John Donnelly Johnston v Hi-Fert Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

official notice

decision of a delegate of the commissioner of patents

Application  :      No. 669403 in the name of  John Donnelly Johnston

Subject:      Coating granular fertilizers

Action: S.59 opposition by Hi-Fert Pty Ltd.

Hearing

Decision:      Issued            .

Abstract:      Opposition unsuccessful. Claims closely compared with the prior art and found to be novel and involving an inventive step.

Opponent's concerns under S.40 found to be not objectionable.

Opponent was advised that verbal evidence from its declarant was not appropriate in the circumstances.

patents act 1990

decision of a delegate of the commissioner of patents

Re:Patent Application No. 669403 by John Donnelly Johnston and opposition under S.59 of the Patents Act 1990 by  Hi-Fert Pty Ltd.

background

Application 669403 (52601/93), for a patent for an invention relating to coating granular fertilizers, comprises a complete specification filed on 21 December 1993, with priority claimed from provisional application PL6569 filed on 24 December 1992. The application was advertised accepted on 6 June 1996 and opposed on 4 September 1996. The opponent’s evidence-in-support was served by 4 March 1997, and, after the evidence-in-answer was served, the applicant filed a request to amend the specification. The amendments were advertised as allowable on 4 December 1997, and the opponent’s evidence-in-reply was served by 26 February 1998.

The opposition was heard in Canberra on 15 June 1998. The applicant was represented by Mr Ken Hamilton, patent attorney, and the opponent was represented by Mr John Maciel of Counsel and Ms Catherine Hustwick, patent attorney. Mr Karl Walter, one of the opponent’s declarants, was also present at the hearing.

At one stage whilst arrangements were being made for the hearing the opponent’s attorneys referred to Mr Walter “appearing as a witness”, but the matter was not referred to the applicant’s attorneys in sufficient time for them to prepare for dealing with a witness, so I decided that it was not appropriate for Mr Walter to give evidence at the hearing. However, he had provided evidence in the usual form of written declarations, in the opponent’s evidence-in-support and evidence-in-reply. Under the circumstances, I think Mr Walter not giving verbal evidence-in-chief was the best course of action, since it was highly likely that complications relating to “further evidence” may have arisen; and this would have delayed the hearing and/or possibly resulted in a second hearing. I did allow Mr Walter to make some comments on his evidence at the hearing.

THE SPECIFICATION

The specification indicates that the invention relates to a process relating to coating granular plant fertilizers with mineral nutrients such as sulphur and/or trace elements, which assist in plant growth. Prior art methods of coating the granules with the nutrients mixed with binder materials such as oils or waxes are unsatisfactory because the binder is absorbed into the fertilizer thus eventually reducing adhesion of the nutrients. One prior art method uses concentrated mineral acids to create a reactive layer on the surface of the fertilizer granules, but this method is allegedly inappropriate for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read John Donnelly Johnston v Hi-Fert Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] APO 57
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

John Donnelly Johnston opposed a patent application 669403 by Hi-Fert Pty Ltd for a process of coating granular fertilizers with mineral nutrients such as sulphur and trace elements. The applicant’s specification describes a process that involves mixing granules of fertilizer with a dilute mineral acid, a desired quantity of a component including sulphur and/or at least one supplemental micronutrient, and an acid neutralising agent, thereby causing liberation of heat energy which removes water as water vapour and at the same time causing precipitation of at least one reaction product of the acid and neutralising agent which binds the component to the surface of the granules in the form of an adherent coat. The opposition raised three objections: novelty, inventive step and non-compliance with Section 40 of the Patents Act. The delegate of the Commissioner of Patents considered the cited prior art and concluded that the claims were novel and involved an inventive step. The delegate further found that there were no valid objections to the specification under Section 40. The opposition was dismissed.