TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re: Opposition to removal of trade mark registration 1306114 SNOWFLAKE (25) – request by Julie Tarte for extension of time to file evidence in support, objection by Snowflake Designs, Inc.
| Delegate: | Katrina Brown | |
| Representation: | Removal Applicant: | Blake Knowles of Spruson & Ferguson |
| Removal Opponent: | Sam Wilson of CCS Legal Pty Ltd | |
| Decision: | 2019 ATMO 24 Trade Marks Regulations 1995 – regulation 9.18 – extension of time to file evidence in support – exceptional circumstances not established – extension of time refused. | |
Background
This matter concerns a formal objection by Snowflake Designs, Inc. (‘the Removal Applicant’) to an application in the name of Julie Tarte (‘the Removal Opponent’) for an extension of time (‘EOT’) to file evidence in support (‘EIS’) of the opposition to the removal of trade mark registration 1306114 SNOWFLAKE (‘the Trade Mark’).
The Removal Opponent’s EIS was due to be filed by 26 June 2018.
On 26 July 2018 the Removal Opponent applied for an EOT of two months to file the EIS. The reasons provided with the EOT request were as follows:
We had started the process with one solicitor, and that didn’t go anywhere, I then applied for a court hearing to show my evidence but didn’t realise I was meant to do this after submitting my evidence, I then had Greg spend 1 day and $600 to do this, only to find out this was the incorrect process, he then met with a new solicitor who wanted $5000 to help me apply for an extension, which I just can’t afford…I was overseas the last week of June and unable to attend to this from there…my extension application is late as I was having trouble getting help with how to apply for an extension, til my daughter helped me, as I am not that tech savvy, and had already applied for a court case instead. We are a small family business, and don’t have a large amount of resources.
On 30 July 2018 a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks issued a notice of intention to refuse the EOT. The delegate was not satisfied that there was enough information to justify the extension being granted.
On 13 August 2018 the Removal Opponent provided the delegate with additional information including:
Our solicitor called 4 days before our evidence was due to let us know she would no longer be acting for us, this gave us little time to compile what we had already given her.
Karina from Blue Print suggested I file for a hearing, which is what we then did within the time period. Clearly this was incorrect advice from her. At which time we applied for a hearing, not realizing we had to forward the evidence at the same time as applying.
…
From the time of the first letter we commence[d] collecting information on our trade mark…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Julie Tarte v Snowflake Designs, Inc and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] ATMO 24
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the delegate was whether to grant the Removal Opponent an extension of time to file evidence, pursuant to Regulation 9.18 of the relevant regulations. This required the delegate to determine if the Removal Opponent had made all reasonable efforts to comply with filing requirements and was unable to do so despite acting promptly and diligently, or if there were exceptional circumstances justifying an extension.
The delegate considered the Tarte Declaration, which detailed the Removal Opponent's attempts to secure new legal representation after their previous solicitors withdrew. The declaration highlighted difficulties in obtaining timely advice and instructions, including the unavailability of a new attorney until 2 July 2018 and a subsequent delay in receiving a fee agreement. The delegate noted that Regulation 9.18(4) defines "exceptional circumstances" to include situations beyond a party's control that prevent compliance with filing requirements. The delegate found that the circumstances described, including the withdrawal of legal representation and the subsequent efforts to engage new counsel, constituted exceptional circumstances justifying an extension of time.
The delegate ordered that the period for filing evidence be extended.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Written submissions for the hearing were filed on behalf of both parties. The submissions on behalf of the Removal Opponent contained a declaration of Gregory Tarte dated 4 December 2018 (‘the Tarte Declaration’). This declaration sought to provide additional information in relation to the events set out in earlier correspondence from the Removal Opponent and included:At about 4:35pm on Friday, 22 June 2018, I received a phone [call] from Karina Vassili of Blue Print Law. Blue Print Law were representing my wife, Julie Tarte, as the owner of the Snowflake Trademark.…Vassilli: You have not settled our account for our work on the Snowflake matter and we are not in a position to act on your behalf in the matter. The evidence is due to be filed early next week.Tarte: What should we do?Vassili: You could go to the IP Australia website and apply for a court hearing. That will give you more time to collect evidence and otherwise deal with the matter. We will not be providing any further support. …I then rang my wife who was on holidays in Bali and recounted the conversation with Vassili, specifically the advice that seeking a hearing would provide some time, which we would need to re-compile the information – the evidentiary material that we had provided to Blue Print Law over the previous 18 months. …I was trying to identify another trademark attorney to act in the matter…I was advised by Navado Lawyers & Solicitors that the earliest appointment was 9:00am on 2 July 2018. …Julie and I met with Ms Rossi [Navado Lawyers] during the morning of 3 July 2018…On 6 July 2019, we received a fee agreement…After receiving the fee agreement, from 7 to 12 July 2018, I took part in a number of phone calls in which I asked Navado to simply submit a request for an extension of time which would provide Julie with time to think about how to proceed. …At the time of these events, I was extremely busy with other business matters, including running my construction company. Julie was under a lot of pressure and was rather unwell…which affected her ability to properly focus on the Snowflake trademark dispute. I heard the matter, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, on 7 December 2018. The Removal Applicant was represented by Blake Knowles of Spruson & Ferguson. The Removal Opponent was represented by Sam Wilson of CCS Legal Pty Ltd. Regulation 9.18 relevantly provides: (1) A party may request the Registrar to extend a period for filing evidence mentioned in regulation 9.16.(2) The Registrar may extend the period only if the Registrar is satisfied that:(a) the party: (i) has made all reasonable efforts to comply with all relevant filing requirements of this Part; and(ii) despite acting promptly and diligently at all times to ensure the filing of the evidence within the period, is unable to do so; or(b) there are exceptional circumstances justifying the extension. …(4) In this regulation:“exceptional circumstances” includes the following:(a) a circumstance beyond the control of a party that prevents the party from complying with a filing requirement under this Part;(b) an error or omission by the Registrar or an employee that prevents a party from complying with a filing requirement under this Part;(c) an order of a court or a direction by the Registrar that the opposition be stayed.