Jones and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

Jones and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2022] AATA 4407 (20 December 2022)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2022/2261

Re:Lachlan Sidney Jones

APPLICANT

AndCivil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Deputy President R I Hanger, AM KC

Date:20 December 2022

Place:Brisbane

Pursuant to subsection 43(1) of Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision and, in its place, substitutes its own decision that:

1. The applicant’s flight crew licenses be reinstated.

2. That the following conditions be imposed on the applicant’s flight crew licenses:

(a)    for twelve months the applicant is limited to the conduct of aerial agricultural operations as pilot in command in which no passengers or other flight crew are to be carried. These operations are to be conducted only under the civil aviation authorisations held by Namoi Valley Propriety Limited  (ABN 69 646 364 329);

(b)    notwithstanding paragraph 2(a) above, the applicant may conduct private flights as pilot in command if those flights are necessary for the operation of the business of Namoi Valley Aviation Pty Limited. No passengers or additional flight crew members may be carried on any such flight;

(c)    for a period of twelve months

(i)the applicant is to undergo counselling sessions with Tim Watson Munro, or another psychologist approved by the respondent, at a frequency and in a manner determined by Mr Watson Munro, but at least once a month;

(ii)the applicant is to undergo mentoring sessions with Mr Barry Foster at a frequency and in a manner determined by Mr Foster but at least once every two months.

3. While the applicant undergoes counselling and mentoring sessions referred to in paragraph 2(c) above, the applicant is to ensure that Mr Foster and Mr Watson Munro provide a report to the respondent at the end of three months and at the end of six months, and at the end of 12 months, as to the applicant’s progress and such reports are to contain an opinion as to whether the applicant has fully participated in the counselling/mentoring process, and is a fit and proper person to be the holder of unconditional licenses.

.......................[SGD].................................................

Deputy President R I Hanger, AM KC

Catchwords

Civil Aviation – cancellation of applicant’s - aeroplane category (CPL), commercial pilot License – helicopter category (CPL(H), private pilot license – aeroplane category (PPL) and recreational pilot License (RPL) – whether applicant failed in his duty with respect to matter/s affecting the safe navigation/ operation of an aircraft - whether applicant fit and proper person – two incidents involving an aircraft – applicant’s conduct – await final submissions – exiting orders remain in force.

Legislation

Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases

Pantovic v CASA [2015] AATA 992
R v Jones [2019] QDC 79

Secondary Materials

Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President R I Hanger, AM QC

20 December 2022

  1. The Applicant seeks review of a decision of the Respondent to cancel his Commercial Pilot License – Aeroplane Category (CPL), Commercial Pilot License…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jones and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 4407
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) to cancel the aeroplane category commercial pilot licence (CPL), helicopter category CPL (CPL(H)), private pilot licence (PPL), and recreational pilot licence (RPL) held by the applicant, Mr Jones. The dispute arose from two incidents involving aircraft damage on 12 October 2020 and 9 January 2021, and allegations concerning the applicant's integrity, including a prior conviction for operating without authorisations and making false statements.

The court was required to determine whether the applicant had failed in his duty with respect to matters affecting the safe navigation or operation of an aircraft, and whether he was a fit and proper person to hold a pilot licence. CASA's case was based on the applicant's conduct during the two incidents, where aircraft he was flying sustained serious damage, and on his past dishonesty.

The Deputy President found the applicant's flying skill to be undoubted and paramount. While acknowledging the applicant's conduct on the ground during the incidents was foolhardy, particularly his failure to adequately inspect damaged aircraft and his decision to continue flying them, the Deputy President noted that these actions primarily affected his own safety. The Deputy President also considered the applicant's integrity, noting a prior conviction for dishonesty and dishonest statements made in relation to CASA matters. However, influenced by evidence suggesting the applicant was a "work in progress" regarding his integrity and had learned from his errors, and taking into account his current business commitments and supportive family circumstances, the Deputy President decided to give the applicant a chance to retain his licences.

