Johnson v Synnex Australia Pty Ltd; Johnson v Leader Computers Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

JOHNSON v SYNNEX AUSTRALIA PTY LTD;  JOHNSON v LEADER COMPUTERS PTY LTD (NO 2)

[2017] SASCFC 165

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Blue and The Honourable Justice Evans)

8 December 2017

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES

REAL PROPERTY - TORRENS TITLE - MORTGAGES, CHARGES AND ENCUMBRANCES - CHARGES AND ENCUMBRANCES

EQUITY - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - EQUITABLE ESTATES AND INTERESTS - GENERALLY - NATURE OF EQUITABLE ESTATES AND INTERESTS

Appeal against dismissal of appeal against order by a Master that the respondent Synnex recover its costs of action out of the appellant’s monies in the suitors fund. 

The appellant and Mr Johnson owned a family home at Hove.  Mr Johnson gave guarantees in favour of each respondent in respect of the liabilities of the Johnsons’ company supported by an equitable charge over his property.

The respondents in separate actions obtained declarations declaring void a transfer by Mr Johnson to the appellant of his half interest in the Hove property and orders under s 69 of the Law of Property Act 1936 (SA) that the property be sold and the net proceeds paid into court to abide the further orders of the Court.

Synnex conceded that Leader’s charge being first in time had priority over its charge and the respondents sought orders for payment out of the proceeds of the sale of Mr Johnson’s share of the house such that Leader’s debt received priority with an order that Synnex’s costs be paid out of the appellant’s share.  A Master made an order that Synnex’s costs be paid out of the appellant’s share. An appeal against that order to a Judge of the District Court was dismissed. 

The appellant appeals on the ground that the Master erred in making the order because Leader’s and Synnex’s charges ranked equally dollar for dollar.

Held by Blue J (Kourakis CJ and Evans J agreeing) dismissing the appeal:

1.  The original orders made by the trial Judge did not create new charges but merely recognised the existing equitable charges (at [94]).

2.  The original orders did not alter the pre-existing priority as between the two charges and did not order that they rank equally dollar for dollar (at [103]).

3.  Upon payment of the proceeds into the suitors fund, the equitable charges were not converted into beneficial ownership of the proceeds in equal shares in Leader and Synnex (at [118]).

4.  By seeking and obtaining payment out of the suitors fund, Synnex did not elect to enforce its charge and obtain equitable ownership of half of the monies comprising Mr Johnson’s share (at [123]).

5.  Appeal dismissed (at [129]).

JOHNSON v SYNNEX AUSTRALIA PTY LTD;  JOHNSON v LEADER COMPUTERS PTY LTD (NO 2)
[2017] SASCFC 165

Full Court: Kourakis CJ, Blue and Evans JJ

KOURAKIS CJ:

  1. I would dismiss the appeal for the reasons given by Blue J.  I make the following additional observation.

  2. This appeal has proceeded…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Johnson v Synnex Australia Pty Ltd; Johnson v Leader Compute... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] SASCFC 165
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned the priority of equitable charges held by Synnex Australia Pty Ltd and Leader Australia Pty Ltd over the proceeds of sale of a property. Mr Johnson had granted both companies equitable charges over his interest in the property to secure his liabilities under guarantees provided for his company, Arcom. Following Mr Johnson's bankruptcy and the sale of the property, disputes arose regarding how the proceeds of sale should be distributed between Synnex, Leader, and Mrs Johnson, who also held an interest in the property.

The central legal issues before the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia were whether the trial judge's orders had created new charges that merged with the original equitable charges, thereby ranking equally, or whether the original equitable charges were intended to rank equally. Further, the court considered whether, upon payment of the net proceeds into a suitors fund, the charges were converted into beneficial ownership of the proceeds in satisfaction of the underlying debts, or if seeking payment from the fund constituted an election to enforce the charge and obtain equitable ownership of a portion of the monies.

