Jones v Waterdale Enterprises Pty Ltd [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   JONES -v- WATERDALE ENTERPRISES PTY LTD [No 2] [2025] WASC 71

CORAM:   WHITBY J

HEARD:   26 FEBRUARY 2025

DELIVERED          :   6 MARCH 2025

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2326 of 2022

BETWEEN:   TREVOR JONES

Plaintiff

AND

WATERDALE ENTERPRISES PTY LTD

Defendant

WATERDALE ENTERPRISES PTY LTD

Plaintiff by counterclaim

TREVOR JONES

Defendant by counterclaim


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Application for a trial of preliminary issues - Whether court required to determine disputed facts - Whether evidence of surrounding circumstances may be adduced to assist construction of contract - No sufficient saving of time, inconvenience and costs by determination of preliminary issues - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)

Result:

Application dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : P Fletcher
Defendant : C P K Russell SC
Plaintiff by counterclaim : C P K Russell SC
Defendant by counterclaim : P Fletcher

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Fletcher Law
Defendant : HHG Legal Group
Plaintiff by counterclaim : HHG Legal Group
Defendant by counterclaim : Fletcher Law

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Briggs v Curtis Quick & Associates [1999] WASCA 139

Lansdale Pty Ltd v Moore [2009] WASCA 176

Mount Bruce Mining Pty Ltd v Wright Prospecting Pty Ltd [2015] HCA 37; (2015) 256 CLR 104

Palmer v Citic Ltd [No 2] [2019] WASC 14

WHITBY J:

Introduction and summary

  1. The plaintiff was a finance broker from 2002 until he retired on 16 February 2022.  As a finance broker, the plaintiff earned two types of commissions:

    (1) an 'upfront' commission that was paid upon approval of a loan application the plaintiff submitted to a financier; and

    (2) a 'trailing' commission that was paid on an ongoing basis on approved loans until each loan was repaid or refinanced.  The trailing commission was calculated by reference to the outstanding amount under a loan and would reduce as the outstanding amount reduced.

  2. The defendant carries on business under the name of 'Peel Finance Brokers' as trustee of the Boag Family Trust (PFB). The defendant provides a service to finance brokers and specified financiers (the PFB Panel Lenders) which facilitated the submission of loan applications from the finance brokers to the PFB Panel Lenders and the collection and distribution of commissions earned by the finance brokers.

  3. On or about 8 September 2003, the plaintiff entered into an agreement with PFB by which PFB agreed to provide its services to the plaintiff and the plaintiff agreed to be paid 80% of his upfront commissions collected by PFB, and 75% of his trailing commissions collected by PFB.  The parties refer to this agreement as the Sub‑Originators Agreement (SOA).

  4. Up until January 2013, the plaintiff completed loan applications for his clients and submitted them to various PFB Panel Lenders using PFB's facilities.

  5. From late 2004 to January 2013, each month the PFB Panel Lenders paid PFB the upfront and the trailing commissions referable to the current loans in place.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jones v Waterdale Enterprises Pty Ltd [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] WASC 71
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Jones v Waterdale Enterprises Pty Ltd [No 2] involved a dispute over whether the court should determine preliminary issues before proceeding to trial. The defendant, Waterdale Enterprises Pty Ltd, sought a trial of preliminary issues, while the plaintiff, Jones, opposed this application. The primary issue before the court was whether the court should determine disputed facts and whether evidence of surrounding circumstances could be adduced to assist in the construction of the contract. The defendant argued that determining the preliminary issues would be more efficient and timely, potentially leading to settlement and saving costs.

The court considered the defendant's argument that there was a clear demarcation between the issue of the proper construction of the Statement of Agreement (SOA) and the issue of quantum. The defendant contended that determining the preliminary issues would only require the court to examine the terms of the SOA and the facts set out in the proposed statement of agreed facts, without the need for evidence of surrounding circumstances. However, the court found that the plaintiff's opposition was based on the premise that determining the preliminary issues would not necessarily save time or costs, as it would require the court to resolve disputed facts, such as whether the plaintiff repudiated or breached the SOA.

The court ultimately decided against the defendant's application for a trial of preliminary issues. The court held that determining the preliminary issues in this case would not sufficiently save time, inconvenience, and costs. The court noted that the determination of disputed facts was integral to the resolution of the case and that the evidence of surrounding circumstances might be relevant to the construction of the contract. Therefore, the court found that the application for a trial of preliminary issues should be dismissed.

