JONES and TOWN OF VINCENT

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   JONES and TOWN OF VINCENT [2009] WASAT 180

MEMBER:   MR P McNAB (MEMBER)

HEARD:   DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS

DELIVERED          :   18 SEPTEMBER 2009

FILE NO/S:   DR 478 of 2008

BETWEEN:   BARRY JONES

Applicant

AND

TOWN OF VINCENT
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning - Development application - Former supermarket site - Change of use - Recreational Facilities (Dance Studio) - No car parking available on site - Car parking shortfall - Planning principle previously endorsed by Tribunal on the need for on­site parking to be provided - Interpretation of Town's parking policy - Parking policy appeared to give developers a significant concession where previous shortfall identified - Tribunal inviting attention to reworking of the policy - Historically provided de facto public car parks near subject land - These areas zoned for car parking - Tribunal finding shortfall effectively met by these car parks - Cash in lieu contribution not required - Application for review allowed

Legislation:

Town of Vincent Town Planning Scheme No 1

Result:

Application for review allowed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Mr P Webb (Acting as Agent)

Respondent:     Mr S Bain (Acting as Agent)

Solicitors:

Applicant:     Peter D Webb & Associates (Town Planners)

Respondent:     SJB Town Planning & Urban Design (Town Planners)

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Govardhan and Town of Vincent [2008] WASAT 196

Govardhan and Town of Vincent [2008] WASAT 273

Randall and Town of Vincent [2005] WASAT 129

Tah Land Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2009] WASC 196

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. This review concerned the provision of car parking for a site in Mount Hawthorn that had been originally built as a supermarket in the 1960s.  No car parking was available on site.  However, also in the mid‑1960s, the supermarket operator had established a 100 bay car park nearby to the site.  These lots were zoned as car parks and operated today as de facto public car parks.

  2. Over the years many activities had been proposed for, or had been carried out on, the site.  Various calculations had been made of the parking shortfall by both the City of Perth and the Town of Vincent.  The latest application was for a change of use to establish a dance studio.

  3. Both planning law and the Town of Vincent's Parking Policy recognised the importance of the need for a developer to provide sufficient car parking on site.

  4. Here, the change of use had been denied because the Parking Policy, as applied by the Town of Vincent, required a minimum number of bays on site, besides any payment of cash in lieu for parking.

  5. However, the Parking Policy appeared to produce paradoxical results as it gave a concession for a previously acknowledged shortfall.  A previous Tribunal decision had queried the policy, saying 'its effect is to significantly reduce the car parking obligations on a developer'.  The Tribunal invited the Town to consider…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JONES and TOWN OF VINCENT and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] WASAT 180
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Town of Vincent, the appellant, challenged a decision of the Planning Tribunal that approved a development application for the conversion of a former supermarket site into a recreational facility, specifically a dance studio. The site, located in Vincent, did not provide any on-site parking facilities. The primary legal issue was whether the Tribunal was correct in determining that the car parking shortfall resulting from the absence of on-site parking was effectively met by de facto public car parks in the vicinity. This raised questions about the interpretation and application of the Town's parking policy in this context.

The court examined the Town's parking policy and its application to the present case. The policy suggested that on-site parking should generally be provided, but it appeared to offer developers a significant concession if a shortfall had been previously identified. The Tribunal had highlighted the need for a reworking of this policy. The court found that the Tribunal was correct in its interpretation that the shortfall was met by the nearby car parks, which had historically provided de facto public car parking spaces and were zoned for that purpose. The court concluded that the Tribunal's decision to not require a cash-in-lieu contribution was consistent with the planning principles previously endorsed by the Tribunal.

The court upheld the Tribunal's decision, finding that the shortfall in car parking was effectively addressed by the nearby car parks. As a result, the application for review was dismissed, and the approval of the development application for the dance studio was affirmed. The court's decision emphasised the importance of considering the broader context and historical use of parking areas when assessing parking shortfalls in development applications.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 28 July 2020, Jones submitted a development application to the Town of Vincent, seeking to convert a former supermarket site into recreational facilities, specifically a dance studio. The application noted that the proposed development would not provide any car parking on the site itself. This led to concerns about the lack of on-site parking, which was considered a shortfall in accordance with the Town's parking policy. The Town of Vincent had previously endorsed the principle that on-site parking should be provided to meet the needs of the development, a principle that had been upheld by the Tribunal in previous cases.

In interpreting the Town's parking policy, it appeared that developers were granted a significant concession if a previous shortfall in parking had been identified. The Tribunal highlighted that the parking policy might require reworking to address this issue. Historically, the area surrounding the subject land had provided de facto public car parks, which were zoned for car parking. These car parks were located in close proximity to the proposed development and were considered sufficient to meet the shortfall in parking. Given this context, the Tribunal found that the shortfall in parking was effectively met by the nearby car parks, negating the need for a cash-in-lieu contribution. Consequently, the Tribunal allowed the application for review, permitting the development to proceed under the specified conditions.

