Joiner & Anor v The Trustee for the Warren John Dunell Trust

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Joiner & Anor v The Trustee for the Warren John Dunell Trust [2022] QSC 245

PARTIES:

MATTHEW JOINER AND DARRYL KIRK AS STATUTORY TRUSTEES FOR SALE

(applicants)

v
THE TRUSTEE FOR THE WARREN JOHN DUNELL TRUST ABN 72 783 308 505

(first respondent)

AND

MARIA ELENA DUNELL

(second respondent)

AND

WARREN JOHN DUNELL, A BANKRUPT
(third respondent)

AND

FRANK LO PILATO AS TRUSTEE FOR THE BANKRUPT ESTATE OF WARREN JOHN DUNELL
(fourth respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS 6209/22

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Originating Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

11 November 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

31 August 2022

JUDGE:

Kelly J

ORDER:

1.   The application filed 4 July 2022 is dismissed.

2.   I will hear the parties as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

EQUITY  –  TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES  –  POWERS, DUTIES, RIGHTS AND LIABILITIES OF TRUSTEES  –  TRUSTS FOR AND POWERS OF SALE  –  OTHER CASES  –  where the first respondent purported to be an entity described as a trustee  –  where the first respondent applied for orders distributing proceeds of sale of a property in proportions between himself and the third respondent  –  where the first respondent alleged that their share of the property, along with the rest of their assets, were transferred into a trust of which the first respondent was purportedly trustee  –  where the first respondent further alleged that the transfer was recorded in a security agreement  –  whether a trust was created  –  whether a security was created  –  whether the proceeds of the sale should be distributed in the proportions contended for by the first respondent

Property Law Act 1974 (Qld), s. 38, s. 37A, s. 59, s. 11

Baumgartner v Baumgartner (1987) 164 CLR 137; [1987] HCA 59, cited
Blatch v Archer (1774) 1 Cowp 63, cited
Kauter v Hilton
(1953) 90 CLR 86; [1953] HCA 95, cited
McPhail v Doulton [1971] AC 424, cited
Muschinski v Dodds (1985) 160 CLR 583, cited
Muller v Zielonkowsky
[2006] QSC 265, cited
Quintis Ltd (Subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) v Certain Underwriters at Lloyd’s (2021) 385 ALR 639, cited
Re Fettel (1952) 52 SR (NSW) 221, cited
Re Wlodarczyk [2000] 2 Qd R 216, cited

COUNSEL:

“Warren John And Dunell” for the first respondent
B Wacker for the fourth respondent

SOLICITORS:

The first respondent appeared on his own behalf
Piper Alderman for the fourth respondent

Introductory matters and background

  1. This is an application by the first respondent, described as “the Trustee for the Warren John Dunell Trust”, seeking orders in respect of the distribution of proceeds from the sale of real property.  A person claiming to be the trustee appeared in person and announced his appearance as “Warren John And Dunell”.

  2. The third respondent, Warren John Dunell (“Mr Dunell”) and his wife, the second respondent (“Mrs Dunell”), were registered owners, as joint tenants, of land situated at 8 North Aston Court, Bray Park (“the Property”).

  3. On 17 October…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Joiner & Anor v The Trustee for the Warren John Dunell Trust and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QSC 245
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Joiner & Anor v The Trustee for the Warren John Dunell Trust was heard in a relevant Australian court. The dispute involved the distribution of proceeds from the sale of a property, with the first respondent claiming that their share, along with the rest of their assets, were transferred into a trust of which they were purportedly the trustee. They also alleged that the transfer was recorded in a security agreement. The court had to determine if a trust was created, if a security was created, and if the proceeds of the sale should be distributed in the proportions contended for by the first respondent.

The legal issues before the court were whether a trust was created by the Purported Trust Document, and if a security was created by the Security Document. The court had to examine the Purported Trust Document to determine if it met the three certainties required to create a trust, and whether the Security Document created a security over the property. The court had to consider the language used in the Purported Trust Document and the Security Document, as well as the evidence provided by the parties.

The court found that the Purported Trust Document did not meet the three certainties required to create a trust, and that the document did not create a trust. The court found that the Security Document identified the “Warren John Dunell Trust” as the debtor and “Warren-John: Dunell” as the “Trustee/Secured Party”, and that a security was created over the property. The court dismissed the application filed on 4 July 2022 and will hear the parties as to costs.

This decision highlights the importance of meeting the three certainties required to create a trust, and the need for clarity in the language used in trust and security documents. The court's decision also highlights the importance of providing evidence to support claims made in court.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application filed 4 July 2022 is dismissed.

2. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Purported Trust Document relevantly provides:[16][16]First Herrett Affidavit, Ex MMH-2, 78. “CONSIDERATION:a) Exchanger herein agrees to bargain, exchange, assign, convey and deliver to this organization or its appointed Trustee, a promissory note payable upon demand, for ten dollars denominated in Australian 1 Dollar Silver coins…in exchange for 005 certificate(s) evidencing a right of distribution as promised by Settlor.…c) This initial exchange, a description of the consideration, whether personal and/or real property, and the number of certificates issued, shall be documented in the minutes of the organization.…ADMINISTERED AS TRUST ESTATE…d) All assets belonging to the trust estate shall be listed on Attachment sheet WJD-270584-AS or an addendum to Attachment sheet WJD-270584-AS, and administered as provided herein. The Purported Trust Document does not declare a trust over identifiable property but rather the “initial exchange” is to be “documented in the minutes of the organization”. The evidence before me did not include any “minutes of the organization” or “Attachment sheet” or “addendum”. Finally, there is no certainty as to who are meant to be the beneficiaries of the trust. The Purported Trust Document provides that the “Exchanger” is to receive “certificates” which “evidenc[e] a right of distribution as promised by [the] Settlor”.[17] That language might suggest that the “Exchanger” is a beneficiary however it is the Exchanger that “relinquishes all rights to the property exchanged into this organization”.[18] That language would suggest that the “Exchanger” is the settlor. The “Right to Distribution” provides for the trustee to issue “twenty… certificate units” or “TCUs” which “represent… 100% of the rights to distribution from the organization’s trust estate”.[19] The Settlor may own “TCUs” making it both a beneficiary and settlor. If the beneficial interests in the trust were meant to be fixed, all the beneficiaries must be ascertainable.[20] The twenty holders of TCUs (or beneficiaries generally) are not ascertainable. The Purported Trust Document then speaks of the trustees having “discretionary powers to make distributions from this organization without regard to equality of certificate holders…”[21] The “certificate holders” are not identified. [17]First Herrett Affidavit, Ex MMH-2, 78. [18]First Herrett Affidavit, Ex MMH-2, 78. [19]First Herrett Affidavit, Ex MMH-2, 82. [20]McPhail v Doulton [1971] AC 424, 453-4. [21]First Herrett Affidavit, Ex MMH-2, 82. I accept the Trustee’s submission that the Purported Trust Document does not meet the three certainties required to create a trust. I find that the Purported Trust Document did not create a trust. The Security Document identifies the “Warren John Dunell Trust” as the debtor and “Warren-John: Dunell” as the “Trustee/Secured Party”.[22][22]First Herrett Affidavit, Ex MMH-2, 86.