The Deputy President set aside CASA's decision and, in lieu thereof, ordered that the applicant's flight crew licences be reinstated subject to conditions. These conditions included undertaking counselling and mentoring for one year, with regular reports from the counsellors to CASA.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Respondent essentially bases its case on three matters. The Applicant was involved in two serious incidents (Incidents on 9 January 2021 and 12 October 2020) in which the aircraft he was flying suffered serious damage. The third matter relates to his integrity. I will deal with each of these in turn.BackgroundThe Applicant Mr Jones (‘the Applicant’) was born in 1990. He obtained a private pilot license in May 2009. He subsequently went to United States of America where he obtained a United States commercial pilot licence. He returned to Australia in 2013 and commenced agricultural flying training. He passed that in 2014 and continued agricultural flight operations in the United States. Subsequently he flew in Australia but did not convert his United States commercial pilot license to an Australian commercial pilot licence He was charged and convicted[3] for conducting flight operations without holding the required Australian authorisations and with making a false statement. [3] Exhibit 27, R v Jones [2019] QDC 79. He subsequently obtained a private pilot license and an Australian commercial license He has now accumulated over 6400 flight hours and most of his flying is in aerial agricultural operations. That is well known as a dangerous occupation which requires high skill in the pilot. His family has a long history in agricultural flying operations and it is worth mentioning at this point that he says that as a child he was within the family environment indoctrinated to a certain extent to be afraid of the respondent. I accept that evidence from him. However, I should also add that I’m satisfied that nothing that the Respondent or any person acting on its behalf did in its investigations into this matter, or conduct in these proceedings, was other than proper. It was suggested that Mr Kidston who is conducting the investigation had a conversation to the effect that he was ‘out to get him’.[4] I don’t accept that suggestion. Mr Kidston denied the suggestion and took notes at all times and presented as a completely fair and honest witness.[4] Transcript dated 19 August 2022, page 340.Incident in Aircraft VH-ROK on 12 October 2020 It is common ground that on 12 October 2020 the Applicant was involved in an incident in aircraft VH-ROK.[5] That plane is an amateur built F1 Rocket. It is very powerful.[5] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T11-T31, ‘EICMS Case Note Conversation with Glen Shaw’ dated 5 November 2020, pages 105-269 and Exhibit 4, ‘Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 11 August 2022’, page 24, at [99](a). The Respondent alleged that the incident occurred during take-off from a taxiway at Dalby Airport, an uncertified/uncontrolled aerodrome. The Applicant claims that the incident occurred during a landing. The evidence before me indicated that the incident occurred as an event during landing. The applicant gave evidence that in landing after he had touched down, he suffered a failure of one of the brakes which caused the aircraft while on the runway to veer to the right. The aircraft thus became pointed at an oblique angle to the runway. He says he was faced with two choices. He could power down and let the aircraft go into what is described as a “ground loop”[6] or he could apply power and take off.[6] Ibid, T19, page 140.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I observed Mr Jones in the witness box. He is undoubtedly an intelligent man and so much was verified by Mr Watson Munro. Since the incidents in question, he has continued to refine his flying skills and knowledge of relevant rules and regulations. He indicated a responsible attitude to running his new business and I’m satisfied that he has learned from his errors.Conclusion The Applicant’s skill in flying is undoubted. The Applicant’s conduct on the ground was foolhardy. In respect of the incident on 12 October 2020 he possibly made the wrong decision to take off rather than go around but I make no finding in respect of that. It was an agony of the moment decision. After landing, he failed to adequately inspect both the damage to the aircraft and the star pickets with which he collided. He should have. In relation to the incident in 9 January 2021 he should have alighted and inspected the damage, ascertained that the tip of his wing was missing and not taken off again. Once airborne and detecting the aircraft handling differently he should have landed. I am unable to say whether he should or should not have jettisoned his load. He should not have completed the second aerial spraying flight or prepared for a third. His integrity is open to serious question. He has been convicted of an offence involving dishonesty and his attitude to his employer and a fellow employee and CASA involved dishonest statements. Dishonesty in events in which CASA is involved must be taken very seriously. Mr Watson Munro describes him as a work in progress in terms of his integrity. I was impressed by the evidence of Mr Watson Munro. I propose to accept the suggestion of Mr Watson Munro and give the applicant a chance. I propose to let him retain his license to enable him to work. That is the correct or preferable decision. In deciding whether he is a ‘fit and proper person’[36] to hold a licence, I take into account his undoubted skill in flying which I regard as paramount. I am satisfied that as to his behaviour on the ground he has learned from his errors; I take into account that his conduct in failing to inspect the aircraft after damaging it, and continuing to fly knowing that it was damaged, while wrongful, affected his own safety and not that of others.[36] Regulation 269(1)(d) of Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth). I take into account the fact that the Applicant has now bought a business involving significant financial obligations and has a supportive wife working with him hoping to start a family. That is relevant insofar as it gives me confidence that he has and will adopt a more responsible attitude to his work. The Applicant handed up proposed orders in the following terms:“…(1)The decision the subject of the Application for review is set aside.(2)In lieu thereof the Applicant’s flight crew licenses are reinstated subject to the condition that the Applicant undertake counselling with Mr Tim Watson Munro and mentoring with Mr Barry Foster (the counsellor) for a period of one year from the date of this order on a frequency and in a manner as directed by the counsellors.(3)The counsellors are to report to the respondent at six monthly intervals as to their level of satisfaction with the Applicant’s participation in the counselling or mentoring.(4)The orders made on stay application are vacated.…”.[37][37] Exhibit 26, ‘Draft Orders lodged on 19 August 2022’.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court meticulously examined the Applicant's conduct in two separate incidents that occurred on 9 January 2021 and 12 October 2020. The court found that the Applicant's actions during these incidents were foolhardy and demonstrated a lack of due diligence. The Applicant was found to have failed in his duty to ensure the safe navigation or operation of an aircraft. In the incident on 12 October 2020, the Applicant made an instantaneous decision to take off instead of going around after experiencing a brake failure, which resulted in a collision with star pickets. The court noted that the Applicant should have inspected the damage to both the aircraft and the star pickets after the incident. In the incident on 9 January 2021, the Applicant should have inspected the aircraft after discovering that the tip of his wing was missing and should not have taken off again. The court held that the Applicant's decision to continue flying after damaging the aircraft, while wrongful, did not affect the safety of others. The court applied the legal principle that a pilot has a duty to ensure the safe operation of an aircraft, which includes inspecting the aircraft after an incident.