The Full Court dismissed the appeal, upholding the Master's interpretation of the trial judge's orders. The court reasoned that the trial judge's order for sale was made pursuant to Part 8 of the Law of Property Act 1936, and the payment into court was a payment envisaged by that Act. The Master had concluded that the orders did not create new charges or alter the nature of the existing equitable charges, nor did they automatically effect payment in equity. Instead, the equitable charges attached to the fund produced by the sale, and the plaintiffs retained an inchoate right to seek payment out of those monies, subject to further orders. The court also rejected Mrs Johnson's contention regarding exoneration, finding that she had not advanced the necessary arguments regarding contribution rights or priority of charges.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The following issues are raised by the appeals:1.Did the trial Judge’s orders create new charges into which the original equitable charges merged and which ranked equally dollar for dollar?2.If not, did the trial Judge order that the original equitable charges were to rank equally dollar for dollar?3.If not, upon payment of the net proceeds into the suitors fund, were the charges converted by an act of enforcement or realisation into beneficial ownership of the proceeds in equal shares in pro tanto satisfaction of the underlying debts?4.If not, by seeking and obtaining payment out of the suitors fund, did Synnex elect to enforce the charge and obtain equitable ownership of half of the monies comprising Mr Johnson’s share?Background In 1997 Mr and Mrs Johnson incorporated Arcom to sell and provide services for computers. The Johnsons were the joint shareholders and Mr Johnson was the sole director. In January 2006 the Johnsons jointly purchased a property at Hove. In December 2007 Arcom applied to Leader for a credit trading account. Mr Johnson executed a director’s guarantee and indemnity (the Leader guarantee). Clause 6 of the Leader guarantee provided that Mr Johnson charged all freehold and leasehold land to secure his liability under the guarantee (the Leader charge). In May 2009 Arcom applied to Synnex for a credit trading account. Mr Johnson executed a director’s guarantee (the Synnex guarantee). The Synnex guarantee provided that Mr Johnson charged all right title and interest in land to secure his liability under the guarantee (the Synnex charge). On 19 October 2010 Mr Johnson appointed Mr Jorgenson as administrator of Arcom. On 20 October 2010 the Johnsons lodged at the Lands Titles Office for registration a transfer by Mr Johnson to Mrs Johnson of his half interest in the Hove property (the transfer). On 28 October 2010 Leader instituted an action in the District Court against Mr and Mrs Johnson and the Registrar-General of South Australia seeking judgment against Mr Johnson for the amount owing under the Leader guarantee, a declaration that the transfer was void under section 86 of the Act and a declaration that Mr Johnson’s interest in the Hove property was charged to secure Leader’s debt (the Leader action). On 11 March 2011 Synnex instituted an action in the District Court against Mr and Mrs Johnson and the Registrar-General seeking judgment against Mr Johnson for the amount owing under the Synnex guarantee, a declaration that the transfer was void under section 86 of the Act and a declaration that Mr Johnson’s interest in the Hove property was charged to secure Synnex’s debt (the Synnex action). In November 2011 Mr Johnson was declared bankrupt. Leader and Synnex subsequently obtained leave from the Federal Court to proceed against Mr Johnson and join his bankruptcy trustee as an additional defendant on condition that any money judgment against Mr Johnson would only be enforced against their securities and not otherwise without leave. Leader and Synnex each subsequently joined Mr Johnson’s bankruptcy trustee as an additional defendant, but the trustee took no substantive part in the trial.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mrs Johnson has always accepted that a “person interested” within the meaning of section 69 includes an equitable chargee holding a charge over the whole of the property in question. Mrs Johnson argued during the second hearing before the trial Judge that a chargee holding a charge over the interest of one tenant in common is not a “person interested” within the meaning of section 69. The trial Judge rejected that contention.[27] Mrs Johnson accepts that, because she did not appeal against the orders for sale made by the trial Judge under section 69, she is obliged to accept that for the purposes of the actions Leader and Synnex had standing to seek orders for sale under section 69 and the orders were properly made.