John Anochie and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

[2013] AATA  391

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/0466

Re

John Anochie

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal

Senior Member J F Toohey

Date 12 June 2013
Place Sydney

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides not to exercise the power conferred by s 501(2) to cancel Mr Anochie’s visa.

...........................[SGD]...................................

Senior Member J F Toohey

Catchwords

MIGRATION – visa cancellation – applicant imprisoned for importation of cocaine – serious offence – no prior convictions – whether unacceptable risk of harm to the community – exemplary prison record – applicant on work release – current and former employers willing to employ applicant – non-refoulement obligations under international Conventions – construction of Direction 55 in respect of non-refoulement obligations – decision under review set aside

Legislation

Migration Act 1958 ss 36(2)(aa), 501

Cases

Anochie and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] AATA 234

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Anochie [2012] FCA 1440

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZQRB [2013] FCAFC 33

Secondary Materials

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, Direction No. 55 - Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501, 2012

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member J F Toohey

12 June 2013

Background

  1. John Anochie is a citizen of Nigeria. He arrived in Australia in 2000. In 2003, he was granted a permanent spouse visa. In January 2012, the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship cancelled his visa on the ground that, by reason of his conviction and imprisonment for importing cocaine, Mr Anochie did not pass the character test in s 501 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. In April 2012, the Tribunal exercised its discretion not to cancel Mr Anochie’s visa, and set aside the Minister’s decision.  As a consequence, Mr Anochie’s visa was restored and he was released from Villawood Detention Centre where he had been held since his release from prison in February 2012.

  3. In December 2012, the Federal Court found the Tribunal had erred in its approach to the principles of international law to be applied in Mr Anochie’s case and remitted the matter for reconsideration: Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Anochie [2012] FCA 1440. As the Minister’s decision to cancel his visa was in effect restored, in January 2013 Mr Anochie was taken back into immigration detention.

    Legislation

  4. The Minister may cancel a person’s visa if the Minister reasonably suspects that he or she does not pass the character test in s 501(6)(a) of the Act, and the person does not satisfy the Minister that he or she passes the character test: s 501(2).

  5. A person is taken not to pass the character test if he or she has a substantial criminal record.  A person has a substantial criminal record if he or she has been sentenced to a term of 12 months imprisonment or more, or has been sentenced to two or more terms of imprisonment totalling two years or more: subs 501(6)(a) and (7).

  6. Mr Anochie concedes that, by reason…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read John Anochie and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 391
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of John Anochie and the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, the Federal Court of Australia was tasked with reviewing the decision to cancel Anochie's visa on the grounds of his involvement in the importation of cocaine. Anochie, a Nigerian national, was imprisoned for his role in the drug importation scheme. The primary legal issues before the court were whether Anochie posed an unacceptable risk to the Australian community and whether cancelling his visa would breach Australia's international obligations under the non-refoulement principle.

The court examined Anochie's exemplary conduct during his imprisonment, his lack of prior convictions, and the support from his current and former employers. Anochie argued that he was motivated to commit the offence to fund his sister's cancer treatment, a claim that the Minister disputed. The court found that Anochie's involvement in the drug importation began before his sister's treatment needs became apparent, and therefore, his claim lacked credibility. Additionally, the court considered Anochie's remorse, as evidenced by his statements and behaviour while in prison, which included witnessing the adverse effects of drugs on other inmates. The court also noted the potential harsh consequences Anochie would face if returned to Nigeria, including the possibility of punishment under Decree 33.

