John Geletic and Repatriation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

[2013] AATA  406

Division Veterans' Appeals Division

File Number

2012/3810

Re

John Geletic

APPLICANT

And

Repatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President S D Hotop
Brigadier A G Warner, Member

Date 18 June 2013
Place Perth

The decision under review is set aside and, in substitution therefor, it is decided that pleural plaque, contracted by the applicant in 2010, is a "defence-caused disease" pursuant to s 70(5)(a) of the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth).

............................[Sgd]............................................

S D Hotop, Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

VETERANS' AFFAIRS – veterans' entitlements – disability pension – applicant rendered defence service in Royal Australian Air Force from 1975 to 1995 – applicant required to reside in married quarters on base – married quarters constructed of asbestos materials – applicant carried out necessary repairs – applicant exposed to asbestos fibres – applicant contracted pleural plaque in 2010 – Statement of Principles concerning pleural plaque (SoP) – SoP upholds contention that applicant's pleural plaque on balance of probabilities connected with defence service – applicant's pleural plaque arose out of or was attributable to defence service – applicant’s pleural plaque a defence-caused disease – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION

Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth), s 5D(1), s 68 (1), s 70(5), s 120(4), s 120B(3), s 196B(3) and s 196B(14)

Statement of Principles concerning pleural plaque (Instrument No 52 of 2003)

CASES

Holthouse v Repatriation Commission [1982] FCA 113

Re Repatriation Commission and Wicking (1987) 7 AAR 289
Roncevich v Repatriation Commission (2005) 222 CLR 115

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President S D Hotop
Brigadier A G Warner, Member

18 June 2013

Introduction

  1. John Geletic (“the applicant”), who was born in June 1956, served in the Royal Australian Air Force (“RAAF”) from 1 April 1975 to 3 April 1995.

  2. On 10 August 2011 the applicant made a claim under the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) (“VE Act”) for acceptance of a condition described as “pleural plaques” as defence-caused.

  3. On 18 October 2011 a delegate of the Repatriation Commission (“the respondent”) decided that “pleural plaque is not related to service”.

  4. On 28 May 2012 the Veterans’ Review Board (“VRB”) determined that pleural plaque is not defence-caused and, accordingly, affirmed the delegate’s decision of 18 October 2011.

  5. On 31 August 2011 the applicant lodged with the Tribunal an application for review of the VRB’s decision of 28 May 2012.

    The Evidence

  6. The evidence before the Tribunal comprised:

    ·the “T Documents” (T1–T16, pp I–XII, 1–85) lodged by the respondent in accordance with section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth);

    ·statement of the applicant, dated 21 March 2013 (Exhibit A1);

    ·letter from Ian Robertson, dated 22 March 2013 (Exhibit A2);

    ·statement from Frank Middleton, dated 26 March 2013 (Exhibit A3);

    ·letters from Dr Peter Bremner, dated 26 June 2010, 12 July 2010, 12 August 2010, and 30 October 2012 (Exhibit R1); and

    ·the oral evidence of the applicant.

    The Applicant’s Evidence

  7. The applicant tendered in evidence his statement, dated 21 March 2013, and he confirmed that its contents are true…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read John Geletic and Repatriation Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 406
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves John Geletic, who served in the Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF) from April 1975 to April 1993, and the Repatriation Commission. The primary dispute pertains to whether Geletic's pleural plaque, diagnosed in 2010, qualifies as a "defence-caused disease" under the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (VE Act). The matter was adjudicated by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).

The legal issues central to this case revolve around whether Geletic's pleural plaque can be attributed to his service in the RAAF, specifically whether it "arose out of, or was attributable to" his defence service. The crux of the argument hinges on establishing a causal link between Geletic's exposure to asbestos during his military service and the subsequent development of pleural plaque. This requires examining the nature and extent of his exposure to asbestos in various RAAF bases where he was stationed, as well as the Defence Force's awareness and communication of asbestos risks during his service period.

The Tribunal's reasoning was grounded in the evidence presented, particularly Geletic’s detailed account of his exposure to asbestos while performing maintenance and repairs on the married quarters he resided in at several RAAF bases. The Tribunal noted that Geletic was frequently exposed to asbestos fibres through activities such as drilling, sawing, and sanding asbestos panels, installing window treatments, and repairing damage to the houses. The Tribunal also considered the lack of warnings or safety measures regarding asbestos exposure during Geletic's service. It was determined that these exposures sufficiently established a causal link between his service and the development of pleural plaque, thereby qualifying it as a "defence-caused disease" under the VE Act.

