Jianqing Ltd v Linhope International Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Jianqing Ltd to an application under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) by Linhope International Limited for removal of trade mark number 2055948 (25) – HOUSEOFCB – in the name of Jianqing Ltd

Delegate: Debrett Lyons
Representation: Opponent: None
Applicant: Jürgen Bebber of Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Decision: 2022 ATMO 169
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) - section 96 opposition: s 92(4)(a) application for removal – application unsuccessful and Trade Mark to remain on the Register

Background

  1. This decision is pursuant to an application made under s 92(4)(a) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Act) on 12 November 2020 by Linhope International Limited (Removal Applicant) to remove the Registration 2055948 for HOUSEOFCB (Mark) from the register in respect of all the goods for which it is registered, namely:

    Class 25: Shoes; Clothing; Hosiery; Neckties; Scarfs; Girdles; Swimsuits; Trousers; Coats; Skirts; Pyjamas; Infants' clothing; Outerclothing; Gloves (clothing); Hats (Registered Goods)

  2. The Mark is registered with a priority date of 6 December 2019 in the name of Jianqing Ltd. (Removal Opponent).

  3. A Notice of Intention to Oppose the removal application was filed on 4 January 2021 followed by a Statement of Grounds and Particulars on 25 January 2021.   A Notice of Intention to Defend was filed on 3 February 2021.

  4. The evidence in support comprises a declaration of Jianqing Chen made 12 March 2021 with Exhibits A – G.  Evidence in answer comprises a declaration of Richard Southall made 22 June 2021 with Annexures 1 – 26 and a declaration of Brian Walker made 28 June 2021[1].

    There was no evidence in reply.

    [1] The Walker declaration was filed one week after the Removal Applicant’s deadline for evidence in answer but for the reasons given in reaching the Decision it became unnecessary to consider this issue.  Descriptions of the Removal Applicant’s business made later are sufficiently premised on the Southall declaration.

  5. Once the time allowed for filing evidence had ended the parties were given an opportunity to request a hearing or to file written submissions.  The Removal Applicant requested a hearing and paid the appropriate fee.  In line with usual practice, a letter was sent to the parties inviting them to file outline submissions.  The Removal Applicant did so; the Removal Opponent did not.  I was then asked to hear and decide the matter, acting as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks.  I did so on 1 September 2022.

    Legislative framework

  6. Section 92 of the Act provides, relevantly:

    (4)  An application under subsection (1) or (3) (non‑use application) may be made on either or both of the following grounds, and on no other grounds:

    (a)  that, on the day on which the application for the registration of the trade mark was filed, the applicant for registration had no intention in good faith:

    (i)  to use the trade mark…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jianqing Ltd v Linhope International Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] ATMO 169
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Jianqing Ltd (the Removal Applicant) to remove a trade mark registered to Linhope International Limited (the Removal Opponent) from the Register. The Removal Applicant sought removal under section 92(4)(a) of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth), arguing that the Removal Opponent's use of the mark on the registered goods was effectively disqualified due to its character.

The central legal issue before the Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks was whether the Delegate had the mandate under section 92 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* to determine the character of the Removal Opponent's use of the trade mark. The Removal Applicant contended that such an approach would encourage parties to resolve trade mark disputes through applications to the Registrar, rather than more expensive litigation in the Federal Court.

The Delegate reasoned that the established practice of the Trade Marks Office, supported by case law, is that the Registrar does not have the authority to determine such issues under section 92. The Delegate referred to the decision in *Edwards*, which indicated that courts discourage the use of section 92 for purposes other than the removal of unused trade marks. The Delegate found that section 92 was not apt to raise the real issue between the parties in this case, and that parties should not be encouraged to bring inapposite claims simply because they are cheaper, as this can lead to increased costs if the claim backfires.

The Removal Applicant's application for removal was unsuccessful. Accordingly, the Delegate directed that the trade mark registration was to remain on the Register for all registered goods. No award of costs was made as the Removal Opponent had not requested them.

Background

Background to the litigation

Jianqing Ltd, the applicant, sought the removal of a trade mark registered to Linhope International Limited, the opponent, from the Australian Trade Marks Register. Jianqing Ltd argued that Linhope International Limited's use of the registered trade mark on certain goods did not comply with the requirements of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), and therefore, the registration should be removed. Jianqing Ltd's application was based on the premise that Linhope International Limited's use of the trade mark was not genuine or was in a manner that would tarnish the reputation of the mark.

Linhope International Limited opposed the application, asserting that its use of the trade mark was legitimate and in compliance with the relevant provisions of the Act. The opponent argued that its use of the trade mark was in relation to the goods and services for which the mark was registered, and that it had not used the mark in a way that would tarnish its reputation or deceive the public. Linhope International Limited submitted evidence to support its claims, including documentation and witness statements.

The matter was heard by Debrett Lyons, Hearing Officer and Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. The applicant presented its case, outlining the reasons why the opponent's use of the trade mark was allegedly not in compliance with the Act. The opponent responded to the applicant's claims, providing evidence to demonstrate that its use of the trade mark was legitimate and in accordance with the requirements of the Act. After considering the evidence and submissions from both parties, the Hearing Officer found that the applicant's application for removal of the trade mark was unsuccessful, and that the registration should remain on the Register for all of the registered goods.

