John Papaioannou and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

[2015] AATA 370  

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/3222

2013/3226
2013/3227

2013/6649

Re

John Papaioannou

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

John Handley, Senior Member

Date 28 May 2015  
Place Melbourne

The decisions under review are set aside and in substitution it is decided that:

1.    in application 2013/3222, the applicant did not have a capacity to earn between 1 December 2012 and 1 February 2013;

2. in application 2013/3226, the respondent is liable on and from 27 March 2013 pursuant to ss 16 and 19 of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act) for compensation in respect of aggravation of pre-existing cervical and lumbar disease;

3. in application 2013/3227, the respondent is liable pursuant to s 14 of the Act for a tear of the supraspinatus tendon of the left shoulder; and

4. in application 2013/6649, the respondent is liable, pursuant to s 14 for the secondary psychiatric illness which is properly diagnosed as an adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood.

.........[sgd]...............................................................

John Handley, Senior Member

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – applicant suffered back and neck injuries in motorcycle accidents travelling to and in the course of his work as a postal delivery officer – subsequent aggravation of lumbar and cervical disease by work activities – contributed to a significant degree by the employment – frank and traumatic tear of the left supraspinatus tendon – the injury arose out of or in the course of employment – tendon tear was not a disease and applicant did not make a wilful and false representation – also suffered adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood secondary to chronic pain –– decisions set aside

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 sections 14, 16 and 19

REASONS FOR DECISION

John Handley, Senior Member

28 May 2015

  1. The applicant commenced employment with the respondent on a permanent part-time basis in 2003 as a postal delivery officer. He was initially engaged on a walking round in central Melbourne working 25 hours per week at five hours per day. Overtime was regularly available and was undertaken by him.

  2. This review is a challenge to four reviewable decisions made by the respondent affecting his entitlements to compensation, as a consequence of back, neck, left shoulder and psychological injuries. Those decisions and the applicable file references will be identified later.

  3. The applicant contended that he suffered injuries on three occasions in traumatic circumstances. Additionally, the duties undertaken by him in the course of his employment were responsible for an aggravation or an exacerbation of his injuries.

  4. The episodes of traumatic injury were as follows:

    (i)On 26 March 2006 whilst travelling from work and when riding his motorcycle he was struck by a motor vehicle at the intersection of Swanston and Latrobe Streets in Melbourne. He was thrown from his motorcycle and experienced immediate neck and back pain;

    (ii)On 27 May 2010 and when in the course of his work as a postal delivery officer, he was struck from behind by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read John Papaioannou and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 370
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, John Papaioannou, brought a case against the Australian Postal Corporation, disputing his termination of employment and the nature of his injuries. The Federal Circuit Court was tasked with reviewing the decision to terminate his employment on medical grounds. The court was required to determine whether the applicant had the capacity to perform his job and whether there was any evidence of injuries unrelated to his employment with the postal corporation.

The court considered the evidence presented by the applicant and the medical reports submitted by his doctors, including Dr Chan, a general practitioner. Dr Chan’s reports indicated that the applicant had a history of back and neck pain, which had worsened after the incident on 27 November 2012. The court also heard from Dr Mendelson, who concluded that the applicant did not have a clinically significant depressive illness or anxiety disorder, although he acknowledged the presence of emotional symptoms. The court examined the applicant's activities, including his involvement in delivering newspapers and ju-jitsu, to assess their impact on his capacity to work. Ultimately, the court found that the evidence did not support the claim that the applicant had the capacity to perform his job or that his injuries were unrelated to his employment.

