JULIE POSETTI v KOSCIUSKO THREDBO PTY LIMITED
[2004] ACTSC 50 (23 June 2004)
NEGLIGENCE – personal injury – ski resort – claim against resort operator – timber ramp on boardwalk – gradient of ramp – compliance with building code – compliance with Australian Standards – effect of ice on ramp
DAMAGES – personal injury – T7 fracture – damage to associated structures – chronic pain dysfunction syndrome – loss of career – no issue of principle
National Parks and Wildlife Act 1974 (NSW)
National Parks and Wildlife Act Regulations 1974 (NSW), r. 11
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), s 44
Practice Direction No 2 of 2001
No. SC 487 of 2000
Judge: Master Harper
Supreme Court of the ACT
Date: 23 June 2004
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE )
) No. SC 487 of 2000
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
BETWEEN:JULIE POSETTI
Plaintiff
AND:KOSCIUSKO THREDBO PTY LIMITED
Defendant
ORDER
Judge: Master Harper
Date: 23 June 2004
Place: Canberra
THE COURT ORDERS:
Judgment be entered for the defendant.
Contents Page Paragraph
Background 1
The pleadings 5
The case on liability – the plaintiff’s evidence 7
The case on liability – the plaintiff’s supporting witnesses 16
Condition of the ramp – the defendant’s witnesses 24
The footwear issue 35
The meteorological evidence 39
Expert evidence – ski resort management 42
The engineering evidence 48
Damages – the plaintiff’s evidence 76
Damages – the supporting witnesses 106
The general medical evidence 109
The orthopaedic evidence 117
The psychiatric evidence 130
Gradient of the ramp – the regulatory scheme 137
The ice issue 149
Contributory negligence 164
Damages – provisional assessment 165
Conclusion 187
Background
The plaintiff’s claim is for damages for injuries which she suffered when she fell on a ramp at Thredbo in New South Wales on 5 August 1997. The defendant is sued as the company which occupied, managed and controlled the area of land on which the ramp was located.
The company is, and was in 1997, the lessee of part of the Kosciusko National Park, where it operates, for commercial purposes, the Thredbo Ski Resort. The resort is promoted by the defendant as the best resort in the southern hemisphere, and is regarded by many as Australia’s premier ski resort. The land includes extensive downhill ski runs on the south-facing slopes of the Ramshead Range, accessed by a complex of chairlifts and T-bars. At the foot of the slopes lies a substantial village, which includes commercial, club and private lodges and apartments, a hotel and a number of restaurants, cafes, bars and shops. Portions of the village are located on both sides of the Thredbo or Crackenback River, which flows through the valley in a generally northeasterly direction. Whilst primarily a winter resort, Thredbo is a popular destination for tourists in the summer months also, offering a golf course, tennis courts and a bobsled which was installed some ten years ago.
The terrain is steep, and much of the village has been built on sharply…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read JULIE Posetti v Kosciusko Thredbo Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] ACTSC 50
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Background
Background to the litigation
The case hinged on whether the ramp was icy and slippery at the time of Posetti's fall, which she alleged caused her to lose her footing. Posetti provided detailed accounts of her fall, describing the ramp as extremely slippery and icy. However, several witnesses, including resort employees, testified that the ramp was dry and free of ice at the time. Expert evidence was presented regarding the design and construction of the ramp, with conflicting opinions on whether it complied with building codes and safety standards. The court found that while the ramp was steep and potentially slippery, there was insufficient evidence to conclude that it was icy at the time of Posetti's fall. Consequently, the court found in favour of the defendant, holding that Posetti had failed to prove her case on the balance of probabilities.
The matter JULIE Posetti v Kosciusko Thredbo Pty Limited [2004] ACTSC 50 was a personal injury claim brought by Julie Posetti against Kosciusko Thredbo Pty Limited. The plaintiff alleged she suffered a T7 vertebra compression fracture and soft-tissue injuries when she slipped and fell on a wooden ramp at the defendant's ski resort in Thredbo, New South Wales, on 5 August 1997. The case came before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory for a trial, which took place over a number of days between April and July 2003. The Supreme Court was required to determine whether the defendant's negligence in relation to the ramp caused or contributed to the plaintiff's injuries. The case involved extensive evidence from both parties, including expert witnesses on ski resort management, engineering, meteorology, and medical issues. After considering all the evidence, the court found that the plaintiff had failed to establish her case on the balance of probabilities and entered judgment in favour of the defendant. The court also assessed the damages the plaintiff would have been entitled to if she had succeeded in her claim.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the ramp on the walkway at Thredbo ski resort excessively slippery and hazardous in icy conditions, as alleged by the plaintiff?
2. Was the gradient of the ramp on the walkway at Thredbo ski resort too steep for icy conditions, as claimed by the plaintiff?
3. Did the defendant fail to ensure that the surface of the walkway on the ramp was treated to reduce the risk of slipping during icy conditions?
4. Did the defendant fail to adequately supervise or supervise the use of the walkway during icy conditions, making it extremely hazardous?
5. Did the defendant fail to provide adequate warnings of the risk of using the ramp during icy conditions?
6. Did the defendant fail to warn persons such as the plaintiff that they should not walk upon the walkway in icy conditions unless special footwear was used?
7. Were the handrails adjacent to the ramp inadequate, as claimed by the plaintiff?
8. Was the plaintiff contributory negligent in her failure to take proper precautions for her own safety?
9. Was the plaintiff contributory negligent for not wearing appropriate footwear for the prevailing weather conditions?
10. Did the construction of the ramp comply with the Building Code of Australia and Australian Standards?
11. Was the slope of the ramp compliant with the requirements set out in the Building Code of Australia and Australian Standards?
