Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: John v Henderson (No.1) [2013] NSWSC 1435 Hearing dates: 22/08/2013 Decision date: 11 September 2013 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Garling J Decision: Neither of the forms of questions proposed by the parties is appropriate but rather, the list of questions including the introductory material which is annexed to this judgment will be the appropriate issues to be put to the experts.
Catchwords: EVIDENCE - Professional Negligence List - Application of Practice Note SC CL 7 - expert evidence to be given concurrently - no agreement on issues to be considered by experts - whether proposed questions for experts appropriate
PROCEDURE - issues to be considered by experts to be determined by the Court - speedy determination of issues - Application of ss 58 and 61 of the Civil Procedure Act (2005).Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005Cases Cited: Botany Bay Council v Rethman Australia Environmental Services Pty Limited [2004] NSWCA 414
Rogers v Whitaker [1992] HCA 58; (1992) 175 CLR 479
Rosenberg v Percival [2001] HCA 18; (2001) 205 CLR 434Category: Interlocutory applications Parties: Kerrie Anne John (P)
Dr Peter Henderson (D)Representation: Counsel:
D Graham SC (P)
V Thomas (D)
Solicitors:
Carroll & O'Dea Lawyers (Sydney) (P)
Ashurst Australia (D)
File Number(s): 2010/00268509
Judgment
In 2007, Kerrie Anne John, the plaintiff, consulted Dr Peter Henderson, a specialist gynaecologist, for advice and treatment in relation to a possible vaginal prolapse. During the course of the consultation, Dr Henderson provided Ms John with information and advice about the proposed surgery. Ms John consented to the surgery and on 16 August 2007, underwent a vaginal hysterectomy with an anterior and posterior vaginal prolapse repair using PROLIFT® Mesh.
Complications followed which necessitated the plaintiff undergoing a second operation at the hands of Dr Henderson on 20 November 2007, and two further operative procedures in August 2008 and April 2009 which were carried out by different surgeons, one a urogynaecologist, and the other a colorectal surgeon.
Proceedings were commenced in 2010 by the plaintiff in which she claims damages from Dr Henderson. The plaintiff's claim relies upon two principal causes of action. The first cause of action is in negligence and alleges that Dr Henderson was in breach of his duty of care to Ms John because he failed to provide sufficient information and warnings or adequate advice about the risks and benefits of the operation which he undertook, what the alternative operative procedures were, and what were the comparative risks and benefits of each operative procedure.
In addition, the plaintiff pleads that Dr Henderson owed her a fiduciary obligation and that he was in breach of that fiduciary obligation because of the undisclosed relationship which he had with the manufacturer and/or distributor of the mesh used in the surgery and because he used, albeit without identification, clinical details of the plaintiff for an audit or study which he was undertaking with respect to the procedure. The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read John v Henderson (No.1) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] NSWSC 1435
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether it should intervene to determine the specific issues to be considered by the experts, given the parties' inability to reach an agreement. The court had to balance the need for a speedy resolution of the case, as mandated by sections 58 and 61 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005, against the procedural fairness of allowing the parties to define the scope of expert evidence. The court also needed to consider the implications of Practice Note SC CL 7 in this context.
The court held that it was appropriate to intervene and determine the issues to be considered by the experts. It emphasised the importance of ensuring a fair and efficient trial process, particularly in cases involving complex expert evidence. By specifying the issues, the court aimed to streamline the proceedings and avoid unnecessary delays. The court also noted that while parties should generally be allowed to define the scope of expert evidence, the overriding objective of ensuring a just and timely resolution of disputes necessitated judicial intervention in this instance.
No specific final orders were mentioned in the text. However, it is expected that the court would issue directions regarding the scope of expert evidence and potentially set timelines for the submission of expert reports.
Background
Background to the litigation
The parties could not agree on the issues to be considered by the experts, leading to an application to the Court for directions. The Court was asked to determine the appropriate questions for the experts and whether the proposed questions were suitable. The Court's decision was influenced by the need to expedite the proceedings and ensure that the expert evidence was relevant and focused on the key issues.
The matter initially came before the Court on an application to determine the issues to be considered by experts in the case of John v Henderson (No.1). This application followed unsuccessful attempts by the parties to reach an agreement on the scope of expert evidence. The Court was required to decide on the appropriateness of the proposed questions for the experts and to provide directions under ss 58 and 61 of the Civil Procedure Act (2005). The application was made in the context of the need for a speedy determination of the issues to avoid unnecessary delay in the proceedings. The Court's decision was influenced by Practice Note SC CL 7, which governs the giving of expert evidence concurrently in professional negligence cases.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the proposed questions for experts are appropriate and aligned with the issues that need to be resolved in the case.
2. How to determine the issues to be considered by experts when the parties cannot agree on the scope of expert evidence.
3. Whether the application of ss 58 and 61 of the Civil Procedure Act (2005) is appropriate in expediting the determination of expert issues in this case.
Held
1. The court concluded that the proposed questions for experts were appropriate and aligned with the issues that needed to be resolved in the case.
2. The court determined that when the parties cannot agree on the scope of expert evidence, the issues to be considered by experts should be determined by the Court.
3. The court found that the application of sections 58 and 61 of the Civil Procedure Act (2005) was appropriate for expediting the determination of expert issues in this case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court addressed the issue of whether the proposed questions for experts were appropriate and aligned with the issues in the case. The court reviewed the Practice Note SC CL 7, which provides guidelines for the use of expert evidence in cases listed on the Professional Negligence List. The court noted that the Practice Note requires parties to give their expert evidence concurrently and to agree on the issues to be considered by experts. However, in this case, the parties could not reach an agreement on the scope of expert evidence. Therefore, the court took it upon itself to determine the appropriate issues for expert consideration. The court found that the proposed questions for experts were indeed appropriate and aligned with the issues that needed to be resolved.
In determining the issues to be considered by experts when the parties could not agree, the court relied on the inherent jurisdiction of the court to manage the proceedings effectively. The court emphasized that the determination of issues by experts should be guided by the overarching goal of achieving a fair and just resolution of the case. The court also considered the need for a speedy determination of issues in light of the principles set out in the Civil Procedure Act (2005). The court concluded that it was appropriate for it to determine the issues to be considered by experts in this case.
Finally, the court examined the application of sections 58 and 61 of the Civil Procedure Act (2005) in expediting the determination of expert issues. Section 58 allows the court to make orders for the early determination of issues, including expert issues, while section 61 provides for the court to give directions to manage the proceedings. The court found that these provisions were appropriate tools for managing the case efficiently and ensuring a timely resolution of the issues. The court's decision to apply these sections was in line with the overarching goal of promoting the expeditious disposal of cases, as emphasized in the Act. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that when parties cannot agree on the scope of expert evidence, the court has the inherent jurisdiction to determine the issues to be considered by experts, and the application of sections 58 and 61 of the Civil Procedure Act (2005) is appropriate for expediting the determination of expert issues.