The court determined that the respondent had not met the burden of proof required to establish that the applicant had the capacity to perform his job. The court found that the applicant's participation in ju-jitsu did not correlate with the deterioration of his spinal disease, and his involvement in delivering newspapers was not sufficient to equate to his previous employment. The court concluded that the termination of the applicant's employment was not justified based on the evidence presented.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, John Papaioannou, is an employee of the Australian Postal Corporation. He claimed that he suffered injuries to his left shoulder and neck following a workplace incident. The applicant stated that he informed Mr Freeman, one of the authors of a relevant document, about his left shoulder injury but did not mention a neck injury. Mr Freeman, however, recommended that the applicant see a doctor immediately due to concerns that the pain he was experiencing might have stemmed from a previous neck injury. The respondent did not call Mr Freeman to testify. The applicant has been under the care of Dr Swee Onn Chan, a general practitioner, since 1995. Dr Chan's reports indicate that the applicant had intermittent back and neck pain following a motorcycle accident on 27 May 2010. Subsequent consultations with Dr Chan revealed that the applicant reported predominantly back pain but also experienced neck pain. A history was obtained that although some relief had been obtained by physiotherapy, there was a relapse in pain when completing delivery rounds. Dr Chan reported that the applicant had suffered an exacerbation of pain in his back and neck on 22 and 23 November 2012. The applicant also made a diagnosis of back and neck pain and stress on 6 December 2012. Dr Chan associated the stress with the applicant's perception of not meeting the expectations of his employer and his fear that meeting those expectations would exacerbate his back and neck injuries. The applicant believed his injuries were trivialised by management. The shoulder injury of 27 November 2012 magnified his stress. Dr Chan certified the applicant as incapacitated from 21 December 2012 until 18 January 2013 by a combination of left shoulder and neck pain with restrictions of movement. He confirmed that an ultrasound and x-ray of 30 November 2012 demonstrated the presence of a full thickness rotator cuff tear of the supraspinatus tendon with bursal inflammation and impingement. Dr Chan referred the applicant to an orthopaedic surgeon for further management.

