JMC PROPERTY GROUP PTY LTD and PRESIDING MEMBER METRO CENTRAL JOINT DEVELOPMENT PANEL

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   JMC PROPERTY GROUP PTY LTD and PRESIDING MEMBER METRO CENTRAL JOINT DEVELOPMENT PANEL [2017] WASAT 155

MEMBER:   MR M SPILLANE (SENIOR MEMBER)

MR P DE VILLIERS (MEMBER)

HEARD:   6 AND 7 JUNE 2017

SUBMISSIONS ON 11 AND 22 SEPTEMBER 2017

DELIVERED          :   12 DECEMBER 2017

FILE NO/S:   DR 132 of 2016

BETWEEN:   JMC PROPERTY GROUP PTY LTD

Applicant

AND

PRESIDING MEMBER METRO CENTRAL JOINT DEVELOPMENT PANEL
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning - Development application ­ Multiple dwellings ­ Land reserved for 'Public Purposes ­ Car Parking' ­ Reserve not used for designated purpose ­ 'Ultimate Purpose' of reserve ­ Weight to be given to strategic planning ­ Weight to be given to Draft Structure Plan ­ Acceptability of proposed land use ­ Density, plot ratio, height, bulk and scale of development ­ Compliance with scheme and Draft Structure Plan ­ Orderly and proper planning

Legislation:

City of Bayswater Town Planning Scheme No 13
City of Bayswater Town Planning Scheme No 24, cl 1.6, cl 3.6.1, cl 6.3, cl 6.4, cl 8.3.1.3, cl 8.5.2.2, cl 8.5.2.3, cl 8.5.3.2
City of Bayswater District  Zoning Scheme No 21
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA), cl 60, cl 67, cl 67(b), cl 67(m), cl 67(zb)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 252(1), s 257B(3)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 27(2)
State Planning Policy 3.1 ­ Residential Design Codes, cl 6.2.3, cl 6.3.5, cl 6.46, Table 4

Result:

Application for review dismissed
Decision of respondent affirmed

Summary of Tribunal's decision:

On 15 January 2016 JCM Property Group Pty Ltd made a planning application for the development of nineteen multiple dwelling units at 1 Foyle Road, Bayswater.

At a meeting on 19 April 2016 the Metro Central Joint Development Assessment Panel resolved to refuse that development application.

On 29 April 2016 the Tribunal received an application under s 252(1) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) seeking a review of that decision.

Following a hearing at the Tribunal on the 6 and 7 June 2017 and further submissions from the parties on 11 and 22 September 2017, the Tribunal considered the matter and found as follows:

i) that the use of the land for the proposed development was not objectable in terms of the principles of orderly and proper planning; however

ii) the density of the proposed development was excessive and the proposed plot ratio was well in excess of the provisions of both the City of Bayswater Town Planning Scheme No 24 and the Draft Bayswater Town Centre Structure Plan;  

iii) the proposed height of the development did not comply with City of Bayswater Town Planning Scheme No 24 and was unlikely to comply with the recently adopted Draft Bayswater Town Centre Structure Plan; and

iv) the proposed development would be inconsistent with the existing and proposed development on adjoining land in terms its bulk and scale.

Therefore, on the evidence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JMC PROPERTY GROUP PTY LTD and PRESIDING MEMBER METRO CENTRA... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] WASAT 155
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

JMC Property Group Pty Ltd and the Presiding Member of the Metro Central Joint Development Panel were before the State Administrative Tribunal of Western Australia in a case involving a development application for multiple dwellings. The site in question was previously reserved for public purposes, specifically car parking, but had not been used for that purpose. The central issues before the court were the weight to be given to the strategic planning and the Draft Structure Plan, the acceptability of the proposed land use, and whether the development complied with the scheme and the Draft Structure Plan, with a focus on orderly and proper planning.

The court examined the effect of the now 'adoptive' Draft Structure Plan on the land use and nature of the development. The applicant argued that the draft Structure Plan should be given moderate weight due to its consistency with other strategic documentation. However, the applicant also noted the uncertainties surrounding the draft Apartment Design Policy and the potential need for modifications to the proposed densities. Conversely, the respondent contended that the Draft Structure Plan could not be considered as a planning instrument that the City of Bayswater was seriously considering adopting or approving. The respondent argued that the Structure Plan should be given little to no weight, as it was not site-specific and its ultimate approval was uncertain.

The court considered the submissions and concluded that the Draft Structure Plan should be given little weight due to the uncertainties and the lack of site-specific comments. The court emphasised the need for a correct and preferable decision at the time of the review, in line with the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004. The court focused on the criteria outlined in Nicholls and Western Australian Planning Commission and determined that the Structure Plan could assist in informing the general future intended land use and nature of the development of the locality, but it was not determinative.

