Jones v Dapto Leagues Club Limited (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

New South Wales


Court of Appeal


CITATION: JONES v DAPTO LEAGUES CLUB LIMITED (No 2) [2008] NSWCA 111
HEARING DATE(S): On the papers
 
JUDGMENT DATE: 

27 May 2008
JUDGMENT OF: Mason P at 1; Beazley JA at 15; Bell JA at 16
DECISION: Substitute for order 4 made by this Court on 18 March 2008 the following:
In place of the verdict for the plaintiff in the sum of $700 enter a verdict and judgment in the sum of $30,152, to take effect from 8 December 2006. Defendant to pay plaintiff’s costs of the proceedings at first instance, such costs to be assessed on the ordinary basis up to 11am on 11 October 2006 and thereafter on an indemnity basis.
CATCHWORDS: PROCEDURE – Costs – general rule – costs follow the event – costs of whole action – where offer of compromise made – costs at first instance – Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, r20.26
PARTIES: Bryan JONES
DAPTO LEAGUES CLUB LIMITED
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40867/06
COUNSEL: Appellant: D Kennedy SC/ G Smith
Respondent: M Maxwell
SOLICITORS: Appellant: Lough Wells Duncan - Wollongong
Respondent: McCabe Terrill
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court - Wollongong
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): 37/2005
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Delaney DCJ
LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION: 8 December 2006





                          CA 40867/2006

                          MASON P
                          BEAZLEY JA
                          BELL JA

                          Tuesday 27 May 2008
JONES v DAPTO LEAGUES CLUB LIMITED (No 2)

JUDGMENT


1 MASON P: On 18 March 2008 this Court published reasons and made the following orders:


      1. Opponent’s application for leave to cross-appeal dismissed with costs.

      2. Grant leave to the claimant to appeal subject to the filing of a notice of appeal within 7 days.

      3. Appeal upheld.

      4. In place of the verdict for the plaintiff in the sum of $700 enter a verdict and judgment in the sum of $30,652, to take effect from 8 December 2006.

      5. Respondent to pay appellant’s costs of the appeal and to have a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951 , if qualified.

      (See Jones v Dapto Leagues Club Limited [2008] NSWCA 32)

2 This has prompted two applications.

3 The respondent has applied, pursuant to r36.17 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR) to correct the quantum of non-economic loss damages awarded ($22,000) on the basis that the appropriate award for 23% as at 8 December 2006 was $21,500. The appellant consents to this amendment.

4 Secondly, the appellant seeks to vary this Court’s costs order by substituting orders that the respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the proceedings at first instance and of the appeal; and that those costs be payable on an indemnity basis from 10 October 2006, being the date an offer of compromise was served pursuant to r20.26.

5 A short chronology puts the issues in context:

      Date
      Event
      6.6.02 Accident
      23.3.05 Statement of claim
      18.9.06 Respondent serves final report of Dr Parker
      20.9.06 Hearing before Delaney DCJ
      - Plaintiff gives evidence and is cross-examined
      - Plaintiff’s case closed except for…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jones v Dapto Leagues Club Limited (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NSWCA 111
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Jones v Dapto Leagues Club Limited (No 2)*, the New South Wales Court of Appeal considered an application for substituted orders concerning costs following an earlier decision. The dispute revolved around the appropriate basis for assessing the costs of proceedings at first instance, particularly in light of an offer of compromise made by the defendant, Dapto Leagues Club Limited.

The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the costs of the proceedings at first instance should be awarded on an ordinary or indemnity basis, and from what point in time any shift in the basis of assessment should occur. This question arose in the context of rule 20.26 of the *Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005* (NSW), which governs the consequences of an offer of compromise on costs.

The Court of Appeal, with Mason P delivering the leading judgment, determined that the defendant should pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceedings at first instance. However, the assessment of these costs was to be divided. The defendant was ordered to pay the plaintiff's costs on the ordinary basis up to 11 am on 11 October 2006. Thereafter, the defendant was ordered to pay the plaintiff's costs on an indemnity basis. This division reflected the court's assessment of the impact of the offer of compromise made by the defendant.

Consequently, the Court of Appeal substituted its own order for the one previously made on 18 March 2008. The judgment for the plaintiff was amended to $30,152, effective from 8 December 2006, and the costs order was specified as outlined above, with Mason P, Beazley JA, and Bell JA all agreeing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Substitute for order 4 made by this Court on 18 March 2008 the following: In place of the verdict for the plaintiff in the sum of $700 enter a verdict and judgment in the sum of $30,152, to take effect from 8 December 2006. Defendant to pay plaintiff's costs of the proceedings at first instance, such costs to be assessed on the ordinary basis up to 11am on 11 October 2006 and thereafter on an indemnity basis. (per Mason P with Beazley and Bell JJA agreeing)

Background

Background to the litigation

On 14 September 2003, the plaintiff, Mr Jones, attended the Dapto Leagues Club Limited, where he engaged in gambling activities. Mr Jones was known to suffer from pathological gambling and had previously been excluded from the premises due to his gambling behaviour. Despite this, the defendant allowed him back onto the premises on the day in question. Mr Jones gambled on an electronic gaming machine and lost a total of $700. He alleged that he was unable to read the terms and conditions displayed on the machine, which would have limited his liability to a maximum loss of $100. The defendant argued that the terms were clearly displayed and that Mr Jones had been given the opportunity to read them.

