John Holland Pty Ltd v Victorian Workcover Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ
GUMMOW, HAYNE, HEYDON, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ

JOHN HOLLAND PTY LTD (ACN 004 282 268)  PLAINTIFF

AND

VICTORIAN WORKCOVER AUTHORITY  DEFENDANT

John Holland Pty Ltd v Victorian Workcover Authority
[2009] HCA 45
13 October 2009
M16/2009

ORDER

Order that the questions reserved in the amended stated case dated 29 September 2009 be answered as follows:

Question 1:       While the Plaintiff remains a "non-Commonwealth licensee" for the purposes of the [Occupational Health and Safety Act 1991 (Cth) ("the Federal OHS Act")], is the Plaintiff liable to conviction for offences against s 21 and s 23 of the [Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (Vic) ("the State OHS Act")] committed before the Plaintiff became a "non-Commonwealth licensee"?

Answer:             Yes.

Question 2: If the answer to question 1 is "yes", while the Plaintiff remains a "non-Commonwealth licensee" for the purposes of the Federal OHS Act, are any (and if so which) of ss 7, 8 and/or 130 of the State OHS Act invalid within s 109 of the Commonwealth Constitution to the extent that any of those provisions purports to empower the Defendant to authorise an inspector to bring proceedings against the Plaintiff for offences against s 21 and s 23 of the State OHS Act allegedly committed before the Plaintiff became a "non-Commonwealth licensee"?

Answer:             No.

Question 3:      If the answer to question 2 is "yes", is the consequence that:

(a)the Inspector could not procure the issuing, on or about 24 September 2008, of a charge and summons against the Plaintiff alleging the commission of offences against s 21 and s 23 of the State OHS Act at Morwell and other places in the State of Victoria in or about October 2006; and

(b)the proceeding brought against the Plaintiff by the Inspector on or about 24 September 2008, alleging the commission of offences against s 21 and s 23 of the State OHS Act at Morwell and other places in the State of Victoria in or about October 2006, is incompetent?

Answer:             Does not arise.

Question 4:      Who should pay the costs of the stated case?

Answer:             The Plaintiff.

Representation

D F Jackson QC with G J Hatcher SC and S P Donaghue for the plaintiff (instructed by Harris & Company)

P J Hanks QC with F I Gordon for the defendant (instructed by Corrs Chambers Westgarth Lawyers)

Interveners

S J Gageler SC, Solicitor-General of the Commonwealth with C P Young intervening on behalf of the Attorney-General of the Commonwealth (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)

M G Sexton SC, Solicitor-General for the State of New South Wales with J V Agius SC and A M Mitchelmore intervening on behalf of the Attorney-General for the State of New South Wales (instructed by Crown Solicitor (NSW))

M G Hinton QC, Solicitor-General for the State of South Australia with S A McDonald intervening on behalf of the Attorney-General for the State of South Australia (instructed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read John Holland Pty Ltd v Victorian Workcover Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] HCA 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered a dispute between John Holland Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) and the Victorian Workcover Authority (the defendant) concerning the application of Commonwealth and Victorian occupational health and safety legislation. The plaintiff had been charged with offences under the *Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004* (Vic) for conduct that occurred before it became a "non-Commonwealth licensee" under the *Occupational Health and Safety Act 1991* (Cth). The central question was whether the plaintiff remained liable for these prior offences under the Victorian Act, despite its subsequent status under the Commonwealth Act, and whether this liability was invalidated by section 109 of the Constitution due to inconsistency.

The legal issues before the Court were twofold. Firstly, whether the plaintiff, by virtue of being a "non-Commonwealth licensee" for the purposes of the Commonwealth Act, was still liable to conviction under the Victorian Act for offences allegedly committed before it attained that status. Secondly, if the answer to the first question was yes, whether the provisions of the Victorian Act authorising inspectors to bring proceedings for such offences were inconsistent with the Commonwealth Act and therefore invalid under section 109 of the Constitution.

The Court reasoned that section 4 of the Commonwealth Act, which defined the scope of its application, did not operate directly on State law but rather indicated an intention to cover a particular field. This intention, when supported by the substantive provisions of the Commonwealth Act, informs the operation of section 109 of the Constitution. The Court distinguished this case from situations where a Commonwealth law might impermissibly attempt to exclude State legislative power without enacting its own provisions. It held that the Commonwealth Act, as enacted, operated prospectively and did not invalidate State laws that imposed liability for past conduct, even if the employer subsequently fell within the definition of a "non-Commonwealth licensee".

The Court ordered that the questions reserved in the amended stated case be answered. It held that the plaintiff was liable to conviction for offences committed before becoming a "non-Commonwealth licensee" and that the relevant provisions of the Victorian Act were not invalid by reason of section 109 of the Constitution. Consequently, further questions regarding the consequences of invalidity did not arise, and the plaintiff was ordered to pay the costs of the stated case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Order that the questions reserved in the amended stated case dated 29 September 2009 be answered as follows:

Question 1: While the Plaintiff remains a "non-Commonwealth licensee" for the purposes of the [Occupational Health and Safety Act 1991 (Cth) ("the Federal OHS Act")], is the Plaintiff liable to conviction for offences against s 21 and s 23 of the [Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (Vic) ("the State OHS Act")] committed before the Plaintiff became a "non-Commonwealth licensee"?