The Tribunal set aside the decision under review and substituted it with a decision that pleural plaque, contracted by Geletic in 2010, is a "defence-caused disease" pursuant to s 70(5)(a) of the VE Act. This ruling entitles Geletic to benefits and support as a veteran with a service-related illness.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence before the Tribunal comprised:·the “T Documents” (T1–T16, pp I–XII, 1–85) lodged by the respondent in accordance with section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth);·statement of the applicant, dated 21 March 2013 (Exhibit A1);·letter from Ian Robertson, dated 22 March 2013 (Exhibit A2);·statement from Frank Middleton, dated 26 March 2013 (Exhibit A3);·letters from Dr Peter Bremner, dated 26 June 2010, 12 July 2010, 12 August 2010, and 30 October 2012 (Exhibit R1); and·the oral evidence of the applicant.The Applicant’s Evidence The applicant tendered in evidence his statement, dated 21 March 2013, and he confirmed that its contents are true and correct. The applicant’s statement is as follows:“ …2.I joined the Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF) in April 1975 as an 18 year old.3.I served mainly as a steward in the RAAF from 1 April 1975 to 3 April 1993 [sic] completing 20 years of defence service.Pearce4.Between 1975 and 1977 I was stationed at RAAF base Pearce.5.While at Pearce my wife and I resided in married quarters that I understood to be provided by RAAF.6.I was not given a choice of housing and was required to take up the married quarters that were allocated.7.The married quarters that I was allocated were an asbestos house on the base and facing Great Northern Highway.8.My recollection is that all of the married quarters on base were essentially the same 3 bedroom one bathroom asbestos houses. My recollection is that there were six married quarters on base at that time.9.My recollection is that the internal and external walls were asbestos panels and the roof was asbestos.10.No warnings were ever given about the dangers of asbestos or warning me not to be exposed to the asbestos fibres, or even that the houses were made of asbestos. 11.Once allocated the married quarters, I was entirely responsible for maintenance and repair while residing there.12.The married quarters did not have any window treatments and like all others who were allocated married quarters, I installed all the fittings to install curtains and blinds which required me to drill into the asbestos walls and insert plugs to take the screws. I also drilled into the asbestos walls to put in picture hooks to hang photos etc.13.The asbestos was hard and very brittle and I was exposed to asbestos fibres.14.During my time at Pearce I carried out various repairs in the house.15.The house did not have any door stops and so the door handles would often put holes in the walls. 16.I repaired these holes by filling the holes with plaster and sanding the panel before painting the repaired area.17.I also repaired the wall in the toilet which had cracked and pushed inwards. I used a hand saw to widen the crack.18.I placed an ice-cream lid connected to a piece of string behind the crack to pull the wall level so it could be filled with plaster. The wall was then sanded and painted. I was exposed to asbestos fibres while conducting these repairs.19.I also repaired the wall next to the hand basin in the bathroom using the same method.20.I was responsible for all the maintenance on the house and so I also replaced tap washers and torn fly screens.21.While residing in the married quarters at Pearce dust in the house was a constant problem.22.Being so close to Great Northern Highway the vibration from the passing trucks caused dust to fall down from the ceiling. My wife would need to dust the house three or four times a week.23.Low flying aircraft would also cause the dust to fall.24.Often there would be dust on our beds. 25.The dust often resembled fine cobwebs.26.I do not know what the dust was but believe that it was likely to be contaminated by asbestos.27.On vacating the married quarters they had to be returned to their original condition.28.I had to remove all the window fittings, picture hooks and repair any damage to the house.29.The house had to be thoroughly cleaned and put into inspection order.30.To put the house into inspection order I was given three days (the ‘Pre Inspection Period’) to pre pack our belongings, remove them, repair any damage, and clean the house ready for inspection.31.During the Pre Inspection Period I was on duty and attended to the repairs that were necessary. The repairs were conducted both inside and outside the house and I was exposed to asbestos fibres through drilling, sawing and sanding the asbestos panels of the house.32.At that time everyone would do the repairs themselves. I was not aware of any businesses that would do that sort of work until I heard that a business set up in the 1980’s to clean Defence Houses, but I wasn’t aware of any such business during my service.33.In any event we were only paid very little back then and there was no spare money to pay anyone to do that sort of work.34.If you didn’t do it yourself, and the inspection required work to be done, it was very expensive.35.I recall that after I left Pearce I was charged about $18.00 each for two flyscreens that had holes in them that were bigger [sic] than a match head but which I hadn’t noticed. I am not sure of the exact amount that was charged.Townsville36.In 1977 I was posted to base Squadron Townsville and was allocated married quarters in Garbutt.37.The house was two storey and weatherboard on the bottom and asbestos on the top. During my time there the Defence Force put in a new kitchen and installed venetian blinds.38.I put up curtains, installed picture hooks, repaired holes and cracks caused by the door handles, children playing and so on. 39.In 1981 I was posted back to Pearce, and was required to restore the house to its original condition, which again required all fittings to be removed and repairs conducted. 