The case came before the court as a review of a decision made by the Australian Postal Corporation regarding the applicant's claim for injury compensation. The applicant sought to challenge the respondent's decision that he had not suffered any mental disorder capable of diagnosis and that he did not have any clinically significant depressive illness or anxiety disorder. The applicant argued that his complaints were amplified and perpetuated by his resentment and sense of grievance towards Australia Post. The respondent contended that the applicant was capable of working because it learned that he was delivering suburban newspapers in his neighbourhood, an activity which involved walking, pushing a trolley, and inserting the newspapers into letterboxes. The applicant acknowledged that he had been engaged in ju-jitsu for many years, and the respondent sought to associate back and neck pain and aggravation of the degenerative spinal disease with that activity. The case was heard and evidence was presented by the applicant, four doctors, and other clinical information.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant said he explained to Mr Freeman, one of the authors of the document, the circumstances of the left shoulder injury. He was adamant that he did not tell Mr Freeman that he suffered an injury to his neck but said that it was Mr Freeman who had recommended that he attend a doctor immediately after the incident occurred because he (Mr Freeman) was concerned that the pain he then experienced may have had its origin in his previous neck injury. The respondent did not call Mr Freeman to give evidence. Medical evidenceDoctor Swee Onn Chan Dr Chan, a general practitioner, has been the applicant’s doctor since 1995. He wrote a number of reports which are found within the T-documents. His first report dated 28 June 2011 (T36, pages 68-69) records the applicant had intermittent back and neck pain following a motorcycle accident on 27 May 2010. He saw him subsequently reporting complaints predominantly of back pain. On 29 December 2010 he again consulted the applicant who complained of back and neck pain. (The clinical notes record the applicant presented with back and neck pain, joint stiffness, restricted movement and pain radiating into the right buttock. A certificate of incapacity was issued until 27 January 2011). The applicant presented with similar symptoms on 2 June 2011 and a history was obtained that although some relief had been obtained by physiotherapy, there was a relapse in pain when completing delivery rounds. Certificates of incapacity were issued on 2 June and again on 24 June 2011. Dr Chan reported that the back and neck pain commenced on 27 May 2010. He was aware the applicant suffered back and neck pain following a motorcycle accident in March 2006. The pain from that event had largely resolved but did recur intermittently. A report written by Dr Chan on 6 January 2013 (T89, pages 161-162) responded to questions asked of him by an officer of the respondent. He recorded that the applicant had suffered an exacerbation of pain in his back and neck on 22 and 23 November 2012. He also made a diagnosis of back and neck pain and stress on 6 December 2012, the latter condition he associated with a history that he obtained from the applicant perceiving that he was not meeting the expectations of his employer and his fear that meeting those expectations would exacerbate his back and neck injuries. He reported that the applicant believed that his injuries were trivialised by management. The shoulder injury of 27 November 2012 magnified (page 161) his stress. Dr Chan certified the applicant as incapacitated from 21 December 2012 until 18 January 2013 by a combination of left shoulder and neck pain with restrictions of movement. He confirmed that an ultrasound and x-ray of 30 November 2012 demonstrated the presence of a full thickness rotator cuff tear of the supraspinatus tendon with bursal inflammation and impingement. He referred the applicant to an orthopaedic surgeon for further management. In response to a question asking him to identify the injury responsible for incapacity, Dr Chan reported: Particularly his shoulder injury but also taking into consideration his back and neck pain exacerbations and the impact this has on his mental health.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Dr Mendelson was not satisfied that the applicant had any mental disorder capable of diagnosis and he did not have any clinically significant depressive illness or anxiety disorder. He acknowledged that the applicant did suffer emotional symptoms which were an understandable psychological reaction to his physical complaints and his current situation. He also thought the applicant’s complaints were amplified and perpetuated by his resentment and sense of grievance towards Australia Post. In his opinion the applicant did not have any loss of work capacity by his psychiatric illness.Conclusion and Reasons for Decision There were two issues that emerged during the hearing which the respondent contended were relevant to the applicant’s capacity to work and whether he had suffered injuries elsewhere. Those issues were the applicant delivering newspapers and his involvement in ju-jitsu. The respondent contended that the applicant was capable of working because it learnt, shortly prior to the hearing, that he was delivering suburban newspapers in his neighbourhood, an activity which involved walking, pushing a trolley and inserting the newspapers into letterboxes. On closer enquiry, that activity was unpaid, involved about 20 minutes of delivery on most weeks within three or four blocks of the applicant’s home and then in a precinct near a local railway station where the applicant’s son, who was engaged by the newspaper publisher, preferred not to frequent. The applicant’s physiotherapist also recommended that he pursue walking to retain some degree of mobility. I am not satisfied that this activity could be equated with the work previously undertaken by the applicant nor could it point to an inconsistency with the applicant’s assertion of incapacity to resume working his pre-injury routine at five hours per day. The applicant acknowledged that he had been engaged in ju-jitsu for many years and the respondent sought to associate back and neck pain and aggravation of the degenerative spinal disease with that activity. However there was no evidence of the applicant suffering any injury whilst participating in ju-jitsu. Significantly the only involvement in ju-jitsu after May 2010 involved some limited demonstration only but mainly instruction where he stood and walked without any other physical activity. He also observed the participants in his classes whilst seated and was assisted by his daughter who held a black belt and by other senior students. I am not satisfied on the evidence that there is any association between the applicant’s participation in ju-jitsu and the deterioration in his degenerative spinal disease. This review heard evidence of a number of injuries (and the aggravation or exacerbation of them) suffered by the applicant, over many years of his employment with it. In addition to the evidence of the applicant, evidence was also heard by four doctors. A considerable volume of medical and other clinical information was received into evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court evaluated the evidence presented regarding the applicant's mental health, physical complaints, and capacity to work. Dr Mendelson, a psychiatrist, assessed the applicant and concluded that he did not have any mental disorder capable of diagnosis and did not suffer from clinically significant depressive illness or anxiety disorder. However, the court acknowledged that the applicant experienced emotional symptoms as a psychological reaction to his physical complaints and situation. The court also considered the applicant's resentment and sense of grievance towards Australia Post as factors that amplified and perpetuated his complaints.

Regarding the applicant's capacity to work, the court examined the evidence of the applicant delivering suburban newspapers. The court found that this activity did not equate to the work previously undertaken by the applicant or indicate an inconsistency with his assertion of incapacity to resume his pre-injury routine. The court also considered the evidence of the applicant's involvement in ju-jitsu and found no association between this activity and the deterioration in his degenerative spinal disease. The court noted that the only involvement in ju-jitsu after May 2010 involved limited physical activity.

The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the court's consideration of the applicant's mental health, physical complaints, and capacity to work, as well as the association between his participation in ju-jitsu and the deterioration in his degenerative spinal disease. The court's analysis of the evidence and application of relevant legal principles to the facts establish the binding legal principle in this decision.