In conclusion, the court issued an order that the Draft Structure Plan should be given little weight in determining the acceptability of the proposed land use and the compliance of the development with the scheme and the Draft Structure Plan. The court stressed the importance of orderly and proper planning and the need for certainty in the planning process.

Background

Background to the litigation

JMC Property Group Pty Ltd (the applicant) sought approval for a development application for a mixed-use project on a parcel of land in Bayswater, Western Australia. The land had previously been designated for public purposes, specifically for car parking, but had not been utilised for this purpose. The City of Bayswater (the respondent) assessed the application and ultimately refused it, citing concerns about the land's intended use and the potential impact on the surrounding area.

In response, the applicant lodged an appeal with the State Administrative Tribunal (the Tribunal), arguing that the refusal was unreasonable. The applicant emphasised the importance of the Draft Structure Plan, which had been prepared by the City of Bayswater and identified the land as suitable for multiple dwelling residential use. The Draft Structure Plan was considered to be a key strategic document that should guide the Tribunal's decision.

The applicant submitted that the Draft Structure Plan should be given moderate weight, as it was consistent with other strategic documentation and provided relatively certain guidance on the land's intended use. However, the applicant also noted that there was uncertainty regarding the final form of the Draft Structure Plan, as it relied on the Western Australian Planning Commission's Draft Apartment Design Policy, which was still subject to public comment and industry lobbying. The applicant argued that, given this uncertainty, the Draft Structure Plan should be given little weight in determining the acceptability of the proposed development.

The respondent, on the other hand, contended that the Draft Structure Plan was not a planning instrument that the City of Bayswater was seriously considering adopting or approving, and that it should therefore be given little to no weight in the Tribunal's decision. The respondent emphasised that the Draft Structure Plan did not provide specific guidance on the site in question, and that its ultimate approval could not be regarded as certain or imminent.

The matter before the State Administrative Tribunal of Western Australia involves a review of a decision made by the Presiding Member of the Metro Central Joint Development Panel regarding a development application for multiple dwellings on land reserved for "Public Purposes - Car Parking." The Tribunal's review was initiated pursuant to the provisions of section 27(2) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), which mandates that the purpose of the review is to produce the correct and preferable decision at the time of the review. This case is not an appeal or a judicial review but rather a review under the specific statutory framework designed to ensure the correct application of planning laws.

The procedural journey began when the applicant, JMC Property Group Pty Ltd, lodged a development application with the Metro Central Joint Development Panel, which was subsequently reviewed and determined by the Presiding Member. Dissatisfied with the outcome, JMC Property Group sought judicial review of the Presiding Member's decision, leading to the matter being brought before the State Administrative Tribunal. During the review process, the Tribunal invited the parties to submit their views on the effect of the Draft Structure Plan, which had been adopted by the City of Bayswater, on the proposed land use and nature of development. The applicant argued that the Draft Structure Plan should be given moderate weight for its land use guidance and little weight for the proposed densities due to the uncertainties surrounding the Draft Apartment Design Policy. Conversely, the respondent contended that the Draft Structure Plan should be afforded little to no weight as it was not a certain or imminent planning instrument and did not provide specific site-related guidance. The Tribunal's decision hinges on weighing these submissions and determining the appropriate consideration to be given to the Draft Structure Plan in the context of the statutory review.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Therefore, in keeping with the provisions of s 27(2) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act2004 (WA) which states:The purpose of the review is to produce the correct and preferable decision at the time of the decision upon the review.(Tribunal emphasis) the Tribunal contacted the parties and invited them to provide submissions as to the effect, if any, the now 'adoptive' Draft Structure Plan may have on:a)the land use of the site, the subject of the review;b)the nature of development on the site and the subject of the review; and c)what weight the Draft Structure Plan should be given. In submissions filed 11 September 2017 following the Tribunal's invitation, the applicant submitted in regard to land use:The land use provisions of the draft Structure Plan offer the most detailed guidance yet on the range of suitable uses, and the ultimate purpose intended for the land. [Para 30]and:In respect of land use, the identification of multiple dwelling residential as a preferred land use for the site in the draft Structure Plan should be given moderate weight, as it is consistent with other strategic documentation and is relatively certain. [Para 47] In regard to the nature of development on the site the applicant submitted:… it is probable that the densities proposed in the draft Structure Plan will be required to be modified higher by the Western Australian Planning Commission[.] [Para 17]This uncertainty is further compounded by the fact that the draft Structure Plan relies heavily upon built form outcomes identified in the WAPC's Draft Apartment Design Policy (ADP). The draft ADP was released for public comment in October 2016, received over 1000 public submissions during the public advertising period, has not been finalised, and has been subject of intense industry lobbying. [Para 18]and:Final approval of the ADP cannot be regarded as either certain or imminent, and so we have a situation where there is compounding uncertainty, as the draft Structure Plan cannot be finalised until the ADP has first been finalised. [Para 19]. Finally, the applicant submitted:… in this respect, the draft Structure Plan should be given little weight. [Para 48] In its submissions in reply filed on 22 September 2017, the respondent drawing on Terra Sprei Pty Ltd and Shire of Kalamunda [2015] WASAT 134 (at [206]) (Terra Sprei Pty Ltd) submitted that the Draft Structure Plan 'cannot at this stage be characterised as a planning instrument that the City of Bayswater is seriously considering adopting or approving as per cl 67(b) of the Deemed Provisions' and '… it is arguable that the Structure Plan is not a matter to which due regard is required to be had' under that provision [para 8]. In addition, the respondent expressed the view that 'it is a matter for the Tribunal to determine what weight it gives to the Structure Plan having regard to the criteria outlined in Nicholls and Western Australian Planning Commission [2005] WASAT 40. The respondent concluded by submitting at para 29:The Structure Plan assists to inform generally the future intended land use and nature of the development of the locality. However no comment is site specific. Furthermore, the Structure Plan's ultimate approval cannot be regarded as certain of imminent. Accordingly the Structure Plan so should be given little to no weight.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The State Administrative Tribunal, in this case, was tasked with determining the appropriate land use and development proposals for a site reserved for 'Public Purposes ­ Car Parking' that was not being used for its designated purpose. The Tribunal was required to consider the 'ultimate purpose' of this reserved land, which was not explicitly defined in the existing planning schemes. The Tribunal held that the 'ultimate purpose' of such reserved land is to be determined by considering the broader context and objectives of the planning schemes, which include promoting orderly and proper planning and development.

