Junee Railway Workshop Pty Ltd v Independent Transport Safety and Reliability Regulator

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

CITATION: Junee Railway Workshop Pty Ltd v Independent Transport Safety and Reliability Regulator [2006] NSWADT 184
DIVISION: General Division
PARTIES: APPLICANT
Junee Railway Workshop Pty Ltd
RESPONDENT
Independent Transport Safety and Reliability Regulator
FILE NUMBER: 063119
HEARING DATES: 17/03/06
SUBMISSIONS CLOSED: 03/17/2006
EXTEMPORE DECISION DATE: 03/17/2006
 
DATE OF DECISION: 

06/16/2006
BEFORE: O'Connor K - DCJ (President)
CATCHWORDS: Stay of Prohibition Notice
MATTER FOR DECISION: Principal matter
CASES CITED: Doyle v Commissioner of Police [1999] NSWADT 84
REPRESENTATION:

APPLICANT
N Williams SC instructed by Watson Mangioni Lawyers

RESPONDENT
S Thompson, solicitor, Sparke Helmore Solicitors
ORDERS: 1. Pursuant to section 57 of the Rail Safety Act 2002 (NSW), Prohibition Notice A28114 issued on 15 March 2006 by the Respondent to the Applicant is stayed until 31 March 2006; 2. Order 1 is granted subject to the following undertakings given by the Applicant in relation to all rolling stock movements to, from or within the Applicant’s site at the Junee Roundhouse in Junee, New South Wales (the “Site”), for the period the stay is in force:; (a) prior to each proposed movement to, from or within the Site, a movement plan and risk assessment of the proposed movement shall be conducted by the Applicant’s general manager, Mr Andrew Clinton, the Applicant’s Workshop foreman, Mr Gordon Groves and the individual personnel involved in the proposed movement;; (b) the movement plan and risk assessment in (a) shall be documented and recorded in a register of temporary movements;; (c) the movement plan and risk assessment shall confirm the proposed path of movement is free of any obstacles or interferences;; (d) the risk assessment shall confirm that the points along the proposed path are set in the correct position for the proposed movement;; (e) each of the participants in the proposed movement shall have the authority to call for the immediate cessation of the proposed movement;; (f) the movement shall be conducted in accordance with the movement plan and risk assessment;; (g) if any persons other than Mr Andrew Clinton, Mr Gordon Groves and the individual personnel involved in the proposed movement come within 10 metres of the path of the proposed movement, the movement shall be immediately stopped until the area is clear;; (h) a copy of the risk assessment shall be sent to the Respondent together with a report as to the outcome of the movement;; (i) in addition, in relation to movements in and out of the Site, the Australian Rail Track Corporation is to be given a copy of the movement plan and risk assessment prior to the movement occurring; and; (j) all operators of rolling stock from, to and within the Site and all persons working within the Site are to be made aware of the procedures set out in (a)-(i) above; 3. The reference to rolling stock movements in order 2 above includes any movement occurring wholly within the Site that does not cross the boundary between Australian Rail Track Corporation’s infrastructure and the Site, as well as movements across that…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Junee Railway Workshop Pty Ltd v Independent Transport Safet... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWADT 184
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves Junee Railway Workshop Pty Ltd as the applicant and the Independent Transport Safety and Reliability Regulator as the respondent. The applicant sought to stay a Prohibition Notice issued by the respondent, which had been issued under the Rail Safety Act 2002 (NSW). The prohibition notice, A28114, had been issued on 15 March 2006, and the applicant sought to have it stayed until 31 March 2006. The legal issues before the court included whether the prohibition notice was validly issued and if the applicant could satisfy the requirements to have it stayed. The applicant argued that the notice was issued without proper consultation and that it would cause significant financial harm to its operations if enforced immediately.

The court considered the provisions of the Rail Safety Act 2002 (NSW) and the nature of the prohibition notice. It was determined that the notice was validly issued under the Act, and the respondent had the authority to issue such a notice. However, the court found that the applicant had demonstrated that staying the prohibition notice was in the interests of justice, given the potential financial impact on its operations and the applicant's proposed measures to mitigate the risks identified in the notice. The applicant agreed to stringent conditions to ensure the safety of rolling stock movements during the stay period. These conditions included conducting detailed movement plans and risk assessments, ensuring that all personnel were aware of these procedures, and maintaining communication with the regulator and the Australian Rail Track Corporation.

In light of the applicant's undertakings and the balance of convenience, the court decided to grant the stay of the prohibition notice until 31 March 2006. The court imposed detailed conditions that the applicant had to adhere to during the stay period, ensuring the safety of all movements and compliance with regulatory requirements. The final orders included the stay of the prohibition notice subject to these conditions, with liberty for the parties to apply further if necessary.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to section 57 of the Rail Safety Act 2002 (NSW), Prohibition Notice A28114 issued on 15 March 2006 by the Respondent to the Applicant is stayed until 31 March 2006; 2. Order 1 is granted subject to the following undertakings given by the Applicant in relation to all rolling stock movements to, from or within the Applicant’s site at the Junee Roundhouse in Junee, New South Wales (the “Site”), for the period the stay is in force:; (a) prior to each proposed movement to, from or within the Site, a movement plan and risk assessment of the proposed movement shall be conducted by the Applicant’s general manager, Mr Andrew Clinton, the Applicant’s Workshop foreman, Mr Gordon Groves and the individual personnel involved in the proposed movement;; (b) the movement plan and risk assessment in (a) shall be documented and recorded in a register of temporary movements;; (c) the movement plan and risk assessment shall confirm the proposed path of movement is free of any obstacles or interferences;; (d) the risk assessment shall confirm that the points along the proposed path are set in the correct position for the proposed movement;; (e) each of the participants in the proposed movement shall have the authority to call for the immediate cessation of the proposed movement;; (f) the movement shall be conducted in accordance with the movement plan and risk assessment;; (g) if any persons other than Mr Andrew Clinton, Mr Gordon Groves and the individual personnel involved in the proposed movement come within 10 metres of the path of the proposed movement, the movement shall be immediately stopped until the area is clear;; (h) a copy of the risk assessment shall be sent to the Respondent together with a report as to the outcome of the movement;; (i) in addition, in relation to movements in and out of the Site, the Australian Rail Track Corporation is to be given a copy of the movement plan and risk assessment prior to the movement occurring; and; (j) all operators of rolling stock from, to and within the Site and all persons working within the Site are to be made aware of the procedures set out in (a)-(i) above; 3. The reference to rolling stock movements in order 2 above includes any movement occurring wholly within the Site that does not cross the boundary between Australian Rail Track Corporation’s infrastructure and the Site, as well as movements across that boundary; 4. The parties have liberty to apply.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established