12. Were the handrails provided on the ramp compliant with the requirements set out in the Building Code of Australia and Australian Standards?
13. Was the surface of the walkway and ramp compliant with the non-slip finish requirements set out in the Building Code of Australia and Australian Standards?
14. Was the presence of ice on the ramp a cause of the plaintiff's fall, as claimed by the plaintiff?
Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiff failed to establish on the balance of probabilities that there was ice on the ramp at the time of her fall. As a result, the court found that the plaintiff's claim was unsuccessful.
2. The court concluded that the plaintiff failed to establish on the balance of probabilities that the ramp was too steep for icy conditions. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was unsuccessful.
3. The court concluded that the plaintiff failed to establish on the balance of probabilities that the defendant failed to treat the surface of the walkway on the ramp to reduce the risk of slipping during icy conditions. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was unsuccessful.
4. The court concluded that the plaintiff failed to establish on the balance of probabilities that the defendant failed to adequately supervise or supervise the use of the walkway during icy conditions, making it extremely hazardous. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was unsuccessful.
5. The court concluded that the plaintiff failed to establish on the balance of probabilities that the defendant failed to provide adequate warnings of the risk of using the ramp during icy conditions. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was unsuccessful.
6. The court concluded that the plaintiff failed to establish on the balance of probabilities that the defendant failed to warn persons such as the plaintiff that they should not walk upon the walkway in icy conditions unless special footwear was used. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was unsuccessful.
7. The court concluded that the plaintiff failed to establish on the balance of probabilities that the handrails adjacent to the ramp were inadequate. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was unsuccessful.
8. The court concluded that the plaintiff was not contributory negligent in her failure to take proper precautions for her own safety. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was unsuccessful.
9. The court concluded that the plaintiff was not contributory negligent for not wearing appropriate footwear for the prevailing weather conditions. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was unsuccessful.
10. The court concluded that the construction of the ramp did not comply with the Building Code of Australia and Australian Standards. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was unsuccessful.
11. The court concluded that the slope of the ramp was not compliant with the requirements set out in the Building Code of Australia and Australian Standards. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was unsuccessful.
12. The court concluded that the handrails provided on the ramp were not compliant with the requirements set out in the Building Code of Australia and Australian Standards. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was unsuccessful.
13. The court concluded that the surface of the walkway and ramp was not compliant with the non-slip finish requirements set out in the Building Code of Australia and Australian Standards. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was unsuccessful.
14. The court concluded that the presence of ice on the ramp was not a cause of the plaintiff's fall, as claimed by the plaintiff. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was unsuccessful.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory in Julie Posetti v Kosciusko Thredbo Pty Limited [2004] ACTSC 50 considered various issues related to the plaintiff's claim for damages due to injuries sustained from a fall on a ramp at the Thredbo ski resort. The court examined whether the ramp was excessively slippery and hazardous, if its gradient was too steep for icy conditions, and if the defendant failed to treat the surface or provide adequate supervision, warnings, and handrails. Additionally, the court evaluated the compliance of the ramp with the Building Code of Australia and Australian Standards, the presence of ice as a cause of the fall, and contributory negligence on the part of the plaintiff.
Regarding the slipperiness and hazardous nature of the ramp, the court found that while the ramp was steep and its surface smooth, there was insufficient evidence to conclude that it was covered in ice at the time of the plaintiff's fall. The plaintiff's recollection was deemed unreliable, and the court found no evidence to support the defendant's assertion that the ramp was ice-free at the time.
As for the gradient of the ramp, the court concluded that it was steeper than required by the Building Code of Australia and Australian Standards, which mandated a maximum gradient of 1 in 14 for ramps in alpine areas. The court found that the ramp had a slope of 1 in 3.7, which did not comply with these standards.
The court also found that the defendant failed to treat the surface of the ramp to reduce the risk of slipping during icy conditions, as required by the Building Code of Australia and Australian Standards. The court determined that the ramp's surface did not provide an adequate coefficient of friction, making it potentially hazardous in icy conditions.
In terms of supervision and warnings, the court found that the defendant did not provide adequate warnings of the risk of using the ramp during icy conditions or advise visitors to use special footwear. The court found that the defendant's failure to provide adequate warnings and advice contributed to the plaintiff's injuries.
Regarding the compliance of the ramp with the Building Code of Australia and Australian Standards, the court found that the ramp did not meet the requirements for gradient, handrails, and surface finish. The court concluded that the ramp's design and construction did not comply with the applicable standards.
The court found that the presence of ice on the ramp was not a cause of the plaintiff's fall, as there was insufficient evidence to support this claim. The court determined that the plaintiff could have slipped and fallen on the ramp even in the absence of ice, due to its steep gradient and smooth surface.
In terms of contributory negligence, the court found that the plaintiff was not guilty of contributory negligence in her failure to take proper precautions for her own safety or for not wearing appropriate footwear for the prevailing weather conditions. The court rejected the argument that the plaintiff should have used the balustrades to prevent herself from falling, as she had one hand on the balustrade when she slipped.
In conclusion, the court found that the plaintiff had failed to establish her case on the balance of probabilities and entered judgment in favor of the defendant. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a defendant may be liable for injuries sustained on their property if they fail to ensure that the property is safe for public use, including treating the surface to reduce the risk of slipping during hazardous conditions and providing adequate warnings and advice to visitors. Furthermore, the court found that the presence of ice on a ramp is not a necessary condition for a plaintiff to establish liability in a negligence claim.