The matter before this court concerns an application by Jianqing Ltd to remove a trade mark held by Linhope International Limited from the Australian Trade Marks Register. This is a section 96 opposition proceeding under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). Jianqing Ltd applied for the removal of the trade mark on the basis that it had not been used in relation to the registered goods and services. Linhope International Limited opposed the application, arguing that its use of the trade mark was genuine and sufficient. The application was heard by Debrett Lyons, acting as a Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. Jianqing Ltd argued that the character of Linhope International Limited’s use of the trade mark disqualified it from being on the Register, while Linhope International Limited maintained that its use was genuine and continuous. The Delegate found that the fundamental issue was whether the Delegate had the authority to determine the character of the use under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act. The Delegate concluded that, as per established practice and the authority of Gordon J in Edwards, the Delegate did not have such a mandate, and the application for removal under section 92 was thus inappropriate. The Delegate ultimately ruled that the trade mark should remain on the Register, and Jianqing Ltd’s application for removal was dismissed. No costs were awarded as Linhope International Limited did not request them. This decision may be subject to appeal, in which case the matter will be dealt with by the Federal Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Whereas the Removal Applicant’s submissions position the critical issue in the matter before me as being whether the Removal Opponent’s use of the Mark on the Registered Goods is effectively disqualified because of the character of that use, it follows from the case law that the fundamental question is whether, as a Delegate of the Registrar, I have a mandate to determine that issue under s 92. The tested practice of this Office is that I do not[3] and the matter is put beyond dispute by Gordon J who in Edwards spelt out that the courts discouraged the use of s 92 for a purpose other than the removal of unused trade marks. Her Honour wrote:LE 2003 contends that such an approach would have the effect of discouraging parties from availing themselves “of the opportunities afforded by the TMA to resolve [trade mark disputes] by application to the Registrar, rather than by the more expensive alternative of Federal Court litigation.” That submission, while perhaps unobjectionable as a general proposition, is not appropriate here, where it was apparent thats 92 of the TMA was not apt to raise the real issue between the parties in this case. Parties should not be encouraged to bring inapposite claims on the grounds that they are cheaper; such a strategy may, as this case shows, backfire and if that occurs, it will result in more costs being incurred than if the best claim was brought in the first place. If a dispassionate analysis suggests that the client’s only realistic chance of success requires resort to a more expensive forum, then that is the advice an independent adviser should give. Whether the client in those circumstances wishes to pursue the claim is then a matter for the client. If it chooses not to follow that course or the advice, then it does so at its own risk. In the present case, that risk was realised in the form of the costs of the unsuccessful proceeding or application.[3] See, for example, the decision earlier this year in Deco Australia Pty Ltd v Aluwood Australia Pty Ltd [2022] ATMO 79 at [19].Decision and Costs The Removal Applicant has been unsuccessful in its application for removal of the Trade Mark. Accordingly, I direct that registration 2055948 is to remain on the Register for all of the Registered Goods. If the Registrar is served with a notice of appeal from that decision then the registration will be dealt with as the Court sees fit. Costs normally follow the event but the Removal Opponent has made no request for costs and so I do not make any award as part of this decision.Debrett LyonsHearing OfficerDelegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks30 September 2022

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Delegate of the Registrar in Jianqing Ltd v Linhope International Limited addressed the issue of whether they had the authority to determine if the Removal Opponent's use of the Mark on the Registered Goods disqualified them under section 92(4)(a) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The Delegate concluded that they lacked such a mandate, citing the established practice of the Trade Marks Office and the decision in Edwards, where Gordon J emphasized the courts' discouragement of using section 92 for purposes other than removing unused trade marks. The Delegate noted that the courts had discouraged using section 92 for anything other than removing unused trade marks, with the case of Edwards being particularly illustrative. In that case, Gordon J made it clear that the courts were against the use of section 92 for purposes other than removing unused trade marks. The Delegate, therefore, found themselves without the authority to make a determination on the character of the Removal Opponent's use of the Mark on the Registered Goods.

The Delegate also considered whether using section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) was the appropriate means of raising the real issue between the parties in this case. The Delegate found that the use of section 92 was not apt to address the actual issue at hand, which was whether the Removal Opponent's use of the Mark on the Registered Goods effectively disqualified them under section 92(4)(a). The Delegate emphasized that parties should not be encouraged to bring inapposite claims simply because they are cheaper. In this case, the Removal Applicant's choice to pursue a section 92 application, despite the clear indication that it was not the appropriate means of addressing the real issue, resulted in additional costs being incurred. The Delegate underscored that if a dispassionate analysis suggests that the client's only realistic chance of success requires resort to a more expensive forum, then that is the advice an independent adviser should give.

The Delegate also considered the issue of costs in this proceeding. The Removal Applicant was unsuccessful in its application for removal of the Trade Mark, and as a result, the Trade Mark registration 2055948 remained on the Register for all of the Registered Goods. The Delegate noted that the Removal Opponent had made no request for costs, and therefore, the Delegate did not make any award as part of this decision. The Delegate's reasoning in this case demonstrates that, while the use of section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) may be a cheaper option, it is not always the most appropriate means of addressing the real issue between the parties. Furthermore, the Delegate's decision highlights the importance of providing clients with accurate and independent advice regarding the most suitable legal avenues to pursue in any given situation.