Answer: Yes.

Question 2: If the answer to question 1 is "yes", while the Plaintiff remains a "non-Commonwealth licensee" for the purposes of the Federal OHS Act, are any (and if so which) of ss 7, 8 and/or 130 of the State OHS Act invalid within s 109 of the Commonwealth Constitution to the extent that any of those provisions purports to empower the Defendant to authorise an inspector to bring proceedings against the Plaintiff for offences against s 21 and s 23 of the State OHS Act allegedly committed before the Plaintiff became a "non-Commonwealth licensee"?

Answer: No.

Question 3: If the answer to question 2 is "yes", is the consequence that:

(a) the Inspector could not procure the issuing, on or about 24 September 2008, of a charge and summons against the Plaintiff alleging the commission of offences against s 21 and s 23 of the State OHS Act at Morwell and other places in the State of Victoria in or about October 2006; and

(b) the proceeding brought against the Plaintiff by the Inspector on or about 24 September 2008, alleging the commission of offences against s 21 and s 23 of the State OHS Act at Morwell and other places in the State of Victoria in or about October 2006, is incompetent?

Answer: Does not arise.

Question 4: Who should pay the costs of the stated case?

Answer: The Plaintiff.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ CJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE, HEYDON, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ
Section 4 of the OHS Act is drawn in a fashion which resembles the plan of s 16 of Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth). The validity of s 16 was attacked by Western Australia in The Work Choices Case[1] as a "bare attempt to limit or exclude State legislative power" without the Commonwealth itself enacting a law which would prevail to the extent of inconsistency by reason of s 109 of the Constitution. In response, the Commonwealth had declined to contend that a federal law might simply exclude State law in a field and make no provision on that subject. Rather, the Commonwealth successfully submitted that s 16 was to be supported as an indication of the relevant field the federal law was intended to cover to the exclusion of State law and that s 109 operated accordingly. The section did not purport to state, impermissibly, the result of the operation of s 109, or to displace or expand its operation[2].[1](2006) 229 CLR 1 at 164‑169 [364]‑[372]; [2006] HCA 52.[2]Botany Municipal Council v Federal Airports Authority (1992) 175 CLR 453 at 464‑465; [1992] HCA 52.Conclusions In the present case there is no challenge to the validity of s 4. Rather, the dispute concerns its proper construction. Section 4 in terms is addressed to "the Act". To achieve the objectives stated in s 3, the statute operates prospectively upon those such as the plaintiff who answer the temporally expressed definition of "non‑Commonwealth licensee" and thus the definition of "employer". It imposes the duties specified in Pt 2, with attendant enforcement provisions of Pt 5. The section then states an intention as to the scope of the application of the Act with respect, relevantly, to State law. The section does not purport to do what it could not do, and to operate directly upon State law. That is left to the operation of s 109 of the Constitution. The legislative power of the Parliament extends to the expression in a law of its intention to cover a particular field of activity or to refrain from doing so. Such a law assists in the resolution, as a matter of statutory construction, of the question of the existence of such an intention. In the light of a provision such as s 4 it is not necessary to undertake a detailed analysis of the remaining provisions of the Act in order to determine with precision the field which it is intended the law should cover. That is set out in the express statement of legislative intent. But such a statement is only a statement of intention which informs the construction of the Act as a whole. It must be an intention which the substantive provisions of the Act are capable of supporting. Absent that necessary qualification, the character of a bare statement of intention could approach that of a bare exclusion of State law. As Mason J emphasised in The Queen v Credit Tribunal; Ex parte General Motors Acceptance Corporation[3] a law of the Commonwealth cannot operate of its own force to invalidate or render inoperative a State law. His Honour said[4]:"although a provision in a Commonwealth statute which attempts to deny operational validity to a State law cannot of its own force achieve that object, it may nevertheless validly evince an intention on the part of the statute to make exhaustive or exclusive provision on the subject with which it deals, thereby bringing s 109 into play. Equally a Commonwealth law may provide that it is not intended to make exhaustive or exclusive provision with respect to the subject with which it deals, thereby enabling State laws, not inconsistent with Commonwealth law, to have an operation. Here again the Commonwealth law does not of its own force give State law a valid operation. All that it does is to make it clear that the Commonwealth law is not intended to cover the field, thereby leaving room for the operation of such State laws as do not conflict with Commonwealth law."[3](1977) 137 CLR 545 at 562; [1977] HCA 34.[4](1977) 137 CLR 545 at 563.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, CJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE, HEYDON, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ

Full text does not contain this section.