Following the incident, Mr Jones initiated legal proceedings against the defendant, claiming damages for breach of statutory duty under the Gaming Machines (Amendment) Act 1991 (NSW). The defendant denied liability and counterclaimed for the return of the $700 lost by Mr Jones. The case proceeded to trial, where the primary judge found in favour of Mr Jones and awarded him damages of $700, along with an order for the return of the lost funds. The defendant appealed the decision, leading to a subsequent hearing before the Court of Appeal, which resulted in the orders detailed in the case summary.

The facts of this case revolve around Mr Jones's visit to the Dapto Leagues Club and his subsequent gambling activities on an electronic gaming machine. Central to the dispute is whether the terms and conditions of the machine were adequately displayed to Mr Jones, which would have limited his liability to a maximum loss of $100, or if the defendant breached its statutory duty by allowing him to gamble beyond this limit. Mr Jones's history of pathological gambling and prior exclusions from the premises further complicate the matter, as does the defendant's responsibility in permitting his return despite this history. The case's evolution from the initial trial to the Court of Appeal highlights the significant implications of the display of terms and conditions in gambling scenarios and the duty of care owed by gambling establishments to their patrons.

The matter of Jones v Dapto Leagues Club Limited (No 2) came before the court as an appeal against a decision made at first instance in the Local Court. The original proceedings were initiated by the plaintiff, Mr. Jones, who brought a claim against the defendant, Dapto Leagues Club Limited, for damages resulting from injuries sustained during his visit to the club. The case was initially decided in favour of the plaintiff, with a verdict and judgment for $700, but this was later appealed by the defendant. In the course of the appeal, the plaintiff sought to have the original verdict and judgment substituted with a new amount of $30,152, which was allowed by the Court. The defendant was also ordered to pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceedings at first instance, assessed on the ordinary basis up to a specified date, and on an indemnity basis thereafter. This decision followed a series of procedural steps, including an offer of compromise under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, r20.26, which influenced the costs awarded.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the general rule that costs follow the event applies to this case, given the specific circumstances of the offer of compromise.
2. Whether the costs of the whole action should be considered in the assessment of costs at first instance.
3. How the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, r20.26 should be applied in determining the costs for this case.
4. Whether the costs should be assessed on the ordinary basis up to 11am on 11 October 2006 and thereafter on an indemnity basis.

Held
1. The court concluded that the general rule that costs follow the event does not apply in this case, given the specific circumstances of the offer of compromise. Result: Costs follow the event rule does not apply.
2. The court held that the costs of the whole action should be considered in the assessment of costs at first instance. Result: Costs of whole action to be considered.
3. The court determined that Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, r20.26 should be applied in determining the costs for this case. Result: Costs determined under r20.26.
4. The court ruled that the costs should be assessed on the ordinary basis up to 11am on 11 October 2006 and thereafter on an indemnity basis. Result: Costs assessed on ordinary basis until 11am on 11 October 2006 and indemnity basis thereafter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Jones v Dapto Leagues Club Limited (No 2), the Court of Appeal addressed several key issues surrounding the general rule that costs follow the event, the assessment of costs at first instance, and the application of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, r20.26. The Court also deliberated on the basis for assessing costs in the particular circumstances of the case.

Firstly, the Court considered whether the general rule that costs follow the event applied in this case, given the specific circumstances of the offer of compromise. The general rule is that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party's costs. However, there are exceptions, particularly when there are offers of compromise that are not accepted. The Court found that the offer of compromise made by the defendant was not a significant factor in this case because it did not materially assist in resolving the dispute. The Court held that the offer did not alter the application of the general rule in this instance, as it did not provide a reasonable prospect of resolving the matter.

Secondly, the Court addressed whether the costs of the whole action should be considered in the assessment of costs at first instance. The Court noted that in some circumstances, the costs of the whole action may be relevant, especially when there are significant procedural complexities or when the proceedings are of a high degree of seriousness. However, in this case, the Court determined that the costs of the whole action were not necessary to consider because the proceedings were not excessively complex, and the costs incurred were proportionate to the issues in dispute.

Thirdly, the Court examined how the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, r20.26 should be applied in determining the costs for this case. Rule 20.26 provides that the Court may order that costs be paid on the ordinary basis or on an indemnity basis. The Court found that the defendant should bear the costs of the proceedings at first instance on the ordinary basis up to a certain point in time and on an indemnity basis thereafter. This decision was influenced by the conduct of the parties and the timing of the proceedings, which were deemed to have been unreasonably protracted by the defendant.

Lastly, the Court determined that the costs should be assessed on the ordinary basis up to 11am on 11 October 2006 and thereafter on an indemnity basis. This decision was based on the Court's assessment that the proceedings were reasonably conducted up until a certain point, after which the defendant's conduct became unreasonable, leading to additional costs. The Court found that the defendant's unreasonable prolongation of the proceedings justified the shift to an indemnity basis for costs incurred beyond that point.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the general rule that costs follow the event applies unless there are exceptional circumstances, such as an offer of compromise that did not materially assist in resolving the dispute. The Court also reaffirmed that the costs of the whole action are not necessarily to be considered unless the proceedings are of significant complexity or seriousness. Additionally, the Court highlighted the importance of considering the conduct of the parties and the timing of the proceedings when applying the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, r20.26, particularly in determining the appropriate basis for assessing costs. The Court's decision to shift to an indemnity basis for costs incurred beyond a certain point due to unreasonable conduct further underscores the importance of timely and reasonable conduct in legal proceedings.