Administrative Appeals Tribunal
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No: 2014/1361
General Administrative Division )
Re: John O'Brien
Applicant
And: Civil Aviation Safety Authority
Respondent
DIRECTION
TRIBUNAL: The Honourable Justice Benjamin
DATE: 11 March 2015
PLACE: Brisbane
The Tribunal directs the Registrar, pursuant to subsection 43AA(1) of the
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, to alter the text of the decision in this
application so that:
- The words ’casual’ in line 6 at paragraph 106 is now ‘causal; and
- The word ‘casual’ in line 4 at paragraph 107 is now ‘causal’; and
- The word ‘casual’ in line 3 at paragraph 114 is now ‘causal’; and
- The Counsel for the respondent on page 50 of the decision be altered to
‘Ian Harvey’.
..........................[Sgd].........................................
The Honourable Justice Benjamin
[2015] AATA 93
Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION File Number
2014/1361
Re
John O'Brien
APPLICANT
And
Civil Aviation Safety Authority
RESPONDENT
Decision
Tribunal The Honourable Justice Benjamin
Dr W Isles, MemberDate 20 February 2015 Place Brisbane The Tribunal varies the decision of the Civil Aviation and Safety Authority dated
7 March 2014 and the conditions attached to the applicant’s
class 1 medical certificate by providing:(a)The class 1 medical certificate is only valid for operations within Australia;
(b)The applicant is not permitted to conduct night time operations other than as or with a qualified co-pilot; and
(c)The applicant must disclose to his employer, any person lawfully training, assessing, endorsing or re-endorsing him on any aircraft in respect of his
Air Transport Pilot Licence, and other assigned flight crew members of his
colour vision deficiency.
..............................[Sgd]..........................................
The Honourable Justice Benjamin
CATCHWORDS
CIVIL AVIATION – progression from co-pilot to captain – progression from co-pilot to pilot in command – progression from first officer to officer in command – colour vision deficiency (CVD) – protanopia – protanope – Air Transport Pilot (Aeroplane) Licence (ATPL) – Commercial Pilot (Aeroplane) Licence (CPL) – conditions imposed on class 1 Civil Aviation medical certificate –conditions imposed on applicant – Colour Assessment and Diagnosis (CAD) test – Precision Approach Path Indicator (PAPI) – Pseudo-isochromatic Plates (PIP) – Ishihara plates – lantern tests – applicant does not meet medical standard – failure to meet medical standard not likely to endanger the safety to air navigation – decision varied – conditions attached to class 1 Civil Aviation medical certificate varied – only valid for operations within Australia – applicant not permitted to conduct night time operations other than as or with qualified co-pilot – applicant must disclose colour vision deficiency to specified persons.
LEGISLATION
Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth)
CASES
Re Denison and Civil Aviation Authority (1989) 19 ALD 607
Re Becker and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1977) 1 ALD 158; [1977] AATA 12Re Pape and Secretary, Department of Aviation (1987) 16 ALD 97; [1987] AATA 354
SECONDARY MATERIALS
Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth), regs 11.055, 67.010, 67.150, 67.165, 67.180
Milburn NJ, Gildea KM, Perry DL, Roberts CA and Peterson LM, “Usability of Light Emitting Diodes in Precision Approach Path Indicator…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read John O'Brien and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] AATA 93
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the conditions imposed by CASA were necessary to ensure air safety and if Mr O'Brien's CVD constituted a significant enough risk to warrant such restrictions. The court examined the statutory obligations of CASA under the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth) and considered expert evidence on the implications of CVD in aviation.
The court found that while Mr O'Brien's CVD posed some risk, the evidence suggested this risk was manageable given his extensive experience and the presence of a co-pilot. CASA's conditions, particularly the restriction on night flights and international operations, were deemed reasonable to mitigate any potential safety issues. The court concluded that these conditions were not overly burdensome and were necessary to ensure the safety of air navigation.
The court varied CASA's decision, attaching specific conditions to Mr O'Brien's class 1 medical certificate. These conditions included limiting his operations to within Australia and prohibiting him from conducting night flights unless accompanied by a qualified co-pilot. Mr O'Brien was also required to disclose his CVD to specified persons. These measures balanced the need for aviation safety with Mr O'Brien's professional aspirations, ensuring that any residual risk was adequately managed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the light of our findings and other factors, we now consider the evidence in relation to each of the conditions of Mr O’Brien’s class 1 medical certificate and set out our findings as follows.Condition 1 – that Mr O’Brien’s class 1 medical certificate is not valid for an ATPL operation This is the most contentious and difficult aspect of the determination. If this condition remains, Mr O’Brien will be able to continue operating aircraft as a first officer but will not be permitted to fly in a command position as a captain. This will seriously and significantly reduce Mr O’Brien’s ability to reach his full potential in his chosen career. The change in roles as it relates to technical skills is, in many respects, relatively minor. CASA has accepted that Mr O’Brien is safe to conduct flights as a first officer and in those circumstances would fly sectors and undertake almost all of the roles that a captain would undertake in an aircraft. The concern from CASA’s point of view seems to fall into two areas. Firstly, as we have discussed earlier in these reasons, and as is described by Mr Banks in his evidence:[84]The role of the captain versus that of the co-pilot.37.CASA requires a higher minimum standard for aircraft captains than co-pilots which allows for the development of the co-pilot from a minimum acceptable standard to participate competently in the role of co-pilot to a standard where they can perform the role of captain. While the technical skills required are often of a similar standard in which greatest development is expected in terms of aviation relating to knowledge and non-technical skills such as those required for effective Crew Resource Management (CRM).38.Ultimately the captain is responsible for decisions made by the crew and therefore typically has the final say although achieving effective crew coordination and cooperation typically enables better quality decisions as other perspective and options can be considered. As noted by Don Harris (2011), delivering the message is easier to achieve for the captain than the co-pilot as the co-pilot must be both assertive and subordinate. In highly time constrained situations it is the captain who will likely take control of the aircraft and respond based on experience rather than seeking input from crew members. This naturalistic decision making method is less likely or appropriate for a co-pilot who doesn’t have the authority or potentially the necessary experience to act in this expert fashion. It does however mean that the deficiencies in colour vision of a co-pilot are potentially less critical of that of the captain as decisions taken by the co-pilot are more likely to be subject to consideration and input by the entire crew.[84] See above n 70, pp 692 – 693. In terms of that evidence, it must be seen that the issue raised in the 1971 and the 1993 references referred to above in paragraph 93 of these reasons, have to some degree been addressed in training of cockpit management since those times.