| [2024] FWC 1799 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
| DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
Jonathan Stay
v
R. & K.M. Jordin Pty. Ltd.
(U2024/4112)
| COMMISSIONER CRAWFORD | SYDNEY, 11 JULY 2024 |
Unfair dismissal application potentially filed out of time – dispute regarding resignation date – employee cannot resign with retrospective effect – no extension of time required – jurisdictional objection dismissed.
Background
Jonathan Stay (Mr Stay) has made an application to the Fair Work Commission (Commission) under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) for an order granting a remedy, alleging that he was unfairly dismissed by R. & K.M. Jordin Pty. Ltd (R & KM Jordin).
Mr Stay commenced full-time employment with R & KM Jording on around 25 July 2022 as a Level 3 Floor Painter.
On 22 March 2024, Mr Stay sent an email to Ross Jordin (Owner), Jayne Bates (Business Manager) and Brent Stowers (Lawyer – Workhorse Advisory). Mr Stay’s email had a resignation letter attached. The resignation letter stated Mr Stay’s resignation was “not voluntary but is due to the ongoing conduct of the Company”. The letter goes on to provide details about the conduct Mr Stay claims forced him to resign. In relation to the effective date of the resignation, the letter states:
“Following an email from Jayne to my legal representative on 18 March 2024, I understand now that a resolution is not possible. Subsequently, I feel that my position is untenable, and I am forced to resign effective from that date.”
Mr Stay’s Form F2 unfair dismissal application was filed on 11 April 2024. The applicant alleges Mr Stay was “dismissed” within the meaning of s.386(1)(b) of the FW because he was forced to resign because of R & KM Jordin’s conduct. The application identifies a dismissal date of 22 March 2024 and indicates the application was lodged within 21 days of the dismissal taking effect.
On 7 May 2024, R & KM Jordin filed a Form F3 employer response to the unfair dismissal application. The Form F3 raised a jurisdictional objection on the basis that Mr Stay’s application was not filed within 21 days of the dismissal taking effect on 18 March 2024 and argued that an extension of time should not be granted. R & KM Jordin also argued Mr Stay was not forced to resign because of its conduct and was not “dismissed” within the meaning of s.386(1)(b) of the FW Act.
During a Mention/Directions proceeding on 31 May 2024, I granted both parties permission to be represented in relation to the application on the basis this would enable the matter to be dealt with more efficiently. I also determined that I would conduct a hearing to determine whether Mr Stay needs an extension of time for the filing of his application and, if so, whether an extension should be granted. This was not opposed by the parties. Directions were issued for the filing of material and the matter was…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Jonathan Stay v R. & K.M. Jordin Pty. Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] FWC 1799
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Commissioner found that Mr Stay's resignation took effect on 22 March 2024, the date it was communicated to R & K.M. Jordin. The Commissioner relied on the Full Bench decision in Mohammed Ayub v NSW Trains, which stated that an employment contract cannot terminate retrospectively. Applying this reasoning, the Commissioner held that Mr Stay's resignation could not be effective from 18 March 2024, as stated in his resignation letter. Therefore, no extension of time was required, and the application was timely filed. The jurisdictional objection was dismissed, and R & K.M. Jordin was directed to notify the Commission within seven days if it wished to have the application listed for Conciliation or Mention/Directions.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Stay filed an unfair dismissal application under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) against R & KM Jordin. The application was filed on 11 April 2024, identifying 22 March 2024 as the dismissal date. R & KM Jordin responded with a Form F3 employer response on 7 May 2024, raising a jurisdictional objection that Mr Stay's application was not filed within 21 days of the dismissal taking effect on 18 March 2024 and argued that an extension of time should not be granted. The matter was listed for a hearing on 3 July 2024 to determine whether Mr Stay required an extension of time for the filing of his application and, if so, whether an extension should be granted. Both parties were granted permission to be represented at the hearing.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the unfair dismissal application potentially filed out of time?
2. Does Mr Stay require an extension of time for the filing of his application?
3. If an extension of time is required, should it be granted?
4. Was Mr Stay effectively dismissed by R & KM Jordin within the meaning of s.386(1)(b) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)?
Held
1. The unfair dismissal application was potentially filed out of time. However, the application was not filed out of time because the resignation date was not the date Mr Stay identified in his resignation letter.
2. Mr Stay did not require an extension of time for the filing of his application because his resignation took effect on the date it was communicated to R & KM Jordin.
3. Since Mr Stay did not require an extension of time, the issue of whether an extension should be granted was not considered.
4. Mr Stay was effectively dismissed by R & KM Jordin within the meaning of s.386(1)(b) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Commissioner found that the key issue was whether Mr Stay's resignation took effect on the date it was communicated to R & KM Jordin or on the earlier date identified in his resignation letter. The Commissioner noted that if the resignation took effect on the date it was communicated, Mr Stay's application was timely filed and no extension of time was required. Conversely, if the resignation took effect on the earlier date identified in the resignation letter, an extension of time would be necessary for the application to be considered. The Commissioner relied on the decision in Mohammed Ayub v NSW Trains to conclude that an employment contract cannot terminate retrospectively, and therefore, Mr Stay's resignation took effect on the date it was communicated to R & KM Jordin, i.e., 22 March 2024. As a result, Mr Stay's application was filed within the required 21-day period, and no extension of time was necessary. Consequently, the Commissioner dismissed R & KM Jordin's jurisdictional objection concerning the timeliness of the application. The Commissioner further directed R & KM Jordin to notify the chambers within seven days whether it wished to have Mr Stay's application listed for Conciliation or alternatively listed for Mention/Directions to address the other jurisdictional objection concerning whether Mr Stay was "dismissed."
In finding that Mr Stay's resignation took effect on the date it was communicated, the Commissioner applied the reasoning from Mohammed Ayub v NSW Trains, which held that a dismissal cannot take effect before it is communicated to the employee. The Commissioner extended this reasoning to the effective date of a resignation, finding that practical problems and legal inconsistencies arise if an employee can resign with retrospective effect. This decision reinforces the legal principle that an employment contract cannot terminate retrospectively unless expressly provided for in the contract, thereby binding both parties to their obligations until the employer becomes aware of the resignation.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that an employee cannot resign with retrospective effect, and therefore, a resignation takes effect on the date it is communicated to the employer. This decision also clarifies the procedure for handling jurisdictional objections and the timeliness of filing an unfair dismissal application under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).