The Tribunal was also required to consider the weight to be given to a Draft Structure Plan that was not yet finalised and was subject to uncertainty and public comment. The applicant argued that the Draft Structure Plan should be given moderate weight due to its consistency with other strategic documentation and relative certainty. However, the respondent argued that the Draft Structure Plan could not be characterised as a planning instrument that the City of Bayswater was seriously considering adopting or approving, and therefore, should be given little to no weight. The Tribunal found that the Draft Structure Plan, while not yet finalised, could still provide useful guidance on the range of suitable uses and the ultimate purpose intended for the land. However, due to the uncertainty surrounding its final approval, the Tribunal decided to give it limited weight.

The Tribunal also considered the Draft Structure Plan's identification of multiple dwelling residential as a preferred land use for the site. The applicant argued that this identification should be given moderate weight, as it was consistent with other strategic documentation and was relatively certain. The respondent, on the other hand, argued that the Draft Structure Plan's ultimate approval was not certain or imminent, and therefore, its proposed land use should be given little to no weight. The Tribunal found that while the Draft Structure Plan's identification of multiple dwelling residential as a preferred land use should be considered, its limited weight should be attributed to the uncertainty surrounding its final approval.

The Tribunal was also required to consider the extent to which the Draft Structure Plan's proposed densities should be modified due to reliance on the Western Australian Planning Commission's Draft Apartment Design Policy. The applicant argued that the Draft Structure Plan's proposed densities were uncertain and compounded by the fact that the draft Apartment Design Policy had not been finalised and was subject to intense industry lobbying. The Tribunal found that the Draft Structure Plan's proposed densities should be given limited weight due to the uncertainty surrounding the final approval of the draft Apartment Design Policy.

The Tribunal was further required to determine whether the Draft Structure Plan could be characterised as a planning instrument that the City of Bayswater was seriously considering adopting or approving. The respondent argued that the Draft Structure Plan could not be characterised as such and, therefore, should be given little to no weight. The Tribunal found that while the Draft Structure Plan was not yet finalised, it could still provide useful guidance on the range of suitable uses and the ultimate purpose intended for the land.

In determining the weight to be given to the Draft Structure Plan, the Tribunal considered the criteria outlined in Nicholls and Western Australian Planning Commission [2005] WASAT 40. The Tribunal found that the Draft Structure Plan's ultimate approval was not certain or imminent, and therefore, its proposed land use and development proposals should be given limited weight.

In conclusion, the Tribunal's decision provides valuable guidance on the weight to be given to a Draft Structure Plan that is not yet finalised and is subject to uncertainty and public comment. The Tribunal found that while the Draft Structure Plan could provide useful guidance on the range of suitable uses and the ultimate purpose intended for the land, its limited weight should be attributed to the uncertainty surrounding its final approval. Furthermore, the Tribunal found that the Draft Structure Plan's proposed densities should be given limited weight due to the uncertainty surrounding the final approval of the draft Apartment Design Policy. The Tribunal's decision also provides guidance on the criteria to be considered in determining the weight to be given to a Draft Structure Plan.