The Federal Court concluded that, while Anochie's offence was serious, the evidence did not demonstrate that he posed an unacceptable risk to the Australian community. Furthermore, the court found that removing Anochie would contravene Australia's international obligations under the non-refoulement principle. Consequently, the decision to cancel Anochie's visa was set aside, and the Tribunal decided not to exercise the power to cancel his visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Additional evidence since the last hearing comprises:·a further written statement and oral evidence from Mr Anochie;·a further letter in support from Mr Anochie’s former employer, Mr Richard Carr;·a further letter in support from Pastor Samuel Abalo;·a letter from Mr Stephen Amponsah, who also gave oral evidence;·an affidavit of Ms Louise Buchanan, a solicitor at the Australian Government Solicitor, annexing a cable from the Australian High Commission in Nigeria.Mr Anochie’s further evidence In a written statement submitted to the Tribunal, Mr Anochie wrote:The reason why I was involved in an attempt to import cocaine was my sister in Nigeria was in need of money because she had been diagnosed with cancer. She died while I was in prison. I had had no knowledge of the harm that cocaine could do at that time. In Nigeria there are people who are addicted to drugs, but there is not much information about them. While I was in goal [sic] on remand I saw what drugs were doing to young people. While I was in prison I was head the spraying section [sic] of the workshop in Parklea Goal [sic]. I saw young people on methadone having to have instructions repeated many times because their memories were affected. I am truly sorry now that I had any involvement in attempting to import cocaine into Australia, and I would never do it again. In cross-examination, Mr Anochie maintained that the only reason he became involved in importing drugs was in order to fund chemotherapy for his sister, who has since died. He gave evidence that her treatment cost approximately $US7,000. Asked when he learned that she had cancer, he could not recall, other than that it was “before 2006” and “not less than two years before she got to the point where she needed money for treatment”. Mr Anochie was asked why, in a statement dated 26 March 2012 submitted at the previous hearing, he had said “My offending behaviour was driven by a number of factors including the illness of my sister”. (Emphasis added.) Mr Anochie could not recall making that statement but he was adamant that his sister’s cancer was the sole reason he became involved with importing drugs. He said that, by “a number of factors”, he meant only that his work as a bricklayer was unpredictable because of the weather, which made it difficult for him to send her money. In cross-examination, Mr Anochie agreed that he was involved in conduct directly associated with drug importation at least from July 2004, and he conceded that his conduct extended over a period of two years until his arrest in 2006. He did not agree that this suggested that his sister’s illness had nothing to do with his offence. Nor did he agree with the proposition that his consistent attempts throughout the criminal and tribunal proceedings to attribute his conduct to his sister’s illness showed he was attempting to minimise the criminality of his conduct. In his most recent written statement, Mr Anochie said his future in Nigeria would be very harsh, he would not be able to work with the Nigerian government, and he believes Decree 33 is still in operation and could lead to his being punished again for his offence in Australia. Decree 33 is considered below at [50] – [52].Further letter from Mr Carr

Decision

Reasons for decision

For Mr Anochie it is submitted that Mr Carr’s business would be adversely affected by his removal. That may be so, but Mr Carr could no doubt find someone else in time. I do not think any weight can be attached to this consideration.Conclusion The considerations for and against cancelling Mr Anochie’s visa are finely balanced. Only two are of any real significance in his case: the protection of the Australian community, and Australia’s international obligations. For the reasons set out above, none of the other primary, or other, considerations weighs particularly for or against his removal. It will never be possible to say with certainty that a person poses no risk of harm to the Australian community but I am satisfied, on the evidence before me, that Mr Anochie does not pose an unacceptable risk of harm to the Australian community. Added to that, I find that his removal would put Australia in breach of its international non-refoulement obligations. The weight of those considerations leads me to the conclusion that his visa should not be cancelled. The decision under review is set aside and in substitution the Tribunal decides not to exercise the power conferred by s 501(2) to cancel Mr Anochie’s visa.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Buchanan’s affidavit concerning the operation of Decree 33 in Nigeria is considered below.Primary considerationsProtection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct Mr Anochie does not dispute that his offence was serious but says the risk of his reoffending is “extremely slight”. His counsel referred in particular to “a number of unusual characteristics” about his case that support this contention: ·Mr Anochie is not a drug user himself, as evidenced by his negative urinalysis tests in prison, and he does not need to reoffend to support a habit;·he committed no institutional offences while in gaol, and was a model prisoner for over five years;·while in gaol, he saw the effects of drugs on people in gaol and “his eyes are opened”;·he is an enthusiastic and committed worker and employee with steady employment;·he has the unflinching support of an employer who knows of his offence, is completely opposed to illicit drugs, and yet has re-employed him while he was living in the community and while on parole, and would re-employ him again; ·he has the strong support of a number of people who are prepared to vouch for him; and·he has come very close to being removed and the prospect plainly terrifies him; he is an intelligent man and takes this very seriously. The Minister submits that the protection of the Australian community strongly favours cancelling Mr Anochie’s visa. He says Mr Anochie has attempted to minimise the criminality of his conduct and the Tribunal can have no confidence that he is genuinely remorseful or has insight into his offending and, therefore, no confidence that he will not reoffend. Further, the Minister says, Mr Anochie’s conduct amounts to a pattern over a period of two years and not a single, minor mistake. Moreover, he says, the fact that Mr Anochie has proven himself to be a good worker, both in the community and in prison, is no basis for confidence that he will not reoffend in future. In particular, the Minister says:·Mr Anochie denied opening more than three post boxes when clearly he opened more;·he denied using mobile phones for drug-related activities even though he had three phones;·he tried to shift the blame for his offending onto someone else; and·he tried to explain his conduct by reference to his sister’s illness. The Minister does not dispute that Mr Anochie’s sister had breast cancer and died in 2007. However, he says, Mr Anochie’s claim that that he was importing drugs solely in order to fund his sister’s treatment cannot be accepted. I agree. It is not clear when Mr Anochie learned of his sister’s diagnosis. It appears, from his evidence, to have been around 2004, around the time when he is first known to have engaged in contact associated with drug importation (that is, opening post office boxes). His evidence is that he learned of her illness about two years before she required treatment. If so, he cannot have been motivated by her need for treatment when he became involved – even if indirectly – in drug importation.