Johjen Pty Ltd v Body Corporate for Aegean

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read
CITATION: Johjen Pty Ltd v Body Corporate for Aegean [2013] QCAT 387
PARTIES: Johjen Pty Ltd
(Applicant)
v
Body Corporate for Aegean CTS 9646
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER: OCL052-11
MATTER TYPE:

Other civil dispute matters

HEARING DATE: 21 June 2013
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Paul Kanowski, Member
DELIVERED ON: 22 July 2013
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:

1.    In respect of the remedial action notices given by Body Corporate for Aegean CTS 9646 to Johjen Pty Ltd between 14 May 2010 and 22 December 2010, and identified in paragraph 3 of the Reasons for Decision as the first to the fifth notices, a declaration is made that:

a.    the second and fourth notices, and parts of the first notice, are invalid;

b.    the third and fifth notices, and the remainder of the first notice, are valid, and Johjen Pty Ltd has complied with them.

2.    An injunction is granted restraining Body Corporate for Aegean CTS 9646 from relying upon the notices to terminate the management agreement.

3.    The notices must forthwith be withdrawn by Body Corporate for Aegean CTS 9646.

4.    Johjen Pty Ltd must pay $2,465 in costs to Body Corporate for Aegean CTS 9646 on or before 22 August 2013.

CATCHWORDS:

BODY CORPORATE – whether remedial action notices valid and complied with – whether negligence by body corporate manager in carrying out its duties – costs arising from the late supply of statements of evidence

Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld), section 94, Schedule 2
Body Corporate and Community Management (Accommodation Module) Regulation 2008, sections 127, 129
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), sections 100, 102

Kehl v Board of Professional Engineers of Queensland [2010] QCATA 77
Ralacom Pty Ltd v Body Corporate for Paradise Island Apartments (No 2) [2010] QCAT 412
Seed and Anor v Body Corporate for Renaissance Golden Beach [2011] QCAT 246

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION:

APPLICANT: Johjen Pty Ltd represented by Mr Benjamin Kidston of counsel instructed by Mahoney Lawyers
RESPONDENT: Body Corporate for Aegean CTS 9646 represented by Mr Keith Howe of counsel instructed by Carter Newell Lawyers

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. The Aegean is a high rise apartment building in Surfers Paradise. Johjen is the resident unit manager engaged by the body corporate. It has been the manager since 2003. Johjen is also the letting agent for a substantial number of apartments in the building.

  2. A dispute has arisen between the body corporate and Johjen about whether Johjen has been properly performing its duties. For example the body corporate says that Johjen failed to properly supervise cleaning and maintenance staff employed by the body corporate; and that it failed to advise the body corporate of deterioration in the balustrading, the roof membrane, and ventilation ductwork on the roof.

  3. In 2010 the body corporate gave Johjen a series of five remedial action notices under section 129 of the Body Corporate and Community Management (Accommodation Module) Regulation 2008 (Qld):

    ·one dated 14 May 2010 (the first notice);

    ·one dated 20 October…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Johjen Pty Ltd v Body Corporate for Aegean and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QCAT 387
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Johjen Pty Ltd v Body Corporate for Aegean, the dispute centred around allegations of neglect and gross negligence by Johjen, the property manager of a residential building, in carrying out its duties. The dispute was brought before the court by the body corporate, which sought declarations of neglect and gross negligence, along with an injunction and other remedies. The court was tasked with determining whether Johjen's conduct warranted the proposed declarations and whether the body corporate's claims were substantiated.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether Johjen's actions constituted neglect and gross negligence, as alleged by the body corporate. The court examined various aspects of Johjen's conduct, including its oversight of cleaning and maintenance staff, its communication regarding issues such as rooftop problems and balustrading, and its overall presence and management of the building. The court also considered whether the evidence provided was sufficient to establish the body corporate's claims.

The court found that while there were some concerns regarding Johjen's management practices, they did not amount to the level of neglect or gross negligence claimed. The evidence provided by the body corporate was insufficient to establish these serious allegations. The court concluded that Johjen's conduct, while not perfect, did not rise to the level of gross negligence. Therefore, the court rejected the proposed declarations and found in favour of Johjen on the substantive matters. The court also ordered Johjen to pay costs of $2,465 to the body corporate.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I quantify the costs referred to in Senior Member Stilgoe’s direction at $2,465. I will allow a month for payment.CONCLUSION On the basis of the findings I have made, the appropriate orders are those sought by Johjen on the substantive matters, and a costs order for $2,465 in favour of the body corporate.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

A basis has not been established for the proposed declarations based on failure and neglect.Proposed declaration relating to gross negligence The body corporate contended in April 2011 that ‘by the matters set out in [the five notices] [Johjen] has been guilty of gross negligence in the performance of its duties under the Engagement’. As I have found that the conduct of Johjen in response to the remedial action notices was appropriate, I will confine my attention to Johjen’s conduct prior to each of the notices (whether valid or not). I will consider the conduct under the following headings, which encompass the most potentially wrongful conduct:·causing staff to assist residents or Johjen;·failure to supervise cleaning and maintenance staff;·failure to advise of the rooftop problems;·failure to advise of balustrading problems; and·absence from the building. I do not propose to take into account any alleged breaches that have occurred more recently, of which there is some mention in the material. The body corporate quite properly did not seek to rely on that later evidence, as it fell outside the scope of the defined dispute. Causing staff to assist residents or Johjen In discussing the first notice, I have mentioned the four instances observed by committee members. It appears that the body corporate was concerned that these were just the tip of the iceberg. It was concerned that Johjen was, as Ms Johnston put it, ‘directing its efforts to its letting business … at the expense of the building’s maintenance’. Ms Johnston says that Ian Brown told another committee member that private rental maintenance was part of the daily maintenance duties allocated to him by Mr Burnell. I do not attach significance to this last piece of evidence, however, because it emerged in Mr Burnell’s and Ms Bugden’s evidence that Mr Brown was an employee of both the body corporate and Johjen. Johjen for its part says that it inherited a practice where the manager would provide minor assistance to residents, many of whom were elderly, and it carried this on in the interests of good community relations. It denies favouring owners in its letting pool. It says that Mr Brown attended to Johjen’s private banking during only a short period, on his own time, to help out when Ms Burnell was absent because of a family bereavement. Mr Brown gave evidence to similar effect. The explanations given by Johjen are credible. While there may be room for suspicion about the extent of the practice, there is no concrete evidence that Johjen required the body corporate staff to spend more than minimal time on work for residents. I accept Johjen’s explanations. Johjen’s conduct was not inconsistent with a diligent attitude to its duties. The evidence against Johjen on this issue is scant. It does not establish negligence, let alone gross negligence.Failure to supervise cleaning and maintenance staff The body corporate believes that Johjen allowed the body corporate employees to take excessive breaks, and attend to personal tasks such as laundry during working hours. I have discussed at length the limitations in the surveillance evidence for early November 2010. The remainder of the surveillance evidence suffers from similar limitations. The conduct of some staff members is open to question, on the basis of the surveillance evidence, but the evidence falls short of establishing that Johjen failed to adequately supervise or carry out any of its related duties. Gross negligence is not established.