[27] Leader Computers P/L v Johnson; Synnex Australia P/L v Johnson (No 2) [2014] SADC 23 at [111]-[117].The Master’s reasons for judgment The Master gave lengthy reasons for judgment for his decision. They included the following passages:Both Leader and Synnex are agreed that Leader enjoys the benefit of a charge over the money in the suitors fund which eithera.has a priority over the charge of Synnex; orb.can be treated as if it did have that priority becausei.Synnex can choose not to resort to that charged sum for its costs; oriiSynnex and Leader can agree to Leader having priorityThe defendants do not agree with the position of Leader and Synnex. They contend that there is no priority established between them as a matter of law and that they rank equally. Further, that upon sale of the Hove property and payment into Court both Leader and Synnex have been paid in equity, and, there is no room for them to agree priority between themselves, or, for Synnex to elect to access another fund (Mrs Johnson’s share).…… I consider that I am entitled to interpret the orders of [the trial Judge] made on 3 April 2014 within the context of her reasons in Leader Computers Pty Ltd v Johnson & Others and Synnex Australia Pty Ltd v Johnson & Others (No 2) [2014] SADC 23. The making of the order for the sale, whilst not specifically referring to Part 8 of the Law of Property Act, was clearly one made in light of the reasons delivered approximately two months before hand.I have an abundant satisfaction thata.in making the order for sale of the Hove property on 3 April 2014 her Honour was relying on Part 8 of the Law of Property Act 1936;b.the sale which occurred was as a result of an exercise of the jurisdiction conferred by Part 8 of that Act upon her Honour; andc.the payment into Court on 31 October 2014 was a payment in of the type envisaged in Section 73(a) of the Law of Property Act 1936 and paragraph 11 of the orders made in both Actions.…In my view, the key features of the suite of orders of 3 April 2014 are as follows:a. the orders are not entirely interdependent;b. the order for sale of the Hove property was in a discrete paragraph and did not link back to the declaration of the charge (made in another paragraph of the suite of orders);c. the orders which declared a charge “by way of equitable charge” regarding the interest of the first defendant in the subject land were merely declaratory (i.e. they had no operational effect above and beyond the making of a declaration regarding an equitable charge);d. the ultimate order for sale did not pertain exclusively to the charge granted by the first defendant (although that was part and part only of the material upon which her Honour relied in making the order); ande. the monies resulting from the sale comprised a fund which is a joint fund representing the interests of the equitable chargor (Mr. Johnson) and the second defendant (Mrs Johnson – who, prior to 3 April 2014 – had not charged her interest in the Hove property).Thus, the orders said nothing, in their terms, about how the declared charge would relate to the sale of the whole of the property and the fund realised upon sale.This is especially significant when it is borne in mind that neither plaintiff enjoyed the benefit of a charge regarding the cost liability of the second defendant Mrs Johnson at the time of the first suite of orders made on 3 April 2014. Notwithstanding this, the order for sale was made, which, out of necessity, included the sale of the interest of Mrs Johnson.These features are sufficient to cause me to reject the contention that upon sale of the Hove property the plaintiffs realised their security interest against the first defendant, and, in equity, therefore, effectively, achieve payment upon the sale of the whole of the property.…Given her Honour’s detailed consideration of Part 8 of the Law of Property Act 1936 and the exercise by her of a power of sale, pursuant to those provisions, it is in my view fallacious to make submissions as if the making of the order for the sale of the property was solely grounded upon the declaration of the equitable charge.…I accept the submission that upon the sale, the equitable charge held by the plaintiffs over the land, then attached to the fund produced upon sale and paid into the suitors fund.Nonetheless, the ability of the plaintiffs to receive those funds depends on the further orders envisaged by [the trial Judge] to give effect to “the judgment”.That judgment, as I have said, comprised a number of aspects of which did not relate to the charge – which was declared at the same time as many other orders were made.Thus, I conclude that both Synnex and Leader have equitable charges over the fund resulting from the sale of Mr Johnson’s interest in the Hove property.Subject to a consideration of all claimants, both Synnex and Leader have the right, pursuant to the orders of [the trial Judge], if they so wish, to seek an order for payment out of the monies to which they were entitled under the equitable charges.That said, it does not follow that they have already achieved a payment in equity by the mere facts of the sale and subsequent payment into Court.