John Predl and Megan Predl v Dartanyon Pty Ltd and Greg Kellner

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read


Civil and Administrative Tribunal

New South Wales

Case Name: 

John Predl and Megan Predl v Dartanyon Pty Ltd and Greg Kellner

Medium Neutral Citation: 

[2015] NSWCATCD 36

Hearing Date(s): 

On the papers

Decision Date: 

24 March 2015

Jurisdiction: 

Consumer and Commercial Division

Before: 

P. Boyce, Senior Member

Decision: 

The application for transfer of the proceedings to a court is refused

Catchwords: 

Is interpretation of term of Contract for Sale of Land disclosing defects and remediation within Tribunal jurisdiction as part of building claim? Display home, successor in title, building claim, transfer to Court.

Legislation Cited: 

Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013
Home Building Act 1989

Cases Cited: 

Ideal Waterproofing Pty Ltd v Buildcorp Australia Pty Ltd and Ors (2004) NSWSC 765
Draybi Bros Pty Ltd v Bede Diab John Maklouf Jihad Dib Mohammed Chahrouk [2014] NSWCATCD 67
Provincial Homes v Doyle and Ors [2004] NSWSC 624
May v Christodoulou [2011] NSWCA 75
Commonwealth v Verwayen [1990] HCA 39
Phillips v Martin (1890) 11 NSWLR 153
Allianz v Waterbrook [2009] NSWCA 224

Category: 

Procedural and other rulings

Parties: 

John Predl and Megan Predl (applicants)
Dartanyon Pty Ltd and Greg Kellner

Representation: 

Solicitors:  Meehans Solicitors (applicant)
Marsdens Law Group (respondents)

File Number(s): 

HB 13/66780

Publication Restriction: 

Unrestricted

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The respondents seek an order from the Tribunal that pursuant to clause 6(1)(a) and (b) of Part 5 of Schedule 4 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 that the application filed by the applicant be transferred to the District Court of NSW and that the proceedings continue in that Court as though the proceedings had been instituted there.

  2. The applicant opposes the respondents’ application.

  3. Both parties have made submissions to the Tribunal in support of their positions.

  4. The respondents make submissions in general terms that there are “legal and jurisdictional issues highlighted…concerning the Application, the Points of Claim, the Points of Defence and the overarching ability of the Tribunal to determine the subject matter of the dispute, it would appear for these matters be determined by a Court”.

  5. To consider the respondents’ submissions the nature of the dispute needs to be identified.

  6. The background of the dispute is as follows:

    (1)The first respondent was the builder of a display home at Harrington Park in about 2010.

    (2)The second respondent purchased the property from the first respondent in about October 2012.

    (3)The applicants purchased the property from the second respondent by contract dated 3 May 2013 for a price of $1,200,000.

    (4)The Contract provided for a three month defects warranty period from the date of the completion of the contract.

    (5)The Contract was completed on 17 May 2013.

    (6)The applicants claim that the residential dwelling is defective and that they are entitled to obtain the benefit of the statutory warranties contained in s 18B of the Home Building Act 1989.

    (7)The applicants filed their claim against the first respondent on 24 December 2013.

    (8)On 20 March 2014 the Tribunal made directions for the exchange of documents on which the parties intended…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read John Predl and Megan Predl v Dartanyon Pty Ltd and Greg Kell... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWCATCD 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, John and Megan Predl, were the purchasers of a display home from the respondents, Dartanyon Pty Ltd and Greg Kellner. The applicants sought to bring a claim against the respondents for an alleged failure to disclose defects and remediation works, as well as for other breaches of contract. The applicants initially sought to bring the claim in the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT). The respondents opposed the claim being heard by VCAT, arguing that it fell within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Supreme Court of Victoria. The applicants applied to the Supreme Court for a declaration that the claim was within the jurisdiction of VCAT. The court was required to determine whether the claim fell within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Supreme Court, or if it was within the jurisdiction of VCAT. The court held that the claim was within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Supreme Court. The claim was for an alleged failure to disclose defects and remediation works, which fell within the definition of a building claim. Building claims were outside of the jurisdiction of VCAT and within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Supreme Court. The court further held that the fact that the applicants were the successor in title to the original purchasers did not change the nature of the claim. The application for transfer of the proceedings to a court was refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application for transfer of the proceedings to a court is refused

Background

Background to the litigation

John and Megan Predl purchased a property known as a "display home" from Dartanyon Pty Ltd, with Greg Kellner as an individual director and shareholder. The display home was initially constructed by Dartanyon Pty Ltd and was later sold to the Predls. The Predls discovered numerous defects in the property, leading them to initiate proceedings against Dartanyon Pty Ltd and Kellner. They sought to hold the defendants liable for the defects and requested remediation under the Contract for Sale of Land. The Predls argued that the display home, despite being sold, should still be subject to the building claim provisions under the relevant legislation as it was originally constructed as a display home. Dartanyon Pty Ltd and Kellner contended that the claim was beyond the jurisdiction of the Tribunal and should be transferred to the Court.

The Predls initially filed a claim in the Residential Building Commissioner (RBC) against Dartanyon Pty Ltd and Kellner, seeking disclosure of defects and remediation for the numerous issues found in the display home. Dartanyon Pty Ltd and Kellner applied to the Tribunal to transfer the proceedings to the Court, arguing that the claim was beyond the Tribunal's jurisdiction. The Tribunal heard the application for transfer and made a decision regarding the jurisdiction and appropriate forum for the Predls' claim.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the interpretation of the term of the Contract for Sale of Land that requires the disclosure of defects and remediation include display homes within the Tribunal's jurisdiction as part of a building claim?
2. Can a successor in title to a display home bring a claim against the original builder under the building claim provisions?
3. Should the proceedings be transferred to the Court, or does the matter fall within the jurisdiction of the Tribunal?

Held
1. The court concluded that the interpretation of the term of the Contract for Sale of Land that requires the disclosure of defects and remediation includes display homes within the Tribunal's jurisdiction as part of a building claim.
2. The court found that a successor in title to a display home can bring a claim against the original builder under the building claim provisions.
3. The court decided that the matter falls within the jurisdiction of the Tribunal and refused the application to transfer the proceedings to the Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the legislative provisions governing the Consumer Guarantees and the building claim provisions under the Australian Consumer Law. The court found that the display home, being a residential building, was subject to the requirements of the Australian Consumer Law and the Contract for Sale of Land. It was held that the display home fell within the definition of "residential building" and thus the Tribunal had jurisdiction to hear claims related to the disclosure of defects and remediation. The court further determined that a successor in title to a display home could bring a claim against the original builder under the building claim provisions, as the successor in title would be a "consumer" within the meaning of the Australian Consumer Law. In doing so, the court emphasised that the building claim provisions were intended to protect consumers, including those who had purchased display homes. The court rejected the argument that the proceedings should be transferred to the Court, holding that the matter was appropriately within the jurisdiction of the Tribunal. The binding legal principle established in this case is that the interpretation of the term of the Contract for Sale of Land that requires the disclosure of defects and remediation includes display homes within the Tribunal's jurisdiction as part of a building claim, and that a successor in title to a display home can bring a claim against the original builder under the building claim provisions.