John Berns v Kinetic Group Services Pty Ltd and U-Go Mobility Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read
[2024] FWC 3229

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.365—General protections

John Berns
v

Kinetic Group Services Pty Ltd and U-Go Mobility Pty Ltd

(C2024/7791)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT COLMAN

MELBOURNE, 22 NOVEMBER 2024

Application under s 365 – no dismissal – application dismissed

  1. The following is an edited version of a decision given on transcript earlier today. John Berns has made an application under s 365 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Act). The respondents, Kinetic Group Services Pty Ltd (Kinetic) and U-Go Mobility Pty Ltd (U-Go), object to the application on the ground that Mr Berns was not dismissed.

  1. Kinetic contends that Mr Berns freely resigned from his employment with the company, and that he was therefore ineligible to make an application under s 365. In a letter to Kinetic dated 25 October 2024, Mr Berns stated that he was retiring and that his last day would be Friday 22 November 2024. In a reply dated 30 October 2024, Kinetic told Mr Berns that he was not required to work out his notice period, and that he would be paid up to 22 November 2024. His last day at work would be 29 October 2024. Mr Berns said that Kinetic had thereby terminated his employment early, however this is not the case. He remained employed until 22 November 2024. Even if Kinetic’s decision not to require Mr Berns to work during the notice period entailed some breach of contract (there is no evidence of this), that decision did not end the employment relationship (see s 386 and Khayam v Navitas English Pty Ltd[2017] FWCFB 5162). The relationship ended because Mr Berns resigned. This is not a case where the employer terminated the employment during the employee’s notice period. I find that Kinetic did not dismiss Mr Berns.

  1. What of U-Go? Mr Berns contended that on 24 August 2024 he had reached an agreement with U-Go’s general manager to commence employment with U-Go after his retirement from Kinetic, but that on 29 October 2024 the general manager told him that, because of certain views Mr Berns had expressed in his resignation letter, Kinetic, which has a substantial interest in U-Go, directed it to withdraw the offer of employment. In his resignation letter, Mr Berns had requested Kinetic to send his final pay advice to a new email address, ‘mencanneverbewomen@gmail.com’. At the base of the letter the following statement appeared in bold: ‘I acknowledge and pay my respects to the British and European elders, past and present, who introduced civil society and prosperity to Australia, and to our Australian born forebears who fought and died to preserve it’. Mr Berns said that he was deprived of the opportunity of employment with U-Go because of the political views that he expressed in his resignation letter to Kinetic. U-Go denied that there was ever any agreement to employ Mr Berns but acknowledged that there had been discussions about employing him and that a recruitment process was underway, which was subject…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read John Berns v Kinetic Group Services Pty Ltd and U-Go Mobilit... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FWC 3229
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

John Berns applied to the Fair Work Commission under section 365 of the Fair Work Act 2009, seeking relief in respect of his employment with Kinetic Group Services Pty Ltd (Kinetic) and U-Go Mobility Pty Ltd (U-Go). The respondents objected to the application on the basis that Mr Berns was not dismissed. Kinetic argued that Mr Berns resigned and that his employment ended on 22 November 2024, despite his last working day being 29 October 2024. U-Go, on the other hand, denied any agreement to employ Mr Berns and stated that it withdrew its recruitment process due to the content of Mr Berns's resignation letter, which it characterised as transphobic, racist and not conducive to valuing diversity.

The Fair Work Commission had to determine whether Mr Berns had been dismissed by either Kinetic or U-Go. The Commission found that Mr Berns was not dismissed by Kinetic as his employment ended due to his resignation. While there was a decision not to require Mr Berns to work during the notice period, this did not terminate the employment relationship. The Commission also determined that Mr Berns was not dismissed by U-Go because there was no substantiated contract of employment. U-Go had withdrawn the recruitment process due to the content of Mr Berns's resignation letter, which was not considered political opinion but rather inappropriate conduct. The Commission concluded that Mr Berns had not been dismissed by either employer, and therefore had no standing to make his application under section 365 of the Act.

The Fair Work Commission dismissed the application on the basis that Mr Berns was not dismissed by either Kinetic or U-Go. The Commission found that Mr Berns had resigned from his employment with Kinetic, and there was no evidence to support that he was dismissed. Regarding U-Go, the Commission found that there was no substantiated contract of employment, and the recruitment process was withdrawn due to the content of Mr Berns's resignation letter. The Commission's task was to determine the jurisdictional objection to the application, and it concluded that Mr Berns had no standing to make the application under section 365 of the Act. The application was dismissed.