AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES TRIBUNAL
CITATION:JILL DEXTER –v- DONG RONG LUN [2009] ACTRTT (7)
RT 839 of 2008
Catchwords: Reletting fee, fair posting clause; termination via fair posting clause; endorsement of fair posting clauses.
Tribunal:A. Anforth, Member
Date: 16 February 2009
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES TRIBUNAL ) No: RT 839 of 2008
]
JILL DEXTER
(Applicant/Landlord)
AND:
DONG RONG LUN
(Respondent/Tenant)
DECISION
The Office of Rental Bonds is to return the residue of the rent retained to the tenant.
…………………………….
A. Anforth, Member
16th February 2009
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES TRIBUNAL ) NO: RT 839 of 2008
JILL DEXTER
(Applicant/Landlord)
DONG RONG LUN
(Respondent/Tenant)
REASONS FOR DECISION
The facts are not in dispute. The dispute between the parties is wholly one of law.
This matter concerns the residue of a rental bond dispute between the parties. The tenancy commenced on 25 December 2007 for a fixed term of 12 months at a rent of $320.00 per week and a bond of 1280.00. The tenancy was terminated on 23 Augsut 2008 when the tenant vacate to take a posting outside the ACT in the course of his employment. The landlord secured a new tenant on 26 August 2008 at a rent of $330.00 per week.
Part of the bond has been dispersed in accordance with the parties consent. There is a residue of $365.72 held by the Office of Rental Bonds which relates to the dispute between the parties over the landlord’s claim for compensation for a reletting fee and foregone rent pending the signing of a new tenant to the premises.
The original tenancy agreement contained the standard posting clause of section 8 of the Act which read:
(1) The tenancy agreement may be terminated—
(a) if the lessor is posted to Canberra in the course of the lessor’s employment—by the lessor giving the tenant at least 4 weeks written notice; or
(b) if the tenant is posted away from Canberra in the course of the tenant’s employment—by the tenant giving the lessor at least 4 weeks written notice.(2) The tenancy ends—
(a) 4 weeks after the day a notice is received under subclause (1); or
(b) if a later date is stated in the notice—on the stated date.
The matter was listed before the Tribunal on 21 January 2009. Ms Hawkins, real estate agent appeared for the landlord and the tenant appeared in person by phone.
Three issues of law arose for resolution at the hearing. The parties had their say and the Tribunal reserved the matter for written decision. The issues were:
(a)Whether the posting clause required endorsement under section 10 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (the Act) in order to be valid:
(b)The extent to which the landlord was entitled a any part of the reletting fee as part of her damages
(c)The relevance of the fact that the landlord managed to relet the premises for the balance of the fixed term at an increased rent.
The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read JILL DEXTER –v- DONG RONG LUN and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] ACTRTT 7
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The key legal issues were whether the fair posting clause required endorsement under section 10 of the Act, the extent to which the landlord was entitled to any part of the reletting fee as part of her damages, and the relevance of the fact that the landlord managed to relet the premises for the balance of the fixed term at an increased rent. The Tribunal found that the fair posting clause did not require endorsement under section 10 of the Act, as it is permissible for the parties to agree to include the clause in the residential tenancy agreement. The Tribunal also found that the landlord was not entitled to any compensation for the reletting fee or foregone rent, as the tenant vacated the premises in accordance with the fair posting clause, and there was no abandonment or unlawful termination of the fixed term lease by the tenant.
The Tribunal concluded that the Office of Rental Bonds should return the entire remaining bond to the tenant, as the landlord was not entitled to any compensation for the reletting fee or foregone rent. The Tribunal further found that the landlord's claim for compensation for the reletting fee arose under either section 62(1)(b) or section 84(1)(b)(ii) of the Act, which both permit the Tribunal to award compensation for "the reasonable costs of advertising the premises for lease and of giving a right to occupy the premises to another person." However, the Tribunal held that the landlord was not entitled to any compensation for the reletting fee or foregone rent, as the tenant vacated the premises in accordance with the fair posting clause, and there was no abandonment or unlawful termination of the fixed term lease by the tenant.
In conclusion, the Tribunal ordered the Office of Rental Bonds to return the entire remaining bond to the tenant, as the landlord was not entitled to any compensation for the reletting fee or foregone rent. The Tribunal also found that the fair posting clause did not require endorsement under section 10 of the Act, as it is permissible for the parties to agree to include the clause in the residential tenancy agreement.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was listed before the Australian Capital Territory Residential Tenancies Tribunal on 21 January 2009. Ms. Hawkins, a real estate agent, appeared for the landlord, and the tenant appeared in person by phone. Three issues of law arose for resolution at the hearing, which the Tribunal reserved for written decision. The issues were: (a) whether the posting clause required endorsement under section 10 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (the Act) in order to be valid; (b) the extent to which the landlord was entitled to any part of the reletting fee as part of her damages; and (c) the relevance of the fact that the landlord managed to relet the premises for the balance of the fixed term at an increased rent.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the posting clause required endorsement under section 10 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (the Act) in order to be valid.
2. The extent to which the landlord is entitled to any part of the reletting fee as part of her damages.
3. The relevance of the fact that the landlord managed to relet the premises for the balance of the fixed term at an increased rent.
Held
1. The posting clause did not require endorsement under section 10 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (the Act) in order to be valid.
2. The landlord was not entitled to any part of the reletting fee as part of her damages.
3. The fact that the landlord managed to relet the premises for the balance of the fixed term at an increased rent was not relevant to the case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Tribunal addressed the validity of the posting clause under section 8 of the Act and determined that such clauses, when inserted by agreement, are part of the residential tenancy agreement and do not require endorsement under section 10. This conclusion was reached by examining the language of section 8, which allows the incorporation of fair posting clauses into the agreement without them being inconsistent with the standard residential tenancy terms, thereby exempting them from the endorsement requirement. This interpretation was further supported by the practical implications of requiring endorsement for every fair posting clause, which the Tribunal found would be redundant and a waste of resources.
Regarding the reletting fee, the Tribunal held that the landlord was not entitled to any compensation for the reletting fee. This decision was based on the premise that when a tenant vacates in accordance with a valid posting clause, there has been no abandonment or unlawful termination of the fixed term lease by the tenant. Therefore, the landlord's entitlements under sections 62 and 84 of the Act for compensation were not applicable. The Tribunal emphasized that permitting compensation in such cases would abrogate the statutory and contractual rights of the tenant to terminate the lease as per the fair posting clause. Consequently, the Tribunal ordered the Office of Rental Bonds to return the remaining bond to the tenant.