The court did not make any specific orders regarding the determination of preliminary issues but indicated that the matter should proceed to trial without a determination of preliminary issues. The court's decision highlighted the importance of considering the specific facts of each case when deciding whether to determine preliminary issues before trial.

Background

Background to the litigation

The defendant contends that there are features of this action which strongly support a determination of the Preliminary Issues. Those features are:(1) there is a clear demarcation between the issue of the proper construction of the SOA and the issue of quantum;(2) to determine the preliminary issues, the court need only determine the proper construction of the SOA having regard to the terms of the SOA and to the facts set out in the proposed statement of agreed facts (Proposed Facts); [4] (3) given neither party pleads any surrounding circumstances that are relevant to the construction of the SOA, no evidence of surrounding circumstances is relevant to the determination of the Preliminary Issues;(4) to the extent that there are disputed questions of fact, including whether the plaintiff repudiated and/or breached the SOA, the court can resolve these by reference to the correspondence between the parties referred to in the Proposed Facts; and(5) the determination of the Preliminary Issues can be completed in one day, as opposed to a trial which it estimates will take six days.[5] [4] Boag Affidavit TDB-1.[5] Defendant's outline of submissions filed 24 January 2025 Schedule A. The defendant submits that the determination of the Preliminary Issues will result in one of the following outcomes:(1) the plaintiff's claim will be dismissed;(2) the plaintiff's claim will be upheld in part or in full with the quantum to be determined – the defendant says that if this is the result, the parties will be able to resolve the amount to be paid between themselves; or(3) the defendant's counterclaim in relation to the return of documents will either by upheld or dismissed. The defendant says that this is a more efficient and timely way to resolve the proceedings, rather than the way forward proposed by the plaintiff - that being that the parties provide discovery, attend a mediation and then if the matter is not resolved, proceed to a 'full blown' trial. Mr Boag deposes that it is his belief that, given the diametrically opposed views of the parties, it is an all or nothing case which is unlikely to be resolved at a mediation.[6] The defendant says that the determination of the Preliminary Issues will significantly increase the prospect of settlement of the whole action and the counterclaim. [6] Boag Affidavit [34]. Mr Boag deposes that, if the defendant's application for a trial of Preliminary Issues is successful, it will forego the parts of its counterclaim that cannot be determined as preliminary issues.[7][7] Boag Affidavit [32]. The plaintiff submits that, based on the established legal principles, this case is not one in which it is appropriate to determine the Preliminary Issues prior to trial. This is because, the plaintiff says, the court will be required to determine disputed facts as to whether the plaintiff repudiated, or breached a term of, the SOA. The plaintiff says that a determination of the Preliminary Issues in such circumstances would not save time or costs, but rather may increase the costs and delay the resolution of the issues between the parties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court is required to determine disputed facts in deciding the preliminary issues.
2. Whether evidence of surrounding circumstances may be adduced to assist in the construction of the contract.
3. Whether there is a sufficient saving of time, inconvenience, and costs by determining the preliminary issues.

Held
1. The court is not required to determine disputed facts in deciding the preliminary issues. It found that the determination of the preliminary issues could be made by reference to the terms of the Statement of Agreed Facts (SOA) and the correspondence between the parties.
2. The court held that evidence of surrounding circumstances may not be adduced to assist in the construction of the contract. It found that neither party had pleaded any surrounding circumstances relevant to the construction of the SOA.
3. The court concluded that there is not a sufficient saving of time, inconvenience, and costs by determining the preliminary issues. It found that determining the preliminary issues would not necessarily lead to a resolution of the case or reduce the overall time and costs of the proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the arguments presented by both parties regarding the determination of preliminary issues. It noted the defendant's submission that there was a clear demarcation between the construction of the SOA and the issue of quantum, and that the determination of the preliminary issues could be completed in one day as opposed to a six-day trial. However, the court was of the view that the determination of the preliminary issues would not necessarily lead to a resolution of the case or reduce the overall time and costs of the proceedings. The court held that the plaintiff's contention that the court would be required to determine disputed facts was well-founded, and that such a determination would not save time or costs, but rather may increase the costs and delay the resolution of the issues between the parties. The court further held that evidence of surrounding circumstances was not relevant to the determination of the preliminary issues, as neither party had pleaded any surrounding circumstances relevant to the construction of the SOA. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases where the determination of preliminary issues would require the court to determine disputed facts or where there is no sufficient saving of time, inconvenience, and costs, the court should not determine the preliminary issues prior to trial. The court distinguished this case from prior authority that had held that the determination of preliminary issues could be appropriate in certain circumstances, as the facts of this case were unique and did not lend themselves to such a determination.