40.During the three day Pre Inspection Period I conducted these repairs both inside and outside the house and I was exposed to asbestos fibres through drilling, sawing and sanding the asbestos walls.Pearce41.In 1981 I returned to Pearce and was allocated married quarters in North Avenue. This house was brick veneer, but had asbestos in the eaves and in the wood fired hot water system which had to be lit every day.42.As our children got older, they tended to cause more minor incidental damage around the house.43.On vacating the married quarters in 1983 the same procedure had to be followed as in previous married quarters.44.All window fittings had to be removed, all nails and hooks, all holes and cracks had to be repaired. 45.The house had to be thoroughly cleaned, including the windows and roof, and left in inspection order.46.I conducted the repairs both inside and outside the house and primarily carried out during the Pre Inspection Period [sic].Butterworth47.In 1983 I was posted to RAAF air base Butterworth.48.At Butterworth I was allocated temporary married quarters in Vale of Tempe Penang, before moving to a brick/concrete house at Robina Park which was close to the base.49.I do not believe that I was exposed to asbestos fibres during this period, however, on vacating the house the same procedure was involved as with other married quarters which required the removal of all fittings and repair of all damage, cleaning inside and out, including the roof so that the house was left in inspection order.50.I did most of this work during the three day Pre Inspection Period.Glenbrook51.In 1987 I was posted to RAAF base Glenbrook …52.I was again allocated married quarters.53.The house was brick and I do not believe that I was exposed to asbestos fibres during the time I was at Glenbrook.54.On vacating the house, however, the same procedure was involved as with other married quarters which required the removal of all fittings and repair of all damage, cleaning inside and out, including the roof so that the house was left in inspection order.55.I did most of this work during the three day Pre Inspection Period.Wagga56.In 1988 I was posted to Base Squadron Wagga where I was allocated married quarters in Ashmont.57.The house was asbestos and did not have any window treatments and like all others who were allocated married quarters, I installed all the fittings to install curtains and blinds which required me to drill into the asbestos walls and insert plugs to take the screws. I also drilled into the asbestos walls to put in picture hooks to hang photos etc.58.I resided in the house until 1990 and during the time I was there carried out repairs to the house which exposed me to asbestos fibres.59.Again holes were made in the interior walls by the door handles and I repaired them by plastering and sanding the asbestos wall panels.60.On one occasion I repaired an asbestos panel at the rear of the house which had been damaged by a cricket ball. I used a saw and electric grinder to open up the crack.61.I placed a board with a piece of string attached behind the crack and pulled the wall level so I could plaster the crack, after which it was sanded and painted.62.I recall that when I used the grinder I got a mouth full of dust which I spat out and washed my mouth out with water.63.On another occasion I repaired a large crack in the asbestos wall alongside the driveway using the same method referred to in paragraphs 61 and 62 above. I am not sure how that damage was caused as my children would not admit to causing it.64.I frequently repaired cracks and holes in the walls of my children’s bedrooms.65.In 1991 I was offered married quarters on the base. 66.On vacating the house, the same procedure was involved as with other married quarters which required the removal of all fittings and repair of all damage, cleaning inside and out, including the roof so that the house was left in inspection order.67.I did most of this work during the three day Pre Inspection Period.Pearce68.In 1992 I was posted to Pearce.69.Married quarters were not available and so I rented a house in Wanneroo. We were given rental assistance until married quarters became available in 1993.70.In 1994 I vacated the married quarters because my wife and I purchased a house.71On vacating the married quarters, the same procedure was involved as with other married quarters which required the removal of all fittings and repair of all damage, cleaning inside and out, including the roof so that the house was left in inspection order.72.I did most of this work during the three day Pre Inspection Period.Summary73.During the course of my service I was exposed to asbestos fibres when conducting installing fittings to the asbestos houses that I resided in and when conducting repairs to the asbestos panels.74.During the various Pre Inspection Periods I was on duty while conducting the repairs.75.It was a requirement that the houses be left in inspection order and I do not know anyone who would pay to have the repairs done by contractors.76.We were not paid enough to be able to afford outside help.77.The married quarters had to be made suitable to live in by installing curtains, blinds and other home comforts as these were not provided by Defence Housing.78.The repairs were all minor in nature and never [sic] considered having anyone else do them.79.I did not know about the dangers that conducting the repairs posed and so I did not have any reason not to undertake the repairs.80.The reason that I conducted the repairs is because it was a requirement to put the house in inspection order.81.I am not aware of any other time where I have been exposed to asbestos fibres.82.I originally believed that I had been exposed to asbestos fibres when I was a child and helped my brother cut up asbestos sheets.83.I now know that those sheets were not asbestos but hardi-board and they did not contain asbestos.” (Exhibit A1)

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal concludes that pleural plaque, which was contracted by the applicant in 2010, “arose out of, or was attributable to,” the RAAF service (being “defence service” within the meaning of Part IV of the VE Act) rendered by him and is, accordingly, a “defence-caused disease” pursuant to s 70(5)(a) of the VE Act.Decision For the above reasons, the decision under review is set aside and, in substitution therefor, it is decided that pleural plaque, contracted by the applicant in 2010, is a “defence-caused disease” pursuant to s70(5)(a) of the VE Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established