The court also noted that the failure of the Commissioner to communicate the decision of 11 October 1994 prevented the applicant from seeking a timely review of that decision, and consequently, the application should not be dismissed as out of time. The court concluded that the application raised substantial matters that ought to be reviewed by the Court.