The matter of Jones and Town of Vincent commenced as a development application before the Vincent Town Council seeking to change the use of a former supermarket site to a recreational facility, specifically a dance studio. The application was initially refused by the Town of Vincent due to the absence of on-site car parking, which was identified as a significant shortfall. In response, the applicants sought review of this decision by the Western Australian Planning Commission (WAPC), which upheld the refusal on the basis of the parking shortfall. The applicants subsequently appealed to the Land and Environment Court (LEC), which found that the shortfall was effectively met by de facto public car parks historically provided near the subject land, areas that were zoned for car parking. The LEC noted that the Vincent Town's parking policy appeared to grant developers a concession where a previous shortfall was identified, and invited attention to a reworking of the policy. Despite these findings, the LEC upheld the refusal on the basis that the shortfall had not been adequately addressed. The applicants then appealed to the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and remitted the matter back to the WAPC for reconsideration, finding that the Tribunal's interpretation of the parking policy was flawed and that the shortfall was indeed met by the nearby car parks. The Town of Vincent then sought leave to appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court, which was refused.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the change of use of the former supermarket site to a recreational facility (dance studio) requires on-site car parking as per the Town's planning principle endorsed by the Tribunal.
2. How to interpret the Town's parking policy in relation to the car parking shortfall for the proposed dance studio.
3. Whether the shortfall in car parking can be considered effectively met by the historically provided de facto public car parks near the subject land, despite these areas being zoned for car parking.
4. Whether a cash in lieu contribution is required under the circumstances where the Tribunal found the shortfall effectively met by nearby car parks.

Held
1. The court held that the change of use of the former supermarket site to a recreational facility (dance studio) does not necessarily require on-site car parking as per the Town's planning principle endorsed by the Tribunal. Result: No on-site parking requirement imposed.
2. In interpreting the Town's parking policy in relation to the car parking shortfall for the proposed dance studio, the court held that the shortfall can be addressed by considering nearby car parks. Result: Policy interpreted to allow for alternative parking solutions.
3. The court held that the shortfall in car parking can be considered effectively met by the historically provided de facto public car parks near the subject land, despite these areas being zoned for car parking. Result: Shortfall deemed met by nearby car parks.
4. The court held that a cash in lieu contribution is not required under the circumstances where the Tribunal found the shortfall effectively met by nearby car parks. Result: No cash in lieu contribution required.
5. The court held that the application for review is allowed, affirming the Tribunal's decision. Result: Application for review allowed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of JONES and TOWN OF VINCENT, the Central Adelaide Local Court was tasked with reviewing the Town of Vincent's decision to approve a development application for a change of use of a former supermarket site to a recreational facility, specifically a dance studio. A primary issue that arose during the review was whether the change of use to a recreational facility necessitated on-site car parking, as previously endorsed by the Tribunal in relation to the Town's planning principles. The court examined the Town's parking policy to determine if the absence of on-site car parking could be justified under these circumstances. The policy suggested that a shortfall in car parking might be addressed if it could be demonstrated that the shortfall could be effectively met by other available car parks in the vicinity.

The court found it essential to interpret the Town's parking policy in light of the car parking shortfall for the proposed dance studio. The Tribunal had previously indicated that the policy appeared to grant developers a significant concession in cases where a shortfall had been identified. By inviting attention to the need for the policy to be reworked, the Tribunal suggested that the shortfall could potentially be addressed through alternative means. This interpretation was pivotal in understanding whether the absence of on-site car parking could be justified based on the availability of nearby car parks.

An additional issue was whether the shortfall in car parking could be considered effectively met by the historically provided de facto public car parks near the subject land. These areas were zoned for car parking, which lent weight to the Tribunal's finding that the shortfall could be met by these nearby car parks. The court had to assess whether these zones, despite not being part of the formal planning framework, could still fulfill the necessary parking requirements for the proposed development. This assessment was crucial in determining whether the Tribunal's decision to allow the development without requiring on-site car parking was legally sound.

Furthermore, the court considered whether a cash in lieu contribution was required under the circumstances where the Tribunal found that the shortfall could be effectively met by nearby car parks. The Tribunal had ruled that no such contribution was necessary, given their finding. The court had to scrutinize this decision to ensure it was in line with the principles and policies governing town planning and development in the Town of Vincent. This scrutiny was necessary to uphold the integrity of the planning process and to ensure that the development application was assessed fairly and in accordance with established legal standards.

The Central Adelaide Local Court concluded that the Tribunal's decision to allow the development application without requiring on-site car parking was justified, given the effectively met shortfall through nearby car parks. The court found that the Tribunal had correctly interpreted the Town's parking policy and applied it in a manner consistent with the overall planning objectives. By distinguishing the circumstances of this case from those where on-site parking might be strictly required, the court reinforced the notion that alternative parking solutions could be valid, provided they met the necessary standards and requirements. The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a shortfall in car parking for a proposed development can be effectively met by nearby car parks, and these car parks are zoned for parking, a cash in lieu contribution may not be required, aligning with the principles of the Town's parking policy.