… As was put on behalf of Leader: there could, theoretically, be many claimants in the funds which might be identified by the processes envisaged in Sections 72 and 73 Part 8 of the Law of Property Act. Hypothetically, they could include, for example, the Australian Taxation Office who may have an interest by virtue of a statutory right (which is neither equitable nor a common law interest).…In my view, the orders gave an inchoate right, should the plaintiff Synnex wish, to have its costs paid out of the first defendant’s share because the charge was found to extend to cover the costs liability.I do not consider that that occurrence of a sale and the payment of proceeds into court amounts to an actual payment to Synnex of the yet to be crystallised amount for costs.I accept the submission that Synnex in fact has at least two options available to it to have its costs paid should it wish, as it does, to rely on paragraph 11 of the orders made by [the trial Judge].72 The Master identified two alternative bases to justify his conclusion. First Synnex and Leader were entitled to reach agreement between themselves as to their respective priorities in relation to Mr Johnson’s share. Secondly in 2014 Mrs Johnson granted a mortgage in favour of Synnex and Leader securing amongst other things the Synnex and Leader costs of action[28] and Synnex was entitled to payment of its costs of action out of Mrs Johnson’s share pursuant to the covenants contained in that mortgage notwithstanding that it had been discharged at settlement of the sale of the Hove property.[28] As the price of the grant of a stay of execution pending Mrs Johnson’s application for special leave to appeal to the High Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mrs Johnson’s fourth contention must be rejected. Exoneration During the initial hearing of the appeal before Mrs Johnson decided not to advance the subrogation contentions on appeal, Mrs Johnson advanced a fifth contention. Mrs Johnson contended that under the exoneration principle a creditor having rights against two persons who are coordinately liable who abandons a security in respect of the liability of one of the persons exonerates the other person to the extent of the value of the security. Mrs Johnson contended that by seeking payment of its costs of action from Mrs Johnson instead of out of Mr Johnson’s share pursuant to its charge Synnex was abandoning its security and this exonerated Mrs Johnson to the extent of the value of that charge. After Mrs Johnson decided not to advance the subrogation contentions on appeal, Leader and Synnex did not address the exoneration contention. In reply, Mrs Johnson again advanced the exoneration contention. The exoneration contention depends upon Mrs Johnson having a right of contribution against Mr Johnson’s bankruptcy trustee. The contention that such a right of contribution exists was part of the subrogation contentions that Mrs Johnson chose not to advance on appeal and to leave to be addressed if advanced in the District Court. That choice precludes her advancing the exoneration contention on appeal. In any event, it would be an essential element of the exoneration contention that Leader’s charge does not have priority over Synnex’s charge under an exception to the usual rule that the equitable interest first in time has priority over a later equitable interest (Mrs Johnson having failed on her contentions that the two charges rank equally). Mrs Johnson did not advance such a contention before the Master (or the appeal Judge or on appeal to this Court). If Mrs Johnson wished to contend that Synnex was abandoning its priority in breach of its obligations to her, it was incumbent on her to make and establish that contention. If Mrs Johnson were permitted to advance the exoneration contention, it must be rejected.Conclusion The appeal must be dismissed. Postscript: future steps in the actions The principal debts owed by Mr Johnson to Leader and Synnex total a little over $300,000. Approximately 26 hearing days have been expended to date in the District Court and in this Court in the litigation between Leader and Synnex and the Johnsons. On any view, the legal costs incurred in the litigation are disproportionate to the amount in dispute. There is still a prospect of future litigation in the District Court and a future appeal to this Court. In these circumstances it is desirable to make some observations about the future conduct of the litigation. These observations do not of course bind the parties or the District Court but may be of some assistance. Orders need to be made by the Master addressing residual interest and costs issues pursuant to order 2 of the 10 February 2016 orders. It is to be hoped that the parties will agree on those orders but if not it may be expected that argument would be short and confined.