Johnston, Peggy Iris v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

,

~

I N T H E

FEDERAL

COURT

OF

A U S T R A L I A

j

\.\

-._

-. .

-

A

.

A U S T R A L I A N

C A P I T A L

T E R R I T O R Y

1

N o .

1 of

1978

D I S T R I C T

R E G I S T R Y

1

GENEML

D I V I S I O N

-.

1

I N Tl IE MATTER

O F ANDREW

S C O T T JOHNSTON

(DECEASED)

..

BETWEEN

:

TIIE

CO>I;,IONIV'EAI.TH

O F A U S T R A L I A

-

AND

:

PEGGY

I R I S J O H B S T O X

ORDER

J U D G E

X I K I N G

ORDER

D A V I E S

J .

DATE O F ORDER

10 May

1 9 7 9

WHERE

PIADE

C a n b e r r a

THE COURT ORDERS THAT

t h c a p p c a l be d i s m i s s e d arid

t h a t t h c

a p p e l l a n t pay

Lhc

r c s p o n d c u t ' s

t nxcd

cos t s

of

t h e a p p c a l .

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )

1

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

j

DISTRLCT REGISTKY

No. 1 of 1978 '

-- -

GENERAL- DIVISION

j

IN THE MATTER OF ANDRLW SCOTT JOHNSTON

(DECEASED)

BETWEEN : THE COX.lON\*IEALTII

OF AUSTRALIA

-

AND

: PEGGY IRIS .JOHNSTON

REASONS FOR JUDGilTXT

This is an appeal from a decision of the Comilon~realth

Employees'

Compensation Tribunal which determined that the clai~rlant for

Commonwealth employees' compensation, Peggy Iris Johnston, mother

of the deceased, Andrew Scott Johnston, was partially dependent

upon her son at his death, that the employmcnt of the deccased

by the Commonwealth had contrlbutcd to the aggravation of a

cancerous condition f r o m whlch 1 1 1 had suiCL>red , ~ u d that his

death had resulted therefron.

The deceased had bcen a member of the Royal Australian Navy.

In

1970, while on duty with H%IS J-parit, he sought attention froln

.

-

. .

--

- - ..--.

.

.--.v

the Vung Tau Military Base Hospital in Vietnam, was advised that

he suffered from haemorrhoids and was given suppositories.

NO

medical record presently exists of that examination but there was adequate evidence before the Tribunal to support its finding that such examination took place and of the advice and treatment given.

Thereafter, until August 1974 when it was ascertained that I@. Johnston was suffering from carcinoma of the bowel, he believed that he had a haemorrhoidal condition. His mother gave evidence that when Mr. Johnston was on leave in 1971 he used suppositories

and a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Johnston, Peggy Iris v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1979] FCA 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia dismissed an appeal brought by the Commonwealth of Australia against a decision of the Commonwealth Employees' Compensation Tribunal. The Tribunal had determined that the claimant, Peggy Iris Johnston, the mother of the deceased, Andrew Scott Johnston, was partially dependent upon her son at his death. It was also found that the employment of the deceased by the Commonwealth had contributed to the aggravation of a cancerous condition from which he suffered, leading to his death. The deceased had been a member of the Royal Australian Navy and had sought treatment for haemorrhoids at the Vung Tau Military Base Hospital in Vietnam in 1970. The Tribunal found that the inadequate examination at the hospital failed to detect the cancerous condition, which could have been treated if detected at an earlier stage.

The court upheld the Tribunal's findings, rejecting the Commonwealth's argument that there was insufficient evidence to support the findings. The court also rejected the Commonwealth's argument that the failure to detect and treat the cancerous condition did not constitute an aggravation of the disease for which compensation could be claimed under the Compensation (Australian Government Employees) Act 1971. The court held that the words "contraction", "aggravation", "acceleration" and "recurrence" cover the field of the circumstances in which employment may contribute to death or impairment from a disease. The court found that the employment did contribute to the aggravation of the disease and that the Tribunal's decision was justified.

The appeal was dismissed, and the appellant was ordered to pay the respondent's fixed costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The deceased, Andrew Scott Johnston, was a member of the Royal Australian Navy who sought medical attention for what he believed to be haemorrhoids at the Vung Tau Military Base Hospital in Vietnam in 1970. Despite the advice and treatment given, he continued to believe he had haemorrhoids until August 1974, when carcinoma of the bowel was diagnosed. Mr. Johnston died from this cancer on 3 January 1975. His mother, Peggy Iris Johnston, sought compensation from the Commonwealth for her son's death, claiming that his employment with the Commonwealth contributed to the aggravation of his condition and his subsequent death.

This case is an appeal from a decision of the Commonwealth Employees' Compensation Tribunal, which determined that the claimant was partially dependent upon her son at his death, that the employment of the deceased by the Commonwealth had contributed to the aggravation of a cancerous condition from which he had suffered, and that his death had resulted therefrom. The appeal was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether there was sufficient evidence to justify the findings of the Tribunal.
2. Whether the failure to detect and treat the cancerous condition constituted an aggravation of the disease.
3. Whether the claim for compensation was barred by the provisions of the Compensation (Australian Government Employees) Act 1971.

Held
1. The court held that there was sufficient evidence to justify the findings of the Tribunal.
2. The court held that the failure to detect and treat the cancerous condition constituted an aggravation of the disease.
3. The court held that the claim for compensation was not barred by the provisions of the Compensation (Australian Government Employees) Act 1971.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court found that there was responsible evidence before the Tribunal which supported its findings. The Tribunal accepted the evidence of Dr. Goulston, who testified that Mr. Johnston's symptoms were consistent with the development and growth of the cancerous condition. The court agreed with the Tribunal's conclusion that the carcinoma had been present in July 1974, and it was probable that the condition which Mr. Johnston sought treatment for in 1970 was the same cancerous or pre-cancerous condition. The court held that the failure to detect the cancerous condition when Mr. Johnston sought treatment in 1970 constituted an aggravation of the disease, as it led to the failure to treat the condition at an earlier stage. Regarding the claim for compensation, the court found that the claim was made in respect of an aggravation of a disease, not an injury, and the symptoms of the aggravation first became apparent after the proclaimed date of the Compensation (Australian Government Employees) Act 1971. Therefore, the claim for compensation was not precluded by the provisions of the Act. The ratio decidendi of the case is that the failure to detect and treat a cancerous condition in a timely manner can be considered an aggravation of the disease, and the claim for compensation is not barred if the aggravation occurred after the proclaimed date of the relevant legislation.