The court also considered the Applicant's conduct after the incidents, including his failure to inspect the aircraft and his continued flying despite knowing that the aircraft was damaged. The court held that the Applicant's conduct made him unfit to hold an aircraft licence. The court applied the legal principle that a pilot must act responsibly and with due diligence to ensure the safety of the aircraft and its occupants. The court noted that the Applicant's conduct demonstrated a lack of responsibility and a disregard for the safety of others. The court held that the Applicant's conduct made him unfit to hold an aircraft licence.

The court also considered the Applicant's conviction for dishonesty and his attitude towards CASA and his employer. The court held that the Applicant's conviction for dishonesty and his dishonest statements to CASA and his employer evidenced a lack of integrity, which is necessary to hold an aircraft licence. The court applied the legal principle that a pilot must demonstrate integrity and honesty in all dealings with regulatory authorities and employers. The court held that the Applicant's conduct demonstrated a lack of integrity and made him unfit to hold an aircraft licence.

Finally, the court considered whether the Applicant was a fit and proper person to hold a licence, taking into account his skill in flying, his conduct on the ground, and his financial and family obligations. The court held that the Applicant was a fit and proper person to hold a licence, taking into account his undoubted skill in flying, his responsible attitude to running his new business, and his supportive wife working with him hoping to start a family. The court applied the legal principle that a pilot must demonstrate responsibility, integrity, and honesty in all dealings with regulatory authorities and employers. The court held that the Applicant had learned from his errors and had adopted a more responsible attitude to his work.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a pilot must act responsibly and with due diligence to ensure the safety of the aircraft and its occupants, demonstrate integrity and honesty in all dealings with regulatory authorities and employers, and adopt a responsible attitude to their work. The court distinguished this case from prior authority by finding that the Applicant's conduct, while wrongful, did not affect the safety of others and that the Applicant had learned from his errors and had adopted a more responsible attitude to his work. The court followed prior authority in holding that a pilot must demonstrate responsibility, integrity, and honesty in all dealings with regulatory authorities and employers.